Volume 19 - Number 3 - December 2012
Pages: 249 - 368

LETTERS TO THE EDITOR

Eisenstadt, M. (2012). On loss and achievement of the first man on the moon [Letter to the Editor]. Clio’s Psyche, 19(3), 364-365.

https://doi.org/10.70763/761e6675f9e54673cc778e7fdb2823d2

On Loss and Achievement of the First Man on the Moon

letter to the editor

Abstract

In this letter to the editor, the author, a clinical psychologist whose scholarship concerns the relationship of loss to achievement, offers a perspective on the astronaut Neil Armstrong (1930–2012), the first person to walk on the moon during the Apollo 11 mission of 1969. The author notes that Armstrong lost both parents late in life, at age 59, describes this as a late loss profile associated with little creative pursuit, and maintains that loss nonetheless contributed to his accomplishment. The letter recounts the death of Armstrong’s young daughter and reports, citing his first wife’s recollection, that he afterward became absorbed in the space program and withdrawn from his family. The author proposes that Armstrong’s bereavement took the form of a mission, that he distanced himself from his wife and family, and that this led to their divorce in 1994 and his remarriage soon after. The author reads the name Tranquility Base as expressing his goal rather than a response to a frightening flight, and interprets his guilt as relating to the marriage rather than to public acclaim. The letter closes by describing Armstrong as ending his life happily and expressing appreciation for his efforts.

Keywords:

bereavement, clinical psychology, letter to the editor, Moon landing, National Aeronautics and Space Administration (NASA), Neil Armstrong, parental loss, psychohistory, trauma

Dear Editor,

Neil Armstrong (1930-2012) was the first man to reach and walk on the moon, following a four-day ride from the Earth on Apollo 11. As a clinical psychologist whose scholarship is focused on the relationship of loss to achievement, I bring this perspective to my subject. Unlike so many outstanding individuals who suffer parental loss in their early lives, Armstrong’s father and mother both died when he was 59 years old. This is a late loss profile showing little creative pursuits, but loss did contribute to the accomplishment in some ways.

His only daughter, Karen, died at only two years and nine months of age after many and long-lasting bouts of sickness. Armstrong was 31 years old when her death finally occurred. At the time he had a son, Erik, who was four years old and another son, Mark, was born a year later.

He became totally consumed by space travel following his daughter’s death. His wife, Janet, said, “He stayed on the job all night long, totally losing track of time. When he went to Cape Canaveral, he often forgot to call and tell me where he was staying. I’d get frantic. He was possessed by the project” (Leon Wagner, One Great Leap, 2004, p. 135). Armstrong became ever more withdrawn. On March 3, 1966, he entered the Gemini 8 capsule and received a $700 a year raise for the successful flight.

The moonwalk occurred on July 20, 1969, seven years after his daughter’s death. He said, “Houston, Tranquility Base here. The Eagle has landed.” NASA had no idea Armstrong had picked out the name Tranquility in advance for the lunar base. Amateur psychologists might see the name as related to the harrowing space flight and frightful landing. My take was that he saw space travel and the moon as the goal. His bereavement process was to become a man with a mission. He suffered the loss of his wife as a consequence. They divorced in theory in 1990 and a final decree occurred on April 12, 1994. His first wife, Janet Sharon, had married him on January 28, 1956, and Karen died on January 28, 1962.

Page 364

Professional psychologists know the death of a child is something that can often lead to a divorce. Armstrong had parents who lived together for 60 years as a married couple. Why divorce? His solution to losing his daughter was to distance himself both psychologically and indeed physically from his wife and family.

He recovered and married his second wife, Carol Knight, a widow, friend and neighbor whose husband died in a small plane crash in 1989 when he was 49. His second marriage took place on June 12, 1994, soon after the divorce decree.

First wife Janet’s assessment of her husband was that he felt guilty; he got all the acclaim for what thousands did to help him accomplish the famous event. My interpretation is that he couldn’t face the daughter’s death and thus face his wife. Yes, he was guilty, but for what had transpired in the marriage.

He ended his life as a happy man. We all have profited enormously by his tremendous efforts.

Page 365

About the author

Marvin Eisenstadt

Marvin Eisenstadt, PhD, is clinical psychologist on Long Island and a longtime associate of the Psychohistory Forum.

How to cite this article

Eisenstadt, M. (2012). On loss and achievement of the first man on the moon [Letter to the Editor]. Clio’s Psyche, 19(3), 364-365.

https://doi.org/10.70763/761e6675f9e54673cc778e7fdb2823d2

PDF downloads