Volume 09 - Number 2 - September 2002
Pages: 61 - 123

PSYCHOLOGY OF RELIGIOUS EXPERIENCE
SPECIAL ISSUE

Anderson, R. D. (2002). Reverse conversion: From Mormon devotion to depth inquiry of Joseph Smith. Clio’s Psyche, 9(2), 78-81.

https://doi.org/10.70763/1ddfa4ccdcea53130b500eaabb190e4b

Reverse Conversion: From Mormon Devotion to Depth Inquiry of Joseph Smith

article

Abstract

In this article, the author, a psychiatrist and psychoanalyst raised in devout Mormonism, recounts the path that led him to write a psychobiography of Joseph Smith. He describes his Mormon upbringing, including a mission in Great Britain and study at Brigham Young University, and his medical and psychiatric training, during which he came to wonder whether absolute conviction might rest on cultural and psychological factors. He recounts his research on European witchcraft, presented to the American Psychiatric Association and published in the American Journal of Psychiatry, and his reading of historical scholarship on Smith from the late 1960s, after which he says church leaders closed archives and disciplined intellectuals. He describes his psychoanalysis and his withdrawal from religious participation from 1970 to 1988. He identifies a 1988 panel on W. W. Meissner’s Psychoanalysis and Religious Experience as the turning point, prompting him to ask whether The Book of Mormon could be read as a patient on the couch. Taking a naturalistic stance, he reports concluding that the book’s stories transform episodes of Smith’s life, reversing misfortune into conquest and exaggerating conquest into miracle, and cites parallels between Smith and Nephi. He describes his 1999 book, Inside the Mind of Joseph Smith: Psychobiography and The Book of Mormon, Meissner’s assistance, and readers’ responses. He acknowledges the book as incomplete, ending at the publication of The Book of Mormon, and maintains that a psychoanalytic evaluation of Smith and the book has now been done.

Keywords:

The Book of Mormon, The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints (LDS), Joseph Smith Jr., Mormonism, New Testament, psychobiography, psychology of religion, William W. Meissner

There are contradictions in life when one is raised in a home of religious fundamentalism where there is also significant mental illness. Sometimes such clashes—for mental illness is sometimes suspected to occur where there is inadequate devotion or faith in either the individual or family—can result in new and unexpected creations. In devout Mormonism (“Mormon” is the nickname for The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints, founded by Joseph Smith, Jr., with headquarters in Salt Lake City), I served as a missionary for two years in Great Britain, attended Brigham Young University, married in the Salt Lake Temple, and became more than just knowledgeable in Mormon teaching, doctrine, and history. I read the Old Testament completely through twice and the New Testament and The Book of Mormon perhaps 15 times. There was pride in having someone open a book of scripture and read a sentence and then in my being able to peg book, chapter, and, possibly, verse. The personal and very private and prayerful conviction of the validity of The Book of Mormon as divine authentic history following the family background had occurred in my bedroom in my early teens. I had some abilities at speaking and organization, and future local leadership in the Church was in my future.

Mormonism began around 1829, when its founder, Joseph Smith, Jr. (1805-1844), then a 23-year-old semi-educated farm boy living in upstate New York, dictated to scribes a 588-page book of 275,000 words containing a “divinely written” religious history of pre-Columbian America. He said he had been directed to this ancient text, written on gold plates and buried in a hill near his home, by an angel. “Spectacles” through which the ancient writings could be translated were supplied with the book, called The Book of Mormon. Today, The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints accepts this young farm boy as its founding prophet and his account of this event (and other miracles) as canonized scripture, and believes that he has done more for the salvation of the world than any other person except Jesus. The Book covers (mostly) a period from 600 B.C.E. to about 421 C.E., and contains prophets and prophecies, martyrs and missionaries, sovereigns and sermons, and waywardness and warfare. It ascends to high drama with a geophysical holocaust of earthquake, fire, and tidal waves which informed its few survivors of the crucifixion of Jesus in the land they had left and which shortly preceded his dramatic but brief visitation as the resurrected Christ to the New World. The last 200 years of this history descends into furious and all-consuming hatred of antagonistic societies resulting in the complete annihilation of what had been a higher civilization of metallurgy, art, culture, and Christian devotion. The “survivors” in this ethnic destruction became the ancestors of Native Americans, while the last righteous prophet of the destroyed society would become, 14 centuries later, the angel telling young Joseph Smith where he had buried the account. The Mormon Church now accepts this religious history as canonized scripture and views it as a companion book to the Bible. Two weeks after its publication (March 1830), Joseph Smith founded “The Church of Christ,” now The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints.

I followed my father into medical training, and medical school brought some self-awareness that my view of the world seemed restricted. I won summer grants, including one to travel the United States and develop a slide collection on the history of medicine. I saw Eastern historical cities and almost lived inside the vaults of prestigious medical libraries, handling the rarest of manuscripts and incunabula. These works sometimes included the past absurdities of human belief and evidenced the progressive value of scientific thought. Everywhere I looked there were things to learn and questions to be investigated. Not everything seemed to fit into Mormon philosophy. I began to wonder if absolute conviction—including mine—about something—anything—could be a result of only cultural and psychological factors instead of rational thinking based on believable evidence.

Meanwhile, the mental illness in the family had been handled by institutionalization, every existing form of shock therapy, and then by frontal lobotomy. Surely there had to be a better way than cutting up a living brain. I told my father I wished to specialize in psychiatry. He objected, saying that I might lose my faith. I reassured him, “Mormons

Page 78

 sometimes need help for mental problems and I can possibly find ways to adapt psychological knowledge to the church system.” I wondered what it would be like to work in a mental hygiene clinic at Brigham Young University. Because of what would come, there was some small good fortune in my father’s early death just as I finished medical school. My mother lived for another decade as a practicing nurse struggling with chronic leukemia. With both their deaths, I was spared the conflict with parents over my developing religious doubt.

Psychiatric training did intensify the problem of doubt by an increasing awareness of psychological factors that affected or determined beliefs and life-orientation. Then the eccentric professor in the department said, “You are going to waste. What do you want to do?” I understood him to mean that I had special abilities to do research. I said that I wanted to return to the photographic work of medical history but with a focus solely on psychiatry. By this time I had a personal agenda that didn’t need public discussion. I specifically was interested in the history of European witchcraft with the goal of understanding beliefs in demons, witches, and other related items such as possession by evil spirits. (The first healing miracle in Mormonism occurred when Joseph Smith reportedly cast a demon out of a twisted, contorted man who was being hurled around the room but then saw the commanded evil spirit leave his body and found himself floating in space up to the ceiling.) My travel time was three weeks but I read furiously before and after. The largest library on witchcraft in the United States—perhaps the world—is at Cornell University in Ithaca, New York. As I had done in the previous travel, I took weekend side trips to the Mormon history route that began in upstate New York, crossed the United States through Ohio, Missouri, and Illinois (where Joseph Smith was murdered), and ended with the covered wagon trek into the Salt Lake Basin, led by Smith’s devotee and successor, Brigham Young.

But now I sensed that my religious belief was in jeopardy, for my research led to two results. As I ended my psychiatric training, I presented a pictorial paper, “A Review of the History of Witchcraft with Some Psychiatric Comments,” at the annual meeting of the American Psychiatric Association. Karl Menninger sat in the front row—he was interested in and approved of my presentation—and the paper was published in the American Journal of Psychiatry. The second result was that I believed that this European massive pogrom, mostly against older women, was the result of a cultural delusion encouraged by corrupt religious men, and I began to wonder if I might be participating in a cultural delusion.

I continued in local leadership positions in the Mormon Church but historical discoveries enhanced my religious doubt. Beginning in the late 1960s, there was a significant upsurge in new factual documentation about Joseph Smith and the start of Mormonism. With studies led by the “New Mormon Historians” and now dubbed the period of “Mormon Historical Camelot,” virtually every major supernatural claim made by Joseph Smith was challenged by very good, if not absolutely solid, opposing documentation that countered or changed his official and canonized story. Following this period of relative openness by the Mormon hierarchy—a “brief shining moment”—the leaders closed the doors to the archives, and condemned and excommunicated intellectuals within the Church. This not only left a bad taste about their anti-intellectual stance but also gave evidence of censorship and fabrication of Mormon history supported by every period of church leadership since Joseph Smith.

Partly to provide more professional quality in my treatment of patients, I entered psychoanalysis that allowed for a reworking of my childhood rearing and training. I took psychoanalytic institute courses, went through a divorce and successful remarriage, withdrew from religious participation, shied away from religious interest, and focused on private practice and building a new life without a supernatural substrate. This period lasted from 1970 to 1988, when William W. Meissner, SJ, MD, came to town to discuss his Psychoanalysis and Religious Experience (1984).

My psychoanalyst office partner would chair the meeting at the Jesuit University. Would I be part of the panel? No. Reconsider. No. Re-reconsider. Oh, all right. In the two months remaining, I read Meissner’s book three times and then read 4000 pages on religion and on religion and psychiatry. All of my previous work on the history of medicine and psychiatry, the courses at the institute, as well as previous religious knowledge came into play for my four-minute discussion. I had some anticipatory anxiety about this program, for childhood training never fully goes away. I was entering the “enemy’s lair.” Mormon scripture declares that all other (Christian) religions are man-made with abominable creeds and corrupt leaders. The Book of Mormon singles out

Page 79

 Roman Catholicism as the worst, declaring it to be (in language paralleling early 19th-century Protestantism) founded by the devil, “most abominable above all other churches,” slaying “the Saints of God,” corrupting the Bible, and filled with gold and silver, silks and scarlets, fine linens and harlots—all while seeking the “praise of the world.” In reality, of course, all the participants in the discussion with Meissner were fine people.

I was the one panelist challenging and critical, for I labeled Meissner’s book “scientific but not science,” focusing on the basic religious assumptions inherent in the book. (Science and academic history exclude supernatural explanations from consideration, limiting themselves to “sense” data that can be replicated. Belief in the supernatural is non-“sense”ical.) I quoted an early 20th-century Catholic theologian who disagreed with a naturalistic history of the witchcraft craze because it was “based on a false supposition in denying the existence of evil spirits, and consequently leads to wrong conclusions.” The tension in the air was palpable but Meissner defused it by a pleasant joke that brought relieving laughter from the audience.

What happened next changed my life. People, both known and unknown, told me I had “hit a home run,” “rung a bell,” and “dealt with the essentials.” These comments were followed by telephone calls from acquaintances expressing a more sober appreciation for my comments. I wondered whether, because I had some awareness of basic issues in religion and psychiatry, I could apply these abilities in understanding The Book of Mormon. Could I re-read The Book of Mormon as if the book was a patient on the couch? By this time, it was clear to non-Mormon historians and some non-believing or doubting Mormons that all searches for external evidence for this “divinely written” pre-Columbian American religious history had failed. As decades had passed, the Book showed evidence of being only a product of the early 19th-century American frontier. Reflections of U.S. religious and political conflicts of that day seemed clear. But I knew from psychiatric knowledge and practice that the Book had to reflect Joseph Smith’s personal experiences. And that had hardly been touched on by others. Further, the Book had to tell us something about his underlying personality. Was it a disguised autopsychobiography?

I took an explicitly naturalistic stance, discounted supernal claims, and set out to know who were the real-life persons behind the (fantasy) figures in the book. As has happened to others, a mental struggle suddenly gave way to stunning awareness and clarity. I not only realized from Joseph Smith’s life who the remarkably evil person at the start of the Book was (a doctor who operated without anesthesia on seven-year-old Joseph Smith’s leg became the drunk, thieving, and murderous sword-wielding Laban), I also realized, with much greater importance, the mental mechanisms and technique Joseph Smith used in changing his life story into The Book of Mormon stories. Now this hypothesis could be tested again and again throughout this book of 588 pages and 275,000 words covering a 1000-year period. It proved repeatedly valid. As one devout Mormon said to me, “It wasn’t the first or second time you pointed this out but the 13th or 14th time that it became convincing.” With awareness of Smith’s mental mechanisms (along with information such as court records and his mother’s biography of Joseph Smith) I could begin to understand him and place him into known psychiatric categories, particularly narcissism.

As my book progressed over a 10-year period and was published in 1999, I thought about my experiences with Meissner. In small dinner groups, as well as his writings, he had presented as a pleasant man of erudition, warmth, and excellent knowledge. I contacted him, asked for his review and help. He informed me of his forthcoming psychobiography of Ignatius (Ignatius of Loyola: The Psychology of a Saint, 1992), sent some of his 200 published papers along for assistance, read a preliminary draft of my book, and sent back a four-page single-spaced very useful critique. I was able to incorporate some of his suggestions as well as ideas and references from his book on Ignatius. When my book was published, he wrote a positive and insightful commentary for the back of the book.

Inside the Mind of Joseph Smith: Psychobiography and The Book of Mormon can be read on three psychological levels. At the foundation level, allegory, simile, and metaphor are used to parallel The Book of Mormon stories with his life. It is at this level that Smith’s mental techniques come into play and become the keys to unlock the parallels. These techniques are 1) reversal of misfortune and inferiority into the fantasy of conquest and superiority and 2) exaggeration of this fantasy into miracle.

For example, Joseph Smith was the fourth child of a man who claimed supernatural abilities

Page 80

and whose dreams the family considered visions. By the time he dictated this story, Joseph Smith had superseded his father as a “visionary.” But Joseph Smith and his family had been and were on the edge of poverty and sometimes hunger. They were viewed by their neighbors with amiable contempt as ineffectual and perhaps alcoholic. The Smith family had moved more than 10 times in a 16-year period, continually failing to find productive lives. Then they made one major move from New England to upstate New York in a wagon. At the time, 10-year-old Joseph was lame and weak from his previous leg surgery and treated in a contemptible and brutish fashion by others.

The Book of Mormon begins as if written by Nephi, the fourth child of a father with supernatural abilities and whose dreams are stated to be visions. Nephi is becoming a great prophet, even superseding his father. Similarly to the Smith family, The Book of Mormon family, under direction from God, had multiple small moves to and around the Red Sea extending over eight years (while living with miracles from God), and then one gigantic move by ship to the New World, all under divine guidance and emphasizing the spiritual righteous leadership, courage, and strength of Nephi in adversity.

At the second psychological level, Smith’s mental processes can be fit into known psychiatric categories, and labels, modified to his unusual characteristics, can be discussed. The third and highest abstract level is the discussion from the psychoanalytic literature, found in brief discussions and epigraphs throughout the book, and then emphasized in the last chapter, “Diagnosis and Commentary.”

Inside the Mind of Joseph Smith has now gone through a second printing (2001) but it has not jarred the Mormon establishment. The few reviews have varied from mixed to positive. The largest gratifying response has been in letters, e-mails, and telephone calls from a level of Mormons who knew enough to be troubled over the problems in early Mormonism. They included professors of history, psychology, and sociology; physicians; attorneys; and former and present Mormon Bishops and High Councilmen. Most had some degree of conflict stirred by the book and wondered, “What do I do now?”

Indeed. The book is historically incomplete for it ends with Joseph Smith’s life at the point The Book of Mormon was published. During the remaining 14 years of his life, he created the only truly successful American religion, now growing like wildfire. With the contradictions between his supernatural claims and documented history, and the complete failure to find any external evidence for The Book of Mormon, one might wonder why. So my book, which only begins to deal with the acceptance of The Book of Mormon and the formation of a culture, is psychologically incomplete. These issues I have tried to address in other papers and forums. But, incomplete and faulty or not, a psychoanalytic evaluation of The Book of Mormon and Joseph Smith has now been done.

Page 81

About the author

Robert D. Anderson

Robert D. Anderson, M.D., is a retired psychiatrist who lives in the Northwest. Following thirty years of private practice, he now does occasional temporary assignments with Native Americans and inner-city mental hygiene clinics. He is the author of Inside the Mind of Joseph Smith (1999) and of articles in Dialogue and the American Journal of Psychiatry. Dr. Anderson comes from devout Mormon background, has moved past поп-belief to somewhere between agnosticism and atheism, yet sees himself as willing to help the Church in its evolution from fringe cult to mainstream religion when it can tolerate public criticism from within and accept various degrees of belief in Joseph Smith from among its leaders. Dr. Anderson may be contacted at .

How to cite this article

Anderson, R. D. (2002). Reverse conversion: From Mormon devotion to depth inquiry of Joseph Smith. Clio’s Psyche, 9(2), 78-81.

https://doi.org/10.70763/1ddfa4ccdcea53130b500eaabb190e4b

PDF downloads