Volume 24 - Number 2 - Winter 2018
Pages: 135 - 251

THE PSYCHOANALYSIS OF PSYCHOANALYSTS

Carveth, D. (2018). Why I write about guilt. Clio’s Psyche, 24(2), 135-137.

https://doi.org/10.70763/7de32147a4f1055bed9e4faf3485a84d

Why I Write about Guilt

article

Abstract

The author writes his free associations on guilt and its role in analysts’ and analysands’ lives.

Keywords:

anxiety, The Denial of Death, Ernest Becker, existentialism, guilt, illusory defenses, melancholic sociology, psychoanalysis, Psychoanalytic Thinking: Essays in Critique, psychohistory, The Sacred Canopy: Elements of a Sociological Theory of Religion, splitting, terror-management theory, unconscious

In my forthcoming book, Psychoanalytic Thinking: Essays in Critique (London: Routledge, 2018, in press), I trace what I call “The Melancholic Existentialism of Ernest Becker” (Ernest Becker, The Denial of Death, 1973) and the related melancholic sociology of Peter Berger (The Sacred Canopy: Elements of a Sociological Theory of Religion, 1965) to the unresolved depression that prevented them from seeing the splitting and the one-sidedness entailed in their attitudes of despair and disgust. Becker and his followers in “terror-management theory” have the peculiar idea that death anxiety is our primordial fear, the Ur-anxiety motivating the denial of death through the quest for immortality and various forms of heroism, just as Berger thinks we construct society and religion as illusory defenses against what he takes to be the reality of chaos and anomy (“The Melancholic Existentialism of Ernest Becker,” Free Associations, Vol. 11, Part 3, No. 59, 2004: 422-29).

For these thinkers, in seeking to analyze and resolve defenses, psychoanalysts threaten to expose the unbearable reality against which we must defend ourselves. Society, religions, and heroic projects of various sorts function as “shields against terror,” without which we must go mad. By “existentializing” anxiety in these ways, grounding it in allegedly unbearable existential truth, these thinkers avoid having to consider what alternative grounds there might be for it, what other explanations might account for their terror or persecutory anxiety and depression. Grounds such as unconscious guilt, perhaps? Here is an example of such thinking:

“Yes, I’m anxious and depressed about the human condition, by the absurdity and meaninglessness of life, not because I’m cheating on my wife or my taxes, or mean or neglectful toward my kids, or a self-centered egotist, racist, sexist, and classist…no, no,

Page 135

it’s la condition humane. I don’t need analysis to get at the deeper reasons for my malaise, I just need better denial of death, better terror management or maybe Paxil.”

I could cite reams of clinical material from my practice to support my claim that underlying the variegated forms of suffering patients present, the hysterical and psychosomatic symptoms, the anxiety and depression, the patterns of self-limitation and self sabotage, lie the moral failings, the character flaws, the petty envy, greed, and meanness, the death wishes toward others, the schadenfreude and the outright crimes and misdemeanors that in an earlier age, prior to our culture of narcissism, people took it as the goal of their lives to combat, to struggle, to transcend. There’s a novel idea for those struggling with existential angst: how about finding meaning in trying to be a better person, facing and battling your faults, even getting your mind off yourself long enough to consider that other people might be real and have needs and sufferings you might help to relieve?

Few analysts think this way, at least not publicly. We are too afraid of being seen as “superegoish” and, thanks to Freud’s regrettable decision to fold conscience into the superego, we have lost touch with this crucial distinction. People who are out of sync with their conscience are fodder for the persecutory superego, which will generate, one way or another, the physical, mental, and social pain that serves as the equivalent or substitute for the genuine guilt they will not face. As Lucius Annaeus Seneca put it, “Let wickedness escape as it may at the bar, it never fails of doing justice upon itself, for every guilty person is his own hangman” (Seneca the Younger).

However, the reason few analysts think or speak this way is not only that they fear being accused of being moralistic, but also that like their patients, like everyone else in the culture of narcissism, like everyone else, period, they are reluctant to face their own seamy side. I don’t say “dark” side, for that sounds sufficiently grand to be almost acceptable. Like Nietzsche’s Zarathustra, we can accept being great sinners, just not the petty and pathetic creatures we often are. Analysts are not inclined to help patients confront and rise above failings they have not managed to face or deal with in themselves. We know what happens to whistleblowers in this society. Can you really blow the whistle on others when you haven’t blown it on yourself and live in dread that someone will?

Page 136

I write about guilt because I’ve been struggling with it most of my life. With the help of analysis, I’ve understood that most of my hysterical and psychosomatic symptoms, my anxiety and depression, however grounded in childhood conflicts and pain, have also been rooted in my reactive narcissism, aggression, and wrongdoing. I’ve had to struggle, and still struggle, to repent and to be a better man. With a little progress in this project over the years, my symptoms abated, my creativity was enhanced, and I have been more successful in finding peace and love. There are a lot of fancy psychoanalytic theories that those unready to really face themselves can play around with, but no genuine cure will be achieved until they do.

Page 137

About the author

Donald L. Carveth

Donald L. Carveth, PhD, is Emeritus Professor of Sociology and Social & Political Thought at York University, current Director of the Toronto Institute of Psychoanalysis, and author of The Still Small Voice: Psychoanalytic Reflections on Guilt and Conscience (2013). He may be found on the web at: www.yorku.ca/dcarveth.

How to cite this article

Carveth, D. (2018). Why I write about guilt. Clio’s Psyche, 24(2), 135-137.

https://doi.org/10.70763/7de32147a4f1055bed9e4faf3485a84d

PDF downloads