Volume 06 - Number 4 - March 2000
Pages: 133 - 184

THE FUTURE OF PSYCHOHISTORY

Dervin, D. (2000). The family origins of creativity [Review of the book The Creative Matrix: Anxiety and the Origin of Creativity by Andrew Brink (2000)]. Clio’s Psyche, 6(4), 181-183.

https://doi.org/10.70763/e698959e9b93e4de823526327ffed84a

The Family Origins of Creativity

book review

Abstract

This review of Andrew Brink’s study of creativity describes the book’s effort to trace creative processes to a biopsychological matrix in the mother-infant attachment relationship. The reviewer reports that Brink, drawing on John Bowlby’s attachment theory and an evolutionary perspective on wound-healing adaptation, argues that creativity begins in the instinctual attachment system and differentiates in response to anxiety from suboptimal early attachment. On this account, aesthetic objects serve as anxiety organizers and containers, and cultural products as repair codes. The review outlines the book’s survey of psychoanalytic positions (Freud, Rank, the English object relations school, Alice Miller), its treatment of creativity and bipolar disorder through Nancy Andreasen and Kay Redfield Jamison, and its reading of Lowell, Sexton, and Plath through family studies by Cohen and Gibson. The reviewer judges the survey chapters deftly balanced, finds the Cohen-Gibson model very broad as a predictor of a specific disorder and somewhat dated, and considers Brink strongest when he departs from his models, as in his chapter on regeneration. The reviewer questions the attachment framework as deployed, contending that it remains focused on the maternal dyad and neglects identification and the oedipal restructuring of the psyche, so that Harold Bloom’s theory of the anxiety of influence falls outside its scope. The reviewer concludes with a favorable overall assessment, crediting the book with clarifying a still obscure area.

Keywords:

Andrew Brink, anxiety, basic fault, book review, The Creative Matrix: Anxiety and the Origin of Creativity, Emily Dickinson, evolutionary perspective, Leonardo da Vinci, maternal dyad, Michael Balint, mirroring, Mona Lisa, palimpsest, psychohistory, Simon Grolnick

What do Middlemarch, the Mona Lisa, The Three-Penny Opera, and the gnomic squiggles of Emily Dickinson have in common? Granting they are all products of the creative imagination, one might still be forgiven for answering, “Not much.” The whole field of creativity is so complex that no simple, candid response can satisfy this question. Still, if one probes these random examples a bit, one may recall a recent X-ray analysis of Leonardo’s masterpiece revealing it to be a palimpsest with his own image underneath, and the analyst Simon Grolnick described Emily Dickinson as poetry surrounded by prose. This sense of misfit, which the Hungarian-English Michael Balint referred to as the “basic fault,” emanating from a failure in the maternal dyad, may also have something to do with the traces of mirroring in Leonardo’s mysterious Mona.

Reversing perspective from the creative product to its process is irresistible, yet to find a single unifying explanation for the perplexing mysteries of creativity is a daunting task, and on art as on sex everyone is a self-proclaimed expert. The field of creativity, even within the restrictions of psychoanalysis, is so enormously complex that reductionism is unavoidable. In Andrew Brink’s narrowed focus on origins and anxiety, the trick is to avoid the so-called genetic fallacy, a psychoanalytic term having nothing to do with genes but with the tendency to account for complex phenomena exclusively through origins.

The present aim to trace creative processes to a biopsychological matrix is thus both valid and hazardous. Adopting an evolutionary perspective, Brink suggests that earlier species have been hardwired for a kind of problem-solving, wound-healing adaptation which Homo sapiens has acquired and converted to psychological ends, although the higher that organisms evolve the lower the capacity for regeneration. Drawing on the attachment theory of Bowlby and others, he examines the ways in which nurturant processes can go awry in the maternal dyad, leading to various creative adaptations. “Creativity begins with the in-

Page 181

stinctual attachment system which unites mother and infant at the start of life. Creativity differentiates adaptively, in response to anxiety, in the exceptional skills with materials, words, and notes found among artists, writers, and composers.” Rather than possessing any distinctly imaginative faculty, “every artist or writer produces a personal iconography, primarily as a result of attachment-induced anxieties, only secondarily in response to social ills and injustices.” This trauma-based anxiety, which cues creative responses—cures, solutions, adaptations—stems from a “sub-optimal attachment style at the opening of life” (p. 1).

Attachment theorists, who to me tilt toward the input-output mode of behaviorism rather than the vicissitudes of identification explored in psychoanalysis, propose three models: secure, anxious-ambivalent, and avoidant (a fourth, disorganized/disorientated, was added later). Among the latter, anxieties over security intrude or prevail; however, reparative strategies also may come into play. Brink’s matrix of creativity is situated in the “‘interactive repair’ between mother and infant” (p. 6). In this universal matrix, the initial creative response is a resource, democratically deployed across the human spectrum; it may culminate in homeostasis and the sense of inner well-being, of feeling all together and connected, as well as in a product of inspired genius to be cherished down through the ages. I suppose it can also result in kitsch, doggerel, or romance fiction, but that is another question, for creativity is construed here as basically a self-regulating adaptation rather than a source of original visions (p. 8).

Brink’s strategy is two-pronged. On the one hand he wants to exceed the limitations of object relations. On the other hand, he wants to extend the insights of Bowlby to the inanimate objects that form the building blocks of aesthetic experience; Brink terms aesthetic objects “anxiety organizers and containers” to be reproduced a la Winnicott in a “safe place” (p. 179). He also aspires to further his own earlier studies of Loss and Symbolic Repair (1977), Creativity as Repair (1982), and Bertrand Russell: The Psychobiography of a Moralist (1989). His overall thrust is melioristic; he makes the organism’s self-organizing capacities a key concept. In his conclusion, he expands on the biologically-based regenerative capacities of creativity and considers cultural products as providing “repair codes,” an invaluable traditional function lost in the modern period, but in need of being re-instated on newer but more limited grounds.

After introducing his themes in Part I, he reviews several psychoanalytic positions on creativity, including Freud and Rank, the English object relations school, and Alice Miller. These mini-studies are insightful and deftly balanced. Part III examines creativity in a bipolar context. The investigators here are Nancy Andreason and Kay Redfield Jamison, the one over-relying on empirical data, the other on genetic inheritance. Here the theme wrapped inside his others emerges in his seeking to preserve creativity as a centrally human endeavor rather than as an illness or a genetic defect.

The poets Robert Lowell, Anne Sexton, and Sylvia Plath are considered from studies by Cohen and Gibson. They profile a family isolated from the community, hampered by an “abusive, weak, or absent father and an over-controlling mother,” complicating attachment for the child and arousing allied anxieties (pp. 158, 168). The mother blames the father for the family’s isolation or ostracism, and “singles out a promising boy or girl to “push” toward delivering the family from its obscurity. The delegated child was to establish or restore family prestige by outstanding achievement” (p. 158). If this formula of ineffectual father/overbearing mother sounds familiar, that’s because it coincides with contemporaneous psychoanalytic constructs of homosexuality, notably by Irving Bieber in the early 1960s. The model, which also anticipates Helm Stierlin’s studies of the child-delegate as family savior, could apply equally well to Adolf Hitler as to Bill Clinton, neither of whom need be viewed as bipolar or, for that matter, creative, though Hitler tried. In other words, the Cohen-Gibson model is extremely broad as a predictor of a specific disorder and somewhat dated. Nonetheless, Brink makes good use of it in interpreting the three poets’ blighted careers.

Brink seems to me at his best when he is out on a limb, thinking independently of his models or carefully interrogating them as in his chapter on regeneration. Bound to the maternal dyad, attachment theorists—at least as deployed here—feel regressively focused to me; they neglect narratives of internalization/identification that form a self otherwise assumed to be already in place. They have little, if anything, to say of the radical restructuring the psyche undergoes during the oedipal triangulations which profoundly affect gender-identity and the cultural forms with which creativ-

Page 182

ity interacts. Thus, for example, the male poet’s oedipal patterns in Harold Bloom’s well-grounded Anxiety of Influence theory would be out of bounds since it is occurs beyond the maternal dyad; assuming pre-oedipal precursors, they are not the final determinants.

Overall, there is much to applaud and admire in Brink’s always stimulating and richly informed study. I finished it doubly appreciative of the great distance between origins and output, of the necessary if elusive links between them, and grateful for genuine contributions to a still obscure area which his investigations allow us to see more clearly.

Page 183

About the author

Dan Dervin

Dan Dervin, PhD, emeritus professor at Mary Washington College in Fredericksburg, Virginia, is a prolific author and frequent contributor to psychohistory. His book, Father Bosetti in America: A Biographical Study, is due out in August from Cache Glade Publications. Professor Dervin may be contacted at .

How to cite this article

Dervin, D. (2000). The family origins of creativity [Review of the book The Creative Matrix: Anxiety and the Origin of Creativity by Andrew Brink (2000)]. Clio’s Psyche, 6(4), 181-183.

https://doi.org/10.70763/e698959e9b93e4de823526327ffed84a

PDF downloads