Volume 01 - Number 4 - March 1995
Pages: 1 - 21

MISCELLENOUS ARTICLES

Barry, H. III. (1995). Will the 1996 presidential election resemble 1948? Clio’s Psyche, 1(4), 3-4.

https://doi.org/10.70763/033cc385728c51d97360020ed57776f0

Will the 1996 Presidential Election Resemble 1948?

article

Abstract

In this article, the author compares Bill Clinton’s prospects in the 1996 presidential election with Harry Truman’s in 1948, writing in early 1995 after the Republican victories in both houses of Congress in November 1994. He maintains that Clinton’s reelection is more probable than Truman’s was at the equivalent point in 1947. He cites precedent: nine of twelve earlier presidents who sought reelection after defeating a predecessor or a member of the predecessor’s party won, while only four of nine vice-presidents who succeeded through death or resignation won the next election. The author contrasts Clinton’s ambitious initiatives and willingness to compromise with the Republican Congress with Truman’s denunciation of Congress and rejection of its domestic program. He also proposes that Democrats will be more united behind Clinton, and that the Republicans are unlikely to field a candidate as well known as Thomas Dewey. He concludes that Clinton is likely to be president as the second millennium begins.

Keywords:

1996 U.S. presidential election, Bill Clinton, Colin Powell, domestic policies, Dwight D. Eisenhower, foreign policies, Harry S. Truman, inflation, leadership, military, national unity, psychohistory, public opinion polls, Strom Thurmond

President Clinton in early 1995 is way down in the public opinion polls and has received much of the blame for the Republican victory in both houses of Congress in the election of November, 1994. The 1996 presidential election, for which Clinton has already announced his candidacy, promises to be similar to that of 1948. In that year, Truman had low popularity ratings and was widely blamed for the Republicans’ gaining the majority in both houses of Congress in 1946. Yet, Truman was reelected in 1948, contrary to the predictions of most public opinion polls. I believe that in early 1995, the reelection of Clinton is more probable than was the reelection of Truman at the equivalent time, early 1947. Clinton’s advantages are based on his presidential situation and on his style of leadership.

Clinton in 1996 will be the 13th president who becomes his party’s candidate for reelection four years after winning the election against his predecessor or against a member of his predecessor’s party. The election was won by nine of his 12 predecessors who were in the same situation. Voters usually give a second term to a president who replaced a president of the opposing party. Truman was one of nine vice-presidents who became president because of the death or resignation of his predecessor. Only four of these presidents, including the only president from Missouri, were their party’s nominee and the winner of the next election.

Clinton’s presidential leadership is both assertive and conciliatory. He proposes ambitious, idealistic initiatives but is willing to cooperate and compromise with the Republican majorities in Congress. He tries to regain the allegiance of Democrats who have recently voted for Republicans.

Truman’s aggressive leadership and rejection of the Republican domestic program antagonized many voters. Many people have attributed Truman’s election in 1948 to his aggressive denunciations of the “do nothing Republican Congress” and Dewey’s appeals for national unity and conciliation. In my opinion, Truman would have won by a larger margin if he had been more conciliatory or if Dewey had been more aggressive.

The winner of the 1996 presidential election will depend partly on events from early 1995 until late 1996. I believe that Truman’s defiantly liberal domestic policies impaired his popularity during the corresponding interval from early 1947 to late 1948. There were serious efforts to deny him the Democratic nomination for president. General Eisenhower probably would have won the Democratic nomination if he had been willing to accept it. Many Democrats supported Thurmond, the States’ Rights “Dixiecrat” candidate, or Wallace, the Progressive candidate. General Eisenhower probably would have been elected if he had sought and won the Republican nomination in 1948 instead of 1952. Dewey was probably the strongest alternative Republican nominee.

Clinton appears to be in a more advantageous position. His domestic policies should help to maintain slow growth of productivity and inflation. His foreign policies should promote peaceful settlement of disputes. If a crisis requires military intervention by the United States, such an action should increase Clinton’s popularity. Compared to Harry Truman’s situation, in 1996 the Democrats

Page 3

should be more united behind Clinton, even if Jesse Jackson becomes an independent candidate for president. General Colin Powell is an unlikely possibility for the role of General Eisenhower. The Republicans are unlikely to nominate a candidate as well-known and as acceptable to voters as was Dewey. Thus, despite the best efforts of the pundits to politically bury our only president from Arkansas, the “man from Hope” is likely to be president as we reach the second millennium.

Page 4

About the author

Herbert Barry III

Herbert Barry III, PhD, educated in psychology at Harvard and Yale, taught at the University of Connecticut prior to serving as a research and psychology professor at the University of Pittsburgh for 38 years. He served as President of the International Psychohistorical Association, is a Research Associate of the Psychohistory Forum, and is a proud member of MENSA. He has published 100s of articles with presidents and their birth order among his specialties. Dr. Barry may be contacted at .

How to cite this article

Barry, H. III. (1995). Will the 1996 presidential election resemble 1948? Clio’s Psyche, 1(4), 3-4.

https://doi.org/10.70763/033cc385728c51d97360020ed57776f0

PDF downloads