Volume 23 - Number 1 - Fall 2016
Pages: 1 - 101

THE PSYCHOLOGY OF ELECTION 2016

Barry, H., III (2016). Voting for global welfare or America first. Clio’s Psyche, 23(1), 34-37.

https://doi.org/10.70763/e1021d43911ca2c1845910d84f40aeae

Voting for Global Welfare or America First

article

Abstract

This article contrasts Democratic support for global welfare with Republican emphasis on national military supremacy and American exceptionalism in the 2016 U.S. presidential race between Hillary Clinton and Donald Trump. Drawing analogies to the 1964 Johnson-Goldwater and 1940 Roosevelt-Willkie elections, the author predicts Clinton’s victory, citing her moderate positioning, party unity, and Trump’s polarizing traits, while noting economic conditions, climate change evidence, and potential terrorism as variables that could alter the outcome.

Keywords:

American exceptionalism, Donald Trump, global welfare, Hillary Clinton, national military supremacy, psychohistory, psychology of the election, U.S. elections

Democrats generally support global welfare, expressed by efforts to protect the environment, counteract global warming, promote international cooperation, and strengthen the activities of the United Nations. Republicans generally support national military supremacy and American exceptionalism, expressed by Donald Trump’s repetitious promise to make America great again.

The cycle of a presidential election every four years differ-

Page 34

entiates the United States from parliamentary government, such as in Canada, the United Kingdom, and Germany. The 2016 presidential election features a contest between Democrat Hillary Rodham Clinton, whose national prominence began as the wife of former President Bill Clinton, and Donald J. Trump, a real estate developer who became a billionaire and host of a popular television show “The Apprentice.”

Predictions are perilous. Casey Stengel, successful manager of the New York Yankees baseball team for many years, said, “I never make predictions, especially about the future.” Nevertheless, in June 2016 I predict that Hillary Clinton will be elected President of the United States in November 2016.

Prediction of the future can be aided by comparisons with similar past situations. The presidential election most similar to 2016 might be 1964. Democratic Vice President, Lyndon B. Johnson, became President because of the assassination of President Kennedy in 1963. In common with Hillary Clinton, Lyndon Johnson represented affiliation with the recent past. The Republican nominee, Barry Goldwater, was perceived as a conservative extremist because of his militant foreign policy during the Cold War against the Soviet Union. He also advocated reducing the activities of the federal government and defending states’ rights. President Johnson successfully portrayed himself as moderate instead of extremist in foreign policy. He persuaded Congress to approve a civil rights bill in July 1964, four months before the presidential election; Goldwater voted against the bill. Johnson thereby won the votes of most African Americans. Goldwater won the electoral votes of his state, Arizona, and only five southern states: Alabama, Georgia, Louisiana, Mississippi, and South Carolina.

An earlier comparison is the presidential election of 1940. Democratic President Franklin D. Roosevelt sought an unprecedented third elected term. His Republican opponent, Wendell Willkie, in common with Donald Trump, had been a business executive rather than a politician. Willkie was an internationalist but many Republicans and a substantial minority of Democrats were isolationists, believing in “America first” and adamantly opposing military involvement in Europe while Hitler’s armies conquered Denmark, Norway, Luxembourg, Holland, Belgium, France, and threatened England. Incumbent Roosevelt won by a large margin. This comparison of candidates’ backgrounds and foreign policy positions favors Democrat Hillary Rodham Clinton, the ally of

Page 35

Democrat President Obama.

Constitutional Amendment 22, limiting the President to two elected terms, was ratified in 1951. Since then, the elections of 2000 and 2016 have been the only ones in which Democratic presidents have been ineligible incumbents. In 2000, President Bill Clinton obviously favored Al Gore, his vice president. In 2016, President Barack Obama favors Hillary Rodham Clinton, his principal opponent for the Democratic presidential nomination in 2008 and his Secretary of State in the subsequent four years.

The Republican nominee in 2000, George W. Bush, was the Governor of Texas and the first child of former Republican President George H. W. Bush. George W. Bush was a very sociable person who gained the support of most Republicans. In 2016, Donald J. Trump is highly egotistic, even narcissistic, flaunts his earned wealth and has insulted most of his rival presidential candidates. His controversial proposals include a high wall separating the United States from Mexico, forcing Mexico to pay for it, deporting 11 million undocumented immigrants, and other international interventions to “make America great again.” Many women disapprove of him. Hillary Clinton has the probable advantage of potentially being the first female President of the United States.

In 2000, Democratic presidential nominee Al Gore, in addition to many other Democrats, disapproved of President Bill Clinton’s sexual behavior with Monica Lewinsky. This sexual behavior was obviously the reason for President Clinton’s impeachment by the Republican majority in the House of Representatives. Gore was defeated by a small and controversial five-vote margin in the Electoral vote (271-266), although he won the popular vote. In 2016, I expect that Hillary Clinton will lead a unified Democratic party. Many Republicans are adamantly opposed to Donald Trump. Hillary Clinton will win if she slightly exceeds the 0.5% margin of popular votes over Trump that Gore (48.4%) obtained over Bush (47.9%). I expect that Hillary Clinton will obtain a much larger margin of votes over Trump.

Influential variables might affect the outcome of the election. One might be the condition of the national economy. Continuing economic recovery would benefit Hillary Clinton. A new collapse, or rapid inflation, of the United States dollar before November 2016, would benefit Donald Trump. Convincing proof of global warming caused by recent human activities, which is denied by

Page 36

 many Republican elected officials, would favor Hillary Clinton. A successful terrorist attack in the United States would favor Donald Trump.

Page 37

About the author

Herbert Barry III

Herbert Barry III, PhD, educated in psychology at Harvard and Yale, taught at the University of Connecticut prior to serving as a research and psychology professor at the University of Pittsburgh for 38 years. He served as President of the International Psychohistorical Association, is a Research Associate of the Psychohistory Forum, and is a proud member of MENSA. He has published 100s of articles with presidents and their birth order among his specialties. Dr. Barry may be contacted at .

How to cite this article

Barry, H., III (2016). Voting for global welfare or America first. Clio’s Psyche, 23(1), 34-37.

https://doi.org/10.70763/e1021d43911ca2c1845910d84f40aeae

PDF downloads