
Volume 10 - Number 3 - December 2003
Pages: 75 - 158
Brink, A. (2003). The editor responds [Letter to the Editor]. Clio’s Psyche, 10(3), 117-118.
The Editor Responds
Andrew Brink, childrearing, David Beisel, “The Evolution of Childhood,” historian, Joe Dowling, letter to the editor, Lloyd deMause, Peter Petschauer, psychohistory, response from the editor
The Editor Responds:
As a historian, I use many different ideas, especially Lloyd’s on the history of childhood. Indeed, this semester all 135 of my students in four
Page 117
classes (two Western Civilizations, one Psychohistory, and one Childhood and Youth in History) have read and have been separately quizzed on deMause’s “The Evolution of Childhood.” I accept and use his central point on childrearing, as do Dave Beisel, Joe Dowling, Peter Petschauer, and other historians. Peter was inspired by “The Evolution of Childhood” and uses Lloyd’s materials appreciatively, but wishes Lloyd would be more open to other research and developments, as do I. Historians use different ideas, including Lloyd’s, and I do not appreciate Lloyd’s unflattering depictions of us and our work (I do not see why the work of historians should drive him to tears! (ELN, p. 108) However, we historians are interested in careful documentation as well as varied ideas.
Regarding your [unpublished] query about a symposium on Lloyd’s next book, Clio’s Psyche paid Lloyd a great compliment, at your behest, by making his book the basis of a symposium. We had never done this before. It will be up to our Editorial Board as to whether we will do it again for his next book or anyone else’s book.
Paul H. Elovitz
Franklin Lakes, NJ
Page 118
How to cite this article
Brink, A. (2003). The editor responds [Letter to the Editor]. Clio’s Psyche, 10(3), 117-118.



