
Volume 07 - Number 4 - March 2001
Pages: 167- 218
Elovitz, P. H. (2001). Psychoanalysis and history: Andrea Sabbadini: A meet-the-editors interview [Interview]. Clio’s Psyche, 7(4), 212-214.
Psychoanalysis and History: Andrea Sabbadini: A Meet-the-Editors Interview
Abstract
This interview, conducted over the Internet in October 2000, is Paul H. Elovitz’s conversation with Andrea Sabbadini, a London-based psychoanalyst born in Milan and editor of Psychoanalysis and History. Sabbadini describes the journal, founded in 1998, as a peer-reviewed, twice-yearly forum for historians who research psychoanalysis or use its ideas. He says he is not hostile to psychohistory but would be uncomfortable seeing the journal described as psychohistorical. He regards it as an extension of applied psychoanalysis about which he has reservations, citing speculation about past individuals and macrosocial events in caricatured examples drawn from submissions to his journal. Elovitz replies that such wild analysis is not psychohistory and defends the field as careful observation and research. Sabbadini acknowledges that his knowledge of the field may be limited. He advises psychohistorians to publish in leading psychoanalytic journals. He is pessimistic about psychoanalysis as therapy and more hopeful about its application to cultural fields, including history. He attributes American analysts’ limited interest in applied work to their medical training. The discussion also covers his work on time and on film, his move to England to explore the work of R. D. Laing, identification and parental loss, violence, and paranoia. On the last he maintains that paranoia is highly destructive but is reluctant to blame social ills wholly on leaders’ pathology. He names Dante, Dostoyevsky, Shakespeare, Freud, Goffman, Laing, and Erikson as influences.
Andrea Sabbadini, British Journal of Psychotherapy, British Psychoanalytical Society, British Psychological Society, editor, Even Paranoids Have Enemies: New Perspectives on Paranoia and Persecution, International Journal of Psychoanalysis, International Psychoanalytical Association (IPhA), psychoanalysis, psychohistory, Psychoanalysis and History, psychotherapy, supervision, teaching, Time in Psychoanalysis (Il Tempo in Psicoanalisi)
Andrea Sabbadini is a practicing psychoanalyst, psychoanalytic supervisor, teacher of analysis, and editor of Psychoanalysis and History. He was born in 1950 in Milan, Italy, and for over 25 years has lived in London, England. His professional memberships include: the British Psychological Society, the British Psychoanalytical Society, and the International Psychoanalytical Association. He is the Book Review Editor and on the Editorial Board of the International Journal of Psychoanalysis and is an Advisor to the British Journal of Psychotherapy. In addition to being the author of numerous book chapters, articles, and reviews in leading professional journals, he is editor of Il Tempo in Psicoanalisi [Time in Psychoanalysis] (1979) and Even Paranoids Have Enemies: New Perspectives on Paranoia and Persecution (1998) (with J. Berke, S. Pierides and S. Schneider). He co-edits Web site <www.psychoanalysis.org.uk>. Dr. Sabbadini was inter-viewed over the Internet in October 2000. He may be reached at .
Paul H. Elovitz (PHE): What brought you to psychoanalysis?
Andrea Sabbadini (AS): A deep-seated curiosity to understand the complexities of human experiences and interpersonal relationships in a developmental (i.e., historical) perspective.
PHE: Tell me about your publication and its editorial policies.
AS: Psychoanalysis and History is a relatively new journal (the first issue came out in 1998). It is in English and is published twice yearly. Its papers are peer-reviewed and are sent to us through a network of International Associate Editors. The journal intends to fill a gap by providing a scholarly forum for historians who either research psychoanalysis or who use psychoanalytic ideas in their work. [For more information, visit <www.artesianbooks.co.uk>.]
PHE: As editor of a publication called Psychoanalysis and History, please tell me if your publication is at all psychohistorical and how you feel about psychohistory.
AS: I am not hostile to it, but I would feel uncomfortable about myself and our journal being described as having a psychohistorical approach. I think we don’t.
PHE: Is your North American Editor’s (Nellie Thompson) background in history and psychoanalysis, an aberration or typical of your editors?
AS: I would say quite typical not only of our editors, but also of most of our contributors.
PHE: Do you see psychohistory as the natural extension of applied psychoanalysis, or as another genre altogether? One you are uncomfortable with?
AS: An extension (how “natural” I don’t know!) of applied psychoanalysis, but one about which I have reservations, on the grounds of what too often seem to be rather wild speculations about past individuals and events — especially when mechanisms about interpersonal relationships are applied to macrosocial/political phenomena of the kind: the Koreans suffer from an inferiority complex in relation to the Japanese and react to the ensuing castration complex by projecting their envy. Or when the only effort to understand, say, the Nazi period boils down to deciding whether Hitler was a psychopath or a paranoid schizophrenic, given what we know of his early relationships with his parents. Of course, these are caricatures but based on papers submitted to our journal by authors calling themselves psychohistorians. Please accept my apologies if you think I am being grossly unfair — if I am, it is out of ignorance, not of malice.
PHE: Your comments do not surprise or offend me. I see your comments as a reflection of your being unfamiliar with much important and interesting psychohistory. My model of psychohistory is based on my 10 years of training in psychoanalysis and a quarter-century of practice of psychotherapy and psychoanalysis. It is not prone to wild speculation, but careful observation and research. Normally, I do not hang psychological labels on my subjects or even use psychoanalytic terminology. As the editor I have had partial success in getting our authors to follow my lead. It is true, there are many people who have the notion
Page 212
that wild analysis is acceptable in psychohistory, which is certainly not the case. However, wild analysis of historical situations is not psychohistory, it is just ill-founded speculation cloaked in psychological language. I am also fascinated by what people project onto history — especially when they are professional historians.
If you are not publishing psychohistory, and those submissions have some merit, feel free to forward them to us. Our editors and referees help educate people about what constitutes good psychohistory. A minority of submitters offering weak articles will work diligently to improve their work and perhaps change their notion of what constitutes psychohistory in the process.
Do my comments at all affect your view of the field?
AS: As I have said earlier, I am aware that my views about psychohistory may be colored by my insufficient knowledge of the field. Your comments, as well as the opportunity of this interview, encourage me to get more accurate and less biased information. I am in agreement with your suggestion that some people project onto psychohistory all sorts of fantasies which belong somewhere else. Of course, many have been, and still are, doing exactly the same with psychoanalysis.
PHE: Which of your psychoanalytic works are you most proud of? How might it be used by those doing psychohistorical work?
AS: Perhaps some of my publications on the concept of time and how it represents a crucial dimension to the psychoanalytic experience — but I just don’t know whether it would be of much use to historians.
PHE: What are you working on now and when do you expect to have it published?
AS: I’m currently involved in the application of psychoanalytic ideas to film studies and I am working with a colleague on a Japanese film dealing with the issues of memory and time, which we hope to publish in the next few months.
PHE: What special training was most helpful in your doing psychoanalytic work? How has it affected your scholarship?
AS: No special training as such. But I find reading, discussing my work with colleagues, attending conferences, teaching and lecturing, and the disciplined focusing of mind on a topic which is a condition for writing (and for answering interview questions!) to be always enriching.
PHE: Have you published, or do you plan to publish, an autobiography or any autobiographical writings?
AS: I have written a book with an autobiographical component, but I do not intend to publish it for the time being.
PHE: What brought you to England?
AS: I came here in the early 1970s, attracted by the prospect of exploring alternatives to conventional psychiatric treatments, and in particular by the work of R. D. Laing and his colleagues. But I stayed for a variety of other complex personal and professional motives.
PHE: How do British and Italian analysts and analysands differ?
AS: I can only answer this by generalizations. For instance, by suggesting that Italians are more prone than the British to follow cultural trends and to abandon them when they perceive them as being no longer fashionable. I must add I have very limited experience myself with Italian analysands.
PHE: How do you see psychoanalysis developing in the next decade and beyond?
AS: I do not feel too optimistic about the future of psychoanalysis as a form of therapy, nor do I think its success will depend on its presenting itself as a (natural) science and on a vast investment of energies in so-called research. I am more optimistic about extending the application of its ideas to cultural fields, including history.
PHE: What do we as psychohistorians need to do to strengthen our work in the eyes of psychoanalysts?
AS: Probably try and publish first-quality psychohistorical articles in first-quality psychoanalytic journals, so that more psychoanalysts will familiarize themselves with your approach.
PHE: For 35 years I have been a strong advocate of both psychoanalysis and psychohistory. A major disappointment to me has been how few American-born psychoanalysts have any interest in applying what they comprehend about the unconscious beyond their own clinical work. I have gone to innumerable meetings of analytic institutes where there are case materials, psychoanalytic theory, and discussions of Freud, but rarely anything that we would term applied psychoanalysis or psychohistory. The last historical subject I went to at an institute involved three veterans of World War II, who are psychoanalysts, recounting
Page 213
their war stories. In doing this they functioned not as analysts, but as literate older men reminiscing about their youth. Do you have any ideas as to why this lack of application of analysis beyond the consulting room is the case, if indeed it is the case in Europe?
AS: I guess that in the U.S. the medical background required to become a psychoanalyst, at least until recently, must play an important role in terms of the professional identity of psychoanalysts, and therefore of what they may consider as their fields of expertise or interest. This mostly does not apply to our European colleagues (the French are a good example), who seem more open to move out, metaphorically speaking, from their consulting rooms and explore other territories.
PHE: Some Psychohistory Forum researchers have been struggling with the issue of identification with a particular parent and achievement. If you would like to comment on this, it would be helpful to them.
AS: Identification is an important developmental process — and even later in life we mostly learn through identification with those we love and respect. But of course, we must also be capable to dis-identify from old objects when the models they provide are no longer satisfactory.
PHE: In your experience and life, are high achievers more identified with their fathers?
AS: Fathers and mothers! But parental loss may affect the children in all sorts of different ways — from turning them into big achievers to paralyzing their creativity — depending on the quality of their previous identifications, on their own personality or psychopathology, and on their capacity to mourn their losses.
PHE: What are your thoughts on the psychodynamics of violence in our world?
AS: That we have to live with it but, at the same time, also keep working for a more peaceful world — also through gaining a deeper understanding of the causes of violence.
PHE: In light of your having edited a book, Even Paranoids Have Enemies: New Perspectives on Paranoia and Persecution, what are your thoughts on paranoia in leaders and nations?
AS: I would say that paranoia is the most destructive component in interpersonal and macrosocial relationships. I am, however, reluctant to entirely blame social ills on the pathology of leaders. Too often nations tend to have the leaders they deserve.
PHE: Any advice to leaders on how to deal with paranoid leaders and nations gripped by paranoid delusions?
AS: Early diagnosis, maybe?
PHE: What books were important to your development?
AS: Where to start? Dante. Dostoyevsky. Shakespeare. And, of course, Freud.
PHE: Who was important to your development as a student of psychosocial phenomena? Did Erik Erikson have any impact on you?
AS: Ervin Goffman and R.D. Laing, back in the early 1970s. Yes, I do admire some of Erikson’s books. I think he is a much better writer, less dry and more creative, than many other psychoanalytic authors.
PHE: Thank you for granting this interview, I would like to wish you every success with your publication.
AS: Thank you, Paul, for giving me the opportunity to reflect on some important questions.
Page 214
How to cite this article
Elovitz, P. H. (2001). Psychoanalysis and history: Andrea Sabbadini: A meet-the-editors interview [Interview]. Clio’s Psyche, 7(4), 212-214.



