
Volume 01 - Number 2 - September 1994
Pages: 1 - 12
Elovitz, P. H. (1994). Some of your definitions of psychohistory. Clio’s Psyche, 1(2), 11.
Some of Your Definitions of Psychohistory
Abstract
This article, an editor’s compilation of responses to a call for definitions of psychohistory, reproduces statements from five sources. Rudolph Billion defines psychohistory as the study of conscious and unconscious motives behind individual and collective human action. Thomas Gehrmann, who was prompted by his doubts about how psychohistorical some sessions at the June 1994 International Psychohistorical Association convention were, proposes that its nucleus is the fetal drama and birth trauma, and that changing child-rearing modes produce distinct psychoclasses. The article also abbreviates “A Statement of Principles,” an unsigned text by Richard Morrock distributed at the convention. It describes psychohistory as a discipline that crosses disciplinary boundaries, relates social and irrational phenomena to child-rearing, and comprises six subdisciplines. Peter Loewenberg’s definition from Decoding the Past combines historical analysis with social science models and psychodynamic theory, and treats the observer’s countertransference as part of method. Paul Roazen, quoting Encountering Freud, describes a collaboration of psychoanalysis and history that reconstructs the past from fragmentary evidence.
childrearing modes, collective regression, Paul Roazen, Peter Loewenberg, psychoclasses, psychohistory, Richard Morrock, Rudolph Billion, Thomas Gehrmann, unconscious
We are pleased to note a response to our call for definitions of psychohistory. Rudolph Billion, Leff Families Professor of History at Brandeis University, writes “psychohistory studies the motives, conscious and unconscious alike, of human doings whether individual or collective.”
Thomas Gehrmann of Rüsselsheim, Germany, declares that the “nucleus of psychohistory” is “the ‘foetal’ drama (plus birth trauma)” which “is the fundamental experience of human beings. People gather in small groups for collective regression and reenact this experience in various cultural forms….” and “the evolution of childrearing modes establishes different psychoclasses, that show different social, mental and cultural abilities….”
Gehrmann left some of the 1994 International Psychohistorical Association Convention (IPA) sessions in June wondering in what sense they were psychohistorical which prompted him to think about definitions.
“A Statement of Principles,” written by Richard Morrock, but unsigned, was distributed at the June IPA Convention. Despite a disclaimer in small print, it was mistakenly thought to be issued by the organization. The Editor wondered if it were prompted in part by our call for definitions. In the interests of space, we have abbreviated it.
“Psychohistory is a discipline which defies disciplinary boundaries.” It “draws the connections between seemingly unrelated social currents…and the irrational element which appears so often in history and politics” and “relates all of these phenomena to childrearing practices…. Among the subdisciplines in psychohistory are:” psychobiography, the history of childhood, group fantasy analysis, psychoeconomics, psychoanthropology and the history of psychology.
Peter Loewenberg, our distinguished featured psychohistorian of this issue (pp. 58), welcomed our including his definition from his fine book, Decoding the Past:
“Psychohistory, one of the newest methods of historical research, combines historical analysis with social science models, humanistic sensibility, psychodynamic theory and clinical insights to create a fuller, more rounded view of life in the past. (Decoding the Past 1983: p. 14) …it is the only model of research that includes in its method the countertransference phenomenon the emotional and subjective sensibility of the observer (Decoding the Past 1983: p. 3)”
Subscriber Paul Roazen, Professor in Social and Political Science at York University, Toronto, offered these thoughts on psychohistory from his book, Encountering Freud (Transaction Publishers, 1990). It is an “interdisciplinary collaboration” of “psychoanalysis and history” that “reconstruct[s] the past on the basis of fragmentary evidence, yet in as scientific a spirit as is compatible with the frequently subjective nature of the material.” Through psychohistory “we can be partially freed from the parochialism of our own educational background” (Encountering Freud, 1990, p. 261) and “professional training.” (Encountering Freud, 1990, p. 280)
Page 11
How to cite this article
Elovitz, P. H. (1994). Some of your definitions of psychohistory. Clio’s Psyche, 1(2), 11.



