
Volume 13 - Number 2 - September 2006
Pages: 81 - 107
Elovitz, P. H. (2006). In Memoriam: John Caulfield (1922-2006) [Memorial]. Clio’s Psyche, 13(2), 104.
In Memoriam: John Caulfield (1922-2006)
Abstract
This memorial tribute to John Blakeley Caulfield (1922–2006), a longtime member of the Psychohistory Forum’s Advisory Council, recounts his life and death. The author reports his birth in Guttenberg, New Jersey, his Irish-American family’s economic hardship during the Great Depression, his education at Seton Hall University and Darlington Seminary, and his ordination in 1947. The tribute covers his three and a half decades of parish and hospital work, his part in founding the National Association of Catholic Chaplains, his departure from the formal priesthood in 1981, his marriage, his advocacy of optional celibacy, his work with the homeless in the Bowery, and his fundraising in Florida, including for the Forum. It describes his final illness and his choice to die under hospice care. The author characterizes him as known for humanity and good humor. He attributes Caulfield’s leaving the priesthood chiefly to disappointed expectations of reform after Vatican II and, on the basis of a remark Caulfield once made, suggests that loneliness also contributed. The tribute closes by noting that the Forum and Clio’s Psyche will miss him.
family, “Funding Psychohistory: An Interview with John Caulfield,” memorial, John Caulfield, medical intervention, psychohistory, Psychohistory Forum
John Blakeley Caulfield, who served for years on the Advisory Council of the Psychohistory Forum, died in his own bed at 1:35 pm on June 24, 2006, surrounded by his devoted family. His struggle with ill health included a heart bypass operation in 1999 and extremely painful pancreatitis beginning in 2001. After two full years of maintaining a reasonable quality of life while on hospice, he chose to die of liver failure rather than subject himself and his family to further medical interventions offering no prospect of good health. He did not want to be a burden on his loved ones.
Caulfield was born on March 22, 1922 in Guttenberg, New Jersey, as the second son of an Irish-American family that included four younger sisters. His family suffered a devastating economic setback during the Great Depression, resulting in his identifying strongly with the poor and needy. John worked his way through college, graduating from Seton Hall University and then the Darlington Seminary in Mahwah, New Jersey prior to being ordained as a priest in 1947 in preparation for his career of service. For three and one half decades he served in various parishes and did considerable hospital work. In the 1970s he was a founder and president of the National Association of Catholic Chaplains.
Though John Caulfield left the formal structure of the Catholic priesthood in 1981, he always considered himself a priest, continuing to preach and do hospital and charitable work. After marrying Marie Trum in 1982, he campaigned for reform within the Church, especially for a return to the tradition of optional celibacy. For several years he worked with the homeless in the Bowery in lower Manhattan. Following his move to Florida in 1987, he turned his hand to fundraising for charitable groups, while continuing to serve as a part-time hospice and hospital chaplain. As a member of the Forum’s Advisory Council, he worked to strengthen the financial basis of our activities. See Paul H. Elovitz, “Funding Psychohistory: An Interview with John Caulfield” Vol. 2, no 1 (June, 1995), pp. 20-24.
John Caulfield was known for his humanity and good humor. He was a tall, dignified man with a warm smile. Indeed, even on June 14th when we last spoke, he remained humorous, though the telephone was soon too heavy for him to hold.
Optional celibacy, which had been the official policy of the Church until the Middle Ages, as well as the de facto situation of most priests prior to modern times, was a policy Caulfield came to advocate. He felt that parish priests should be free to marry if they so desire, as do Anglican and Eastern Orthodox priests. Counseling is an important part of the duties of the clergy and he came to believe that without having experienced family life it is hard to effectively counsel people about it. His wife Marie commented that after leaving the priesthood, he preached in a very different manner. With more and different types of life experience, Caulfield felt anger, compassion, frustration, love, pain and other feelings experienced in marriage differently and more deeply. Helping to raise the younger two of Marie’s three children, enabled him to talk more effectively and empathically with them and young people in general.
There is no single, definitive reason why John Blakely Caulfield chose to leave the Catholic priesthood to which he had devoted his life. Central to his motivation was disappointed expectations of further reform after Vatican II; he felt anger and frustration at the injustices within the Church. Based upon a comment he once made to me, I think that an added consideration was loneliness—even while surrounded by a crowd of adoring people. The Psychohistory Forum and Clio’s Psyche will miss a valued advisor and good friend.
Page 104
How to cite this article
Elovitz, P. H. (2006). In Memoriam: John Caulfield (1922-2006) [Memorial]. Clio’s Psyche, 13(2), 104.



