
Volume 09 - Number 2 - September 2002
Pages: 61 - 123
SYMPOSIUM
Burris, C. T. (2002). 1,001 celibate nights. Clio’s Psyche, 9(2), 107-108.
1,001 Celibate Nights
Abstract
In this article, part of the celibacy symposium, the author, a psychologist of religion, responds to Anthony T. Massimini’s “The Psychological Damage of Forced Celibacy” and to the debate over Dan Dervin’s “Father Joseph Bosetti: Pioneer Priest in the Rockies.” The author sets aside claims about celibacy’s divine origins and observes that nearly all faith traditions regulate sexual expression. The author suggests that this is because sex, which survey respondents list among sources of mystical experience, can appear to religion as a competitor to transcendence. The article contrasts the religious framing of celibacy, bound up with marriage and family, with a secular meaning of abstaining from sex. It maintains that abstinence is not always religiously motivated and that sexual desire varies across a population like other psychological traits. It proposes many varieties of celibacy beyond the priestly one. Declining to debate whether Bosetti’s achievements resulted from sublimation, the author offers a Freud-inspired proposition that anything can be a threat or a defense. The author concludes that only when threats and defenses are relinquished can people, celibate or not, hope to reach the integrated ego Massimini describes.
Anthony T. Massimini, celibacy, Father Joseph Julius Bosetti, psychohistory, psychology of religion, sexual assault
As a psychologist of religion who is professedly committed to scientific objectivity, I cannot speak to claims regarding celibacy’s divine origins. Perhaps it is, indeed, “a gift” to some, as Massimini suggests.
In the popular mind, celibacy is a Roman Catholic issue but nearly all faith traditions regulate sexual expression—sometimes vigorously. Why? Sex can serve as a pathway to transcendence. Survey respondents list sex—along with mind-altering substances, rhythms and dance, and nature—as potent sources of blissful, even mystical, experience. Thus, we should not be surprised that zealous religious proponents sometimes label sex and drugs, rock ‘n’ roll, and pantheism as “evil” or “false gods.” In effect, these alternate pathways can be perceived as competitors in the transcendence marketplace and therefore as threats to religion.
In Massimini’s religious framework, for example, celibacy is juxtaposed against sex, marriage, and family in an “all or nothing” sort of package. In contrast, in a secular framework, celibacy simply means “no sex.” Marriage and family are afterthoughts—although, curiously, one or both often get linked back to sex. Consider a couple in a committed, sexually expressive relationship, who choose neither marriage nor children. To many North American religious believers, this unmarried couple is “living in sin.” To pro-family individuals, religious or secular, this childfree couple is branded either as an object of pity or as “selfish,” no better than garden-variety fornicators. Both views tacitly acknowledge sex’s power as a transformative agent.
Not all who abstain from sexual activity do so for explicitly religious reasons, however. The image—magnified by the recent scandals—of priests bursting at the libidinal seams from years of repressed sexual urges is a grossly selective one, at best. The urge to express oneself sexually, priest or not, falls under the same statistical bell curve as other psychological variables. Most of us are average, so individuals at both extremes catch our attention. Thus, “recovering sex addicts” are talk show guests, and the DSM-IV—the bible of psychiatric diagnosis—labels those who are either chronically uninterested in, or downright disgusted by, sex as “disordered.” Celibacy, whether institutionalized or not, is likely perceived as a sanctuary by such persons.
I am reminded of a boy who once confided to me that he kept track of the number of days he went without masturbating as a gauge of personal piety. He could correctly label the sexual anatomy but would become nauseous and faint when sex education was presented in health class. Born into Catholicism, he never considered priesthood but rarely dated and remained a virgin well into his 20s.
There are, I would suggest, a “thousand little celibacies” in addition to the one reserved for Roman Catholic priests. Unless victims of psychological or physical coercion, all must choose whether and how to express themselves sexually. Celibacy can be embraced as a joyful calling, begrudgingly accepted as a job requirement, touted as holy glamour, or sought out as an ideological storm shelter.
Page 107
Thus, instead of joining in the debate as to whether Fr. Bosetti’s priestly achievements were the beneficent result of sexual sublimation, I will put forth an idea that is true to the spirit (if not the letter) of Freud: Anything can be a threat; anything can be a defense. Only when threats are defused and defenses dropped, when the mortal struggle to maintain the self-as-separate is no longer felt, do men and women—celibate or not—have hope of Massimini’s “well-integrated ego that is capable of universal love for self, others, nature, and God.”
Page 108
How to cite this article
Burris, C. T. (2002). 1,001 celibate nights. Clio’s Psyche, 9(2), 107-108.



