
Volume 19 - Number 3 - December 2012
Pages: 249 - 368
SPECIAL ISSUE PART III: SOME VETERANS BRINGING HOME THE VIOLENCE OF WAR
Barglow, P. (2012). Soldiers going berserk. Clio’s Psyche, 19(3), 286-289.
Soldiers Going Berserk
Abstract
In this article, the author considers sudden killings of civilians and fellow service members by U.S. military personnel, which have made the phrase going berserk a familiar media term. The author sketches the Norse Berserkers and the possible role of muscarine, notes the classification of going berserk in DSM-IV as a culture-bound syndrome synonymous with amok, and describes incidents including the 2009 shooting of 13 people at a Texas military base by Captain Hasan Nidal, the 2012 shooting of 16 Afghan civilians by Sergeant Robert Bales, and the 1968 My Lai massacre led by Lieutenant William Calley. The author also cites New York Times counts of killings by veterans of Iraq and Afghanistan. The author disputes the common attribution of such acts to war stress and post-traumatic stress disorder, questioning what PTSD research has yielded. The author instead points to alcohol and earlier brain injury in the Bales case, ideology and an impending deployment in the Nidal case, and, for Calley, speculates about a denial of inner emptiness. The author concludes that soldiers going berserk reflects a complex condition without a single cause, unrelated to any major psychiatric category, and proposes that ancient Greek myth and drama (Achilles, Cleomedes, Ajax, Heracles) offer fuller understanding.
domestic terrorism, “going berserk”, Hasan Nidal, homicide, post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD), psychohistory, substance dependence, United States military, veterans
Several shocking instances of a sudden slaughter of innocent civilians by U.S. military personnel during past years have made the expression “going berserk” a common media and household term. Historically viewed, Berserkers were Norse warriors who battled, often naked, in an uncontrollable, trance-like bestial fury first mentioned in Haraldskvaedi, a late 9th century skaldic poem. “Baresark” may refer to a thin shirt made from a bear pelt. The combatants possibly ingested the stimulant-hallucinogen muscarine, a natural ingredient of some mushrooms, which causes a loss of inhibitions similar to the result of alcohol in vulnerable individuals. Today, berserk behavior is considered on the boundary between heroism and insanity. But substance dependence remains important. From 2000 to 2006, half of the homicides in Australia involved alcohol consumption (Australian Institute of Criminology, 2009), a statistic mirrored by data from the U.S. and Canada.
In November 2009, Captain Hasan Nidal murdered 13 innocent persons at a Texas military base. His family reported that he had become a radical Muslim about a decade earlier, and many assumed his motivation was associated with radical nationalistic or religious ideology. Yet many journalists have downplayed the influence of a radical ideology in this incident. For example, Charles Krauthammer wrote, “Nidal is a criminal not a Muslim victim” (Washington Post, 2009) and Evan Thomas asked whether Nidal was “a ‘nut case’ or a Muslim fanatic” (Newsweek, 2009). This past March, Sergeant Robert Bales shot 16 Afghan civilians while intoxicated with alcohol. The press reported that he suffered from PTSD and in prior years might also have had a traumatic brain injury (TBI). Symptoms for TBI are protean, and treatment depends on the severity of brain injury. Afghan President Hamid Karzai called this event “intentional murder,” and the incident had international significance.
These notorious incidents have been replicated in miniature in recent years in individual murders committed by members of U.S. military forces. In 2009, three soldiers from Fort Carson’s
Page 286
Warrior Battalion Transition Unit murdered a fourth, Kevin Shields, whose death was featured in a PBS documentary named The Wounded Platoon. The murder was attributed to roadside war stress, too-frequent tours of duty, poor screening of recruits by the military, and care providers’ mistakes in medication management. On January 13, 2008, the New York Times counted 121 instances in which veterans of Iraq or Afghanistan killed relatives, other service members, or strangers after returning home from war. The Times article noted that such murders by soldiers without a prior criminal history occurred about twice as often during the six months after the 2001 U.S. invasion of Afghanistan than took place in the six months before. On March 23, 2012, Attorney Brocton Hunter, who specializes in the PTSD defense for veteran criminals, noted that “waves of veteran-committed crimes rise after every major military conflict.” Contemporary American military administrative leaders discourage killing sprees because they jeopardize the safety of our soldiers captured by enemy forces and may inhibit their defectors from joining our army (Dave Grossman, On Killing, 2009).
Most medical and journalistic commentary has attributed these recent incidents to war stress and trauma-induced PTSD. Earlier, Jonathon Shay noted that descriptions of the berserk state in Vietnam era soldiers were “beastlike, godlike, insatiable, frenzied, suspicious, revengeful, cruel, inhuman, and crazy.” Absent were prudent self-preservation, rational human appreciation, and realistic restraint. Shay speculated that a severe outbreak of berserk frenzy might generate a subsequent PTSD condition, not vice versa (Achilles in Vietnam, 1995, p. 98).
In psychiatry’s DSM-IV classification, “Going Berserk” is concluded to be a “Culture-Bound Syndrome” synonymous with “Amok.” It is considered a male illness accompanied by persecutory ideas, automatisms, amnesia, exhaustion, psychotic experiences, and dissociative reactions “precipitated by a perceived slight or insult.” Many of these typical symptoms are also found in the categories of Intermittent Explosive Disorder, in bipolar disorder’s “manic” pole of typical behavior, and in the category of Acute Stress Disorder. But PTSD, the popular diagnosis du jour, has been the most common medical psychiatric disorder associated with frenzied murderous rampages in recent history by experts and the
Page 287
American public.
PTSD was made a disease by the American Psychiatric Association in 1980. The term appeared in the New York Times 40 times as often from 2000 to 2010, than from 1980 to 2000. Hundreds of millions of dollars of brain and clinical research have been devoted to identify its cause, but have yielded no robust data, little understanding, and no help in formulating treatments (Barglow, Skeptical Inquirer, 2012). Instead of the muscarine perhaps used by Viking warriors, the size of the hippocampus brain structure and fluctuations in levels of the chemical substances like cortisol, epinephrine, norepinephrine, glutamine, and GABA have been hypothesized to link PTSD to violence. But there is little connection between PTSD and other American Psychiatric Association diagnostic categories with the violent murderous incidents summarized above. Sgt. Bales was intoxicated, suffered from alcoholic delirium, and had been brain damaged earlier. Captain Nidal had not been in combat, and his behavior was fueled both by a radical Muslim ideology and the threat of an assigned tour of overseas duty— not by the aftermath of war trauma.
The example of 2nd Lieutenant William Calley, the leader of a highly publicized 1968 massacre in Vietnam, offers additional information for understanding berserk behavior. (Although others may view him as simply following orders, this is not my assessment.) This massacre took place 44 years ago—before the discovery of PTSD—in the absence of terrorist ideology and without the influence of alcohol. Calley was a “bland young man burdened… with much ordinariness” who had “little cause for pride, inner security or self-esteem.” He elicited no respect from superiors or subordinates in the military and seemed bereft of any conviction or ideology. He failed seventh grade and dropped out of college before working as a bellhop and dishwasher (Douglas Linder, My Lai: An Account, 1999, p. 14). Yet he, too, ran amok. Could his rampage have been a way of denying a vast inner nothingness?
My conclusion is that the phenomenon of “soldiers going berserk” represents an enraged complex mental condition without a solitary cause. It is unrelated to any major psychiatric category or even directly to the emotional traumatic aftermath of warfare. Psychiatry and brain studies provide woefully inadequate explanations
Page 288
for amok sprees by soldiers. Are more satisfying answers to these puzzling and horrific episodes provided elsewhere? Yes, ancient Greek myths and drama are rich domains to search for replies to this query. What kind of human psychological pain and what intentions lead to lethal frenzies? In Homer’s writing, Achilles’ dishonorable mutilation of Hector’s corpse is attributed to enormous rage at the death of his foster brother Patroklos. But his behavior was preceded by a profound earlier period of self-destructive wrath at being deprived of a concubine that he was convinced he deserved for his proven valor.
The 492 BCE athlete Cleomedes of Astypalacea was accused and convicted of foul play that led to his murder of a boxing match opponent. He became “mad through grief” and (like Sampson) pulled down the pillar holding up a roof, killing 60 children. In Sophocles’ Ajax, the mythic hero becomes enraged when he fails to be presented Achilles’ armor as a reward for his valor. But the goddess Athena fooled him into murdering cattle and shepherds instead of Odysseus, who grabbed the prize. When he realized what he had done, these twin humiliations drove him to suicide. In Euripides’ Heracles, the protagonist, who miraculously survived the staggering battle stressors of his 12 labors, insanely murders his wife and children (Barglow and Murphy, American Journal of Psychiatry, 2011). He regains his sanity and survives through the empathic compassion of his friend Theseus, who provided him with rich gifts. Such ancient psychohistorical explorations can help us to make sense of the above senseless slaughters by soldiers through their artistic blending of universal truths with the uniqueness of a specific traumatic external environment.
Page 289
How to cite this article
Barglow, P. (2012). Soldiers going berserk. Clio’s Psyche, 19(3), 286-289.



