
Volume 22 - Number 4 - March 2016
Pages: 225 - 337
SPECIAL ISSUE
Brenner, I. (2016). Portrait of a terrorist. Clio’s Psyche, 22(4), 247-249.
Portrait of a Terrorist
Abstract
In this article, the author recounts the November 1938 shooting of the German diplomat Ernst vom Rath in Paris by Herschel Grynszpan, a stateless 17-year-old Polish-Jewish youth born in Germany. The account withholds Grynszpan’s identity until the end and then contrasts him with assumptions about militants inspired by Al-Qaeda or ISIS. The author describes his childhood displacement, his sense of alienation, his undocumented stay in Paris, and his wish to avenge his family, who were stranded at the border. The author characterizes the shooting as an attempt to draw international attention to the persecution of his people. The author reports, quoting Joseph Goebbels’s diary, that the Nazi leadership used vom Rath’s death on November 9 to justify the pogrom known as Kristallnacht, and gives figures for the synagogues destroyed, Jews killed, and men sent to concentration camps. The author maintains that Grynszpan was never honored as a champion of Jewish suffering, unlike the Warsaw ghetto fighters, and suggests that historians may have absorbed Nazi propaganda blaming him. The article closes with questions about what can be learned when persecuted groups feel justified in avenging their dead, when such acts succeed or backfire, and how easily fear and violence against a vulnerable minority can be provoked.
Al-Qaeda, family history, hate, Islamic State of Iraq and Syria (ISIS), love, outsider, psychohistory, terrorism
The 17 year old boy was the youngest of six children born to religious parents who had to leave their home country because of rising political tensions and the fear of persecution by the ruling class. He was seven years old at the time and this move had a serious and deleterious effect on his development. He never felt accepted nor part of his new country, always feeling like an outsider. His family was never granted citizenship, which exacerbated his sense of alienation. He strongly identified with his religious group and remained insulated and separate from the larger community, which viewed this group with wariness at best and deep hatred at worst.
He grew up maladjusted and hot tempered, doing poorly in school despite his intelligence and his getting into fights. He was an outcast. As his ethnic group became overtly persecuted in this new country, he wanted to return to his homeland, but was not legally allowed to do so. Being underage and essentially stateless, he felt increasingly unsafe and restless. His family became progressively more destitute and he decided to travel to Belgium, after which he went to Paris without proper papers. There he moved in with relatives who also were in dire straits. Because of his illegal status, he was afraid to look for a job and be caught by the authorities. As his new situation became intolerable to him and his poverty stricken relatives, he got word that his family was forced to leave the country but were denied access to anywhere else. As a result, they, along with thousands of other refugees, were trapped in a no man’s land at the border.
This profoundly distraught teenager reacted strongly to his family’s plight, and out of a sense of helplessness, wanted to avenge their suffering. With his remaining money, he went to a gun shop and purchased a handgun and bullets. He then found his way to the embassy and demanded to speak to the ambassador, claiming he had secret knowledge of vital, national importance. The ambassador had just left the building, so he was directed to the
Page 247
man second in command, at which time he shot the official five times at close range. Making no attempt to escape, he was determined to bring international attention to the cruelty which his people were being subjected to, and reportedly yelled out this reason as he pulled the trigger. While he was in custody, his victim died of his wounds, and he was charged with murder.
Who was this brazen terrorist capable of such a high profile assassination? A Muslim extremist inspired by Al-Qaeda or ISIS? A violent jihadi influenced by a charismatic imman preaching revenge for the suffering and deaths of innocents in Afghanistan or Syria? No. This young man was an obscure Polish-Jew, born in Germany, named Herschel Grynszpan, whose memorable act in early November 1938 was actually blamed for starting the Holocaust! The Nazi regime was already planning reprisals against the Jews as their “legalized” noose was being further tightened. Joseph Goebbels, Propaganda Minister, cynically exploited this event to justify the national pogrom, which came to be known as Krystallnacht, or the “night of shattered glass.”
Junior Ambassador Ernst vom Rath’s death on November 9, 1938, coincided with the 15th anniversary of the Beer Hall Putsch in Munich of 1923, the most hallowed date of the Nazi year. This excerpt from Goebbels’ diary revealed sinister thinking: “In the afternoon the death of the German diplomat vom Rath is announced. That’s good…. I go to the party reception in the old Rathaus. Terrific activity. I brief Hitler on the affair. He decides: allow the demonstrations to go on. Withdraw the police. The Jews should feel the people’s fury.” He goes on to write, “that’s right. I issue appropriate instructions to the police and party. Then I give a brief speech on the subject to the police and party. Then I give a brief speech on the subject to the Party’s leadership. Thunderous applause. Everyone dashed to the telephone. Now the people will act” (Peter Longerich, Holocaust: The Nazi Persecution and Murder of the Jews, 2010, 111).
By the time the bloodlust ended, 200 synagogues and thousands of Jewish properties were destroyed; billions of dollars of damage are estimated to have occurred (Gerald Schwab, The Day the Holocaust Began, 1990). Almost 100 Jews were murdered and 30,000 more were forced into concentration camps. The true face of Nazi tyranny was thus revealed to the world.
Grynzspan, curiously, was never recognized as a hero who
Page 248
championed the cause of the suffering of the Jewish people, the way that others who followed him were. Most notably, those who fought in the Warsaw ghetto uprising have come to epitomize pure martyrdom. Historically, we may have fallen prey to the same Nazi propaganda that incited the violence in the first place: that it indeed was all Grynszpan’s fault and that whatever he brought on was deserved. Other aspects to this often overlooked aspect of Holocaust history (Rita Thalman and Emmanuel Feinerman, Crystal Night, 1974) are worthy of further research and are beyond the scope of this brief essay.
What lessons, if any, can be learned from the past when members of a large group who are oppressed and persecuted feel justified to avenge the deaths of their brethren? When is it effective in bringing about changes and when does it backfire? How easy is it to sway public opinion, induce fear in the populace, and provoke a violent backlash against a vulnerable minority?
Page 249
How to cite this article
Brenner, I. (2016). Portrait of a terrorist. Clio’s Psyche, 22(4), 247-249.



