Volume 07 - Number 1 - June 2000
Pages: 2 - 50

THE FUTURE OF PSYCHOANALYSIS

Cofresi, N. I. (2000). A Latina analyst’s perspective. Clio’s Psyche, 7(1), 20-22.

https://doi.org/10.70763/8c6d39a0e9e6f344fb6a2d83c7c6787c

A Latina Analyst’s Perspective

article

Abstract

In this article, written for the section “The Future of Psychoanalysis,” the author reflects from her own experience on what psychoanalysis offers and where it is heading. She recounts growing up between New York City and rural Puerto Rico, with two languages and cultures and repeated uprooting. She also recounts family expectations for Puerto Rican women of her generation that conflicted with the autonomy she came to value through education during the feminist movement. She describes her own psychoanalytic treatment and training as the means by which she has integrated these opposing worlds. She reports working in academic psychology, where many regard psychoanalysis as non-empirical. She relates colleagues’ and students’ questions about how a Latina woman can espouse Freud’s theory, which imply that it is sexist, racist, and ill suited to someone of her background. In reply she cites the integration of feminist and cultural critiques into the theory and the outreach by psychoanalytic societies to culturally different and economically deprived groups. Drawing on her work with inner-city Latino and Appalachian patients and on one analytic case, she contends that analysis gives a space for storytelling and meaning-making, in which a less restrictive life narrative can be built. She maintains that Latinos, persons of color, and immigrants can benefit, though she notes that the demands of their lives often prevent access. She concludes that extending practice to such patients is a reason for optimism about the future of psychoanalysis.

Keywords:

autonomy, feminist revolution, free associations, Latina analyst, psychoanalysis, psychobiography, psychohistory, Puerto Rican culture, sense of self, Theodor Reik, trauma

My family often moved in the search for ever elusive economic stability. Consequently, I grew up surrounded by the asphalt and brick structures of New York City and was also raised in the mountains of rural Puerto Rico. The simultaneous experience of living within two different cultures with different values and speaking two distinct languages left indelible marks on my own psyche. My sense of self was further disjointed by the difficulties engendered by the exposure to the traumas and losses implicit in repeated uprooting. Typical for Puerto Rican women of my generation, I was expected by my family to put their needs before my own. However, I learned to value my auton-

Page 20

omy because I was educated in the midst of the feminist revolution, away from my familial and cultural milieu. In response to these discrepant demands, I often felt and sometimes still feel divided. Psychoanalysis has been for me the medium to integrate the many opposites coexisting in my mind.

In more than one area of my life, I inhabit contrasting worlds. In my personal life, I struggle to integrate my Puerto Rican heritage with the mainstream, middle-class, Anglo-American world to which a graduate education has made me privy. In my professional life, I work to meet the challenges of academic psychology, while becoming versed in psychoanalysis, a discipline dismissed as not empirical by many academicians. In my endeavors, I am grounded and guided by knowledge gained through years of psychoanalytic treatment and training. Though not always named or acknowledged, psychoanalysis quietly resonates in my discourse with students, colleagues, and friends, many of who are strangers to psychoanalysis. Whether they know it or not, my psychoanalytic perspective enriches our discussions.

On a more discordant note, colleagues and students ask: How can I, a Latina woman, espouse Freud’s theory? Implied in the question is the notion that psychoanalysis is sexist, racist, and ill suited to treat someone of my background. In my answers, I talk about the ongoing integration of feminist and cultural critiques with the theory. I describe the efforts by many psychoanalytic societies across the nation to provide outreach and services to the culturally and racially different and to the economically deprived. Sometimes, I even reveal the impact in my own life of a psychoanalytic experience. I tell of my own work with inner-city Latino and Appalachian patients. I describe the integration made possible by a method and a process that allows inner stories to unfold.

For instance, a Latina woman came to me, seeking a way to understand and put together the discordant strands of her life. She claimed that only a Latina woman could understand her experiences. I, too, wondered what it would be like to conduct an analysis with a woman whom I perceived to share my background. In retrospect, there are more differences than similarities between us.

What brings us together, two Latina women from different countries of origin, raised in different parts of the nation, with different histories? We are conjoined by her need to tell, and by my willingness to listen, informed by psychoanalytic theories. As she searches and finds words to express the inexpressible, we examine the many conflicts created in her by her experiences in two cultures, one dominant, one, until now, oppressed. We examine how her early experiences continue to reverberate in her present relationships and in the way she construes her perceptions. From her telling, we unravel the past. In the attempts at understanding, we weave her future. In this manner, we slowly reconstruct a life narrative that may be less restrictive in its possible outcomes.

Psychoanalysis as a therapeutic modality provides a space for individual storytelling and meaning-making, a time and place to transform the ideograms of the mind into coherent life narratives. Through this method, a capacity for unencumbered appreciation of the juxtaposition of blessings and tragedies can be discovered. Latinos and persons of color may have lives disrupted by uprootedness and unfortunate life circumstances. For them, as it has been for others, psychoanalysis is a unique vehicle to bridge what was then and what is now. The psychoanalytic relationship makes possible an all too rare opportunity to engage in a reflexive interplay of the past and the present with an objective but caring significant other. Persons of color and immigrants can certainly benefit greatly from taking the time to creatively connect to, examine, and possibly reframe neurotic feelings about their circumstances, themselves, and others. Unfortunately, the exigencies of life of persons of color in the United States does not often permit these individuals to make use of what psychoanalysis has to offer. Hopefully, this may change more rapidly in the second century of psychoanalysis.

This is not to say that all Latinos and immigrants react to their life trajectories in the way that I have described for my patient and for myself. However, for those similarly situated, psychoanalysis may help consolidate hard-won intrapsychic achievements over very oppressive and restrictive past and present circumstances. The widening extension of psychoanalytic practice to such non-traditional patients is one more reason to be optimistic about the future of psychoanalysis.

Page 21

About the author

Norma I. Cofresí

Norma I. Cofresí, PhD, is an assistant professor of psychology at Cleveland State University and was a 1998-1999 Fellow of the American Psychoanalytic Association. She is a candidate-in-training at the Cleveland Psychoanalytic Institute and has a psychoanalytic practice in the inner-city. Professor Cofresí may be reached at .

How to cite this article

Cofresi, N. I. (2000). A Latina analyst’s perspective. Clio’s Psyche, 7(1), 20-22.

https://doi.org/10.70763/8c6d39a0e9e6f344fb6a2d83c7c6787c

PDF downloads