
Volume 10 - Number 3 - December 2003
Pages: 75 - 158
Brink, A. (2003). Brink-Elovitz September 11 exchange on historians’ response to the Emotional Life of Nations symposium in Clio’s Psyche, September 2003 group meeting [Letter to the Editor]. Clio’s Psyche, 10(3), 117.
Brink-Elovitz September 11 Exchange on Historians’ Response to the Emotional Life of Nations Symposium in Clio’s Psyche, September 2003
childhood trauma, Clio’s Psyche, The Emotional Life of Nations (ELN), letter to the editor, Lloyd deMause, Paul Elovitz, psychoanalysis, psychohistory
To the Editor:
Though Lloyd deMause is no special hero of mine, I do believe I grasp his central point about childhood trauma in history and its far-reaching implications. (I gave up on heroes a long while ago but admit that Harry Guntrip may have been one.) I admire Lloyd’s tenacity and his intellectual discipline and brilliance as writer and speaker. I have more questions and theoretical points of difference with Lloyd’s book than I want to say just now, but didn’t want to go beyond “certain caveats” (p. 34) as I knew that the contributions would supply more than enough. But I was surprised and shocked by the range of exception-taking, especially by historians who failed to engage with the main issue of child abuse. I didn’t come away with much sense that historians enjoy working with ideas … that touch on the painful aspects of childhood experiences, including our own. Only Leon Rappoport and myself saw how extraordinary The Emotional Life of Nations really is and were willing to say so—but we aren’t historians. I am still slightly in shock over the symposium and want to think about it some more.
Andrew Brink
Greensville, Ontario
Page 117
How to cite this article
Brink, A. (2003). Brink-Elovitz September 11 exchange on historians’ response to the Emotional Life of Nations symposium in Clio’s Psyche, September 2003 group meeting [Letter to the Editor]. Clio’s Psyche, 10(3), 117.



