Volume 13 - Number 3 - December 2006
Pages: 109 - 177

DANIEL DERVIN’S SUFFER THE CHILDREN
SYMPOSIUM: COMMENTS

Breiner, S. (2006). Reflections on Dervin. Clio’s Psyche, 13(3), 153.

https://doi.org/10.70763/148148d62be67e0916a833931bd32b26

Reflections on Dervin

response article

Abstract

This article is a response in the symposium on Dan Dervin’s Suffer the Children, which concerns the treatment of children in the early Christian centuries. The author discusses the documentation Dervin’s article assembles on the early Church’s response to children. He reports that the fourth-century Church condemned child abandonment because an abandoned child might be raised into prostitution and the father might unknowingly commit incest with his daughter, and not because of the harm to the child. He maintains that concern for the abandoned child itself did not arise until about 800 A.D. He is sharply critical of St. John Chrysostom, faulting his hostility toward Jews and calling him an early anti-Semite. He also describes Augustine’s turn from a life of pleasure to piety. Drawing on avoidance of washing, beating, rigidity, and dualist attitudes, he characterizes the period’s leaders and much of its population as having an anal psychological configuration. He judges that Dervin’s article shows a society rationalizing its destructive treatment of small children. He closes by asking what the psychological condition of parents and of political and religious leaders must have been over so many centuries.

Keywords:

abandonment, catholic theology, childhood trauma, Christian era, Dan Dervin, medieval childhood, medieval Europe, psychohistory

The article contains a long list of documentation on Christianity’s early response to children. Though he notes that abandonment of children was common, the reason for the condemnation by the Church in the fourth century puts a different slant on things. The sin that was to be considered was not the abandonment of or indirect murder of children by such behavior, but the danger that such a child would be picked up and turned into a prostitute and the father would unwittingly have incestuous sex with his daughter. The early church was against the sin of incest, not the abandonment or murder of a child. That did not come into play till about 800 A.D.

St. John Chrysostom was “a pivotal figure” in the early church. But his distortions and hostility can be seen in his vicious diatribes against the Jews. He was one of the earliest and most vicious of the anti-Semites to follow.

In reading the material of this period of time the avoidance of washing, bathing and general cleanliness, along with the beating and rigidity indicates a general anal psychological configuration in the leadership and much of the population. Quite correctly, the author notes the “dualist attitudes,” which further confirms the anal dynamics. A further example was Augustine, who was a libertine and hedonist of the most intense quality, who made a sudden reversal into marked piety leading to his sainthood.

The article clearly demonstrates a society that rationalized its disturbed destructive and sadistic response to small children. The question that looms in front of us is, “what must have been the psychopathology of parents and political and religious leaders for so many centuries?”

Page 153

About the author

Sander J. Breiner

Sander J. Breiner MD, FAPA, is a Professor of Psychiatry at Michigan State University and Associate Professor of Psychiatry at Wayne State University. At both universities, he trains and supervises psychoanalysts. He is also author of over 100 scientific articles and books including, Slaughter of the Innocents: Child Abuse through the Ages and Today (1990). Dr. Breiner may be contacted at sjbreiner@comcast.net.

How to cite this article

Breiner, S. (2006). Reflections on Dervin. Clio’s Psyche, 13(3), 153.

https://doi.org/10.70763/148148d62be67e0916a833931bd32b26

PDF downloads