Volume 23 - Number 2 - Winter 2017
Pages: 103 - 223

THE PSYCHOLOGY OF EXTREME NATIONALISM
SPECIAL FEATURE

Elovitz, P. H. (2017). David Lotto-Featured Journal of Psychohistory editor [Interview]. Clio’s Psyche, 23(2), 197-207.

https://doi.org/10.70763/d3802b1dc0d80d8a3c8ccc6ccc068e7c

David Lotto-Featured Journal of Psychohistory Editor

interview

Abstract

This interview, conducted online by the editor Paul H. Elovitz, features David Lotto, a psychoanalyst in private practice in Pittsfield, Massachusetts, and editor of the Journal of Psychohistory. Lotto recounts his path from physics to psychoanalysis and psychohistory, which he defines broadly as the study of psychological motivations behind human events, and recalls presenting “The Psychohistory of Vengeance” to Robert Lifton’s Wellfleet Psychohistory Group. He describes his editorial aim of publishing referenced scholarship, argues that opinion pieces belong outside scholarly journals, and recommends training in psychoanalytic theory, psychology, political theory, economics, and history. He faults Anna Geifman, Nancy Kobrin, and Jerrold Post for analyzing terrorists’ motives without acknowledging comparable United States conduct, describing this in terms of projective identification, and makes a parallel criticism of Vamik Volkan. He urges psychohistorians to examine their own motives and characterizes Elovitz’s outlook on societal improvement as Whig history, which Elovitz disputes. Lotto attributes violence to narcissistic injury and accumulated guilt, and terrorism to narcissistic injury and intergenerational trauma, citing the Crusades, colonial rule, and United States military action in predominantly Muslim regions. Elovitz agrees with much of this but objects to Lotto’s emphasis on Jimmy Carter, and Lotto maintains that Carter’s foreign policy was militarily aggressive. The interview also covers his education, mentors, and formative books.

Keywords:

David Lotto, editor, family history, interview, Jewish-American, Journal of the American Psychoanalytic Association, Journal of Psychohistory (JOP), psychoanalysis, psychobiography, psychohistory, psychology of terrorism, psychotherapy, scholarship, teacher, Wellfleet Group

David Lotto was born as the elder of two sons on December 18, 1946 in Manhattan to first generation Jewish-American parents whose parents came from Eastern Europe. His father worked several jobs, including as an x-ray technician, as well as a salesman of home products, cemetery plots, and mutual funds before working for the New York City Housing Authority. His mother, meanwhile, worked as a homemaker and secretary and later as an elementary school teacher in New York City public schools. The family moved to the Bronx when he was five, and he graduated from the Bronx High School of Science at age 16. In 1967 David graduated from Brandeis University with a double major in physics and psychology as well as a minor in the philosophy of science. He then entered

Page 197

the clinical psychology graduate program at the University of Chicago in 1967, where he connected with David Bakan who was interviewed by Clio’s Psyche as a featured scholar in our September 1998 issue. After President Richard Nixon ended graduate school deferments for the Vietnam War, he and Bakan went to York University in Toronto, where he received his master’s degree in 1969 and doctoral degree in psychology in 1974.

For two years he served as the chief psychologist at Cornwall General Hospital before starting his own private practice in Pittsfield, Massachusetts, which is still active today. He underwent a seven-year analysis with Paul Lippmann and completed the four-year psychoanalytic training program at the Westchester Institute for Psychoanalysis and Psychotherapy.

Dr. Lotto is the editor of the Journal of Psychohistory where he has reintroduced refereeing. He has authored over 25 journal articles in the Journal of Psychohistory, the Journal of the American Psychoanalytic Association, the Journal of the American Academy of Psychoanalysis, and Clio’s Psyche about many topics including Freud, sacrifice, the Manhattan Project, politics, the Tea Party, advertising, psychoanalytic history, war, violence, terrorism, and cults. In addition, he has also written many book reviews. He resides in Pittsfield, Massachusetts, where he practices psychoanalysis and psychotherapy, and lives with his wife Norah Walsh. They have three daughters and three grandchildren. Lotto (DL) was interviewed online by the editor (PHE) who has known him for about three decades.

PHE: When did you first get interested in psychology and psychoanalysis?

DL: In my sophomore year at Brandeis where I was a physics major, I took my first psychology course, Psychology 18b: Motivation, with Richard Jones. We read some Freud, Erikson, Maslow (who taught at Brandeis), and Richard’s favorite, Andras Angyal. I liked Freud, particularly Civilization and Its Discontents (1930). It was a whole new interesting and exciting world.

PHE: What personal factors influenced your openness to psychology and psychoanalysis?

DL: Curiosity about trying to understand how things work, first in physics about things inanimate and then in psychology about people, which included me, although there was a great deal of

Page 198

interest in understanding what was up with the various behavioral strangeness, which I saw around me. Also, I probably was motivated to understand more about the one-year-long severe depressive episode my father had undergone in my freshman year.

PHE: What brought you to psychohistory?

DL: What always interested me about psychoanalysis was how it could be a powerful way of understanding a whole lot of things that humans, individually but especially in large groups, were about, far more than psychoanalysis as a therapeutic method. Psychoanalysis can and has been “applied” in many areas, such as literature, art, and biography; but for me, understanding current events of importance was the most interesting and valuable area to which psychoanalytic insights could be applied. This implies examining context, and most importantly, the history; how things got to be the way they are, in order to best understand what is going on now. This led to psychohistory, which recognizes psychological motivation as important in understanding both the present and the past.

PHE: How do you define psychohistory?

DL: Broadly. Anything that explores the psychological motivations that are involved in driving human-caused events past, present, and future.

PHE: How did you come to edit the Journal of Psychohistory?

DL: I was asked to help out by a number of people when Lloyd deMause was no longer able to continue as editor. I have been regularly attending the IPA conventions since the 1980s and had published a number of articles in the Journal. I got to know both Lloyd and his wife Susan Hein over the years and feel that the journal has, and hopefully will continue, to publish manuscripts that make valuable contributions to our field.

PHE: What is your approach to editing the Journal of Psychohistory?

DL: To publish original high-quality scholarly articles that explore the motivations of groups and individuals that lead to increasing our understanding of why things are the way they are, and, possibly, how they might be changed.

PHE: What are you working on now? What is its importance and when do you expect to have it published?

DL: Nothing at the moment other than adding additional mate-

Page 199

rial to my recent paper on terrorism.

PHE: What is your primary affiliation? Is it psychology, psychoanalysis, psychohistory?

DL: I have affiliations to all three, as well as being a clinician. I also have interests and connections in many other areas. I don’t feel the need to identify one as primary; I am comfortable having multiple identities and doing different professional as well as non-professional activities at different times and in different contexts.

PHE: What special training was most helpful in your doing psychohistorical work?

DL: A broad liberal arts education, with a good bit of history included, graduate school in clinical psychology (particularly learning about research methods in the social sciences to be able to critically evaluate empirical research), and formal psychoanalytic training, particularly learning about the different psychoanalytic models for understanding human behavior.

PHE: What training should a person entering psychohistory today pursue?

DL: Psychoanalytic theory, psychology, political theory, economics, and history. These are the areas that I think are most important for obtaining the fullest understanding of current events.

PHE: I am very appreciative of your ability to bridge the divide between different psychohistorians. You have been a member of the oldest psychohistory society, Lifton’s Wellfleet Psychohistory Group, and organizations like the Psychohistory Forum and the International Psychohistorical Association, which have few crossover members or contributors. Please tell me about this ability and how you have done it.

DL: It has to do with taking on a persona, role, or perhaps even an identity. For me it is somewhat similar to what I do when I am sitting with patients. Freud and classical analysts describe it as a form of detachment; self-psychologists call it taking an empathic stance. In essence, treating and relating to whomever you are interacting with respectfully and focusing on understanding what they are saying, or the position they are taking, while letting your judgment about the merits of what you are hearing and whether you agree, disagree, like, or don’t like it, remain in the background. This does not mean that you can’t express your views or reactions,

Page 200

including strong and even passionate disagreement or opposition to the other—but there are specific times, places, and venues in which to do this; and they need to be contained within a respectful framework.

PHE: What was it like giving a paper on the psychology of revenge at your first Wellfleet Group meeting about 10 years ago, sitting across from Jane Fonda and next to Norman Mailer?

DL: Awesome. Last October was the 50th and alas final meeting of the Wellfleet Psychohistory Group. About 10 years ago, I brazenly sent Robert Lifton a copy of my just written paper titled “The Psychohistory of Vengeance” (2006), as there were several references to his work in it, and told him that my wife Norah and I would be vacationing in Wellfleet for two weeks in June. He and his wife Betty Jean graciously invited us over for drinks on the veranda overlooking the ocean and he invited me to present the paper at the next Wellfleet meeting. The meetings were held in a small one-room structure connected to the main house by an old beam. The room was about 30’ x 15’, with a large conference table with seats around and additional seats lining the walls, and could squeeze in about 40 people. The meetings started on Friday after lunch and went through lunch on Sunday. (Meetings in New York City were occasional luncheons at a restaurant near Lifton’s apartment with a speaker and short discussion.)

So it’s Friday afternoon and I’m first up. I am seated at the table, near the head where Lifton sits. There’s an old guy on my right, who turns and introduces himself as Norman Mailer. Jane Fonda and her lapdog are on the other side of the table. Fonda and Lifton knew each other, as they were both heavily involved in the anti-war movement in the early 1970s.

PHE: I have always been struck by your strong concern for economic and political justice. Tell me about your identification with the underdog and how it developed.

DL: I just heard this interview with a research psychologist on National Public Radio, describing a set of research studies on this very matter. Their findings are that most people, in some studies as high as 90%, will root for, prefer, and be more sympathetic toward the underdog. True in multiple areas, from rooting for one side or the other in a contest to animated circles rolling or being pushed up hills, the underdog is preferred. So, if most people most of the time are really for the underdog, we have to explain why in the “real

Page 201

world” underdogs not only don’t do very well, but seem often to be disdained; they’re losers, as Trump would say. The vital question should be how is it that most people’s natural inclination to root for the underdog, which is kind of synonymous with supporting economic and political justice, gets suppressed, and how this situation developed.

PHE: Tell me why you are critical of some fellow psychohistorians, such as Anna Geifman, Nancy Kobrin, and Jerrold Post. If I am correct in remembering that for a while you were critical of Vamik Volkan, please explain that as well.

DL: I wrote a paper about this titled “On the Pot Calling the Kettle Black: the Perils of Psychohistorical Partisanship,” which I think was published in the Journal of Psychohistory about six or seven years ago. The first three authors you mention are all Americans who are writing about the psychopathology of our terrorist enemies, which is part of a sub-genre of psychohistorical and psychological analyses of the bad behavior of our terrorist enemies that has grown up enormously since 9/11. Their descriptions of the pathological motives and actions of the terrorists have a great deal of overlap with the motives and actions of this country. None of the three authors makes the slightest reference to any similar actions committed by the United States. I think this is a problem and certainly affects their credibility in my eyes, as they are showing they have a huge blind spot and one suspects the presence of projective identification—putting one’s bad and unacceptable parts onto the enemy other while maintaining that you and your people are not like that.

My criticism of Volkan is slightly different; he writes of the psychopathology of Greeks, Serbs, and Armenians engendered by the trauma they have experienced, all who are to some extent enemies of the Turks, but says nothing of any similar psychopathology on the part of the Turks, although he is well aware that the Turks have experienced a good deal of their own trauma.

PHE: Recently, at one of our meetings you suggested that I am a Whig historian. Why is this, and how does it reflect our different approaches to improving society?

DL: Any historical analysis that describes a process in which things are getting better as time goes on is doing Whig history, by definition. The tone of disparagement concerning Whig history is that it is obviously a comforting notion. It sure would be nice if basically things were getting better all the time. Then we could feel

Page 202

 optimistic and hopeful about the future, which we are passing on to our children and grandchildren, because we have convinced ourselves that things are bound to get better. Such an obvious and blatant wish fulfillment makes such accounts suspect. There’s no difference that I can see in terms of what to do to try to make things better. This is of course a highly desirable and worthwhile thing—it’s just that there’s no guarantee that our endeavors will be successful.

PHE: As a teacher of the Holocaust, Stalin’s Gulag, genocide generally, and especially the murder of about a third of my fellow Jews in my own lifetime, I have to take exception to the implication that I may believe things are getting better all the time. They are not. However, I made the case for societal improvement in the Clio’s Psyche December 2014 issue in the “Are We More or Less Civilized Symposium.”

DL: Indeed, acknowledging that sometimes things do get worse for a while is not inconsistent with Whig history—but “when I take the long historical view, things are generally getting better” is the essence of Whig history.

PHE: What do we, as psychohistorians, need to do to strengthen our work?

DL: As above, look within more and realize that you and your people are governed by the same or similar motives as those you are attributing to others; and when you write or speak it is important to acknowledge this in some way. Also, I would like to see more scholarly writing—where opinions or analyses are supported by some references.

PHE: As an editor and scholar I couldn’t agree more. However, opinion pieces—however valuable—are much easier than doing in-depth research.

DL: Yes, they are. But I would argue that they have no place in a scholarly journal—there are many other outlets for opinion editorials—newspapers, newsletters, magazines, and the entire blogosphere.

PHE: What is the importance of childhood to psychohistory?

DL: A very complicated and controversial issue, essentially the same as the question in developmental psychology of the importance of events of childhood in determining adult behavior. The

Page 203

answers are by no means clear.

PHE: How do you explain the growth and psychology of fundamentalism?

DL: Long term I would argue there’s far less fundamentalism now than in the past few centuries. There are major problems with defining and categorizing “fundamentalism.” Is it religious only? What about political ideologues? The John Birch Society, the Klan? Were dedicated Nazis fundamentalists? What about Orthodox Jews, flag waving super-patriots, etc.?

PHE: What are your thoughts on the psychology and psychodynamics of violence in our world?

DL: I have written many words on this subject. Two important factors are the response to narcissistic injury and ways of dealing with accumulated guilt.

PHE: How do you understand the psychology of terrorism?

DL: Basically as a response to narcissistic injury currently inflicted mostly by the government of the United States and other governments which we support. Narcissistic injuries to Muslims at the hands of Christians goes back to the Crusades, continues through centuries of warfare between Christian Europe and the Ottoman empire, followed by the atrocities and oppression on the part of the colonial powers, chiefly Britain and France, from the collapse of the Ottoman empire at the end of WWI until the end of colonial rule in the early 1960s.

Also, starting in the late 1970s with the “Carter Doctrine,” which declared that assuring an uninterrupted supply of oil from the Persian Gulf was a vital national interest, the United States, with the help of local allied governments, has used military violence against Muslims on numerous occasions and in many locations throughout the predominantly Muslim areas of the world. In addition to protecting our access to oil, there was fighting the Cold War by aiding anyone who would claim to be anti-communist and attacking those we saw as too close with our arch enemy the USSR (as in our support of the Mujahideen in Afghanistan), and most recently, pursuing the Global War on Terrorism have been used as justifications for our use of violence in the Muslim world. The combination of the effects of the intergenerational transmission of trauma and the ongoing drone attacks, bombings, and ground combat engagement in Afghanistan and Iraq, particularly when these

Page 204

acts result in harming innocent civilians, is what fuels the burning desire for revenge that provides the fuel that feeds anti-Western Muslim terrorism.

PHE: While I agree with most of your points, you typically provide only a part of the picture. I am struck by your choosing to make an example of the comparatively liberal Carter, who brokered the Camp David Peace Accords with Begin and the man he called “my brother” Sadat, pushed through the Panama Canal Treaty, and refused to go to war with Islamic states during the oil and the Iran Hostage crises, rather than the Bushes, who actually went to war against Islamic states, and Reagan. Carter’s actions were all done at great political cost, which had much to do with his being a one-term president. Like many political radicals, you appear to me to direct your criticism much more at liberals who are sympathetic to many of your views than to conservatives who totally oppose them.

DL: I just looked at the Wikipedia entry for the 1980 Democratic Convention in which Edward Kennedy, who was characterized as the more liberal, was battling the centrist Carter. You cite some of Carter’s more positive actions, but he had an extremely militarily aggressive foreign policy led by arch Cold Warrior Brzezinski (Afghanistan and the “Carter Doctrine”).

PHE: In keeping with your call for psychohistorians to question their own motivations, there are two powerful elements to mine. As a young teenager I was repulsed by some very articulate and smart communist relatives who were always harshly critical of the US no matter what our country did. This in the Stalinist period! Consequently, I have a negative gut response to one-sided approaches from the right or left. I dislike the tendency to almost automatically sacrifice that which is better for that which is perfect. My historical perspective also leads me to question this approach—we humans do better, not perfect.

DL: Relatives with political blind spots is not a reason to ignore or minimize the many bad things that our country has done.

PHE: How can psychologically oriented scholars have more impact in academia and on society in general?

DL: Don’t be afraid to speak truth to power. We do this mostly by writing and publishing in our journals on topics that are of genuine human concern. Well-argued analyses of important current events is what we do best. I think this is where our energies should go.

Page 205

Also, as above, strive to be aware of and take into account our own biases, and work toward minimizing their influence.

PHE: How can we recruit new people to the field?

DL: Don’t recruit; let people find us.

PHE: On a personal note, what was it like and how did it impact your view of life when you and your new wife moved to an island in Newfoundland, living without electricity and running water for a year and a half? Did learning how to build things with your own hands have much impact on your self-image and respect for ordinary workers?

DL: Nothing ordinary about building things. It’s something to learn about and has the reward of actually being able to do some useful things, which I think is very good for self-esteem. Living without electricity and running water has been done by many. I think it is a strength to learn how to adapt to conditions as they are where you are.

PHE: What books were important to your development?

DL: In the realm of non-fiction, not necessarily in order—Freud’s Civilization and its Discontents, Erik Erikson’s Childhood and Society (1950), Norwood Russell Hanson’s Patterns of Discovery (1958), Russell Jacoby’s The Repression of Psychoanalysis (1983), and Douglas Kirsner’s Unfree Associations: Inside Psychoanalytic Institutes (2000). In fiction I was influenced by John Steinbeck, Kurt Vonnegut, and Thomas Pynchon.

PHE: Who was important to your development as a student of psychosocial phenomena? Did Erik Erikson have an impact on you?

DL: I liked Childhood and Society, but mostly he is a grandfather figure who was important to people I have had contact with.

PHE: Are there any mentors who come to mind?

DL: Richard Jones, Stephen Toulmin, Ricardo Morant, David Bakan, Anna Ornstein, Robert Lifton, and Paul Lippmann.

PHE: What is your psychoanalytic/psychotherapeutic experience and what is its influence on you as a psychohistorian? How has it changed your vision of the world?

DL: I see the same motives and ways of looking at the world that I am looking at psychohistorically.

Page 206

PHE: Please list the five people who you think have made the greatest contribution to psychohistory in order of their contribution.

DL: Erikson, Lifton, deMause, Binion, and you.

PHE: Thanks for a most informative and interesting exchange.

Page 207

About the author

Paul H. Elovitz

Dr. Paul H. Elovitz, PhD, began organizing scholarly meetings when he started as a faculty member at Ramapo College and then as convener of the Institute for Psychohistory Saturday Workshops (1975-1982). In 1982, he founded the Psychohistory Forum to nurture psychohistorical research and continues to lead its Executive Council. In 1994, he created Clio’s Psyche (cliospsyche.org) to publish its scholarship, of which he is Editor-in-Chief. Prof. Elovitz is a historian, psychoanalytic researcher, and author of well over 400 publications, covering presidential psychobiography, teaching, documenting the field of psychohistory, and much more. After taking his doctoral degree in history, he trained and practiced as a psychoanalyst for three decades, and in 2019 was made the first Research Psychoanalyst by the New Jersey Institute for Psychoanalysis. Elovitz is the author of The Making of Psychohistory, editor of The Many Roads of the Builders of Psychohistory, and edited or wrote eight other books. He is a founding member and past president of the International Psychohistorical Association (1978-) who held all but one of its offices and continues to serve on its leadership council. He is the sole founder of the IPhA who has attended and presented at all of its annual meetings. In recent years, he has devoted himself to editing, publishing, and writing psychobiography.  Prof. Elovitz was a founding faculty member at Ramapo College who previously taught at Temple, Rutgers, and Fairleigh Dickinson universities. Aside from teaching Western and World Civilizations, his focus on teaching was on American, English, and European history; childhood; gender; genocide; the Holocaust; identity; leadership; psychobiography; psychohistory; the psychology of creativity and innovation; and war and peace. Presently, he teaches post-graduate courses on creativity, psychoanalysis, psychobiography, and other aspects of psychohistory online at psychoanalytic institutes. A Festschrift honoring him is scheduled for publication in Clio’s Psyche in 2024. He may be contacted at .

How to cite this article

Elovitz, P. H. (2017). David Lotto-Featured Journal of Psychohistory editor [Interview]. Clio’s Psyche, 23(2), 197-207.

https://doi.org/10.70763/d3802b1dc0d80d8a3c8ccc6ccc068e7c

PDF downloads