
Volume 11 - Number 4 - March 2005
Pages: 113 - 159
SPECIAL ISSUE
Elovitz, P. H. (2005). Some concluding thoughts from the perspective of a male psychohistorian. Clio’s Psyche, 11(4), 150-156.
Some Concluding Thoughts from the Perspective of a Male Psychohistorian
Abstract
In this concluding article to the special issue on women at work and in modern life, the author, writing as a male psychohistorian, offers historical, personal, and psychoanalytic reflections on the preceding contributions, among them Kristine Larsen’s on women in physics, Tim Myers’s on home repair, Nancy C. Unger’s “The Beauty Myth,” and Judith Harris’s “Remembering My Mother.” Starting from Freud’s remarks on women, the author draws on teaching, clinical practice, family history, and wide reading rather than a stated method. The author argues that much male denigration of women rests on denial of the dependency and female authority of early childhood, extends this reading to Islamic fundamentalist hostility toward Western gender roles, citing Sayyid Qutb and Mohamed Atta, and maintains that Western societies also keep women subordinate, referring to Rita Ransohoff’s Fear and Envy. The author expresses concern about the costs to young women of aiming to excel in every role, contends that the first woman to become U.S. president will have to prove herself tougher than her male predecessors, and proposes that women’s liberation is both internal, freeing oneself from inherited maternal models, and external, through legal and social change. Sketches of Mary Wollstonecraft, drawing on Diane Jacobs’s biography, and of Mary Shelley’s writing of Frankenstein illustrate these processes. The author closes with a personal note on changing sex roles in his own family and wishes women well.
dark continent, female psyche, gender roles, male perspective, psychoanalysis, psychohistory, Sigmund Freud, women liberation
Sigmund Freud, who practiced psychoanalysis primarily with women patients, thought that the great unanswered question was “What does the woman want?” Elsewhere he declared that “anatomy is destiny” and that the “life of adult women is a ‘dark continent’ for psychology.” Despite his bewilderment over the motivation of women, the founder of the psychoanalytic method went well beyond the frustrations of most men since he worked hard to listen to women because his work expresses openness to different explanations. Women, and men who are quite attuned to women, have been explorers into this “dark continent” of the female psyche.
While welcoming all contributors, and anonymously sending their papers to our referees, we especially sought women authors for this issue. Indeed, I felt rather ambivalent when asked to write a concluding essay for this special issue: shouldn’t a woman be writing it? Perhaps. But there are things that need to be said from a historical, personal, and psychoanalytic perspective, and each reader can decide the value of this man’s comments.
Sigmund Freud, who practiced psychoanalysis primarily with women patients, thought that the great unanswered question was “What does the woman want?” Elsewhere he declared that “anatomy is destiny” and that the “life of adult women is a ‘dark continent’ for psychology.” Despite his bewilderment over the motivation of women, the founder of the psychoanalytic method went well beyond the frustrations of most men since he worked hard to listen to women because his work expresses openness to different explanations. Women, and men who are quite attuned to women, have been explorers into this “dark continent” of the female psyche.
While welcoming all contributors, and anonymously sending their papers to our referees, we especially sought women authors for this issue. Indeed, I felt rather ambivalent when asked to write a concluding essay for this special issue: shouldn’t a woman be writing it? Perhaps. But there are things that need to be said from a historical, personal, and psychoanalytic perspective, and each reader can decide the value of this man’s comments. — perhaps it’s no accident that divorce was a part of their journeys in the course of pursuing their goals in a world of men.
Kristine Larsen has felt like something of an outsider in the world of physics yet her career has progressed notably and she maintains a strong sense of her own femininity and individuality even if she
Page 150
keeps her tattoos but not her pierced eyebrow hidden from the professional world. Her article helps answer the question of why there are not more women in science. On January 14, 2005 Harvard President Lawrence H. Summers suggested innate, biological differences as he tried to goad women into pursuing math and science — at least that’s how he justified his “foot-in-mouth” difficulties. However, there is no need to search for genetic differences between the sexes when there are such obvious attitudinal and behavioral reasons: Larsen describes the “culture of physics” as inhospitable to women.
Role reversals cause considerable confusion in society while offering new options for it. They also take some pressure off men to be the sole family provider, protector, and home repair expert. Tim Myers provides some humor in his description of the reactions of traditional males to his wife’s handling of home repair needs. House husbanding may be much more common now then it was in the world of our parents where the stay-at-home husband was seen as a failure, but it still can be very hard on the egos of those involved. For example, when I recently met the husband of a younger colleague who had just joined our faculty after getting her doctoral degree in California, he said he “just” stayed home with the three children. Conversation revealed that he was also working nights as a watchman to help support the family economy. To me this had the same ring as the comments from the large number of women I have met through the years who have informed me that they did not work. As mundane as this may sound, further inquiry made it clear that they raised children, ran households, provided essential support systems for husbands, organized school and community activities, cared for sick relatives, and usually had part-time jobs. Despite their lack of self-confidence, the experience of these women usually made them wonderful workers. Their male counterparts now face a similar struggle to establish a sense of self-worth.
Despite Nancy Unger’s valuable references to the issue of women as superwomen, the dilemma of the modern woman who is told she can achieve everything in contradictory roles is otherwise not sufficiently covered in our issue. I understand the excitement occasioned by new possibilities being opened to women, but from observing and listening to them — women and gays seem most interested in gender courses — I am also aware of the cost. In teaching “Childhood and Youth in History,” “Sex Roles in Society,” “Leaders, Passion, and Success,” and “Manhood,” I sometimes feel sad for young women who want to “have it all” and “do it all” without realizing the price involved. For most, there are not enough hours in the day or enough physical, mental, and emotional energy to achieve these things, especially if they pursue goals that usually require dichotomous attributes, values, and ways of thinking and acting. To be “superwoman” — perfect professional, perfect wife, perfect mother and daughter, to have all of the wonderful attributes of women while succeeding in the world of men, which is governed by very different attributes — is an impossibility even for most high-achieving women. Indeed, I know some talented high-achieving career women who have dropped out of the “rat race” to spend time with their children because they found more satisfaction in this than in focusing on their professions.
First Lady Laura Bush, with her new mission to help young men and boys at risk do as well as women in school and work, while avoiding addictions and gangs, is doing a worthwhile thing. But it should be noted that she is very much in the pattern of the woman who stands behind a man, that of woman-as-enabler. Nineteenth-century authors such as Samuel Smiles (1812-1904), who reveled in writing about high-achieving men, often gave credit to the woman behind the man. Like St. Augustine, Smiles believed that it was the mother who made the man. In the great, 20th-century age of the male-dominated corporatization of industry, in which women were relegated to the roles of wife, mistress, secretary, schoolteacher, nurse, daughter, sister, factory worker, maid, or prostitute, it was women who literally enabled men to look good: men could concentrate on pursuing success in the world of business because they had women buying their clothes, dressing them, and caring for their personal appearance, as well as managing their social lives and maintaining connections essential to upward professional mobility. The value of a wife as a “support system” making great success possible is what some high-achieving, successful professional women later came to realize and talk about when they said what they needed most was a “wife.” Of course, successful female professionals also face the envy — and sometimes the sabotage — of secretaries and wives, who see them as a threat rather than an inspiration.
Only when American women and men are
Page 151
willing to accept women as capable chief executives in their own right, rather than as wives of presidents who are content to pursue such crusades as literacy, will the U.S. be ready for the first woman president. Much of the country could not tolerate the Clintons’ notion of a co-presidency. Similarly, in the 2004 election, Teresa Heinz Kerry was not well received as a strong, outspoken woman who refused to speak in a politically correct fashion or to abandon the name of her deceased first husband. It has long been my conviction that the first woman “allowed” to be president will be tougher than any of her male predecessors. (See my “America’s Second Woman President” in the September 2000 issue, 7(2): pp. 69-70.) It seems to be necessary to society that the first generation of women who run countries must be tested by war to prove that they are tougher than their male allies and political rivals, as were Golda Meir and Margaret Thatcher, two women who made it to the top without the benefit of being the daughter or wife of a political leader. The relationship between women and war is an important subject. In the long run, the female “dark continent” is inclined to be less violent than the male “dark continent” because women are more prone to talk than to fight. Some of them may remember the birth pangs they suffered bringing into the world the lives lost in warfare.
Historically, men have not had much interest in young children or the early years of life. Males have taken pride at the sight of the newborn and briefly held it before handing it over to a wife, nanny, or wet nurse until it reached an age of interest to the male psyche — typically at puberty, though historically sometimes as young as six or seven years of age (the beginning of latency). By the late 1930s some psychoanalysts had begun to get past Freud’s focus on the Oedipus complex to deal with the reality of the pre-Oedipal world, in which men are controlled by women more so than at any other time in their lives. This change in perspective was brought about in part by a number of brilliant women psychoanalysts, such as Anna Freud, Melanie Klein, Freda Fromm-Reichmann, and Helene Deutsch.
In practicing child and adolescent therapy for a number of years, I found that it was taken as a given that boys had a harder time growing up than girls. Girls could identify with their mothers, who normally have been a fairly consistent presence within the home, while boys had to identify with fathers who mysteriously went off to some unimaginable office, foundry, or other job that the boy could not readily visualize. This was in sharp contrast to the usual historical situation of boys seeing their fathers go off to the fields close by the home and joining them to assist in the harvest as soon as they were able. Carol Gilligan (see our March 2004 issue, p. 10
(4): pp. 121-131) has written, rather brilliantly, on issues of male, and especially female, identification, and, in the case of boys, dis-identification.
In the past, young children were often kept within the woman’s section(s) of the home, or harem, until they reached the age of about five. Though in England and America there may not have been harems, a holdover of men’s lack of interest in young children is revealed in early 20th-century photos that show boys as old as four or five in dresses as a reflection of their being within the domain of their mothers as well as the ease of toilet training in these clothes. Men often spend the rest of their lives demonstrating that they do not need the women who gave them life and nurtured them long enough to be prepared for the world of men outside of the home. The male inclination to say “We don’t need women” is a denial of ever having been small and weak, and of the desire to return to the joys of being cared for.
In my experience as a historian, man, and psychoanalyst, the basis of much male denigration of women is the need to deny the dependency, weakness, and female domination of the early years of life. A well-educated and often generous, yet “rough around the edges” man comes to mind. Along with many men of his era, he demeaned women in general, saying that they were “just holes [vaginas], if you turn them upside down, they are all the same.” With other men, he shook hands hard to demonstrate that he was stronger than they were; he sometimes hugged women until it hurt: squeezing an outspoken older cousin of his wife so hard that he literally broke several of her ribs. He married a sheltered woman a decade younger than he was and kept her “pregnant and down on the farm [the suburbs]” while he worked quite long and hard building a business. He left for work before dawn. When he returned home, he said hello to his wife and children, ate dinner, and fell asleep immediately in front of the television set, only awakening long enough to go to bed. Meanwhile, his wife began to feel restive as she developed a sense of herself as a separate person. The response of this powerful man, who claimed women were interchangeable, when she brought up the idea of di-
Page 152
vorce, was to collapse with all of the symptoms of a heart attack. He had to be rushed to the emergency room because, unconsciously, the threatened loss of attachment to a woman “broke his heart.” This happened several times before he “hardened his heart,” accepted divorce, and cut his former wife out of his life. His tough, “hard as nails” demeanor concealed a desperate need for a woman. With his second wife, he appears to have dropped his superior, denigrating manner and paid some more attention to her needs. He has a more stable marriage with a woman who appears to be more realistic about the man she married than his first wife had been.
In addition to the denial of the need for women on an individual level, all-male societies of boys’ clubs, sports teams, armies, and so forth, are further “proof” to men that women aren’t necessary. Of course, the locker room talk in these groups focuses on sexual triumph over women — men do love being on top in the struggle of the sexes. In most societies the “dark continent” of man’s desire to subordinate, dominate, impregnate, use, rape, and defile women is protected from exploration by a common wall of denial. An important element of the Islamic fundamentalist revulsion toward the West is based not simply on satellite television images of scantily clad women drinking Coca-Cola and eating fast food. Rather, the threat of women becoming men’s equals and bosses revives fears of male dependency on women. Western presentations of men and women as equals in society — even in images as seemingly innocuous as that of a woman driving a car — serve to dangerously blur the distinctions between gender roles. Sayyid Qutb (1906-1966), an intellectual father of the modern Islamic fundamentalist movement, was an Egyptian who came to America in the late 1940s. In a town in Colorado, he had no problem attending a Christian church service. Though to his mind the minister was not properly enlightened as to how to worship God, Qutb remembered that Muhammad had told his flock to tolerate the two other monotheistic religions. However, Sayyid Qutb could not tolerate the church dance that followed, in which men and women held each other in their arms. This violated a fundamental tenet of Islamic puritanism and his sense of the appropriate relationship between the sexes. Incidentally, Muhammad himself seemed quite comfortable with women, and far more concern for women’s rights is expressed in the Qur’an than in either the Old or New Testament (Subbash Inamdar, Muhammad and the Rise of Islam: The Rise of Group Identity, 2001).
Mohamed Atta (1968-2001) is a good example of a Muslim who lived in the Western world, where he was quite uncomfortable with the relationship of the sexes. In his last will and testament, this leader of the September 11 suicide attacks on Manhattan specified that his body, in being prepared for burial, should not be touched (and therefore “defiled”) by the hands of a woman. Beyond the fantasy that there would be enough body left to be defiled by a woman’s hands after the fuel-laden plane crashed into the World Trade Center, is the reality of Atta’s unconscious desire to be cared for by a woman. Despite the protests of his father, a Cairo doctor who despises Americans and the West, Mohamed, until he went to college, would sit upon his mother’s lap. To me, Atta is an example of male counter-dependency impulses being manifested in hypermasculinity and its subordination of women.
Western men like to denigrate their Arab counterparts for keeping women under the veil or having them walk steps behind them. Arranged marriages, honor killings, economic dependence, and restrictions on education and public appearance outside of the family are concepts that the West has, for the most part, left behind. Yet the same desire to keep women subservient exists in Western society. However much “modern,” educated Western men like to denounce others for their subservient treatment of women, they share the same impulses, though they carry them out in different ways. For example, in the hierarchies of power and status women are typically paid less money and kept in roles making them subservient to men. Rita Ransohoff (1916-2003), a longstanding psychoanalyst/ psychologist member of our intellectual group, wrote about this cross-cultural phenomenon in her last book, Fear and Envy: Why Men Need to Control and Dominate Women (2001).
Women’s liberation is a process involving not simply equal employment opportunities and pay, property rights, equal educational opportunities, and laws prohibiting discrimination, but also transformation within the minds of women, so that they are willing — and able — to question that which they have observed, been taught, and been rewarded for while growing up.
Lauren Gargani, a student at Ramapo Col-
Page 153
lege, has noted that despite outward efforts to steer girls and young women toward leadership roles and the self-esteem necessary for aggressive competition in the workplace, there remains an abundance of poor role models for girls, and gender stereotypes still prevail in the playroom. She cites the ever-popular Disney “princess” films as prime examples of overwhelmingly passive female “heroines,” whose greatest lesson to girls is that beauty is worth more than independence or intelligence. Nancy Unger, in her essay “The Beauty Myth,” does a good job of bringing this to our attention, and points out (in personal correspondence) that in the popular Shrek series, intelligence and independence take precedence to beauty, though she acknowledges that this might be “the exception which proves the rule.” The collective standard of perfection for female appearance is not merely time-consuming; it inhibits women from becoming involved in the rough-and-tumble competitive world. Men, in contrast, are much more concerned with pushing to victory rather than looking good, which turns out to be invaluable training for success in business and politics.
The female inclination to defer to men is reflected in a variety of ways, even in those who have moved beyond the home to the competitive workplace environment. Why do women feel so much pressure to be caring, nurturing, and considerate of others as their less talented male counterparts often walk briskly past them to the top positions in society? I’m reminded of a brilliant young colleague, who did some editing for this publication. After realizing how beautifully she wrote and edited, I asked if she might want to help out. She said “yes” and amazed me with her talent and ability. Though I greatly appreciated and was delighted to have the help, before long I “looked a gift horse in the mouth.” Was she doing this because she genuinely wanted to do it, or was she having trouble saying “no” to an older colleague? After I got past her polite “glad to help you,” I soon came to the not surprising conclusion that she indeed preferred doing her own publications, though she seemed to need my “permission” to say that. The Texas-born, traditional female secretary we had at our college years ago, who referred to her boss as “my office husband,” was a marvelous facilitator for the work of her superiors. Though she loved her job and would have preferred staying in New Jersey where her adult children and grandchildren lived, when her husband, whom she did not seem to especially like, retired and decided he wanted to move to Oregon, she dutifully and tearfully said her “goodbyes.”
It does not seem easy to be a woman. Is it because in part they have had to live with the results — namely, loss of virginity, and consequent pregnancy and childbirth — of sexual experimentation, as well as the threat of ostracism from society as a result of sexual behavior? For men, sexual activity has been proof of masculinity, and the likelihood of negative consequences has historically been far less than for women. Women limit their intake of liquids, and food for that matter, in ways that would be onerous to most men and struggle with body image to an extent that is unimaginable to most men (for the latter see Joan Brumberg, The Body Project: An Intimate History of American Girls, 1998).
According to the Old Testament, “the Lord sayeth, be fruitful and multiply.” My former suburban students certainly are not listening. I am reminded of a massive volume called The Fear of Being a Woman: A Theory of Maternal Destructiveness (1964), in which Joseph C. Rheingold describes an enormous number of clinical cases involving women struggling with, and far too often overcome by, the fear of replicating their mothers’ role when bringing a child into the world. I have sometimes observed this painful phenomenon in the struggles of women in my own psychoanalytic practice caseload. For example, a vivacious 38-year-old mother of three dreamt the night before the birth of her first child that her precious baby was in a cottage with her mother and she was locked out. Her manic bouts would result in hospitalizations during which her children would be left with her mother and she was locked out of their lives for periods of time — just as her dream foretold. Is the unconscious fear of stepping into the role of their mother by becoming a mother one of the factors in why our current generation of well-educated, prosperous, suburban women are having so few children?
Woman’s liberation is both an internal and an external process. The internal process is about the intrapsychic process of a woman freeing herself from what she saw and was usually taught about the role of women. This internal liberation involves a girl or woman deciding what she wants. It means filtering through the impulses, messages, and social programming she had previously accepted as a given. Liber-
Page 154
ating herself from the constraints of her first and primary role model is not an easy process. In “Remembering My Mother,” Judith Harris provides valuable insights on intergenerational grandmother-mother-daughter transmissions and the common lack of clear boundaries between mothers and daughters and the lifelong force of these messages in the psyche. Indeed, part of the struggle results from the fact that liberation from early prohibitions appears to be a betrayal of the teachings of she who gave life itself. (The equivalent experience in a man is often the repulsion he feels at the thought of his country — to many emotionally experienced as the “motherland”
— being attacked and betrayed.) The second, external process of liberation involves breaking loose from the constraints of society: the laws that treated women as property, rather than as potential owners of property, that enslaved women to their fathers, brothers, and husbands, and made them subjects, rather than citizens. This involves breaking down barriers to the education and employment open to men. Such external liberation often means going counter to the forces of family, spouse, and society. The price people have to pay is great. The external and internal processes of liberation are not easy.
Mary Wollstonecraft (1759-1797) is a wonderful example of a woman who was an important change agent because of her own personality as well as because of the new ideas and opportunities available to her. Diane Jacobs in Her Own Woman: The Life of Mary Wollstonecraft (2001) provides valuable data for the psychohistorical understanding of this feminist pioneer. As the second child and oldest daughter of a middle-class family with a doting, alcoholic father who was gradually losing the family fortune, she deeply resented that her elder brother was breast-fed and she was not, that her elder brother was formally educated while she had to rely primarily on informal and self-education, that he had property rights and she did not, that upon the death of their father he was the head of the family by virtue of his gender and she was not despite her greater capabilities, concern, and competence, and that he had a career while the only careers open to her as a genteel woman were companion to an older woman, or as a governess, or as a teacher of girls. She tried each occupation. Each paid poorly, and was seen as temporary — preparatory to marriage.
Mary was the type of girl, and then woman, who had no choice but to speak out — she could not keep her mouth shut. As a teenager and young woman, she stood in front of her mother’s door, blocking her drunken father — who would not hit his beloved daughter — thus preventing him from physically abusing his wife. When a married younger sister had a psychotic episode during a postpartum depression and found her spouse (a good husband by the standards of the time) to be totally repulsive and impossible to live with, Mary stood by her sister. She could make a home for her sister and fight for the right for the mother to have possession of her child, but could not change the laws and customs leaving the child in the custody of the father — the baby soon died from the lack of a mother’s care. Similarly, Mary Wollstonecraft suffered grievously at the death of her best friend as a result of childbirth — a fate she herself would suffer. In her early books she wrote about the situation of women and the upbringing of children in a manner that reflected the mindset of an Enlightenment woman who had not yet questioned the basic assumptions of her era. Her way of viewing the world would soon change dramatically.
The French Revolution (1789-1799) was the thunderbolt to the consciousness of many, including Mary. When Edmund Burke denounced the Revolution and then Thomas Paine’s The Rights of Man, she answered with her own Vindication of the Rights of Man (1790). She went to Paris as a revolutionary fellow-travelling journalist, eager to throw off the bonds of oppression on humankind. While standing up for the rights of man she also insisted on the rights of women, however much “liberated men” did not want to hear this. Mary came to see marriage as a form of legal prostitution and enslavement. In Paris, she fell madly in love with the Revolution and an American by whom she became pregnant: for her free love meant the equivalent of a totally devoted marriage without the bonds of legal marital “servitude.” As her lover traveled more and pulled away from this strong woman whom he seems to have experienced as somewhat engulfing, Mary’s response came in the form of two suicide attempts. On one occasion as he literally walked away without looking back at her, she threw herself into London’s icy Thames River, from which she was unhappily saved by some boatmen. The disconnect between Mary’s dreams of true equality and sharing between the sexes and the reality of her own desperate emotional needs and the standards of her times was enor-
Page 155
mous. Fortunately, in the radical thinker William Godwin, she found a man with whom she shared not passion but a like-minded devotion to equality for men and women alike. Her early death left the world with the book A Vindication of the Rights of Woman (1792), an older daughter who committed suicide upon learning that Godwin was not her biological father, and an unhappy younger daughter who struggled with an unloving stepmother and pined at her birth mother’s gravesite, dreaming of becoming as great a writer as the mother she never knew.
The death of Mary Wollstonecraft in childbirth was no accident. This path-breaking feminist was killed by an avoidable infection following the birth of her second child: childbirth fever was caused by the unwashed hands of a doctor who removed the afterbirth. This was a monstrous, pervasive, yet avoidable cause of women’s death until the later 19th-century in Western society. It was only when doctors started consistently washing their hands and women stopped giving birth on an almost yearly basis, as well as being worked to death in child and husband care, that Western women stopped dying before their male counterparts. It is no accident that girls, from birth, are more durable than boys and develop earlier in life. This had to be, in order for women to pass through the Darwinian type of struggle that the conditions of their lives inflicted upon them.
Among the reasons that enabled the teenage Mary Wollstonecraft Shelley (1797-1851) to literally dream up and write Frankenstein, or, The Modern Prometheus (1818) were her experiences of childbirth, childcare, the death of an unnamed infant child, and the dream that her dead baby had come back to life. The creation of life without the birth process which killed her mother and brought pain and uncertainty to her own life was something far more likely to be on her mind than in the consciousness of her brilliant male literary companions Lord Byron and Percy Shelley in the contest as to who could come up with the best ghost story during a rainy June on a Swiss lake (see my “Nightmare, Dreams, and Creativity, “in Paul Elovitz, ed., Historical and Psychological Inquiry, 1990, pp. 362-369).
The transformation of sex roles in America in my lifetime has been enormous. The unchallenged male chauvinism of my post-WW II childhood, just like the legal racial segregation of the same period, has been confronted and is in retreat. Women are a part of society as never before. They have far more doors open to them, far more pressures on them, and far less certainty as to what they will do with their lives. The French may say vive la différence, yet throughout the globe, America represents a confusion of sex roles. This causes widespread bafflement, especially in certain areas of the Islamic world controlled by men devoted to the male subordination of women. To increase their options in whatever part of the world they live, women must undergo an intrapsychic transformation and their societies must allow economic, legal, and social changes. I wish them well in creating a world different and better than the one into which they were born.
In my essay I have endeavored to bring historical, personal, and psychohistorical perspectives to the understanding of the preceding essays. I want to conclude with a personal note. I marvel at the transformation in sex roles and rights in my own family and lifetime. How did we change from the world of arranged marriages and women-as-subservient-to-men to the present ideals of our educated elite? From the world of my grandmother, who was born in Eastern Europe and was married prior to World War I by arrangement to a man she saw as well below her social class because she was considered an “old maid” as she approached her mid-20s? She may never have liked her husband, and, in fact, did not share her bed with him for the last 35 years of their lives, but she remained a loyal wife because no other option appeared open to her; she had crossed an ocean to America in emigrating, but she was unwilling to cross the intra-psychic ocean which divorce would have required. Grandma may not have provided “spousal privileges,” but she otherwise was a wifely caretaker and her spouse reflected his attachment to her by dying just months after she did.
Page 156
How to cite this article
Elovitz, P. H. (2005). Some concluding thoughts from the perspective of a male psychohistorian. Clio’s Psyche, 11(4), 150-156.



