Volume 22 - Number 1-2 - June-September 2015
Pages: 1 - 121

SYMPOSIUM RELATED ARTICLES

Cifelli, D., & Elovitz, P. H. (2015). Insights from psychohistorical journal editors. Clio’s Psyche, 22(1-2), 81-90.

https://doi.org/10.70763/92bf5e6240737e0326ea59846a83e076

Insights from Psychohistorical Journal Editors

article

Abstract

This article, one of the symposium-related pieces, presents questions and answers with editors of three psychohistorical journals, gathered as research material for “Three Psychohistorical Journals” by David Cifelli and Paul H. Elovitz. Charles B. Strozier and Lawrence Shiner discuss the Psychohistory Review, David R. Beisel and David Lotto the Journal of Psychohistory, and Elovitz Clio’s Psyche. The questions cover each journal’s mission, readership, refereeing procedures, editorial succession, and institutional support, including the Group for the Use of Psychology in History and Sangamon State University. Strozier and Shiner give differing accounts of why the Review ended in 1999. Strozier cites psychohistory’s failure to win recognition within history, though he says it has been absorbed into historical writing. Shiner cites fewer strong submissions, competing projects, and reduced university funding. Beisel says he did not share Lloyd deMause’s view of psychohistory as a science or the psychogenic theory. He faults deMause’s essay “The Independence of Psychohistory” as damaging to relations with historians, and says he sought a more academic tone. He also stresses training in historical method for newcomers. Lotto describes the Journal‘s transition to peer review. Elovitz characterizes the three journals as respectively theoretical and political, historical, and concerned with contemporary events. He maintains that others use psychohistorical insights while ignoring the organized field, doubts that politicians draw on them, and recounts anecdotes about the Carter and Reagan administrations.

Keywords:

Bob Lentz, Charles B. Strozier, Clio’s Psyche, David Lotto, David R. Beisel, The History of Childhood Quarterly, The Journal of Psychohistory (JOP), journal editors, Lawrence Shiner, psychohistory, The Psychohistory Review, “Three Psychohistorical Journals”

Below are the questions and answers forming a part of the research materials on which the article, “Three Psychohistorical Journals,” was based. David Cifelli and Paul Elovitz formulated the questions and Cifelli contacted the editors, who were nice enough to reply and subsequently authorized their publication. Because of a delay caused by Larry Shiner being at a conference in Paris, Elovitz, rather than Cifelli, made the successful contact with him. Bob Lentz, who for its first nine years was Associate Editor of Clio’s Psyche, suggested that the Q & A should be published, but chose not to be interviewed. Cifelli asked Elovitz questions about psychohistory that went beyond his editorship. These materials are shown below in their entirety.

Charles B. Strozier (May 3, 2015)

  1. How did you view the mission of the Psychohistory Review?

I am not sure I ever thought of my purpose in founding the Psychohistory Review as having a mission per se. It was clear to me that psychohistory had emerged as an exciting new intellectual venture and needed a broad-based journal of high standards without a focused or somewhat ideological purpose.

  1. What was the relationship, if any, of the Psychohistory Review with the Group for the Use of Psychology in History (GUPH)?

The Group for the Use of Psychology in History had already been founded within the American Historical Association by me and several colleagues and the Psychohistory Review logically became its journal. Such a relationship between such groups and their journals is a common practice. I always felt it was important to maintain this connection to insure our legitimacy.

  1. How did you build the readership, including many library subscriptions?

It was difficult to build a readership. It happened one reader and one library at a time. By the mid-1970s we had about 400-500 subscriptions.

  1. Did the readership and mission change over time?

Not really, though as a publication we became more formal and the journal was bound better.

  1. Did you encourage the publication of clinical research?

I never included clinical research. That seemed to me outside the realm of psychohistory. Perhaps I was wrong.

Page 81

  1. What kind of a refereeing system did you use? How many referees?

I always tried to have a couple of readers review an article. Sometimes, if I personally solicited an article from someone of stature I might compromise on one outside reader. Usually, readers were from those on the Editorial Board.

  1. How was Larry Shiner chosen to be your editorial successor?

Larry was a good friend at Sangamon State University (now the University of Illinois/UIS) and had gotten interested in the journal. The only reason we survived was because the university provided financial support. When I left for CUNY in 1986, someone at Sangamon had to take it over or it would have died. I was very pleased with his commitment to the journal for the next decade.

  1. What contributions did you make as an Associate Editor after Shiner took over?

I helped Larry with reading papers and generally consulted on things, but the journal was entirely his project after I left.

  1. Why did the Psychohistory Review cease publication in 1999 and how was the decision arrived at?

The Psychohistory Review ceased publication because Larry got tired of it, as I did, but probably the more fundamental issue is that it was clear by then that psychohistory was never going to be recognized within the discipline of history as more than ephemeral. Very few people (other than me) had had appointments as such in it. Almost no one published under its name. This was in marked contrast with what seemed to be unfolding in 1972. Psychohistory in this sense had died. But we might say psychohistory is dead, long live psychohistory. It has firmly taken root by being absorbed into the writing of history. There do remain the thorny issues of training and method, but by the late 1990s it seemed time for me and Larry to move onto other things.

Lawrence Shiner (June 20, 2015)

  1. How did you get involved with the Psychohistory Review and how did you view its mission?

I first became involved by writing some book reviews, one of which turned into a review article. I may have also vetted a couple of submissions that touched on areas of European history with which I was familiar. I became editor when Chuck (Strozier) accepted a position at CUNY’s John Jay College to work with Robert J. Lifton at the Center for Violence and Human Survival. The History Department at CUNY already had a couple of journals and Chuck’s new duties were going to be demanding. Since there was no one else in our history department with the interest or background to take on editing the Review, I accepted. Actually, I was only affiliated with the UIS History department for part of my appointment, since my primary appoint-

Page 82

ment was in philosophy, although I also taught courses in European intellectual history for the history department and published on the philosophy of history, including a book, The Secret Mirror: Literary Form and History in Tocqueville’s “Recollections” (Cornell, 1988)—although it was a literary analysis not focused on psychology.

  1. Did the readership and mission change over time?

Because my interests were in an interdisciplinary approach to intellectual and cultural history, I tried to expand our contributors and readership to involve scholars whose primary focus was not necessarily on relating history and psychoanalysis. In addition, because of my interest in French history and culture, I made some efforts, with the help of Elizabeth Marvick, to involve French scholars such as Micheline Guiton. I also published some overviews of psychohistory in Europe.

  1. What kind of a refereeing system did you use? How many referees?

Our rule was to use two referees who were knowledgeable in the content field with at least one of them also aware of the methods and problems of relating psychology and history.

  1. Were there controversies that arose from some of the articles published?

I don’t remember any major controversies sparked by particular articles, but Chuck’s memory would be better than mine.

  1. Were there many articles based on theory that were published or rejected for publication?

Without going back to do a count, I can’t say what percentage, but I know there were a number and that I was always alert to and supportive of good endeavours in that direction.

  1. Were there many references to Freud in the articles? To Erikson? What other theorists?

Generally, there were lots of references to Freud and many to Erikson but I was also interested in submissions that were non-psychoanalytic since I felt that the field was the relationship between history and academic psychology of all theoretical orientations, not simply psychoanalysis. My general memory, however, is that there were only a few such pieces.

  1. [Omitted since it is included in the next answer.]
  2. How much editorial and financial assistance was provided by SSU?

At the time I became Editor, the university teaching load was three four-credit-hour courses, and I was given one course released time as Editor, the services of a graduate assistant who did the bulk of the initial text editing, and, crucially, secretarial help from the Public Affairs division, specifically from the staff of the publication Illinois Issues (a publication de-

Page 83

voted to state government). In addition, there was a small direct subsidy to cover those printing costs not taken care of by subscription earnings.

  1. What editorial contributions were made by other scholars, such as Associate Editor Lawrence Friedman?

In terms of support from others involved such as Associate Editors and Contributing Editors, Board members, etc., I could break it down roughly this way. The Contributing Editor, for most of the time, was on the staff of Illinois Issues and supervised the members of the secretarial staff who helped us with final proofing and generally made sure high stylistic and publication standards were maintained. Of the Associate Editors, Chuck was, of course, deeply and continuously involved; the Review was his creation and he cared a great deal about it. Larry Friedman was less involved and his commitment declined as time went on since he was consumed with his own scholarly work. Our Book Review Editor for part of the time was Mark Johnson, who held a MA in history from UIS and worked closely with Chuck on selecting books for review and the reviewers. We relied heavily on our Board members to seek submissions, evaluate submitted papers, and review books.

  1. Why did the Psychohistory Review cease publication in 1999 and how was the decision arrived at?

There were at least three factors in the decision to shut down. First, and most important, the stream of really good submissions became smaller during the last two years. Second, both Chuck and I had major writing projects underway in addition to heavier teaching loads, the latter exacerbated in my case by a third factor. The third factor was that a change in the University’s budgetary situation led the administration to make clear it could no longer support the Review to the extent it had done previously and that we would definitely lose the direct subsidy we had received, probably the graduate assistant, and possibly even the released time for me as Editor.

  1. What role did the Board of Editors play in the decision?

Chuck and I talked at length about the first problem, the decline in the volume of high quality submissions. Since we had taken pride in the high academic standards of the Review as worthy of comparison with other journals in the field of academic historical research, we felt it crucial to have a sufficient pool of academically rigorous articles from which to choose. We felt it better to cease publication when we were at the top of our form rather than to have the Review gradually decline. Consequently, we consulted with a few Board members who had been actively involved with the Review, and although most were reluctant to see the Review shut down, they fully understood and supported our decision.

David R. Beisel (May 13, 2015)

  1. Why and when did Lloyd deMause choose you as editor of the

Page 84

Journal of Psychohistory?

I was having dinner with Lloyd deMause and his wife at the conclusion of our first International Psychohistorical Association (IPA) Convention in June 1978, which I had run as the first convention chair. I had also been voted by the membership into the position of IPA president at the Business Meeting. The outcome of that vote was a surprise to me. An even bigger surprise came when Lloyd asked me to succeed him as the Journal’s editor. I first asked if he would promise not to interfere with any editorial decisions and he promised he would not. He kept that promise for the 10 years I was editor. He thanked me when I said yes because he said, “It would allow [him] to do all the writing he wanted to do without having to spend [his] time editing.”

  1. You are listed as Associate Editor of the Journal of Psychohistory in the fall of 1978. Were you the editor at that time?

I think I assumed the editorship with the next issue because Lloyd had already prepared the Fall 1978 issue.

  1. Did you share Lloyd deMause’s view of psychohistory as a science and emphasize hypotheses and theories much like the hard sciences? In reading deMause’s theories on fantasy analysis, the fetal origins of history, and toxic mothering, did you agree or disagree with them and how did it influence your editorship?

I never shared Lloyd’s view of psychohistory as a science or as a field trying to become one, or favored the lock-step dogma of the “psychogenic” theory or the total emphasis on childhood to the determinant of everything—it left history out of psychohistory. I felt then as I do now that his essay “The Independence of Psychohistory,” in which he called historians “astrologers” and psychohistorians “astronomers,” was not only off the mark but was a needless insult to my fellow historians and counter-productive to our being accepted by them, which in the long run proved to be the case.

  1. Did you inherit a mature Journal of Psychohistory or wasn’t it well established when you became editor?

Not sure what you mean by “mature” and “well established.” The JOP was well established because it had been publishing for several years and had a solid subscriber base. Some of the scholarship that had been published there, though extremely provocative, was based on solid evidence (Binion’s work on Hitler, Lloyd’s early work on childhood, things on the 19th century family, Kren on the Holocaust, on trauma, on sibling sequence, etc.), so it was “mature” in that sense. I thought under my editorship it would become more solidly academic and less theoretical.

  1. How did the Journal of Psychohistory grow under your editorship in a variety of terms (including readership)? Were there changes in who subscribed?

At one point in the early 1980’s Lloyd told me the readership was up to

Page 85

8,000, making us the second largest history journal in the country (according to him). I never checked his numbers, just took him at his word. I do know by personal anecdote that a goodly number of psychoanalysts and historians told me they let their subscriptions lapse when he started promoting his “birth stuff,” as many called it.

  1. How did you feel about non-professionals submitting articles to the journal?

Not sure what you mean by “non-professionals.” There were a number of contributors who were independent scholars without academic affiliations whose work I encouraged and published (Bob Rousselle, a PhD in ancient history from SUNY Binghamton; Mel Kalfus, Vice President of an advertising firm who got his PhD in American history at New York University after publishing with us). I was interested in any good work from any source, though it was clear from what we published that we mostly published the work of academics and therapists. But that was who was submitting. Anyone without a history, social science, or psychological background or a background in the humanities was unlikely to submit manuscripts anyway.

  1. What was the nature of the refereeing system you used and how helpful and time consuming was it?

I used two to three referees per article, sending out those articles that made the first cut, myself. It was a very time consuming process, particularly in those pre-computer days as everything had to be sent out via regular mail and we had to wait weeks for things to get to and fro.

  1. How would you describe the tone of the Journal of Psychohistory under your editorship?

I think the tone was serious—at least I hope it was—perhaps a little too academic, but I was very much aware of the charges being leveled at the journal as not being scholarly enough and was trying to offer some sufficiently documented essays to convince our critics to take us seriously. Perhaps I cared too much about the critics.

  1. What were your thoughts about the Psychohistory Review and the GUPH during your editorship? To what extent were they seen as rivals of the Journal and the IPA? How do you view Clio’s Psyche, which came into existence after your editorship?

I was never resentful of GUPH or the Psychohistory Review, though Strozier did throw lots of barbs at us and hit below the belt many times—I thought he was more outrageous than Lloyd sometimes and chalked it up to the desperate need we all felt to gain the respect of historians as a legitimate field. I felt the Review was a little boring but saw us as dividing the field into two groups, one a bit more conservative and the other a bit more innovative, two streams that enriched each other. I was never as militant as Lloyd in maintaining an image of two rival groups. When Clio came along I welcomed it as a fresh place to create dialogue and

Page 86

learn from. It has become a superb publication under Paul’s stewardship.

Beisel: Concerning more general questions and answers

  1. How do you think the next generation of psychohistorians should be trained? Should they have an extensive clinical and/or historical background?

Not sure how to answer this. I think people with an interest will gravitate to us. (I suspect it will always be a small group.) It is clear that there will be no Psychohistory Departments at any universities. My main concern is that people without training in the rigors of academic historiography will diminish the already diminished reputation of the field by a too casual approach to the historical side of research. I think that has to come first, before psychology or in addition to psychology; it is something that’s very difficult to learn on one’s own.

  1. Do you see a new wave of students entering the field as psychohistorians? Or is psychohistory largely dominated by the older generation? Are most newcomers mature scholars or clinicians who take up psychohistory later in life?

If popularity of subject is any guide, there are large numbers of untapped young people who would be happy to study psychohistory (8,000 have passed through my classes since 1978 and today my section and that of Denis O’Keefe fill up every semester). One semester’s encounter seems to be enough for most of our students, however. The question remains: where can they continue to study? I recommend continuing to read psychohistory while pursuing traditional fields such as sociology, history, and the humanities. Professionally, there is no advancement in the historical profession as the dogma of the AHA that psychohistory is dead (and the general ridicule of the field) alert young scholars that doing psychohistory isn’t going to get them anywhere. One can hope that once people get established and begin to feel there’s more to motivation than their elders have permitted them to see, they will find their way to the psychological and psychohistorical literature. Therapists are more inclined to come to us than social scientists—at least at the present moment. That is all to the good. But one can never predict what the next scholarly fashion might be. That’s why psychohistory isn’t a “science.”

David Lotto (May 11, 2015)

  1. When did you officially start editing the Journal of Psychohistory?

I became assistant editor in the spring of 2010 and became co-editor in the spring of 2014.

  1. Are you inclined to view psychohistory as a science or humanity?

That’s a complicated question and would take quite a while to answer fully. Quick summary: Within the boundaries of the quasi academic realm suggested by the science-humanity dichotomy, it’s a social science like history, psychology, sociology, anthropology, political science, or

Page 87

pedagogy. Psychohistory has affinities for and can share subject matter with areas usually considered to be within the domain of the humanities (for example, literature, art, music, etc.).

  1. How did Lloyd deMause or Susan Hein choose you as editor?

I have been involved with the IPA since the mid-1980’s and have known Lloyd and Susan for a long time.

  1. What are the challenges you face now as editor of the Journal?

Completing the transition to a peer-reviewed journal, which means continuing to attract manuscripts that meet the journal’s scholarly criteria.

  1. Is there a new wave of young scholar clinicians writing for the Journal, or does it tend to be dominated by the older generation?

It’s really a bit early for me to answer this question. I’ve only been co-editor for a year and at that time we had a substantial backlog of articles that had been accepted for publication. Previously, Lloyd always encouraged young and new writers, chiefly by giving presenters at the IPA convention—including students—a place to publish their work. We continue to welcome new contributors and will publish anything that meets the criteria of the journal. See the inside of the front cover of the journal for more specific information about criteria.

  1. Has the focus of the Journal changed since the editorships of Beisel and deMause?

If you look at the inside of the front cover there’s a list of the members of the Editorial Board. All of these people have agreed to act as peer reviewers. I select the three, four, or five reviewers based on the fit between the subject matter of the manuscript and the area of expertise of the Editorial Board member. In the past, there were some papers published in the Journal that would probably not have been acceptable to the current readers.

Paul H. Elovitz (During weekly meetings in April and early May, 2015)

  1. What makes psychohistory special and how does this connect to your vision of the mission of Clio’s Psyche?

Human beings are motivated far more by their emotions than by abstract ideas. The beauty and specialness of psychohistory is that it connects the emotions to the intellect and owns this reality rather than denying it. As Clio’s editor, this is one of my guiding principles. This is related to my not usually focusing on theory.

  1. Any regrets about starting Clio’s Psyche or any article you published?

No! It has all been a learning experience and quite an exciting adventure. In retrospect, it would’ve been good to go beyond our newsletter format to a traditional 6×9 inch journal format a few years earlier because col-

Page 88

leagues take the more expensive journal format more seriously. But we had to be sure that our finances were in place and that we didn’t go bankrupt. Regarding articles, I very occasionally scratch my head at the judgment of our referees. As to my own articles, I am mostly pleased when I look at them, although I certainly would write some differently at the present time.

  1. What’s the relationship between the Journal of Psychohistory, the International Psychohistory Association, and the Psychohistory Forum’s Clio’s Psyche?

There is no relationship beyond them all advocating psychohistory. The Journal is privately owned by the deMause family and has no legal relationship with the IPA. I serve on the Board of Editors of the Journal and am a founding member of IPA, past president, and the only colleague who has attended all 38 of the annual conferences. There is a lot of overlapping of membership and what we do. There are some colleagues who avoid the Journal and the IPA but find Clio and the Psychohistory Forum more to their liking.

  1. Is anyone in line for the future editorship of Clio’s Psyche?

One of the three journals went out of existence because the editors chose not to search for a replacement, even though there were several colleagues who, upon hearing of its demise, would gladly have assumed the position. The privately owned Journal of Psychohistory has transitioned to a new editor who has restored a refereeing system. Whether Clio’s Psyche will do the same upon my incapacity or retirement is yet to be determined. We welcome colleagues of all ages joining us in our editorial work.

  1. Can I view the three psychohistorical journals I have been reading about as on a spectrum?

Yes, in terms of broad generalizations from the perspective of their entire history, the Journal has been more theoretical and political in its approach, the Psychohistory Review more historical and devoted to the history of ideas, and Clio concerned with contemporary events and avoiding psychoanalytical/psychohistorical jargon. Each is unique in its own way.

Elovitz: Concerning more general questions and answers

  1. Why hasn’t psychohistory become the next big thing?

The basic principle is to take the message and ignore the messenger. Historians, journalists, and others use the psychohistorical messages when dealing with specific problems, but usually ignore or condemn the organized field. I identify as both a historian and a psychohistorian. The average layperson when they hear the word “psychohistory” thinks it makes perfect sense to combine history and psychology.

  1. Is psychohistory helpful in solving society’s problems? Do you see a role in public affairs for psychohistorians?

Page 89

Certainly psychohistory can be helpful. However, it is doubtful that politicians take our work into consideration, although there may be exceptions. For example, Jimmy Carter’s sister Gloria told me that while he was president, Carter read the 1977 book some of us contributed to on him, which emphasized the danger of his taking America to war. (However, there is no direct evidence that this influenced his decision not to go to war.) During the Reagan administration Lloyd deMause and a colleague went to the White House and gave a psychohistory seminar to a group of staff members. When Lloyd asked what the staff took away from the seminar, they were told that the staff listened to everyone and that the next week an astrologer would be giving a seminar. Subsequently, those close to Reagan reported that the astrologer definitely had some influence, at least in the timing of certain actions.

Concerning the second part of your question, Robert Jay Lifton and Vamik Volkan have certainly had a positive public role, but they have been viewed overwhelmingly as psychiatrists dedicated to peacemaking, rather than as psychohistorians.

Page 90

About the authors

Paul H. Elovitz

Dr. Paul H. Elovitz, PhD, began organizing scholarly meetings when he started as a faculty member at Ramapo College and then as convener of the Institute for Psychohistory Saturday Workshops (1975-1982). In 1982, he founded the Psychohistory Forum to nurture psychohistorical research and continues to lead its Executive Council. In 1994, he created Clio’s Psyche (cliospsyche.org) to publish its scholarship, of which he is Editor-in-Chief. Prof. Elovitz is a historian, psychoanalytic researcher, and author of well over 400 publications, covering presidential psychobiography, teaching, documenting the field of psychohistory, and much more. After taking his doctoral degree in history, he trained and practiced as a psychoanalyst for three decades, and in 2019 was made the first Research Psychoanalyst by the New Jersey Institute for Psychoanalysis. Elovitz is the author of The Making of Psychohistory, editor of The Many Roads of the Builders of Psychohistory, and edited or wrote eight other books. He is a founding member and past president of the International Psychohistorical Association (1978-) who held all but one of its offices and continues to serve on its leadership council. He is the sole founder of the IPhA who has attended and presented at all of its annual meetings. In recent years, he has devoted himself to editing, publishing, and writing psychobiography.  Prof. Elovitz was a founding faculty member at Ramapo College who previously taught at Temple, Rutgers, and Fairleigh Dickinson universities. Aside from teaching Western and World Civilizations, his focus on teaching was on American, English, and European history; childhood; gender; genocide; the Holocaust; identity; leadership; psychobiography; psychohistory; the psychology of creativity and innovation; and war and peace. Presently, he teaches post-graduate courses on creativity, psychoanalysis, psychobiography, and other aspects of psychohistory online at psychoanalytic institutes. A Festschrift honoring him is scheduled for publication in Clio’s Psyche in 2024. He may be contacted at .

How to cite this article

Cifelli, D., & Elovitz, P. H. (2015). Insights from psychohistorical journal editors. Clio’s Psyche, 22(1-2), 81-90.

https://doi.org/10.70763/92bf5e6240737e0326ea59846a83e076

PDF downloads