
Volume 07 - Number 3 - December 2000
Pages: 102 - 164
Barry, H., III. (2000). Election 2000 hindsight. Clio’s Psyche, 7(3), 155-156.
Election 2000 Hindsight
Abstract
In this article, the author offers an assessment of the 2000 U.S. presidential election contest between George W. Bush and Al Gore, submitted on November 10, 2000. The author sets out three influences, in order of importance, for each of four outcomes. Bush’s victory is attributed to voter desire for change after eight years of one party’s presidency, greater Republican campaign spending, and Bush’s personal appeal and campaign slogan. Gore’s defeat is attributed to public perceptions of his character linked to his association with President Clinton, Ralph Nader’s candidacy (notably in Florida), and voters’ perception of him as serious and controlled, with his achievements creating distance from some voters. Gore’s near victory is attributed to his position as incumbent Vice President during national prosperity, his record in public office, and his populist campaign. Bush’s near defeat is attributed to his brief record, proposals the author says favor the wealthy, and his Texas Republican identity in opposition to federal intervention. The author adds that smaller factors, such as Gore’s selection of Joe Lieberman as running mate, also mattered. The author characterizes these influences as group fantasy among voters rather than psychobiography, then notes similarities in the candidates’ backgrounds and describes contrasting psychological patterns in each, traced to family relationships. The author predicts that Democrats will win Congress in 2002 and the Presidency in 2004, with Gore again facing Bush.
Al Gore, George W. Bush, group psychology, psychohistory, psychological differences, U.S. presidential election
The election of George W. Bush instead of Al Gore as President of the United States is a single choice that will make a large difference for many aspects of national life from tax cuts to Supreme Court appointments. This essay identifies three influences that are the most important reasons (in order) for each of four results: victory for Bush, defeat for Gore, almost victory for Gore, and almost defeat for Bush. [Editor’s Note: Article was submitted November 10.]
Why Bush Won. (1) The voters tend to desire a change after eight or more years of the Presidency by the same individual or party. This desire is consistent with the election of Clinton in 1992, Carter in 1976, Nixon in 1968, and Kennedy in 1960. The desire was especially strong because of the highly publicized sexual misbehavior by President Clinton. (2) Much more money was spent on the Republican than Democratic campaign. The Republicans therefore could afford more publicity and paid personnel. (3) Bush displayed a gregarious, friendly personality. His broad appeal was reinforced by his slogan, “compassionate conservative.” He attracted votes from many Democrats and Independents.
Why Gore Lost. (1) He is generally regarded as deceitful and politically opportunistic. These characteristics were attributed to him mainly because of his association with President Clinton. (2) Nader as an active candidate for President attracted a substantial number of votes from Gore, including in Florida, where Gore would otherwise have won the state’s electoral votes and thereby the election. Gore also needed to counteract Nader by emphasizing environmental and liberal issues that alienated conservative voters. (3) Gore is viewed as excessively serious and controlled. His outstanding intelligence and achievements established a barrier between him and some voters. The majority of voters probably felt closer identification with George W. Bush, who is more gregarious and intellectually limited.
Why Gore Almost Won. (1) He is the incumbent Vice President during a time of prolonged national prosperity and growth. He has participated prominently in the Clinton administration, and was supported by President Clinton. (2) He is highly intellectual with a background of major achievements. For the past 24 years he was successively a U. S. Congressman, Senator, and Vice President. (3) He campaigned for President primarily as a populist, appealing to the larger number of Democrats than Republicans and to the many disadvantaged people who have been left behind by the national prosperity.
Why Bush Almost Lost. (1) His political and other accomplishments are rather brief and meager. His emphasis on social skills is accompanied by a public impression that his intellect is mediocre. (2) His proposals favor the wealthy few and therefore are unpopular with the majority of voters. (3) His emphatic identity as a Texas Re-
Page 155
publican who opposes federal government interventions antagonized many voters in the Northern cities.
Many more variables contributed to the difference between victory and defeat in the extremely close election. I believe they were smaller or less general influences. An example is Gore’s choice of Joe Lieberman, an observant Jew, as his Vice Presidential candidate. This decision almost won the electoral votes of Florida and helped in many other states. The combination of a Christian and Jewish nominee was attractive to ecumenically-oriented people of all religions in addition to voters who advocate strict separation of the federal government from the Christian church. On the other hand, anti-Semitic Southerners might have contributed to Bush’s victory in all the Southern states.
The foregoing influences mainly refer to group fantasy or group psychohistory of the voters rather than to the psychobiography or psychohistory of the two candidates. In some respects the rivals are similar. Both are the first son and namesake of a politically prominent father. Both have a strong and prosperous family background. Both campaigns were planned and conducted with the benefit of expert advisors and many public opinion polls. Both candidates made very few mistakes.
There are notable psychological differences between the rivals. A dominant defense mechanism of Bush is denial of grief, anxiety, and guilt. One of the origins was the death of his younger sister from leukemia when he was seven years old. He became closely bonded with his grieving mother and developed a pattern of sociability, humor, and leadership. Symptoms of his denial include mediocre academic performance and self-destructive alcohol consumption. His emotional adjustment is fragile, but his self-control is strong, indicated by his decision to abstain from alcohol following his 40th birthday.
A dominant defense mechanism of Gore is compartmentalization of his personality. In different situations he is an ambitious politician, zealous scholar, loyal subordinate, introspective philosopher, devoted husband and father, and hedonistic prankster. He loyally but ambivalently strives to conform to the desires of his late father, who was loving but strict and demanding. His compartmentalized personality accounts for the erroneous public perception of him as changeable and unstable.
Future elections will be affected by the very narrow electoral vote victory of George W. Bush despite the very narrow popular vote victory of Al Gore. With the continuation of small Republican majorities in the U.S. Senate and House of Representatives, members of the Republican Bush Administration will probably try to exploit their control of the federal government, without cooperating with the Democrats. The opposition Democratic Party will be angry and energized to win control of Congress and the White House in future elections, compensating for Gore’s defeat this year. I therefore predict that the Democrats will win majorities in the Senate and House of Representatives in 2002 and the Presidency in 2004, and that Al Gore as the Democratic nominee for President in 2004 will again have the opportunity to defeat George W. Bush.
Page 156
How to cite this article
Barry, H., III. (2000). Election 2000 hindsight. Clio’s Psyche, 7(3), 155-156.



