Volume 12 - Number 1 - June 2005
Pages: 1 - 34

SCHIAVO
SPECIAL FEATURE

Dervin, D. (2005). Saint Terri: Deification in place of mourning. Clio’s Psyche, 12(1), 7-8.

https://doi.org/10.70763/cf0d02ec99e61a64137b8a2c3b03e030

Saint Terri: Deification in Place of Mourning

article

Abstract

This article, part of the special feature on Terri Schiavo, offers the author’s reflections on American public responses to her case during her final days in Easter week 2005. The author suggests that the responses reflect a failure to mourn, an unwillingness to relinquish earlier attachments with unresolved issues, which are displaced onto Schiavo. On this view, the causes gathered around her, which cast her as a late-term fetus, a battered wife, or a starved Holocaust victim, carry underlying anger and older grievances. The author then follows a more speculative line of association, comparing televised images of Schiavo with Bernini’s Saint Teresa in Ecstasy, and suggests that her supporters may implicitly wish to preserve her in an ambiguous state between life and death. Asking why this case drew such attention when others did not, the author recalls that Congressman Tom DeLay, a prominent advocate, and his family made a private decision when his father suffered a head injury, and raises the question of her being a young, attractive white woman. Citing Elisabeth Bronfen’s Over Her Dead Body: Death, Femininity, and the Aesthetic (1992), the author places her within a Western artistic tradition of representing beautiful, deathlike women, and invokes Freud’s “The Uncanny.” The article closes by asking whether she will be forgotten, as the Elián González controversy was, or remembered as a secular saint.

Keywords:

cultural causes, emotional injury, failure to mourn, genocidal policies, grievances, Holocaust victim, mourning, psychohistory, religious controversies, Terri Schiavo, unresolved issues

As I reflect on the meaning of Terri Schiavo in her final days midway into Easter week, 2005, her image and condition are by now familiar throughout the world. Her story has become a magnet for controversies and narratives that increase daily and exponentially. Finding it impossible to do justice to such many-sided complexity, I will restrict myself to an interpretation of an emotional theme which no doubt has already occurred to many others. This is the failure to mourn, the inability or unwillingness to let go of a previous attachment with unresolved issues which Terri stands-in for. This situation of prior impasse and present displacement onto Terri provides a commentary on various high-profile religious and cultural causes that reveals a tangle of underlying rage and demonizing style. Terri thus becomes the late-term fetus whose umbilical tubes have been removed, the battered wife, or the starved Holocaust victim of genocidal policies. But underlying these images among the crowd of protesters are likely to be more painful memories of emotional injury and long-cherished grievances.

This inability-to-mourn interpretation no doubt accords with most mainstream mental-health professionals. Beyond this I would like to pursue a more exceptional line of associations. The televised images of Terri—her white virginal face tilted upward, her eyes discreetly closed, her lips receptively parted—evoke parallels with Bernini’s Saint Teresa in Ecstasy. Captured in an exalted moment, the saint is possessed by the Lord as totally as her contemporary namesake has been possessed by others’ causes and agendas. Animated by others, Terri seems to inhabit a privileged and even blessed state of consciousness. Because oxygen was not sent to her brain during a crucial time-lapse following a heart attack 15 years ago, she is said to be in a vegetative state and, according to attending physicians, “brain dead.”

But paradoxically, Terri is treated as being very much alive, not only by a medical life-support system but by a spiritual life-support network of devoted followers. She must be alive in some sense, so we tell ourselves, because short of timely interventions she faces imminent death. Is she unconscious or, as her friends have maintained, aware? In pain or at peace? Present or absent? It thus seems plausible that it is precisely this interstate that not only galvanizes Terri’s supporters but that they implicitly strive to preserve. For some reason, they strive to keep their “Saint Terri” just as she is.

To ask why and to entertain motives is to open the proverbial can of worms. Don’t go there, the voice of prudence whispers, and its advice is sound. But where we can go is to the historical and cultural context. One may then ask, “Why Terri?” Others have been placed in similar states and had their life-support systems quietly cut off without any uproar. One of Terri’s strongest champions, Congressman Tom DeLay, went through this ordeal when his father suffered a near fatal head injury, and the family huddled together to make their decision in private and without controversy. Terri is supposedly different, but then every case is slightly different.

Should it be factored in that Terri is an attractive young white female? Can there be something appealing in the passive image of a beautiful woman in a deathlike trance or coma? Elisabeth Bronfen’s Over Her Dead Body: Death, Femininity, and the Aesthetic (NY: Routledge, 1992) explores the surprising links between femininity and death in Western art and literature and how the beautiful lifeless female body has become fetishized. Think of the naked women on anatomists’ operating tables, of the hypnotized women in Charcot’s clinic, of the undead women entombed in Poe’s tales. Of especial interest to Bronfen are Millais’ rendition of the drowned flower-child Ophelia along with other Pre-Raphaelite paintings by Dante Gabriel Rossetti of Miss Siddall, notably her saintly up-tilted posture as his “Beata Beatrix.” Writing as a feminist scholar, Bronfen views women under patriarchy as contradictorily combining “plenitude and lack” (p. 122).

Suffice it to say, Terri shares this ambience and thus joins a long-standing tradition of ambiguously represented women. Moreover, there is something uncanny in the responses her person has been able to elicit. As we know, Freud’s paper on “the

Page 7

‘uncanny’” begins with one’s feelings of ambivalence and misgivings over whether something seemingly inanimate is really alive, or whether something seemingly lifeless might be animate. The uncanny is another way of addressing contradictory, emotionally-charged perceptions, which consistently in the present context apply to women.

What should ultimately be made of all this? Will Terri soon be consigned to oblivion, like the now forgotten brouhaha over Elián González? Or is she a secular saint for our time, a virginal martyr whose uncanny power to signify immortal flesh must be preserved at all costs?

[Editor’s Note: The previous three articles reflect more of what American society and individuals in it project onto Terri Schiavo than on what an individual goes through emotionally when a beloved one falls into a vegetative state prior to death. Our concluding article describes one woman’s struggle with this issue and its aftermath. Though it is more of a cry from the heart than an analysis of Schiavo, the editors and referees feel it adds an important dimension to the discussion.]

Page 8

About the author

Dan Dervin

Dan Dervin, PhD, emeritus professor at Mary Washington College in Fredericksburg, Virginia, is a prolific author and frequent contributor to psychohistory. His book, Father Bosetti in America: A Biographical Study, is due out in August from Cache Glade Publications. Professor Dervin may be contacted at .

How to cite this article

Dervin, D. (2005). Saint Terri: Deification in place of mourning. Clio’s Psyche, 12(1), 7-8.

https://doi.org/10.70763/cf0d02ec99e61a64137b8a2c3b03e030

PDF downloads