Volume 11 - Number 2 - September 2004
Pages: 33 - 76

PSYCHOLOGY OF ELECTION 2004
SPECIAL FEATURE

Barry, H. (2004). A second “JFK” presidency? Clio’s Psyche, 11(2), 51-52.

https://doi.org/10.70763/417fbbf2e9d5a28a855a11894b2e795a

A Second “JFK” Presidency?

article

Abstract

This article, part of the special feature on the psychology of the 2004 election, compares Democratic nominee John F. Kerry with President John F. Kennedy. The author sets out similarities in name, including shared first name and initials, and in political and biographical circumstances: Kerry’s support for Kennedy in 1960 at St. Paul’s School, service as junior Senator from Massachusetts, Roman Catholic affiliation, naval war records, lack of administrative experience, and campaign autobiographies (Profiles in Courage and A Call to Service). Differences in age, family, marriages, and health are also listed. The author proposes that a middle name reproducing the maternal family name, which Kennedy and Kerry share with several other presidents, may be associated with an emphasis on public service, presidential ambition, and appeal to female voters. The author also suggests that such presidents developed strong affiliation with their fathers. Rutherford B. Hayes, whose 1876–1877 election the author compares to that of George W. Bush in 2000, is offered as a precedent. The author views Kerry favorably and anticipates that he will be the next president.

Keywords:

2004 U.S. presidential election, George W. Bush, John F. Kennedy (JFK), John Kerry, presidential psychobiography, psychohistory, psychology, U.S. politics

People who share the same name usually feel mutually affiliated and are perceived by other people as closely connected. President George W. Bush, for example, is obviously associated with his father, former President George Herbert Walker Bush. Nevertheless, differences seem to be more prominent than similarities in the two Bush presidencies. The incumbent President Bush ardently hopes that his potential re-election will be one of the differences.

Senator John Forbes Kerry shares many similarities with President John Fitzgerald Kennedy. A seemingly trivial difference was noted in a recent letter in the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette. The writer stated that she was too young to vote for JFK for President in 1960 and that she intended to vote for “JFK” for President this year.

John F. Kerry for a long time has been aware that he shares the same first name and the same three initials with John F. Kennedy, as well as the same liberal values and internationalist approach to the world. In 1960, Kerry supported Kennedy for president, contrary to the sentiments of most of the other students at his boarding school, St. Paul’s School in Concord, New Hampshire. Kerry met Kennedy briefly a couple of times while Kennedy was President because Kerry was dating Janet Auchincloss, the half-sister of Jacqueline Kennedy. Kerry deeply grieved the assassination of Kennedy.

Presidential nominees Kerry and Kennedy differ in some important respects. Kerry is older, has had a longer political career, and his parents died prior to his run for the presidency. Unlike Kennedy, he divorced and remarried, and his second wife is older, richer, and born abroad, in contrast to Jacqueline Kennedy. Kerry’s recent prostate surgery is better publicized and a less severe health problem than Kennedy’s Addison’s Disease.

Kerry and Kennedy are similar in important respects. Both were Democratic nominees for the presidency two years after being re-elected to the U. S. Senate. It was the first re-election for Kennedy, the third for Kerry. Both were the Junior Senator from Massachusetts. The Senior Senator from Massachusetts was Republican Leverett Saltonstall for Kennedy, Democratic Ted Kennedy for Kerry. Both candidacies for president featured their status as war heroes and their Democratic Party affiliation. The religious membership of both is the Roman Catholic Church. Both wrote campaign autobiographies, Kennedy’s Profiles in Courage (1956, during his bid for the vice presidency, reissued in paperback in 1960 during his presidential campaign) and Kerry’s A Call to Service (2004), stressing service to the country. Both were decorated naval heroes who lacked administrative experience prior to running for the presidency.

A potentially influential similarity between Kennedy and Kerry is that the middle name of both is the maternal family name. Mother Rose Fitzgerald was daughter of a popular Mayor of Boston. Mother Rosemary Forbes was a member of a wealthy and prestigious family. That similarity may have contributed to their emphasis on public service, ambition for the presidency, and popularity among female voters.

The maternal family name was reproduced in the middle name of several presidents of the United States. In addition to Kennedy, they were James Knox Polk, Rutherford Birchard Hayes, Thomas Woodrow Wilson, Franklin Delano Roosevelt, Lyndon Baines Johnson, Richard Milhous Nixon, Ronald Wilson Reagan, and George Herbert Walker Bush. Biographies of these presidents, who generally exhibited emphasis on public service, indicate special affiliation and similarity of traits between the president and his mother’s family.

Sons share the surname in addition to the gender of their father. Presidents whose middle name reproduced the maternal surname generally also developed strong affiliation with the father. President Kennedy imitated the compulsive adul-

Page 51

tery of his father. John Kerry imitates the intellect and emotional restraint of his father.

John Forbes Kerry’s first name reproduces the middle name of his father, Richard John Kerry. A presidential precedent for dual maternal and paternal names is Rutherford Birchard Hayes. Born after the death of his father, Rutherford Hayes, Rutherford B. Hayes was a heroic Major General in the Civil War. The circumstances of his election as President in 1876-1877 were closely similar to those of George W. Bush in 2000. The inaugural address by Hayes stated that he owed his election to the “zealous labors of a political party” but that “he serves his party best who serves the country best.” His highly conscientious, honest, conciliatory, and peaceful presidency is potentially an admirable precedent for John Forbes Kerry, who I anticipate will be our next president.

Page 52

About the author

Herbert Barry III

Herbert Barry III, PhD, educated in psychology at Harvard and Yale, taught at the University of Connecticut prior to serving as a research and psychology professor at the University of Pittsburgh for 38 years. He served as President of the International Psychohistorical Association, is a Research Associate of the Psychohistory Forum, and is a proud member of MENSA. He has published 100s of articles with presidents and their birth order among his specialties. Dr. Barry may be contacted at .

How to cite this article

Barry, H. (2004). A second “JFK” presidency? Clio’s Psyche, 11(2), 51-52.

https://doi.org/10.70763/417fbbf2e9d5a28a855a11894b2e795a

PDF downloads