
Volume 06 - Number 3 - December 1999
Pages: 89 - 132
Elovitz, P. H. (1999). In memoriam: H. Stuart Hughes (1916-1999): From the “supporting cast” of psychohistory [Memorial]. Clio’s Psyche, 6(3), 131.
In Memoriam: H. Stuart Hughes (1916-1999): From the “Supporting Cast” of Psychohistory
Abstract
This memorial tribute marks the death on October 21, 1999, at age 83, of the historian of modern Europe H. Stuart Hughes. The author recounts Hughes’s relationship to psychohistory, reporting from his memoir Gentleman Rebel: The Memoirs of H. Stuart Hughes (1990) that he was close to his Harvard colleague Erik Erikson and regarded himself as a supporting figure in the field. The author notes that William Gilmore’s Psychohistorical Inquiry bibliography rates Hughes’s essay “History and Psychoanalysis: The Explanation of Motive,” in History as Art and as Science (1964), very highly. The author reports that Hughes attended the American Historical Association meeting at which Richard L. Schoenwald decided to start the first psychohistory newsletter, the predecessor of The Psychohistory Review, and encouraged that decision. The author observes that the memoir opens with a question from Hughes’s psychoanalyst rather than with his family background, which included his grandfather Charles Evans Hughes, and relays his wife’s view that psychoanalysis was essential to his later life. The author characterizes Hughes as an intellectual, scholar, government researcher, political activist, and senatorial candidate who opposed conventional thought.
American Historical Association (AHA), Erik Erikson, Gentleman Rebel: The Memoirs of H. Stuart Hughes, H. Stuart Hughes, Harvard University, History as Art and as Science, memorial, Psychohistorical Inquiry: A Comprehensive Research Bibliography, psychohistory pioneer, The Psychohistory Review, Richard L. Schoenwald, William Gilmore
H. Stuart Hughes, a distinguished historian of Europe and friend of psychoanalytically informed history, died on October 21, 1999, at the age of 83. In Gentleman Rebel: The Memoirs of H. Stuart Hughes (1990), Hughes reports being close to Erik Erikson, his colleague at Harvard, and serving in the “supporting cast” of psychohistory (p. 237). William Gilmore, Psychohistorical Inquiry: A Comprehensive Research Bibliography (1984), calls “History and Psychoanalysis: The Explanation of Motive,” in Hughes’ book, History as Art and as Science (1964), “classic” and “must reading” (p. 44). Several years ago, in researching an American Historical Association meeting at which the late Professor Richard L. Schoenwald (1927-1995) decided to start the first psychohistory newsletter (the predecessor to The Psychohistory Review), it came to my attention that Hughes was there, encouraging this pathbreaking action.
Hughes starts his memoirs not with the mention of his patrician family—Charles Evans Hughes who ran for President and served as Chief Justice of the Supreme Court was his grandfather—but with a question from his psychoanalyst, Avery Weisman. Stuart Hughes, in the words of his wife, “could not have lived the life he did, at least the last 40-plus years of it, without benefit of psychoanalysis” (personal communication). And what a life it was: H. Stuart Hughes left his mark as a pre-eminent intellectual, prolific scholar, government researcher, political activist, senatorial candidate, and enemy of conventional thought.
Among his survivors are his wife Judith who is a modern European historian at the University of California in San Diego, a psychoanalyst, and a historian of psychoanalysis. We wish to thank her for answering questions at a most difficult time in her life.
Page 131
How to cite this article
Elovitz, P. H. (1999). In memoriam: H. Stuart Hughes (1916-1999): From the “supporting cast” of psychohistory [Memorial]. Clio’s Psyche, 6(3), 131.



