Volume 30 - Number 1 - Fall 2023
Pages: 1 - 137

ESSAYS IN HONOR OF WILLIAM MCKINLEY RUNYAN

Demorest, A. P. (2023). Why did Skinner cut off his emotions? An idiographic approach to psychobiography. In J. W. Anderson, P. H. Elovitz, & N. D’Andria (Eds.), William McKinley Runyan Festschrift. Clio’s Psyche, 30(1), 82-90.

https://doi.org/10.70763/21c5bba1dd6aed9ab48c2b34c1a0adde

Why Did Skinner Cut Off His Emotions? An Idiographic Approach to Psychobiography

festschrift article

Abstract

In honor of Runyan’s championing of the idiographic approach, an idiographic method using Tomkins’ Script Theory is illustrated through analysis of Skinner’s avoidance of emotions.

Keywords:

B. F. Skinner, curiosity, festschrift, idiographic approach, Irving E. Alexander, Life Histories and Psychobiography, psychobiography, psychohistory, salience, Script Theory, Society for Personology, Silvan S. Tomkins, William McKinley Runyan

My History with Mac and the Idiographic Approach

The first title of this paper is meant as a tribute to William McKinley Runyan’s wonderful paper, “Why did van Gogh cut off his ear?” (1981). The second title is intended to pay homage to his

Page 82

wonderful book, Life Histories and Psychobiography (1982), in which the final two chapters are on idiographic methods and psychobiography. These two works were published just as I began graduate school, and Mac’s strong voice in calling for the idiographic study of individual lives was deeply influential to my professional development. Mac was also one of the original members of the Society for Personology, and I count myself lucky to have come to know him when I joined the group years later. Beyond admiring his work, I came to admire him as a person for his insatiable curiosity and generosity of spirit. I offer this paper on an idiographic approach to psychobiography in honor of Mac’s influence on me and the field.

As Mac pointed out, “idiographic” can refer both to a goal and a method. An idiographic goal seeks an in-depth understanding of a particular individual. Mac argued persuasively that although American psychology has been dominated by the goals of understanding people in general or groups of people, the study of individuals is a worthy enterprise for which psychology has much to offer. This would presumably be obvious to clinicians who engage fully in this enterprise in their daily work, but in academic psychology, there has been a tendency to see the enterprise as in essence not scientific. Mac’s 1982 book played a major role in correcting this bias, as it took a decidedly systematic and scientific approach to the study of individual lives. I remember hearing Mac’s voice as a representation of rationality in the face of pervasive prejudice. Here is just one example of many of his arguments that have stuck with me: “To the cry of ‘How can you generalize from that idiographic study?’ the equally appropriate response is ‘How can you particularize from that group or population study to the individual?’” (Runyan, 1982, p. 172).

As a method, the idiographic approach focuses on the discovery of those psychological variables significant to a particular individual and how those variables are organized within that individual. In his 1982 book, Mac reviewed a number of these methods. My goal in this paper is to describe and illustrate an additional one that has emerged since 1982, which I have found especially fruitful in my work. This approach is based on Silvan S. Tomkins’ (1987) Script Theory.

Tomkins’ Script Theory

Script Theory adopts the assumption that each person has their own unique views of life, which have emerged from their

Page 83

unique inheritances and experiences. It employs general psychological knowledge about emotions, motivations, and cognitions all people share as a function of being human: in particular, that there are many kinds of emotions we can experience; that we are motivated to increase positive emotions and decrease negative emotions; and that we develop schemas for understanding those emotional experiences that have been significant in our lived experience. However, the theory also assumes there is uniqueness in which emotions are most significant for each individual, in the priorities and strategies for maximizing positive emotion and minimizing negative emotion, and in the particular schemas each individual forms about emotional experiences. Below I review the basics of Script Theory and then illustrate the application of this theory to the case of psychologist B. F. Skinner.

According to Tomkins’s Script Theory, personality is organized around “scenes.” A scene is an emotional experience consisting of at least one emotion and one object or event that evokes the emotion; a scene can also include information about people, props, actions, etc. To understand and deal with emotionally significant experiences, people cognitively but nonconsciously link scenes together based on their similarities. This co-assembling of scenes results in “scripts,” which are implicit assumptions for anticipating and dealing with families of similar scenes, to maximize positive emotions and minimize negative emotions. According to this model, personality is a function of the significant scenes an individual has experienced and the expectations they have implicitly developed for anticipating and dealing with families of co-assembled scenes. The individual is both dramatist and actor, constructing the scripts through which to understand and live life.

Tomkins argued we are all endowed with the ability to feel a range of emotions, and we each meet a range of events in our lives, and thus each individual has many scripts. Further, people begin building rudimentary scripts as early as infancy. For example, the experience of physical distress caused by hunger innately leads an infant to cry out. Depending on how the caretaker responds, the infant’s distress can be alleviated or magnified, and from these differences can emerge individual differences in the first basic scripts about how one’s distress is relieved or made worse. With age comes both more experiences and a greater cognitive capacity for linking experiences together. For example, in the first six months of life, infants do not cry or show fear when returning to a

Page 84

doctor’s office for inoculation, but after six months, they do. Thus, with an increasing capacity for memory and imagination, the individual develops the ability to co-assemble similar emotional experiences that occur far apart in time.

According to Tomkins, in the initial stages of script formation, scenes determine what form a script will take. Important features of scenes are extracted and co-assembled, and the emerging script is modified to accommodate the information provided by newly met relevant scenes. At some point, however, a script is sufficiently formed enough to determine the individual’s experience of scenes. The script directs the individual to scan events for script-relevant properties and to synthesize analogs from those events, and in this way the script becomes self-confirming. A script established and used in self-confirming ways will require substantial disconfirmation in newly met scenes to be modified. It is the self-confirming nature of scripts that makes for the consistency of personality, and it is the disconfirmation of scripts in novel emotionally significant scenes that allows for personality change.

Thus, Script Theory offers a way to capture the complexity and uniqueness of human experience. In applying this theory to psychobiography, the best way to identify the important scripts that define an individual’s personality is to examine the individual’s narratives. Many different sources of narratives might be fruitful: autobiographies, diaries, letters, interviews, speeches, and professional writings. There are two steps required in deriving scripts from the narratives appearing in these sources: one, significant scenes must be identified; and two, scripts must be extracted from those scenes. Below I illustrate how each of these steps can be accomplished, using the case of psychologist B. F. Skinner.

Identifying Scripts for B. F. Skinner

To identify significant scenes, one method is to look for when emotion is expressed. Script Theory claims scenes are organized around the experience of emotion, and thus the appearance of emotion in a narrative should signify the basis for a scene. Given Skinner’s radical behaviorism (denying emotions have any role in determining human behavior), it is somewhat surprising that he expresses emotion at all in his autobiographical writings. One example occurs when Skinner recounts that he experienced “homesickness” in his first year at college and sent an illustrated book to his parents with a “maudlin” inscription of which he was soon “ashamed.” He also reports writing an imaginative story

Page 85

about the experience a few years later, suggesting he had scripted the scene. Skinner (1976/1984) reproduced that imaginative story in his autobiography:

Father and mother had laughed at Henry’s first letters. Prosaic descriptions of college, the food, and his health, but with them an occasional unguarded note of homesickness…. His overtones of homesickness increased as the months passed until a book came, carefully planned to reach home on mother and father’s wedding anniversary. It was a large book, a gift edition in blue and gold, called Beautiful Homes of History. On the first page was carefully written: ‘To father and mother, whose home surpasses the beauty and holiness of any of these. Henry.’ Mother read it with moist eyes, and hated to have father smile at it.… But after it was put on top of the bookstand, father occasionally laughed at it; and sometimes mother smiled too…. Two months afterward Henry came home for the holidays. But during the first hour when he told them his joyous history, no one spoke of the book. No one even spoke of homesickness.… That night before [mother] went to bed she went to the bookstand and ran her fingers over the cool gold letters on the blue cover.… Then with a little swell of feeling she lifted the cover. But the first page had been removed with a sharp knife. (pp. 202-203)

Thus, this portrays an emotion-laden scene worthy of a script analysis.

Once a scene has been identified, the next task is to derive a script from it. According to Tomkins, people form scripts by linking together different but similar emotional experiences, so scripts are more general than scenes. Further, to enable the individual to predict and respond to future experiences, the script provides a sequential outline of what events should be expected to follow in what order. Thus, to derive scripts from scenes, we must translate the particular scene into abstract and sequential form. Applying these principles to this scene would yield a script such as the following: “I express homesickness toward intimate authority figures 🙠✇ they ridicule me 🙠✇ I feel shame 🙠✇ I avoid such expressions in future.” This could also be written in narrative form as: “If I express homesickness toward intimate authority figures, they will ridicule me and leave me feeling ashamed, therefore I should avoid such expressions in future.” We cannot know from only one scene

Page 86

 how abstract the elements of a script are (e.g., whether this script applies to other types of emotions besides homesickness, or other types of people besides intimate authorities); for that, we would need the full family of scenes.

A second method for finding significant scenes is to look for “identifiers of salience” (Alexander, 1988). Irving E. Alexander proposed that people signal important material by how they tell their stories. If we can learn to read these signals, we can know what is most important to them. He named nine identifiers of salience: primacy (what comes first), frequency (what recurs), emphasis (what is accented), uniqueness (what is unusual), negation (what is denied), omission (what is missing), error (what is a mistake), isolation (what does not fit), and incompletion (what is left unfinished). Some of these signals of importance might be intentional (e.g., emphasis) and others not (e.g., error). They are especially valuable as guides to significant material when a person is not emotionally expressive, as is the case for Skinner.

Another scene from Skinner’s first year in college was made salient by many of Alexander’s identifiers of salience. When Skinner was spending time with his younger brother Ebbe while he was home for the holidays, Ebbe suddenly developed a severe headache, fell unconscious, and died. The first account Skinner gives of this experience is in an autobiographical chapter in which he writes “I was not much moved” (Skinner, 1967, p. 388). This is salient by negation (not much moved) and uniqueness (how many people would not be moved by such a thing?). The account Skinner gives in his full autobiography a decade later contradicts the first account (error) as well as demonstrates a double negation: “I was far from unmoved” (why not simply say he was moved?). Further, although his two accounts differ in whether he was moved, they both continue in the same paragraph with the same odd association (uniqueness and isolation); Skinner reports that he had once in childhood struck his brother with an arrow and was shocked when years later he heard Hamlet’s lines:

Let me disclaiming from a purpos’d evil
Free me so far in your most generous thoughts
That I have shot mine arrow o’er the house,
And hurt my brother. (Skinner, 1976/1984, p. 210)

Both accounts end here without any explanation of the association (incompletion).

Page 87

The negation, error, and incompletion in Skinner’s accounts of this scene suggest he is not giving the full story; he may even be defending against his own awareness of it. In such a case, it becomes important to identify other related scenes to fill out the script. From his reports of this scene, it appears Ebbe’s death led Skinner to recollect and feel guilty about past harm he had done to his brother. In looking for related scenes in his autobiography, I found only one instance in which Skinner did anything harmful to his brother, and it hardly seems to merit profound feelings of guilt: He tricked Ebbe into stepping on a cow pie. However, I also found that sibling rivalry was made salient by both negation and frequency: After recounting that Ebbe enjoyed more affection from their parents, Skinner reports he was never aware of any rivalry; he repeats this denial of rivalry in two other places as well. Again, this negation might give evidence of censorship on Skinner’s part.

What about any related imagery in imaginative stories, which might be less defended since they are not autobiographical? An informative instance occurs in Skinner’s professional writing when he offers an example to illustrate the behavioral approach to “Freudian dynamisms.” This example imagines a boy feeling rivalry with his brother over affection from their parents, leading him to aggress against his brother. But punishment from the parents leads the boy to feel guilty, and thus to repress any knowledge of his aggressive tendencies. Putting these various narrative accounts together suggests that Ebbe’s sudden and unexpected death might have reawakened Skinner’s previously repressed guilt about past hostile feelings toward his brother, resulting in further repression of his feelings (at first characterized as being not much moved). This indicates a script along the lines of the following: “If I express hostility to an intimate peer, intimate authorities will punish me, making me feel guilty; therefore, I should avoid even being aware of those hostile feelings.”

Implications of these Scripts

The two scripts extracted thus far show some similar elements in sequence, indicating they may both belong to a more general script. In both, an emotion is felt and expressed (homesickness; hostility) but is met with a negative response from intimate authorities (ridicule; punishment); this leads to feelings of negative self-judgment (shame; guilt) and censorship of the original emotion. There may be sub-scripts within this general script: For example, perhaps positive emotions such as affection are at risk for

Page 88

ridicule and shame, whereas negative emotions such as hostility are at risk for punishment and guilt.

Regarding the earlier question of how abstract the script elements should be, other scenes in Skinner’s autobiography suggest a range of emotions are relevant to this general script, which applies to both parents. For example, in one scene involving the emotion of pleasure, Skinner tells his father he has made a date to meet a girl to talk about Dostoevsky, and his father responds by laughing “with half-veiled disgust.” In another scene involving pleasure, Skinner tells his mother he is going to a piano recital with tea afterward, and his mother responds with the remark: “Don’t you think that’s so effeminate?” It thus appears that Skinner experienced a host of scenes in which a range of emotions was met with negative responses from both parents, leading him to feel ashamed and guilty about these emotions and to censor them in his behavior and his thoughts. Indeed, this pattern of disavowing feelings characterized Skinner’s professional claims in radical behaviorism: He argued that the experience of emotion has no place in the science of human behavior. This analysis of some members of a family of scenes and their consequent script might explain why Skinner cut off emotions.

I hope in this paper to have illustrated how a script analysis can be fruitfully used to capture both the complexity and uniqueness of the human experience. It is a valuable tool to add to our list of idiographic approaches to psychobiography.

Page 89

References

  • Alexander, Irving E. (1988). Personality, psychological assessment, and psychobiography. Journal of Personality, 56, 265-294.
  • Runyan, William McKinley (1982). Life Histories and Psychobiography. Oxford University Press.
  • Skinner, B. F. (1967). B. F. Skinner. In Edwin Boring & Gardner Lindzey (Eds.), A History of Psychology in Autobiography, Vol. V (pp. 387-413). Appleton-Century-Crofts.
  • Skinner, B. F. (1984). Particulars of my life. New York University Press. (Original work published 1976).
  • Tomkins, Silvan S. (1987). Script theory. In Joel Aronoff, Albert I. Rabin, & Robert A. Zucker (Eds.), The Emergence of Personality (pp. 147-216). Springer.

About the author

Amy P. Demorest

Amy P. Demorest, PhD, is the Eryn L. Oberlander Professor of Psychology at Amherst College. She earned a BA from Williams College and a PhD from Duke University, and she has done a research fellowship at the Center for Psychotherapy Research at the University of Pennsylvania and a clinical fellowship at the Massachusetts Institute of Psychoanalysis. Her book, Psychology’s Grand Theorists (2004), provides an idiographic analysis of Freud, Skinner, and Rogers. She can be reached at .

How to cite this article

Demorest, A. P. (2023). Why did Skinner cut off his emotions? An idiographic approach to psychobiography. In J. W. Anderson, P. H. Elovitz, & N. D’Andria (Eds.), William McKinley Runyan Festschrift. Clio’s Psyche, 30(1), 82-90.

https://doi.org/10.70763/21c5bba1dd6aed9ab48c2b34c1a0adde

PDF downloads