
Volume 06 - Number 2 - September 1999
Pages: 41 - 88
Chappell, J. S. (1999). Flame wars in the brave new world of e-mail. Clio’s Psyche, 6(2), 58-60.
Flame Wars in the Brave New World of E-mail
Abstract
In this article, the author, a clinical psychologist, sets out his observations of flame wars, meaning angry written exchanges on mailing lists and chat rooms. He draws on 21 months on the Psychohistory Discussion List and fifty years of clinical practice. He proposes that flame wars begin when a posting contains a key word or concept that resonates with deep, unresolved, unconscious issues of one or more readers, who then respond with defensive and insulting retorts. He recounts two episodes from the list. The first is a 1998 thread about a college student’s remark on his teachers, which the author attributes to readers’ identification with the student’s conflict between play and work. The second is a 1999 thread on abortion, whose intensity he attributes to a fear of nonexistence among some pro-life participants. In both, he observes that the underlying issue was never raised, and he doubts that naming the second would have helped. He compares these episodes with face-to-face disputes over sex education in his community thirty years earlier, attributing the opposition there to earlier sexual trauma among some opponents he knew clinically. He maintains that the absence of face-to-face cues online, and the persistence of written words, sharpen defensive reactions. He concludes that little maturation results and that the hidden trauma remains ready to reignite.
clinical psychology, defense mechanisms, email, flame wars, online communication, polemics, psychohistory, Psychohistory Discussion List
To be flamed on the Internet is to be directly insulted by an angry written message in response to something submitted to chat rooms and mailing lists. Volleys of insults sometimes develop into flame wars, often enveloping rather innocent bystanders. How could this be explained? My perspective on flame wars is from the vista of 21 months on the Psychohistory Discussion List and 50 years in clinical psychology.
Flame wars appear to begin when a posting contains some key word or concept that resonates with deep, unresolved, enduring unconscious issues of one or more readers. Illustrative of this mechanism was the trigger statement posted on the Psychohistory List in May, 1998:
Subject: Teaching—Hello, everyone. I overheard a quote yesterday that intrigued me. Suprisingly, it was from a 20-year-old college student, referring about [SIC] one of his teachers. He said, “I have yet to see a teacher who can do the work that he assigns.” I find this interesting and rather true. I want to hear your opinions on his statement.
Responses began immediately with some posters supporting the student’s plight; others the appropriateness of such assignments; while others wandered astray, citing procedural and structural shortcomings of educational institutions in various countries. Amazingly, even a confessing complainant accused some fellow administrators at his own institution of not providing proper support for him to fulfill his responsibilities. Slurs, attributions, and insults became blatant in less than a day: “G. is casting poison baits around again, hoping to make a few liberals feel sick.”
Though the level of heat was rather low, it endured for over a week. No posting was offered that illumined the basic motivational origins of such a discussion. Being new to mailing list culture, I constrained myself and did not address the basic issue, which, in my view, was that a 20-year-old adolescent scholar was caught in the cross currents of wanting to party or play freely as a
Page 58
child and being assigned to work as an adult. He chose to play, was late with an assignment, and projected a fault onto the teacher, which had a faint ring of accuracy: “He can’t do the work either!” It is my thesis that the concept resonated with memories of a few mailing list subscribers who identified powerfully with the student’s plight and posted recounts of their own painful experiences. Not one posting told of the desire of wanting it both ways, or confessing to playing the role of a child in preference to producing as an adult. Several posters simply reiterated the basic accusation citing personal experiences as if to validate the projection. Not very convincing to this observer. The flame war extinguished after about a week when no one posted any more to the subject. Venting was apparently successful. Would a posting clarifying the adolescent dilemma have doused the flame war? Perhaps.
Another example occurred early February, 1999. There had been much media coverage of abortionist doctors and the anti-abortion Web site sponsors who were successfully sued for instigating violence against doctors who performed abortions. On the Psychohistory List a subject title appeared, “abortion = child abuse.” The floodgates opened. Impassioned postings supported by “evidence” appeared on each side of the abortion issue. Moderate postings were lost in the exchanges as the polemicists treated them to benign neglect.
Having “known” several of the participants for several months, it was my impression that a discernible division, roughly between conservatives and liberals, followed the well established paradigm, conservative = pro-life and liberal = pro-choice. The war raged for about two weeks with considerable invective and ire, sometimes resulting in a vapid coup-de-grâce, a diagnostic label from the DSM-IV.
The unconscious issue never broached was the deep sense of futility some folks experience when they seriously think of their absence from the human race. This is not a suicidal end, but a beginning that never was, when one contemplates, “My parents could have aborted me!” Even unhappy, harshly used and abused people feel worthy of existence. Life’s struggle produces its own reward. But when the thought of non-existence, because of a parental decision “to abort me,” begins to break through into consciousness, some individuals are emotionally thrown into the extremely alarming state of psychological anomie: refugees in nowhere, absolutely nowhere! A conceptual place of nothingness, no personal history, no self, no parents, no affiliations to provide comfort or solace, and no hope of returning to a life that never existed. What defenses exist, what skills facilitate coping with life that never was or will be? Such persons appear to cope with the profound, near catastrophic anxiety of psychological anomie by immediate reversion to a pro-life position, marshaling extensive arguments expressed with endless fervor and detail: Outlaw all abortions! The intensity of passion is equivalent to the threatened anxiety of psychological anomie.
No one on the Psychohistory List offered this psychodynamic explanation. If offered, those so afflicted would probably deny it applied to them. They defend against such insight and anxiety by adopting and fighting for the pro-life position. Would a posting clarifying the origin of such fervor extinguish the flame war? Not likely—much too threatening.
Advancing arguments with great passion during flame wars on mailing lists and chat rooms is not unique to the abortion issue or limited to Internet communications. Shakespeare knew this when he had a character speak about “…hell knows no wrath as a woman scorned!” It is a common mechanism of defense when individuals have deeply buried traumatic issues triggered by key words or concepts which occur in daily life. Thirty years ago when I was struggling to establish sex education in the public schools of my small community, there were many face-to-face flame wars filled with great passion during school district meetings (in town meeting format). I knew many of the anti-sex education combatants clinically. Significant numbers of them had experienced wide varieties of sexual traumas: early sex abuse, pubescent rape, teen pregnancy, illegal abortion, and embittered shotgun marriages. Some of my patients even committed their beloved sons and daughters to similar early sexual traumas by refusing to provide factual sexual information to their children. Instead they set sharp social restrictions with no meaningful explanation sensible to adolescents. Defensively, they shrilled vigorous opposition to sex education, expressing the belief, “Once they know about sex, the little fools will go out and do it like rabbits.” Clearly, projection by parents, but as is the case with most defense mechanisms, virtually no one could see that reflection.
Page 59
Life on the Internet is a special social situation most of us have never experienced before. The transmission of written communications is instantaneous. We lack the myriad of cues face-to-face discussion provides. Apparent age, tone of voice, appearance, and demeanor, to name only a few, are cues which usually temper verbal expression and perception in face to face communication. On the Internet we are left with only stark words from unseen strangers on screen or printout. Triggering words and concepts, unique to unconscious traumas, have durability as they “stare back,” providing much opportunity to arouse defenses against re-experiencing personal traumas. A quick retort posting is made in passionate defense of the trauma. Often the retort contains an insulting attribution about the author of the original triggering statement. The basic traumatic issue is never revealed for it is too painful and humiliating. Passionately preaching the defense brings the relief of avoidance. Vindication is granted as others harmonize the same defensive melody. And so flame wars begin and spread, but little maturation occurs, as the tinder of hidden trauma remains undisturbed ready to ignite again.
Page 60
How to cite this article
Chappell, J. S. (1999). Flame wars in the brave new world of e-mail. Clio’s Psyche, 6(2), 58-60.



