Volume 16 - Number 1 - June 2009
Pages: 1 - 105

THE PSYCHOECONOMICS
SPECIAL ISSUE ON FISCAL CRISIS, ECONOMIC FANTASIES, AND DENIAL

Elovitz, P. H. (2009). Psychological explorations of economic crises. Clio’s Psyche, 16(1), 1-6.

https://doi.org/10.70763/90415f9b8d0fe2da891b58a2dab18f8d

Psychological Explorations of Economic Crises

article

Abstract

In this article, introducing the special issue on fiscal crisis, economic fantasies, and denial, the author sets out his concern that psychological factors are largely absent from public discussion of the 2008–2009 financial and economic crisis. He recounts a remark attributed to Paul Volcker that economists and psychoanalysts are in the same business. He also cites Laura Tyson’s comment on NewsHour with Jim Lehrer that a collective delusion about housing values preceded the crash, and he reports that a college panel of business and academic experts made almost no psychological reference. He questions whether Dan Ariely’s Predictably Irrational and Akerlof and Shiller’s Animal Spirits go beyond confidence, corruption, and fairness. He describes mania and panic in market behavior and compares economic depression to individual depression, an analogy he uses in teaching. He contrasts Herbert Hoover’s reliance on market forces with Franklin Roosevelt’s deficit spending and rhetoric. He reports a correlation between the ends of presidencies and economic decline, which he attributes to national feelings of abandonment. He is critical of short-term investment horizons and of tax-cut policies, and he maintains that American free-market economics is more myth than reality. He concludes that psychoeconomics is largely unexplored, is unimpressed by the announced programs of two upcoming conferences, and expresses optimism that those trained to explore the unconscious will develop the field.

Keywords:

Conalee Shneidman, economic depression, economic policy, Paul Volcker, political leadership, psychoanalysis, psychoeconomics, psychohistory, psychology, psychotherapy, unconscious, Wall Street

Economics, finance, and fiscal policy are about psychology, not only according to psychohistorians, but also to Paul Volcker, the world-famous economist and former chairman of the Federal Reserve (1979-1987), at least as on the occasion reported to me. When introduced at a cocktail party to the late psychologist and psychoanalyst Conalee Shneidman, Volcker said they both were in “the same business.” Figuring out unconscious motivation is a challenge for psychoanalysts dedicated to helping individuals out of their personal morass and economists attempting to lead society out of its economic depressions and recessions. Of course, working with the irrationalism of individuals who are motivated to come to therapy in the safety of a consulting room is much easier than working with the mass delusions and hysterias which overtake Wall Street, the world financial establishment, and our economic and political leadership.

The resistance to the psychological study of economics is intense, yet in the height of the current fiscal and economic crisis there has been some fleeting acknowledgement of psychological factors. For example, former chairman of Clinton’s Council of Economic Advisors (1993-1995) and lead-

Page 1

ing economist Laura Tyson declared on the October 23, 2008 “NewsHour with Jim Lehrer,” “there was a collective delusion” that the housing market would only increase in value. Occasional references to psychology in the frantic days of October did not appear to result in any sustained psychological interest in the subject. There were some accusations of denial by those in power and clearly some feelings of schadenfreude in reference to the fall of some economic titans. However, the panel of ten so-called experts from business, finance, and academia sponsored by my college in October was noteworthy for the absence of psychological references, with the exception of a stigmatized economics leader being declared to be living in a world of his own fantasies. I came away from the presentation with the sense that the “experts” were as bewildered by the economic collapse as everyone else and that the positive function of the meeting was in assuaging the anxiety of those present by reassuring them that they were not alone in their economic losses and bewilderment.

Of late, I am finding a few references to behaviorist academic studies related to economics, such as Dan Ariely’s Predictably Irrational: The Hidden Forces That Shape Our Decisions (2008). Since the word “psychology,” but not much real psychological analysis, is becoming an “in word” which sells some books, today’s (April 19, 2009) New York Times Book Review includes coverage of Animal Spirits: How Human Psychology Drives the Economy, and Why It Matters for Global Capitalism, by George A. Akerlof and Robert J. Shiller. From the review, at least, it does not appear that the book by these University of California-Berkeley and Yale economists gets past discussing the “animal spirits” of confidence, corruption, and fairness leading to inevitable booms and busts.

The roots of the typical denial of serious psychological elements in economics are perhaps worth speculating

Page 2

about. Despite marketing studies demonstrating the extent to which consumer behavior is driven by emotional considerations, people generally prefer to avoid facing the role of emotion and unconscious motivation in economic life. In good times the stock market is generally blindly trusted as a rational system maximizing economic well-being, and during extreme economic downturns it is viewed as an inscrutable entity beyond the capabilities of mere mortals to understand, or as a system subject to massive manipulation on the basis of the self-interest of many involved. Yet even a cursory look at “the Market” reveals that there is room for psychohistorical inquiry.

The role of mania and panic in economic activity is striking. Investors rush to buy the “hottest stock,” which becomes a self-fulfilling prophecy of economic success. To keep the commissions coming and the economic snowball rolling, investors from around the world are found, using mysterious devices such as securitized mortgages. (Investors who thought they were purchasing a solid piece of the American dream, mortgages in the homes of America, found themselves cheated, confused, and angry.) Of course, when the tide turns there is a self-fulfilling prophecy of economic decline, causing a panic. A crisis of confidence sweeps over the market like a tidal wave washing away the reputations of even magicians of the market like the “Oracle of Omaha,” Warren Buffet, who has recently apologized to his investors. As the economic community and country slip toward depression, the future looks too bleak to invest in.

In teaching college students about economic depression, I have always drawn an analogy to individual human depression. My clothes and hair dishevelled, speaking slowly in a discouraged, angry manner as I shuffle across the front of the classroom, looking at the floor, I ask the students to describe the mood and behavior of someone they have known who was severely depressed. In short order the class

Page 3

discussion turns to the anger beneath the surface of the depressed individual. Before long we are discussing the depression of an entire society. As a consequence of this activity, the class comes to better understand the recent societal anger at those taking millions in bonuses while the government bailed out their companies and the appeal of those who offered leadership out of depression. Franklin Delano Roosevelt’s rhetoric of “the only thing we have to fear is fear itself” was aimed precisely at breaking the cycle of gloom deepening the downward spiral of the Great Depression of the 1930s.

Psychoanalysts know that mood swings and depression are not forever. The questions are how deep and long-lasting they will be and what can be done to end them and prevent future ones. Will our economic recession (dare I say “depression”?) last nearly as long as our manic phase? In recent American history I have noted a correlation between the end of a presidency and a decline of economic activity, which I have correlated with the country feeling a sense of abandonment by the outgoing president. Will the actions of the government and economic establishment shorten, lengthen, or make no difference to the length of the current economic slump? Twentieth-century history provides contradictory lessons. President Hoover, who had a great reputation as a humanitarian, mostly relied on market forces for recovery, which turned the fiscal crisis of 1929 into the Great Depression. FDR’s use of massive government involvement and deficit spending helped provide government jobs for many and build the infrastructure, but it took World War II to fully restore the economy.

The language used to describe various aspects of the present crisis is vivid enough to make psychoanalysts and psychohistorians take notice. Billionaire philanthropist and investor George Soros warns that bailing out the banks could turn “them into ‘zombies’ that suck the lifeblood of the

Page 4

American economy.” Others depict credit as the “lifeblood of the economy.” This imagery of zombiism and vampirism may represent a fear that the American economy could be among the living dead. Perhaps there is some basis for this fear.

In fact, the long-term health of the American economy is very much in doubt as manufacturing is exported to Asia, the American trade deficit continues, the country is dependent on foreign loans, and the younger generation is mostly concerned with consumerism, entertainment, finance, and sports. The focus has been more on the next quarter’s dividends than on building for the future, without much concern about the societal results of the investments. Those with the strongest ideological commitment to capitalism focus on tax cuts for the rich as the path to economic growth at a time when our industry and infrastructure are rusting. Throughout the George W. Bush years they focused on weakening the government’s social safety network on the grounds that this was a disincentive to hard work and personal planning, as well as because the private sector could do a better job. For example, the Social Security System was attacked as non-sustainable because it did not have the high returns individuals could get from the stock market—such arguments are not heard during this period of collapsing stock prices. Heralded by ideologues of capitalism since the Reagan years, American free market economics is, as I discovered in the course of teaching economic history, more myth than reality. In one of the great ironies of history, the Chinese communist government is overseeing vast development of its economic infrastructure, focusing on future growth. The divergence between the mythologies and realities of economic and political systems never ceases to amaze me.

For the last quarter century I have had an interest in the development of the paradigm of psychoeconomics, which this special issue is designed to help build. Regrettably, the

Page 5

field is mostly virgin territory. However, the Association for the Psychoanalysis of Culture and Society and the National Association for the Advancement of Psychoanalysis have scheduled meetings this year focusing on the current fiscal crisis. Although initially I am unimpressed by the psychoeconomic elements reflected in the presentation titles of the preliminary programs, I remain optimistic that people trained in the exploration of the unconscious will help develop our knowledge in this important area.

Page 6

About the author

Paul H. Elovitz

Dr. Paul H. Elovitz, PhD, began organizing scholarly meetings when he started as a faculty member at Ramapo College and then as convener of the Institute for Psychohistory Saturday Workshops (1975-1982). In 1982, he founded the Psychohistory Forum to nurture psychohistorical research and continues to lead its Executive Council. In 1994, he created Clio’s Psyche (cliospsyche.org) to publish its scholarship, of which he is Editor-in-Chief. Prof. Elovitz is a historian, psychoanalytic researcher, and author of well over 400 publications, covering presidential psychobiography, teaching, documenting the field of psychohistory, and much more. After taking his doctoral degree in history, he trained and practiced as a psychoanalyst for three decades, and in 2019 was made the first Research Psychoanalyst by the New Jersey Institute for Psychoanalysis. Elovitz is the author of The Making of Psychohistory, editor of The Many Roads of the Builders of Psychohistory, and edited or wrote eight other books. He is a founding member and past president of the International Psychohistorical Association (1978-) who held all but one of its offices and continues to serve on its leadership council. He is the sole founder of the IPhA who has attended and presented at all of its annual meetings. In recent years, he has devoted himself to editing, publishing, and writing psychobiography.  Prof. Elovitz was a founding faculty member at Ramapo College who previously taught at Temple, Rutgers, and Fairleigh Dickinson universities. Aside from teaching Western and World Civilizations, his focus on teaching was on American, English, and European history; childhood; gender; genocide; the Holocaust; identity; leadership; psychobiography; psychohistory; the psychology of creativity and innovation; and war and peace. Presently, he teaches post-graduate courses on creativity, psychoanalysis, psychobiography, and other aspects of psychohistory online at psychoanalytic institutes. A Festschrift honoring him is scheduled for publication in Clio’s Psyche in 2024. He may be contacted at .

How to cite this article

Elovitz, P. H. (2009). Psychological explorations of economic crises. Clio’s Psyche, 16(1), 1-6.

https://doi.org/10.70763/90415f9b8d0fe2da891b58a2dab18f8d

PDF downloads