Volume 20 - Number 1 - June 2013
Pages: 1 - 125

THE PSYCHOLOGICAL MEANING AND USES OF HUMOR

Beisel, D. R. (2013). Humor as a psychohistorical source. Clio’s Psyche, 20(1), 69-76.

https://doi.org/10.70763/7230b2b03e2da37352abf1a659545b44

Humor as a Psychohistorical Source

article

Abstract

In this article, the author argues that historians and psychohistorians should treat humor as a source, making the case through assembled examples rather than a stated framework. He observes that the historical profession seldom produces or studies jokes. He contends that a biographical subject’s attitude toward humor, including reactions to jokes aimed at the subject, can help fill out a portrait, and he cites Lyndon Johnson, John F. Kennedy, and Hitler in this connection. He also points to puns, slips, and one-liners about leaders, and to family roles such as the comic. Turning to groups, he proposes that shifts in the styles and subjects of jokes indicate the preoccupations of social classes and ages, from the Enlightenment to the 1960s, and suggests that search and social media trends might track the moods of large groups. He is admiring of Alan Dundes’s psychoanalytic study of German national character through folklore, Life Is Like a Chicken Coop Ladder, and disputes historians’ reluctance to speak of group character. He reads the absence of jokes about Pearl Harbor and 9/11 as a sign of persistent traumatic memory. He contends that the Third Reich suppressed jokes about Hitler while Allied cartoons, films, and songs ridiculed him as a defense against collective fear, and he describes Holocaust and gallows humor as a means of coping. He concludes that neglecting humor overlooks part of what it means to be human, and he urges psychologically oriented historians to mine it, eventually including the humor of psychohistory.

Keywords:

American Historical Review (AHR), humor, psychohistory, psychology, Schadenfreude, World War II (WWII)

Individual historians can be hilarious as private individuals, but when it comes to their publications and public personas they are deadly serious. I wonder if the staid American Historical Review has ever published a joke in its 118-year history.

The dour nature of the historical profession—except for those marginalized scholars studying humor as part of popular culture—is reflected in the fact that while a seemingly endless supply of jokes exists for virtually every field of human endeavor, from psychiatry to bartending to plumbing, I’ve yet to come across more than two jokes from historians about historians. The first is by the editor of this journal who said: “When historians meet they say, ‘Hi, what’s old?’” The second one I’m about to cite.

Overheard at an American Historical Association convention sometime in the late 1970s, “A group of inebriated scholars return to their hotel room after a night of heavy drinking and encounter a chambermaid going off duty. When they invite her back to their room for a drink she asks, ‘What group is this?’ ‘The American Hish-torical Association’ is the slurred reply. ‘I’m asking,” she says, ‘because most convention groups invite me back to their room for sex.’” What this reveals about the psychology of historians I leave for others to decide.

“Jokes” specifically directed against psychohistorians began in earnest in the late 1970s when the first wave of major criticisms from outsiders began systematic efforts to discredit the field. Among them was the familiar, tired, but inevitable, “Psychohistory—the history of psychos,” or, “That’s the theory in a nutshell, where it belongs,” or the uncaptioned New Yorker cartoon showing a door labeled, “Psychohistory Ward.”

Page 69

Historians do sometimes include references to humor in their studies, most often to enliven their narratives, though humor can provide considerable insight into a biographer’s subject. Sometime back in the early 1980s, I remember reading a psychoanalytic article entitled, “The Favorite Joke as a Diagnostic Tool.” What is valuable in clinical practice could also shed light on a historian’s biographical subject if used judiciously and in conjunction with a host of other evidence.

But if we can’t find our subject’s favorite joke in the documents (today’s favored joke is tomorrow’s stale memory), it is still important to know how our historical subjects think and feel about humor in general, whether they prefer clever witticisms to slapstick, practical jokes to puns, and how they react to humor directed at themselves. Lyndon Johnson had a particularly thin skin when it came to humorous criticisms hurled at his persona and policies, while JFK was able to invite the occasional pundit to the White House for dinner. It is well known that Hitler could laugh at all kinds of jokes—except political jokes and dirty jokes, which may be the most important ones behind understanding what made him tick.

These observations seem like common sense, yet historians often overlook the obvious. Keeping alert for humorous tidbits may profit biographers in delineating parts of the puzzles they confront in their ongoing efforts to build more complete pictures of the historical persons they are working on. This includes the role parents have delegated their children to play in their families of origin.

Family dynamics may reveal much about which child is the favored one, who is the delegated hell-raiser, which one is the diplomat, who is the nerd, who is the jock, who is the quiet one, or who is the comic. My father and his five siblings shared a pool of common humor, yet each specialized in their own comic style: one favored wry comments, another puns, a third dirty jokes, a fourth excelled at visuals, a fifth at Don-Rickels-like put-downs.

Psychohistorians more than historians will want to pay special attention to the humor in puns, malapropos, Freudian slips, and mock Freudian slips. A good example of the latter comes from Bobby Kennedy. When asked if he was going to challenge Lyndon

Page 70

Johnson for the presidency he said, “I have no designs on the White House, and neither does my wife, Ethel Bird.”

It hardly needs mentioning that there exists an endless supply of one-liners ridiculing leaders, natural targets for displaced hostility toward authority. Mort Saul on the presidential election: “Al Haig is throwing his helmet into the ring”; Israeli Premier Golda Meir to Israeli military hero Moshe Dayan: “Don’t be so modest. You’re not that important”; Winston Churchill on Ernest Bevin, “A sheep in sheep’s clothing”; and Dwight Eisenhower on General MacArthur, “I studied theatrics with him for twelve years.”

Psychological historians know that denial can sometimes cover hidden affirmations and self-deceptions. In a late-December 1941 visit to the White House, British Prime Minister Winston Churchill, standing stark naked in the privacy of his room, was suddenly taken by surprise as FDR came through the door, prompting Churchill’s famous line, “You see, Mr. President, I have nothing to hide,” though there may be more here than meets the eye.

Humor can also be used in assessing the psychology of groups. A few mainstream historians have successfully utilized shifts in styles of humor to highlight the preoccupations of a particular social class or capture the tone of a particular age. I am thinking here of the 18th-century Enlightenment, a time of change when philosophes were trying “to change the general way of thinking,” effectively using satire and witty aphorisms as instruments of reform. We are only partly wrong in our image of all Parisians waiting expectantly for the latest bon mot from Voltaire.

One thinks also of the 1960s, when the use of satire was once more a force for social and political change, from the outrageous Lenny Bruce whose pioneering irreverence set the stage for much that followed, to the African-American and female stand-up comics of the counterculture who broke new ground in the civil rights and feminist movements.

The many psychological functions of humor have, of course, been extensively studied by psychologists and humorists, including Freud, and a good deal is known about them—the role of Schadenfreude, the leveling function of bringing down the high and mighty, the pleasure of displacing onto container groups one’s own

Page 71

projected vulnerabilities, and how that feeds our group sense of superiority, promotes cohesion, and reinforces stereotyping.

Nowadays, with Google Search, Twitter trends, and other programs, it may be possible to track the shifting moods, the conscious, semi-conscious, and unconscious attitudes and fantasies of large groups by tracing trends in the type of jokes circulating at any given moment. When plotted over time it may mean something psychologically significant about how a particular age cohort or social class or nation is feeling if we detect a sudden surge in the popularity of dead baby jokes, or of apocalyptic humor, or Helen Keller jokes, or “retard” jokes, or disaster jokes, or leader jokes, or jokes about Chinese efforts to poison the West. Shifts in humor may allow us to trace demographic trends as well, as in the not surprising proliferation of jokes and cartoons about the physical, psychological, and sexual consequences of aging that flood our daily emails, a witness to an ever-enlarging aging population trying to find ways to manage anxieties about illness and death.

For decades, historians have been told that statements about national character should be avoided (though they often place judgments about it into their work anyway, often unawares). Anthropologists are more adept at capturing the total way of life of a people and have done a better job in integrating a culture’s sense of humor into their studies. Chief among these is Alan Dundes’ Life Is Like a Chicken Coop Ladder: A Study of German National Character Through Folklore (1984). A brilliant study, Dundes’ psychoanalytic analysis correctly connects the deep and widespread scatological obsession of German humor and its preoccupation with feces to anal fixations brought on by the widespread practice of harsh and too-early toilet training. (See the June 2005 issue [Volume 12. No. 1] of this journal for a memorial to Dundes (1934-2005) by Howard Stein, and for Dundes’ posthumous article, “Sacrilegious Folk Humor,” prepared by his longtime co-author Carl Pagter.)

Despite what historians assert, there is something to the notion of “group character,” especially when it comes to identifying it through humor. We intuitively understand there is a unique, perhaps indefinable quality to Irish humor, to African American humor, to Jewish humor. Bel Kaufman, the 100-year-old granddaughter of Jewish author Sholem Aleichem, begins her course on

Page 72

Jewish humor at Hunter College (CUNY) with a joke. “The Frenchman says: ‘I am tired and thirsty. I must have wine.’ The German says: ‘I am tired and thirsty. I must have beer.’ The Jew says: ‘I am tired and thirsty. I must have diabetes’” (New York Times, May 11, 2011).

No need to try to dissect this one. It brilliantly captures the essence of Jewish humor by exposing the self-deprecating, I’ll-undermine-myself-before-you-do, ever looking-on the-dark side, underdog position, resisting and reflecting the outcome of 2,000 years of persecution, brilliantly reinforcing the partial-truths of three stereotypes in the bargain.

Sometimes daring, unexpected crossovers may steal from one culture to make a point in another and become a powerful political tool, as in the way the most famous line of stand-up Borsch-Belt comedian Henny Youngman (“Take my wife, please!”) has been expropriated by a young stand-up Palestinian-American comic, Dean Obbeidallah, “Take my land, please!” (New York Times, March 5, 2013, A20)

While it is important for historians to recognize the importance of the kind of humor predominant in a group, it is also important for them to note when humor is absent. There are no jokes about Pearl Harbor, for example, and only one or two about 9/11, which suggests the deep pain of persistent traumatic memories lasting more than a decade, or even over several generations.

Other than traumatic reasons why humor may be obliterated exist, too. Members of the Einsatzgruppen death squads sent to murder Jews, communists, and intellectuals in Poland might find it hilarious when a comrade’s sleeve was splattered with the brains of the child he has just murdered (Goldhagen, Hitler’s Willing Executioners, 1996), but when it came to self-observation, the Nazis were woefully incapable of laughing at themselves. In the Third Reich, anyone who risked telling a Hitler joke was systematically denounced and imprisoned. The same fate befell cabaret performers who playfully taught their trained monkeys to give the Hitler salute at the end of their act. It was only later in World War II, when the war was being lost, that dark humor came to Germany, used as a way of coping with the war’s traumas.

Page 73

The Allies were the first to make fun of Hitler and the Nazis, doing so long before World War II began. Look, for example, at the superb intuitive and psychologically sophisticated political cartoons produced by David Low in the British press. In 1939, Fritz Kuhn, the Bundesfuehrer of the pro-Nazi German American Bund, was arrested on charges of grand larceny in New York, inspiring newspaper headlines announcing the arrest of “the Hotsy-Totsy Nazi.” A famous sequence in Charlie Chaplin’s film, The Great Dictator (1940), captures the “Führer” dancing with a large balloon of the world. Hitler was enraged.

Things accelerated when war broke out. A 1942 New Yorker cartoon finds Hitler addressing the Nazi-filled Reichstag: “I think I can say, without fear of contradiction”

That same year, Spike Jones and his City Slickers recorded a novelty song, “The Führer’s Face,” which became a wildly popular hit in 1943. “Ven der Führer says, ‘Vee is der Master Race,’ vee say, ‘Heil!’ (pfut!), ‘Heil!’ (pfut!), right in der Führer’s face. Not to love der Führer is a great disgrace. Vee go, ‘Heil!’ (pfut!), ‘Heil!’ (pfut!), right in der Führer’s face.”

The song figured prominently in Disney’s nine-minute animated Donald Duck cartoon, originally titled “Donald’s Nightmare,” which won the Academy Award for Best Animated Short Feature in 1944. Warner Brothers’ seven-minute animated cartoon joined in the fun, sans song, with “Daffy Duck—The Commando.”

Such devaluing of Hitler and the Nazis through ridicule was a psychological defense, designed to disarm the intense collective fear generated by Hitler and the Nazis.

World War II’s humor came in all forms and was expressed in numerous ways. One issue for the U.S., as for all the belligerents, was how to control sexual energy unleashed by military service, war, and threats of death. There was also the related problem of how to channel sexual energy into the war effort. One clever way was the cute limerick spontaneously created in the U.S. by “Anonymous”:

To back the attack
Don’t sack with a Wac

Page 74

Or lie on the breast of a Wave.
Just sit in the sand
And do it by hand,
And buy bonds with the money you save.
(J.P. O’Neil, personal communication)

World War II’s humor also encompassed what is called “Holocaust Humor,” a deeply divisive issue for scholars and one that reared its head during the 2013 Academy Awards. It may be unseemly to make jokes about six million Jewish dead, not to mention the other millions of victims of Nazism, but the historian committed to reconstructing the past cannot overlook the extraordinary examples of gallows humor circulating in the Jewish communities of Europe, in the death camps, and among the starving millions in Leningrad before, during, and after the war. It has been suggested that there is some doubt about the phrase “gallows humor” (Galgenhumor) these days since the abolition of hanging in the U.S. has meant it no longer holds much meaning to a younger generation and—dark humor about dark humor—should be replaced by the phrase “lethal-injection humor” (William F. Kluckas, personal communication).

Yet, as historian Joseph Dorinson and others have shown, humor can be used as a coping and healing mechanism, especially for oppressed groups. In that spirit, I close with a decidedly painful joke circulating in Hungary in the days immediately following the end of the war.

To set the historical stage, people returned from the camps to nothing. Their homes and business had been expropriated or destroyed. Strangers were living and working there. For many, not a single member of their family remained on the continent and whole communities had disappeared, along with villages, synagogues, and cemeteries. It was as if an entire people had been obliterated. In this milieu, “A Jew who survived the camps returned to Budapest, where he ran into a Christian friend. ‘How are you?’ the friend inquired. ‘Don’t even ask,’ the Jew replied. ‘I have returned from the camp, and now I have nothing except the clothes you are wearing’” (Quoted by Keith Lowe, Savage Continent: Europe in the Aftermath of World War II, 2012).

Page 75

When historians don’t take humor seriously, including humor that reveals painful traumas but seeks by heroic measures to heal from them, they are missing a significant part of what it means to be human. Perhaps psychologically oriented historians can point the way to begin profitably mining this rich untapped resource. In time, it might even happen that we’ll become courageous enough to tackle the humor of psychohistory.

Page 76

About the author

David R. Beisel

David R. Beisel, PhD, earned his degree in Modern European History from New York University and is a Professor Emeritus at SUNY where he taught psychohistory to 8,000 students. He has written widely on American and European history. A collection of new essays, Genres of the Imagination (2021), which he wrote with Irene Javors, is available worldwide on Amazon. His book, The Suicidal Embrace, a study of the diplomatic origins of the Second World War, is available in a new Fourth Edition (2021) from . He can be reached at .

How to cite this article

Beisel, D. R. (2013). Humor as a psychohistorical source. Clio’s Psyche, 20(1), 69-76.

https://doi.org/10.70763/7230b2b03e2da37352abf1a659545b44

PDF downloads