Volume 24 - Number 1 - Summer 2017
Pages: 1 - 133

STUDENT PAPERS AND TEACHING THE ELECTION

Cifelli, D. (2017). Trump’s continuing appeal. Clio’s Psyche, 24(1), 54-56.

https://doi.org/10.70763/471c50ad1a156d7256eddfd747d77931

Trump’s Continuing Appeal

article

Abstract

The author elucidates the motivation of Trump’s supporters. Although the approval ratings of the newly inaugurated president are at record lows, there remains a large segment of the population loyal to Donald Trump because they strongly identify with him and his message. For them, he still represents the hope of positive change for white, working-class Americans. They are able to look past the lies and inconsistencies of the President using various defense mechanisms, including but not limited to denial, displacement, intellectualization, and suppression. In this way, they are able to preserve their perception of him as the maverick about to save their jobs and the greatness of America.

Keywords:

American politics, defense mechanisms, denial, displacement, Donald Trump, economic policies, intellectualization, middle class, political polarization, political supporters, popular appeal, psychohistory, U.S. presidential election

While support has dwindled for Trump after the election (he was inaugurated with the lowest approval ratings of any president ever), most of his voters support him despite his contradictions, lies, and poor initial performance coming to light. Most who remain supportive of President Trump cling to the hope that his contradictions and flip-flops are meaningless in the pursuit of jobs for working class Americans in the rust belt and beyond. While it has been difficult to gauge the personal opinions of those outside of my bubble of suburban New Jersey, the following article represents my understanding of the continuing support of Donald J. Trump.

For many, the Clinton/Trump dichotomy has not disappeared three months after the election and their support for Trump stems from the attitude that he is “still better than Hillary” and replaced the abhorred Obama administration. Trump’s continued unfounded attacks on Obama helps foster this. Besides that, the denial of Trump’s obvious falsehoods plays into the refusal to give up

Page 54

the hope that Trump will be the maverick who saves America. In fact, his constantly shifting stances and unwillingness to elaborate on any of his positions give hope to some that he is not an ideologically entrenched typical politician. Still, others support Trump’s campaign promise to allow Americans the freedom to speak their minds and secure America’s position in the world. They are deaf to the rest of Trump’s controversial message.

Trump has artfully and conspicuously encouraged his supporters to use the defense mechanism of displacement. In each crisis he has faced since his candidacy began, he has either shifted the blame to his enemies, such as the alleged purveyors of “fake news,” or most recently the Freedom Caucus, or else he has responded by shifting attention to another crisis, like Hillary’s emails or Obama’s supposed wiretapping of his campaign. He provides ready scapegoats for his supporters to blame. On some level, his supporters must recognize that his excuses are at best dubious and speculative, but their unconscious desire to not give up on the fantasy of Trump’s revolution leads them to accept his excuses and blaming of others. Similarly, others may recognize his lies, which are so widely publicized and constantly pointed out by respectable institutions and fact-checkers, but choose to deny the truth.

Intellectualization is also at play when supporters see Trump’s demeanor and the way he treats others. The video clips of him mocking a disabled person, demeaning women, and labeling Mexicans as rapists, contrary to popular belief, does indeed inspire negative emotional reactions among some Trump voters. In a group of women I met in the grocery store line, one woman said, “You know all that stuff is a real shame and I would be ashamed if that was my son speaking and acting like that. But you know what, we don’t have to elect a nice guy, we have to elect a president.” His supporters are able to dismiss their emotional reactions and attempt to continue their version of a logical approach toward voting. This rationalization has continued in response to Trump’s falsehoods and other un-presidential behavior during his first 100 days in office.

On a conscious level, many Trump supporters I’ve spoken with use suppression to look past our President’s deficiencies in personality and leadership. When confronted with him picking fights with Arnold Schwarzenegger or any of the scandals of his first 100 days, they respond with “let’s talk about the real issues,” such as securing the border, defeating ISIS, and healthcare. While

Page 55

they may recognize the scandals as flaws, they choose to ignore them. Trump elicits this response when he downplays each scandal as mere white noise from the “fake news.”

Why do these people believe strongly enough in the candidate to go to these psychic lengths? What I hear from supporters is resignation to the fact that he is president. One college student, whose parents escaped Cuba, said, “You know what, he’s our president now, and all of our wagons are hitched, so let’s just support him and hope to God that he is a great president.” Another friend of this student, a white male who resides in a wealthy town, went on to say he voted for Trump, and that he felt a responsibility to now support the president he chose, “in light of all the current stuff.” For older people in my conservative-leaning hometown, the fantasy they have of Trump restoring the greatness of not just America but specifically the middle class is a powerful force.

Many of the people I met in a local dental office were working class men who, after complaining about how expensive dentistry is, offered their opinions on Trump. Their comments of, “when will this ever happen again,” hint at their vision of the incumbent. It is a sentiment I heard echoing in the words of parents of friends, mostly white, upper-middle-class moms who had to go back to work after the recession. For them, Trump is the last man standing in the way of a cascade of higher taxes, immigrants, and political correctness symbolized by Obama. In pursuit of this, to reverse the pendulum, they’re willing to displace, deny, intellectualize, and suppress if it means keeping the dream alive. To recognize Trump’s flaws would be to lose hope for the idyllic America of their dreams—this is unthinkable.

Page 56

About the author

How to cite this article

Cifelli, D. (2017). Trump’s continuing appeal. Clio’s Psyche, 24(1), 54-56.

https://doi.org/10.70763/471c50ad1a156d7256eddfd747d77931

PDF downloads