Volume 06 - Number 4 - March 2000
Pages: 133 - 184

THE FUTURE OF PSYCHOHISTORY

Binion, R. (2000). Psychohistory’s false start. Clio’s Psyche, 6(4), 133, 138-139.

https://doi.org/10.70763/6a130f1dc6f0c829f874e92e5458dced

Psychohistory’s False Start

article

Abstract

In this article, published in the journal’s section on the future of psychohistory, the author contends that psychohistory’s beginning as applied psychoanalysis was a false start. He defines the field by two premises: that history consists of human actions, and that the reasons for those actions are largely unconscious. He argues that the psychoanalytic model encouraged researchers to read clinical findings into the historical record instead of learning motives from it. He also maintains that historical records say little about childhood, that psychoanalysis carried a concern with pathology into the field, and that it centers on individual experience while history is largely large-scale interaction. He faults early practitioners for not adopting an introspective, associative immersion in their subjects. He reports that by the 1970s the field had exhausted its psychoanalytic agenda, turned to other clinical models further removed from history, and declined in courses, output, practitioners, and recruitment. He sees no sign of renewal yet but concludes that one will come, because understanding the world requires knowing why people acted as they did.

Keywords:

applied psychoanalysis, false start, historic behavior, individual and group dynamics, normalcy, pathology, psychoanalysis, psychohistory, unconscious

Two premises together define psychohistory: that human history all reduces to human doings and that the reasons for human doings are largely unconscious. Because it was psychoanalysis that first accessed the unconscious underside of human doings, psychohistory began as applied psychoanalysis. This was a false start. For one thing, it discouraged aspirant psychohistorians from learning the why of historic behavior from the historic record itself and encouraged them instead to

Page 138

read into the historic record what psychoanalysts had learned about patients. For another, even the richest of historic records are short on childhood experience, the stock-in-trade of psychoanalysis, so that psychoanalysis could not even be well applied to history. For a third, a concern with pathology inevitably brushed off from psychoanalysis onto fledgling psychohistory, which should rather have come to terms with normalcy as its first order of business. But above all, the bulk of history is human interaction on a large scale, whereas the stuff of psychoanalysis is individual experience, including individual experience in groups.

Despite its fealty to psychoanalysis, fledgling psychohistory missed its calling as well in that, even while it fitted psychoanalytic models to history, it failed to adopt and adapt the introspective, associative approach that psychoanalysis requires for patients to see and feel the unconscious underpinnings of their symptoms. The psychohistorical researcher could meet this psychoanalytic requirement through a total intellectual and emotional immersion in his subject, whether individual or group. But this demanding exercise found little favor as against the easier speculative alignment of historic with clinical materials.

Off to a false start among the Freudians, psychohistory ran itself to ground. By the 1970s it had more or less exhausted its psychoanalytic agenda and began casting about for clinical substitutes, which proved ever more cultish and farther afield from history. For outsiders, meanwhile, it lost its novelty and at length its plausibility. Other modes of historical inquiry swiped its most fetching concepts. College courses on the literature and method folded; scholarly output fell off; seasoned practitioners deserted; recruitment slackened. The upshot is a happy one: at the turn of the millennium, the way is wide open for a radical renewal.

Though I see no sign of a viable renewal in the offing, one is bound to come in due course. The reason is simple—as simple as the wonderment that comes with our earliest sense of reality. We keep trying to understand our world, but there is no understanding our world without understanding its past, which means knowing why people have done what they have done. And to know this is, in a word, psychohistory.

Page 139

About the author

Rudolph Binion

Rudolph Binion (1927-2011) was an American historian. His areas of expertise were modern European intellectual and cultural history and psychohistory. Rudolph Binion lived in Paris for six years, where he obtained a diploma from the Institut d’études politiques and worked as a statistician for UNESCO. He received his bachelor’s degree from Columbia University and his doctorate in 1958. After teaching at Rutgers University, MIT, and Columbia University, Binion was appointed Professor of Modern European History at Brandeis University in 1967. In his best-known and most influential book-Hitler Among the Germans (1976)-Binion attempted to explain Adolf Hitler’s personality and political beliefs by means of psychoanalysis. After a long illness, Binion died in May 2011 at his home in Brookline, Massachusetts. [Translated from his Wikipedia page.]

How to cite this article

Binion, R. (2000). Psychohistory’s false start. Clio’s Psyche, 6(4), 133, 138-139.

https://doi.org/10.70763/6a130f1dc6f0c829f874e92e5458dced

PDF downloads