
Volume 09 - Number 1 - June 2002
Pages: 1 - 59
SPECIAL ISSUE
Elovitz, P. H. (2002). Serfs in North America? Clio’s Psyche, 9(1), 46-49.
Serfs in North America?
Abstract
In this article, the author recounts an inquiry prompted by a remark at a Psychohistory Forum Biography Research Group meeting. Lee Shneidman of Adelphi University stated there that serfdom existed in some New Netherland settlements, including Orange and Kings counties, and continued under the patroon system on estates such as those of the Livingston and Van Rensselaer families until the New York legislature ended it in 1791 or 1792. The author distinguishes slavery, serfdom, and indentured servitude, and reports asking Shneidman whether the alleged serfs were bound to the land, worked the lord’s land, held land in common, and needed permission to marry. Shneidman’s answers supported his thesis. The author then reports consulting colleagues. Andrew Brink relays the view of historian Patricia U. Bonomi that colonial Dutch and Huguenot settlements had slavery and tenancy but never serfdom. Edward Cody dismisses the idea, and Ann Marie Plane prefers the terms patroonship and tenancy. The author also reports reading A Factious People, Stubborn for Liberty, The Patroon’s Domain, and Colonial New York: A History, and finding tenant-landlord disputes and feudal language but no direct evidence of serfdom. The author concludes that it is quite unlikely that bondage approximating European serfdom was created in the Dutch Hudson Valley settlements or extended into the early national period. The author remains open to new evidence and invites Shneidman and others to submit responses.
Andrew Brink, Ann Marie Plane, Edward Cody, North America, psychohistory, Psychohistory Forum Biography Research Group, serfdom, slavery
No one doubts the existence of slavery in North America prior to Lincoln’s Emancipation Proclamation in 1863. However, serfdom is identified with medieval Western Europe and Russia prior to the Tsar’s peaceful emancipation of 20,000,000 serfs in 1861. Consequently, my ears perked up at a Psychohistory Forum Biography Research Group meeting when Lee Shneidman of Adelphi University made a passing reference to serfs in some New Netherland settlements, with their bondage continuing even after the American Revolution, into the early 1790s. I wondered, “Could this be true?”
For those readers not versed in the historical distinction between slavery and serfdom, let me spell it out. A slave was chattel property to be bought and sold like a horse, dog, house, or bushel of wheat. Enslavement in the European and ancient Mediterranean worlds was usually a result of kidnapping, defeat in war, being sold into servitude by parents, or being enslaved for debt or the debt of parents. Prior to modern times, slaves were commonly of the same racial and ethnic group as their owners. Custom or law normally gave slaves some limited rights. In the ancient world, slaves were occasionally allowed to earn their own money through the equivalent of overtime work and, even in some instances, buy their own freedom.
Serfdom, in theory though not always in practice, was a different type of servitude. It was created where there were few or no cities and a primarily barter, rather than a money, economy. Free peasants normally became enserfed in dangerous times when they sought, accepted, or were forced under the protection of a knight. The arrangement was for the serf to pay homage to his lord, work a number of days (unpaid of course!) a week on his lord’s land (and the rest on his own), pay additional labor service taxes, get his lord’s permission to marry, and go to his lord for justice when he had disputes with his neighbors. In theory, the serf could not be alienated from the land,
Page 46
though advertisements of serfs trained as domestics or skilled worker for sale in 18th-century Russian newspapers illustrate that in practice serfs were sometimes treated as chattel.
(In the colonial period in North America indentured servitude was commonplace. Unlike slavery and serfdom, this was not a hereditary condition. For a limited period, usually four to seven years, a free person in Europe agreed to work off the cost of his passage to the colonies as a bound laborer. At the end of the period the indentured servant became a free man or woman.)
When, amidst a discussion of serfdom in Russia, Professor Shneidman declared that there was serfdom in Orange and Kings counties in the Dutch colonies of North America, I immediately sought clarification. “Were the alleged serfs bound to the land?” “Did they have to work the lord’s land or were they free to leave at anytime?” “Were their lands held in common (‘the commons’)?” “Did they need the lord’s permission to marry?” In all four cases his answers supported the serfs-in-America thesis. I next questioned the continuation of the alleged serfdom after the English captured “New Amsterdam” and renamed it “New York” in 1664. Further, “Wasn’t this type of servitude immediately repudiated once American forces took control of New York at the end of the Revolutionary War?” In both cases the answer was negative, supporting the “serf thesis.” Professor Shneidman described this serfdom as a part of the Dutch patroon system, enduring into the life of the new republic, on the estates of the Courtlands, Livingstons, Schuylers, Van Rensselaers, and other powerful families of the area. The system ended, he declared, in 1791 or 1792 when it was eliminated by the New York legislature as unbefitting a free country. I wondered if it had eroded before then, due to the attraction of the frontier and the availability of cheap land and work in the cities.
This discussion was well beyond my area of expertise as a psychohistorian, historian of modern England/Europe, and psychobiographer of recent U.S. Presidents. However, I felt sure that I could get more information from others in our psychohistorical community. My first thought was to contact my friend and colleague Andrew Brink in Canada. Though a literature teacher by profession, especially since his retirement from the universities of Toronto and McMaster, Professor Brink has been working intensely on the history of his Dutch/English ancestors in Esopus in New Netherland and New York State. He has published some of his findings in Clio’s Psyche. His completed book, Invading Paradise: Esopus Settlers at War with Natives, 1659-1663, is currently being reviewed by an academic press. Brink’s responses are extracted from three e-mails of March 31 and May 21, 2001, and reprinted with permission. “As to serfdom in New Netherland, I haven’t come up with a ready source but will ask” members of the Holland Society of New York “when I see them. I suppose you could say that the Van Rensselaers and Livingstons as patroons had ‘serfs’ but it needs looking into.” He checked Patricia U. Bonomi, A Factious People: Politics and Society in Colonial New York (1971), who wrote that “the few that retained their status as manors throughout the colonial period did so by surrendering nearly all the ancient privileges which historians who stress the semi-feudal character of New York land patterns rely upon to substantiate their interpretation….” Regarding “the political condition of residents on these manors and estates … it has been shown that suffrage in New York Colony was fairly broad, and included tenants holding life leases—a class more numerous than had once been thought.” (p. 6)
Brink next wrote: “The whole question of servitude is important—futile attempts to enslave Indians as farm workers, buying and selling blacks for the same purpose (my own family at Hurley is deeply implicated here), not to mention the possibility of certain tenancy agreements being close to ‘serfdom’.” He goes on to say that in the 18th century a person he came across in his research “attempted to establish the Hurley Manor and failed….” I wonder whether the manor may have broken down because the “lord” couldn’t find any “serfs?” Demonstrating his persistence, Andrew did not stop there. At his next opportunity at a meeting of the Holland Society, he spoke to Professor Bonomi in person and reported that she:
thinks that there was never serfdom in colonial Dutch/Huguenot settlements; slavery, yes, but no serfdom—a point on which she was emphatic. She says that some historians used to believe the serf theory but few do now. I suppose it is a matter of defining a “serf”; there certainly were many tenant farmers oppressed and miserable enough to think of themselves as “serfs.” But in any real sense they weren’t serfs as they were always free to leave the manor lord’s employ and many did strike out for themselves. Of course, tenant farmers who left forfeited all improvements to the
Page 47
landlord but they were under no obligation to stay. Stories of virtual vassalage probably got started because of bad treatment, for instance, by the Livingstons of Palatine [German] refugees (1710). As you know, William Penn offered these hard-working farmers refuge in his colony. The Van Rensselaers and Hardenberghs had tenant revolts and there were anti-rent wars in the 1840s. (See Alice P. Kenney, Stubborn for Liberty: The Dutch in New York, 1975.)
The willingness to help a colleague, openness to possibilities not previously entertained, readiness to check out the facts, and concern for the plight of the common people, all expressed above, are typical of Professor Brink.
As I waited to hear from Andrew Brink and others I had asked, my own curiosity could not be contained. I spent time in the library and brought home a pile of books, including the Kenny book cited above, in which I learned about a “half freedom granted to Dutch slaves.” (p. 77) I read of “perpetual [land] ownership” which was “to be held as an inheritable fief or feud,” of numerous landlord tenant land and labor disputes, and a slew of other things about the land system. Though some of the language was medieval (“fief” and “feud,” for example), there was no direct evidence that this amounted to serfdom and much to the contrary. (S.G. Nissenson, The Patroon’s Domain, 1973, p. 329) Elsewhere I found interesting materials on apprenticeship, treatment of the Indians, the need for the instruction of slaves in the “Christian religion,” voting, “land riots,” and “feudal clauses” but nothing substantiated the Shneidman thesis. (Michael G. Kammen, Colonial New York: A History, 1975) (A student named Tim Hamilton was kind enough to help me with some of the research since I did not trust the indices of the books to cover everything.)
I decided to ask specialists in Colonial history before rejecting the argument of a colleague as knowledgeable and respected as Professor Shneidman—the author of a book on Aaron Burr and the head of one of the prestigious Columbia University Seminars. Professor Edward Cody, my colleague who was just appointed Acting Provost at Ramapo College, is well known for his sound judgment. He asked a few clarifying questions and then dismissed the notion of serfs in Colonial America without hesitation. Professor Ann Marie Plane of the University of California at Santa Barbara urged me to read some wonderful sounding recent books on servitude in North America and concluded that she “definitely would not call it serfdom in New Amsterdam—it is patroonship and tenancy, but very distinctive, and it may well have provoked consternation in the 1790s as quite authoritarian….” (May 21, 2001 e-mail, quoted with permission)
On the basis of the helpfulness of Professors Brink, Cody, and Plane, as well as my own modest research, I consider it quite unlikely that some form of bondage approximating European serfdom was created in the early 17th-century Dutch settlements in the Hudson Valley and therefore could not have extended into the early national period of American history. Though I remain open to the possibility of new facts being presented supporting the American serfdom thesis, the evidence I have seen runs counter to the forceful argument of Lee Shneidman. He is a man I know to speak his mind forthrightly and to be quite ready to engage contrary opinions. In 1988 I published an article as a result of a difference of opinion with him on the subject of psychohistorical evidence. (“Dreams as a Psychohistorical Source,” Journal of Psychohistory, Winter 1989, pp. 289-296) Perhaps this discussion of the issue of serfdom in North America will prompt him to do the same. As an editor I welcome any submission on the subject and look forward to learning more about forms of
Page 48
bondage we do not usually think about in the 21st century.
Page 49
How to cite this article
Elovitz, P. H. (2002). Serfs in North America? Clio’s Psyche, 9(1), 46-49.



