
Volume 09 - Number 4 - March 2003
Pages: 157 - 210
Elovitz, P. H. (2003). The editor’s book corner: Some books on terrorism, war, and the emotions. Clio’s Psyche, 9(4), 188-189.
The Editor’s Book Corner: Some Books on Terrorism, War, and the Emotions
Abstract
This article, the editor’s book column in the special theme issue on emotions in history and current events, surveys recent books on terrorism, war, and the emotions, most of which the author read for personal use or for teaching. It announces that the author’s article “Teaching About War in Bush’s 21st-Century America” is being republished as the centerpiece of a symposium in the Journal of Psychohistory. The author judges the Rubins’ documentary reader on anti-American terrorism to be a useful selection and reports Barry Rubin’s argument that Americans have favored Muslims in disputes between Christians and Muslims, Israel aside. The author announces a forthcoming review of Subhash Inamdar’s psychobiography of Muhammad and faults Bernard Lewis’s What Went Wrong for lacking psychological interpretation. Thomas Friedman’s collected columns are described as limited by column length and changing opinions. The column also covers Terror and Apocalypse, which the author regrets was issued by a print-on-demand press, and Chris Hedges’s War Is a Force That Gives Us Meaning, which argues that people become addicted to war. Omer Bartov’s recent books are listed. Lloyd deMause’s The Emotional Life of Nations is announced as the subject of a September 2003 symposium in Clio’s Psyche. The author objects to pro-war-with-Iraq statements prefaced by a disclaimer that nobody wants war, and seeks a reviewer for Magai and Haviland-Jones’s The Hidden Genius of Emotion.
Anti-American Terrorism and the Middle East: A Documentary Reader, Barry Rubin, Bernard Lewis, conflict resolution, The Creation of Group Identity, The Emotional Life of Nations, emotional processing, Henry Lawton, Jerry Piven, Journal of Psychohistory (JOP), Lloyd deMause, Longitudes and Attitudes: Exploring the World After September 11, Muhammad and the Rise of Islam: What Went Wrong: Western Impact and Middle Eastern Response¸ Paul Ziolo, peacemaking, psychohistory, Subhash C. Inamdar, Terror and Apocalypse: Psychological Undercurrents of History¸ terrorism, Thomas L. Friedman, warfare
War has been very much on my mind lately, and I am proud to say that my teaching-about-war article, published in our December 2002 issue, is being republished under the title, “Teaching About War in Bush’s 21st-Century America,” as the centerpiece of a symposium in the Journal of Psychohistory, Spring 2003. Most of the volumes discussed below I have read for my own edification or use in teaching my courses: “9/11 and the Psychology of Terrorism”; “War, Peace, and Conflict Resolution”; and “Psychohistory.”
An invaluable selection of documents, with much useful commentary, is Barry Rubin and Judith Colp Rubin, eds., Anti-American Terrorism and the Middle East: A Documentary Reader (2002). Though most of the well-chosen selections are brief, they clearly show a lengthy pattern of violent anti-Americanism in Middle Eastern thought and action, as well as some of the U.S. responses to the terrorism. Barry Rubin also provides extensive commentary on U.S. foreign policy, arguing that, Israel aside, Americans have consistently favored Muslims in disputes between Christians and Muslims, as in the former Yugoslavia in the 1990s. Currently, this husband-wife team has been finishing up a book on Yasir Arafat, with a volume on general anti-Americanism in the world to follow. With the way much of the world is reacting to the policies of file administration in Washington, this third book may have to be a multi-volume set, even if it is published this year.
Subhash C. Inamdar, Muhammad and the Rise of Islam: The Creation of Group Identity (2001) is an interesting study of the founder of Islam by a Mombassa-born New York University psychiatrist of Indian ancestry. We anticipate a full review in our next issue of this ambitious book, which provides a psychobiography of Muhammad and a history of early Islam, as well as a group psychological analysis of Islamic group identity formation during and after the death of “the Messenger.”
Bernard Lewis, What Went Wrong: Western Impact and Middle Eastern Response (2001), had written his book prior to the Islamic terrorism of 9/11 and published it immediately thereafter. Lewis, Dodge Professor Emeritus of Near Eastern Studies at Princeton and the doyen of American Islamists, has written a fine historical book without the slightest hint of psychology or psychohistory. This is a shame because his materials cry out for these interpretations. Recently, when a Psychohistory Forum research group sought to make it the centerpiece of one of our discussions, we ended up devoting very little time to it because of this limitation.
Thomas L. Friedman, Longitudes and Attitudes: Exploring the World After September 11 (2002), is a collection of many of the author’s New York Times columns. As such, it has much value, even if the author does change his opinions rather often and mostly limits them to the 740 words allotted to him for each column on the op-ed page. Friedman is the winner of the 2002 Pulitzer Prize for Commentary.
Jerry Piven, Paul Ziolo, and Henry Lawton, eds., Terror and Apocalypse: Psychological Undercurrents of History Vol. 2 (2002), has 14 diverse, mostly psychoanalytic and psychohistorical essays on various aspects of terrorism. Some are quite valuable. Regrettably, the volume has sold less than I would have liked to see because it was published by a print-on-demand press.
These days I listen to numerous commentators and politicians interspersing their pro-war-with-Iraq sentiments with the phrase, “Nobody wants war, but….” With Shakespeare, I say, “But me no buts.” In War Is a Force That Gives Us Meaning (2002), Chris Hedges, formerly a foreign affairs and military correspondent for The New York Times, writes about how people become addicted to war because of the enormous “rush” it gives. He tackles difficult questions such as “The Myth of War” (Chapter 1) and “The Seduction of Battle and Perversion of War” (Chapter 4), and concludes with “Eros and Thanatos” (Chapter 7). Many of his examples come from his coverage of wars in the Persian Gulf and Bosnia, as well as the war on terrorism. In 2002, he was part of the New York Times team that won the Pulitzer Prize for Explanatory Reporting of global terrorism, and he personally received the Amnesty International Global Award for Human Rights Journalism.
On February 15, Hedges had a conversation with Omer Bartov in The New York Times, “Q & A: Into the Quicksand of Endless War,” (p. B11), that I found to be of value. Bartov, who has
Page 188
expressed some interest in presenting at the Psychohistory Forum this year, should his teaching, research, and parenting schedules allow him to travel from Brown University to New York at the appropriate time, is a historian whose mother was a psychoanalyst. His more recent books include Mirrors of Destruction: War, Genocide, and Modem Identity (2002) and, as an editor, Crimes of War: Guilt and Denial in the Twentieth Century (2002).
Lloyd deMause, The Emotional Life of Nations (2002), has two chapters especially relevant to war: “The Gulf War as an Emotional Disorder” and “War as Righteous Rape and Purification” This volume was reviewed by Howard Stein in our December 2002 issue and will be the subject of a September 2003 symposium in Clio’s Psyche with the commentators being members of our editorial board and historians who have published one or more psychohistorical books.
Cambridge University Press has sent the following volume for which we are looking for a reviewer: Carol Magai and Jeanette Haviland-Jones, The Hidden Genius of Emotion: Lifespan Transformations of Personality (2002). These authors’ approach to emotion is radically different than that of deMause and much more within the tradition of academic psychology.
Page 189
How to cite this article
Elovitz, P. H. (2003). The editor’s book corner: Some books on terrorism, war, and the emotions. Clio’s Psyche, 9(4), 188-189.



