Volume 27 - Number 2 - Winter 2021
Pages: 149 - 271

FABE’S
SYMPOSIUM ON WOODY ALLEN’S COMEDY

Anderson, J. W. (2021). Did Woody Allen’s troubled childhood fuel his humor? Clio’s Psyche, 27(2), 205-208.

https://doi.org/10.70763/b6e710870acb098e584277457ba89d68

Did Woody Allen’s Troubled Childhood Fuel His Humor?

response article

Abstract

In this response article, the author replies to Marilyn Fabe’s lead essay “Woody Allen’s Psychological Slapstick,” which opens the symposium on Woody Allen’s comedy. Fabe contends that Allen’s humor feeds on a damaged self traced to a childhood he experienced as oppressive. Because Fabe wrote before Apropos of Nothing appeared, the author reads the memoir as new evidence in Allen’s own words and asks whether it supports or contradicts her analysis. The author reports that Allen’s remarks on turning distress about mortality and the universe into one-liners bear out the first part of her thesis. Allen’s account of his early years appears to reject the second part: he describes a loving extended family and attributes his outlook to inherited disposition and to learning that all people die. The author maintains that the memoir’s descriptions of his parents nonetheless indicate seriously deficient parenting and unmet emotional needs. The author also cites jokes Allen builds on those experiences as an instance of the process Fabe describes. The author asks why Allen would present his childhood as healthier than it was. The author hypothesizes that Allen is invested in his conviction that life is meaningless, and that conceding childhood deficits would make his fears seem irrational. The response closes by inviting Fabe’s own answer.

Keywords:

Apropos of Nothing, autobiography, childhood, damaged self, emotional pain, film comedy, Marilyn Fabe, parenting, psychoanalysis, psychobiography, Woody Allen

The central theme of Marilyn Fabe’s sparkling essay on Woody Allen is that “his comic genius feeds on [his “damaged self”].” She traces his compromised self to his childhood. Allen “symbolically recasts as funny,” she writes, “his own emotional pain growing up in an environment that he experienced as extremely oppressive and damaging to the self he wished to become.”

In depicting his childhood, Fabe examined biographies and interviews of Allen, but his autobiography, Apropos of Nothing (2020), had not yet been published when she wrote her essay. As I read Allen’s new work, I thought, here we have a trove of new evidence, all in Allen’s own words. Does this memoir support or contradict Fabe’s analysis? The answer is unexpectedly complicated.

Allen makes a comment that bears on the question of whether his emotional pain fuels his humor. He writes,

People ask me do I ever fear I’ll wake up one morning and not be funny….If I woke up and was not funny, I wouldn’t be me. This does not mean you can’t wake up in a bad mood, hating the world, angry at people’s stupidity, raging at the empty universe, which I confess I do on schedule every morning, but it serves to bring out my humor, not erase it. Unlike Bertrand Russell, I can’t do long division.

Page 205

And maybe I can’t transmute my suffering into great art or great philosophy, but I can write good one-liners, which distract momentarily and gives brief relief against the irresponsible consequences of the Big Bang (Apropos of Nothing, 331-332).

Allen, of course, is seeking, and to my ear, succeeding in being funny. But the purport of his statement is clear. He suffers greatly and transmutes his suffering into humor. His comedy also, he tells us, distracts him and gives him momentary relief from all that the Big Bang represents to him. Presumably, he is referring to life, death, our smallness in the universe, and the certainty that our world will end, just as it began, in a gigantic explosion.

So far, so good. But what about the second aspect of Fabe’s analysis, namely, that Allen’s troubled childhood produced the distress that underlies his humor? In Allen’s discussion of his early years, he seems to be trying to refute Fabe’s position. It’s a common trope that comedians have painful childhoods. He asserts that in his early years he neither liked nor trusted people but there was “no explainable reason.” “I say ‘no reason,’” he goes on, “because I came from a large, loving, extended family who were always nice to me.” He adds, “It’s like I was a genetically born louse” (Apropos of Nothing, 5). The explanation, he suggests, is that he inherited his disposition; it did not stem from a distressing childhood.

Elsewhere he expands on his claim that his childhood was, if not ideal, certainly not troubled. He starts by saying he was the darling of his mother’s five sisters. He goes on to note, “I never missed a meal, nor wanted for clothing or shelter, never fell prey to any serious illness… I was healthy, popular, very athletic” (Apropos of Nothing, 11).

“[A]nd yet,” he points out, “somehow I managed to turn out nervous, fearful, an emotional wreck, hanging on by a thread to my composure, misanthropic, claustrophobic, isolated, embittered, impeccably pessimistic” (Apropos of Nothing, 11). He explains that childhood problems did not produce his personality, but rather it was that he learned about mortality—we all will die—and that led him to become convinced of “the meaninglessness of existence” (12).

But there is a crack in his picture of his supposedly healthy childhood. Let’s consider first what he says about his father.

Page 206

While Allen describes him as a sweet, warm man, he makes it clear his father was irresponsible, unable or unwilling to support the family, a dreamer, a philanderer, and a gambler. His mother comes across as even worse. He felt she wasn’t fun or interesting and she was “too strict and pushy” (Apropos of Nothing, 5). He describes her as someone who “took no prisoners” (4). Allen excelled on an IQ test at five or six. “My mother was forever browbeating me, telling me I had such a high IQ, how could I be so complete an idiot” (6), he points out. Later, while talking about how he went to Hebrew school only because his parents pressured him to, he happens to mention that this coercion included his mother striking him: “My mother hit me every day at least once…. [M]om whacked me every day, and it was the old Sam Levenson joke—‘Maybe I don’t know what you did to deserve it, but you do’” (33). His citing that joke is just the process Fabe describes; he is making humor that feeds on his painful experience.

Allen also writes about how mismatched his parents were. “[T]hey disagreed on every single issue except Hitler and my report cards” (Apropos of Nothing, 3). We see the same process here. He concocts a one-liner built on his experience of his parents berating him for his poor grades. Before leaving his early years, I would like to observe that, without a doubt, his mother was bitterly disappointed with her husband; she was forced to be the one to support the family by working as a bookkeeper in a flower shop while also watching the children and taking care of the home.

My conclusion is that Allen directly contradicts Fabe’s position. She says his childhood was troubled; he says it was not. Paradoxically, a close reading of the autobiography supports Fabe. Ample evidence provided by Allen shows that the parenting he received was seriously deficient and he was deprived of the nurturing that leads to a cohesive self. Note too that almost everything that he says about the positive aspects of his childhood refers to externals, such as his having food and shelter. Yet his comments about the deficiencies in his relationship with his parents demonstrate that his deeper needs, his emotional needs, were not fulfilled.

My question is: why did he with either conscious or unconscious intent seek to claim that his childhood was healthier than it was? A common reason for people doing that is they don’t like to think of themselves as troubled people. But Allen doesn’t hesitate to tell us what a mess he is. He describes himself as neurotic, misanthropic, hard to get along with, isolating, and in dread of death.

Page 207

I will attempt to give an answer, and I will also ask Marilyn Fabe how she would respond to this question. I hypothesize that Allen is invested in believing his view of the world to be correct. He is convinced that, given that we all will die, life is meaningless, and, therefore, it only makes sense to be terrified of dying. Given how dangerous the world is, why would a person not be consumed with anxieties? If he conceded that his morbid and nervous view is the result of the deficits in his childhood, then it would be as if he were admitting that his fears are irrational. But maybe Fabe has another explanation.

Page 208

About the author

James William Anderson

James William Anderson, PhD., is Professor of Clinical Psychiatry and Behavioral Sciences, Northwestern University, a member of the faculty of the Chicago Psychoanalytic Institute, and a clinical psychologist in private practice.  He serves as Editor of the Annual of Psychoanalysis and member of the Editorial Board of Clio’s Psyche.  In addition to his book on psychobiography, he has published psychobiographical papers on William and Henry James, Abraham Lincoln, Edith Wharton, Sigmund Freud, D. W. Winnicott, Henry A. Murray, Woodrow Wilson, and Frank Lloyd Wright.  Email address:

How to cite this article

Anderson, J. W. (2021). Did Woody Allen’s troubled childhood fuel his humor? Clio’s Psyche, 27(2), 205-208.

https://doi.org/10.70763/b6e710870acb098e584277457ba89d68

PDF downloads