Volume 18 - Number 3 - December 2011
Pages: 249 - 371

BOOK REVIEWS

Dervin, D. (2011). Eigen on object-relations [Review of the book Madness and Murder: Eigen in Seoul, Volume 1 by Michael Eigen (2011)]. Clio’s Psyche, 18(3), 368-371.

https://doi.org/10.70763/991327d63593b0ba2c45618bf81f6a64

Eigen on Object-Relations

book review

Abstract

This book review considers Michael Eigen’s Madness and Murder: Eigen in Seoul, Volume 1 (Karnac, 2011), which collects three seminars given to an analytic community in Seoul in 2007. The reviewer reports that the seminars begin from Freud’s view of the early ego and then take up Melanie Klein on annihilation anxiety and the paranoid-schizoid and depressive phases, D. W. Winnicott on the infant’s scream as communication, and Wilfred Bion on wounded nourishment. The final seminars, drawing on Eigen’s own work including Toxic Nourishment, turn to destructiveness in relationships, how the other survives it, and contrasting maternal responses to an infant’s vitality. The reviewer judges that Eigen’s insights show how these analysts complement and reinforce one another. The review then addresses psychohistorians, whom it characterizes as favoring universalist theory. It cites David Beisel’s family-systems work, Lloyd deMause’s evolution of parenting modes, the Oedipus complex, and Margaret Mahler’s account of early development as examples. The reviewer proposes Eigen’s synthesis as a paradigm for the pre-oedipal zone of early hazards and traumas. It argues that these persist into adult life and are displaced onto history, and suggests that reconstructing the self before splitting may clarify the form, direction, and tenacity of the splitting on which much psychohistorical work rests.

Keywords:

analyst community, book review, Madness and Murder: Eigen in Seoul, Volume 1, Michael Eigen, Object Relations, psychoanalysis, psychoanalytic seminars, psychohistory, The Psychotic Core, Seoul

Review of Michael Eigen, Madness and Murder: Eigen in Seoul, Volume 1 (London: Karnac, 2011), ISBN-13:978-1-85575-819-3, 92 pages. Paperback, $26.00.

This slender but exceedingly rich and provocative text consists of three seminars which the noted American psychoanalyst and author Michael Eigen (debut work: The Psychotic Core, 1986) delivered on consecutive days to an analytic community in Seoul in 2007. A second volume of follow-up sessions in 2009 is forthcoming.

While Eigen has ventured far into the terra incognita of severe mental disorders and cognate early developmental issues, his home field is the English object-relations school. Thus, the seminars explore major themes in those analysts’ work. After duly anchoring his discourse on Freud’s view that the (early) ego is a “hallucinating wish-fulfilling organ” (p. 3), Eigen locates elements of madness in the other psychic systems of id and superego as well, confirming the axiom that the ego is not master of its house.

He begins with Melanie Klein, who addresses the destructive import of these warring agencies. For her, the primary anxiety is dread of annihilation, and the two ways people go crazy is by becoming schizophrenic or depressed. She then turns these conditions into defenses against annihilation and situates them in early development as the paranoid-schizoid and the depressive phases, the latter leading to reparative gestures and subsequent adaptations.

Recalling that as a young man he had tried out primal scream therapy, Eigen allows for its meeting needs to a limited degree, and next turns to D.W. Winnicott’s approach wherein “it’s not the patient screaming” but “hearing and feeling and coming in contact with the scream within” (p. 27). In infancy, the scream is a communication, a cry against the terror of helplessness, the specter of disorganization, the prospect of hopeless withdrawal. The scream may become accessible in analysis when processed through patients’ dreams.

Page 368

Wilfred Bion enters via a clinical vignette: a patient is indulging a pleasant mood in a restaurant when the waitress refills his cup only halfway; that does it for him, he couldn’t go forward after that (p. 41). From this not uncommon experience, Bion developed the themes of “wounded nourishment” and the “wounding nourisher” (p. 44). “In psychic logic in the psychotic mode, half empty means more than totally empty,” Eigen comments; as a baby, the “patient was fed wounds” and “ate its own or another’s wounds to nourish its psychophysical being” (p. 45). Sometimes this flawed nourishment is associated with a scream. The patient is hopelessly signaling, “Catastrophe in progress. Catastrophe in progress. I’m a catastrophe. Life is a catastrophe. Help me! Help me!” (p. 47). For Eigen, “psychotic language is an SOS in progress” (p. 48).

Eigen’s own contribution to this maddening state of affairs is Toxic Nourishment, and his final seminars round to the theme of murder, drawing on two of his other texts, The Sensitive Self and Emotional Storm. Here, the theme is the ingrained destructiveness in relationships, notably (drawing on Winnicott) how the other survives our destructiveness and how destructive drives can feed on themselves, like an infant who cannot stop screaming (p. 60). Of course, Eigen is also addressing how we handle others’ negativity. These dynamics he anchors in the ways a mother might respond to her infant’s robust alive-and-kicking energies. She can enjoy and affirm these vital energies, short of letting herself be hurt, or she can feel threatened and withdraw, defending herself with a moralistic response—kicking is bad; it is wrong (p. 60). The first mother promotes communication, mutual surviving, and forgiving; the second mother in her fixed omniscience of always knowing best undermines the baby’s trust in itself as well as in her and most likely will not survive intact her empathic failures.

Ultimately, it is Eigen’s seasoned insights that reveal useful ways these analysts complement and reinforce one another. All well and good, one may say; so much for the psyche, what about the history? Speaking of which, these texts appeared decades ago: we’re in a new millennium with a host of new issues to contend with. That was then, this is now.

True enough, but neither time nor history follows a simple chronology. As psychohistorians we want to be tuned into cultural

Page 369

differences and historical changes, but on a scale running from cultural relativism to universalism, we cluster around the latter. We’re not inclined to blow off genital mutilation or child abuse as simply religious or cultural practices. Not surprisingly, in Anna Geifman’s review of Charles B. Strozier, et al., The Fundamentalist Mindset, this mindset is taken as a “universal phenomenon” (Clio’s Psyche [Dec 2010]:17:3:p. 248).

Moreover, most of our writing in the field is validated, clarified, and assigned a degree of authority by recourse to a body of theory with claims to universality. When available, empirical and clinical data can be marshaled to reinforce, or at times complicate, prevailing psychohistorical hypotheses and conclusions. Our choices tend to be pragmatic and serendipitous; David Beisel, for example, deploys family-systems theory to explore parallels with the Hitlers and the European family of nations leading up to World War II (The Suicidal Embrace, 2003). I have relied heavily on Lloyd deMause’s historical evolution of parenting modes, which uses empirical data to trace gradual improvements in child-care (supported by decreasing rates of infant mortality).

Within psychoanalysis, others, along with myself, have gotten a great deal of mileage from classical psychoanalytic accounts of the Oedipus complex as the so-called nuclear conflict underpinning cultural evolution and ongoing generational striving. It encompasses the myth of the primal horde, incest taboos, exogamy, and tools for dismantling the patriarchy. Margaret Mahler’s narrative of early child development as spanning the mother-infant dual unity of symbiosis to separation-individuation, stopping at the threshold of the oedipal period is invaluable for tracing early normal development. Although the universality of the Oedipus complex has been debated at length while simultaneously being taken over as axiomatic by wide-ranging media, Mahler’s scenario is less sensational but also less contestable: every child must to a degree separate from primary caregivers and individuate into a relatively autonomous center of self-initiative.

All of which is by way of proposing Eigen’s synthesis of object-relations theory as a paradigm for filling in a certain void: a zone of elusive hazards, miscues, and traumas which derail infants and toddlers from the prescribed paths of good-enough develop-

Page 370

ment prior to the high cultural visibility of oedipal realities. These early crises do not simply fall by the wayside but can persist to impact adult life in various oblique ways and eventually are displaced onto history. In practical terms, much of our psychohistorical work presumes a prior splitting in the self—resulting in we vs. them positions, hate groups vs. victim groups, and idealized leaders delegated to dispense a boundless supply of goodies to the electorate. But evoking a self-in-formation prior to splitting, along with reconstructions of the forces propelling the split, may reveal something about the form, direction, and tenacity of this inevitable and irreversible split as the individual inevitably stumbles onto the historical stage.

Page 371

About the author

Dan Dervin

Dan Dervin, PhD, emeritus professor at Mary Washington College in Fredericksburg, Virginia, is a prolific author and frequent contributor to psychohistory. His book, Father Bosetti in America: A Biographical Study, is due out in August from Cache Glade Publications. Professor Dervin may be contacted at .

How to cite this article

Dervin, D. (2011). Eigen on object-relations [Review of the book Madness and Murder: Eigen in Seoul, Volume 1 by Michael Eigen (2011)]. Clio’s Psyche, 18(3), 368-371.

https://doi.org/10.70763/991327d63593b0ba2c45618bf81f6a64

PDF downloads