Volume 26 - Number 3 - Spring 2020
Pages: 265 - 387

THE PSYCHOLOGY OF ALTRUISM, SERVICE, AND GENERATIVITY

Elovitz, P. H. (2020). Exploring my impulses for service. Clio’s Psyche, 26(3), 265-273.

https://doi.org/10.70763/83ddfbd1c4f871159c148d7a010e69be

Exploring My Impulses for Service

symposium article

Abstract

The author explores his service activities and their conscious and unconscious roots in his life. As a historian, he studied Eastern European history and then was psychoanalyzed as part of his search as a psychohistorian to understand the roots of his altruistic motivations.

Keywords:

altruism, anger, envy, generativity, identifications, psychic rewards, psychohistory, psychology, service, unconscious motivations

As a psychoanalytically trained scholar, I probe the patterns of my life and seek to understand the roots of my choices. As a young man, I had no idea that my life would lead me to devote considerable energy and time to serving others in unpaid capacities. These activities include being a midwife to the scholarship of others as the organizer of unique scholarly meetings since 1975; encouraging and editing the scholarship of colleagues as a journal editor since 1994; actively encouraging the creation of a new journal that some might see as a competitor of the one I created; serving on the planning committee of the International Psychohistorical Association (IPA); mentoring colleagues, students, and others; after three decades leaving my interesting and paid psychotherapy practice to devote more time to editing and scholarship; and caring for my second wife who is burdened with Parkinson’s disease. Some verification of my contributions to serving scholarship may be found in 12 comments on the book I published on the history of psychohistory (Commentaries on The Making of Psychohistory, Clio’s Psyche Vol. 25, No. 2, Winter 2019: 182-204).

Of course, I am not unique in serving others, and being a college professor provided an economic base for my service activities. Below, I will discuss my conscious and unconscious altruistic motivations as well as my struggle with envy and resentment, the major obstacles to receiving the psychic rewards of more freely serving others.

The immigrant experience of my parents, who arrived separately in America at age 14 and relied overwhelmingly on self-education, had a profound impact on my life. My workaholic

Page 265

mother dreamed of having a formal education and discussing ideas with the well-educated. In retrospect, I realize that she was the greatest influence on my life, but I grew up idealizing and wanting to emulate my father who, like so many other Jewish immigrants of his generation, wanted to be able to talk about “my son, the doctor.” He wanted me to become a physician, declaring that I would be able to “help people, have a respectable profession, and have my own cash register.” Having the economic security and independence of your “own cash register” was important to my father, who had to start his own small business when blacklisted as a union organizer during the Great Depression. But to me, the idea of becoming a doctor was repulsive because even though I associated caring for others with kindness, I associated collecting money from hurting patients with greed. (At some level I was also aware of Dad’s awe and envy of doctors.) As much as I wanted to please Dad in choosing a career, I felt sure I would clumsily kill a patient during an operation (psychiatry was not on our radar!) since Mom had always told me that I had “two left arms, two left legs, and that if my head wasn’t connected to my body I would forget it someplace.”

After struggling in my first year and a half of college to be a good son and please Dad as a premedical student, I rebelliously dropped out of college. My dream was to have an adventuresome life like that of my father, who had the misfortune to live amidst war and revolution. Dad’s refusal to talk to me about most of the details of his adventures in Europe whetted my appetite and would lead me to become a historian. Subsequently, I would also become an analyst and psychohistorian partly to overcome the family’s prohibitions on exploring the past. This was not an easy process. However, by dropping out of college and serving in the military, I achieved a better sense of myself and my capabilities apart from the hotbed of our family dynamics, which were exacerbated by my mother’s four-year-long illness with the Hodgkin’s disease that would kill her. I was also left with an enormous sense of guilt because in my struggles to find myself, I was causing great pain to my parents. At the time, I mostly knew only that I had fallen in love and wanted to start a life with my first wife.

In retrospect, we were two young people who did not know ourselves or each other very well and were pursuing a fantasy of a wonderful life together. Since I had some small savings of money I had earned in high school but no profession, I was not in a very good position to support this blissful life we were dreaming of.

Page 266

Fortunately, both families stepped in and talked us into going back to college; they agreed to provide a modest amount of money so that we would finish our undergraduate education. Since this was the price of getting married, and I had no ready alternative, I accepted. I now realize that Mom had raised me not to be a man of action, but to be a scholar. On her deathbed, she wanted me to promise to be a college professor as she dictated her last will and testament to me; at the time all I would promise was to seriously consider that possibility.

Before long our familial and personal plans were dashed by the birth of our first child, resulting in my becoming not simply a student, but also the breadwinner for a wife and ultimately three children. What could I do? Since I needed a means of supporting my family, I decided I would become a college professor, thus fulfilling the dreams of my mother. To my mind, there were no other ready alternatives since I was not inclined toward business. The complexity of becoming a professor and supporting a family was quite difficult and dependent upon my getting jobs cleaning offices, doing day labor, driving delivery trucks, and working in warehouses. Professionally, as my education advanced, I earned money from a teaching assistantship, adjunct teaching, and as a poorly paid lecturer and associate professor at Temple University.

My wife would become overburdened with childcare and resentful of me. She had entered our relationship very conflicted about living with and then without her parents when she first went away to college. Personally, I was too overwhelmed with achieving my goals of earning a PhD to become a college professor while supporting my family to focus on my own disappointed myth of the perfect life together I had dreamed of. Ultimately, I achieved the goals of getting a PhD, buying a house with a veteran’s no-down-payment mortgage, and becoming a college professor at the type of small college I dreamed of. The turning of these dreams into realities, however, did not bring happiness to either partner in our marriage, ultimately resulting in separation and divorce.

The question became: how do I make the transition from being a somewhat depressed husband to more fully embracing a much more fulfilling life that involved considerable service to others? Being miserable in my home life limited how much I could give to others. Giving and taking are a part of life, as Rabbi Hillel famously said: “If I am not for myself, who will be for me? But if I am only for myself, who am I?” While I was unhappily struggling

Page 267

with the deteriorating relationship with my first wife, as well as my own anger, envy, and frustration, I was not able to give nearly as much to others as when I became more self-accepting and when my home life improved. Therapy played a key role in this process.

After having discovered psychoanalysis and psychohistory, my justification for going into psychoanalysis as part of a training program was to become the best psychohistorian I could become. Beneath this conscious justification was the unconscious reality that I desperately needed psychoanalysis because my marriage was falling apart and my dream of a perfect college was in shambles partly because of collegial prejudices against psychological history. My training in psychoanalysis, after a difficult start, enabled me to have a better sense of myself and the world around me, what I really felt, and what my values were. These values included helping others to a much greater extent than I previously realized. They included fulfilling my mother’s dream to live a life focused on learning and educating people.

As a professor, I soon went beyond educating and mentoring the young. Upon the establishment of Ramapo College, I quickly started organizing interdisciplinary seminars, but I discovered that most of the faculty was far more interested in building a new institution and struggling with the politics of it, rather than in the intellectual exchanges I had in mind. However, as I became involved in organized psychohistory in New York City, this impulse toward intellectual exchange led me to set up seminars in which we helped colleagues from many different fields exchange and nurture their ideas.

In this unpaid activity, which I have now carried on since 1975, I help colleagues develop their ideas, many of which would become articles or books. Like a midwife, I did not plant the seed of the idea; rather, a clinician or scholar would come to me at the Institute for Psychohistory’s Saturday seminars and from 1982 onward at the Psychohistory Forum’s Saturday workshops. This midwifery involved somebody proposing an idea to me, my encouraging them to write a paper or book outline—if they have not already done so—then, after it was vetted by a committee, sending it out to members of the group for people to read prior to our actual meetings, which at first were all-day Saturday meetings. At the meetings, the presenter was not given much time to recap or add new materials since participants had already read her/his idea, but the group participated in a process in some ways analogous to psychoa-

Page 268

nalysis, nurturing their ideas in a safe, non-critical environment (see “Postgraduate Psychohistorical Education,” Clio’s Psyche Vol. 12, No. 3, December 2005: 113, 121-123).

In the early Institute for Psychohistory years, some problems arose because we met under the auspices of Lloyd deMause in the impressive conference room of his business. He vacillated between encouraging and even publishing valuable psychohistorical scholarship and wanting disciples to expand and propagate his own psychohistorical theories. When in 1982 I created the Psychohistory Forum with Henry Lawton as co-director, we avoided these problems because I carefully set the guidelines, starting with providing a safe environment in which knowledge could grow.

Another area revealing my impulse to help others is an inclination to mentor colleagues, students, and friends. I encouraged Henry Lawton to establish his psychohistorical film studies group and showed him how to create a psychological research business at a time when he was earning an advance degree in library science. Initially, one summer when I did not have the necessary income from summer school teaching, the idea was that we would be partners in a research business, but I realized that I enjoyed finding clients, which was not Henry’s strength. This was a period in my own psychoanalysis when I faced the fact that I was quite good at helping others, encouraging colleagues to do psychohistory, and raising money for psychohistory to set up awards, but no good at asking for money for myself. I took on the challenge of trying to do this by becoming a part-time 100% commission salesperson during a summer selling home insulation, which as a lifelong environmentalist I strongly believed in.

After spending my evenings and Saturdays trying to sell the value of the product, if I did not close the sale, I would have spent many hours away from my loved ones without compensation. I’m very proud that by setting closing the sale as a goal, I greatly increased my ability and part-time income. However, I came for good reason to wonder about the possible unhealthy side effects of the particular insulation I was representing, at which point my sales rate dropped dramatically and my career as a salesman ended. I had, in fact, achieved my goal of training myself to do a better job of recognizing my own needs and openly asking something for myself. In analysis and psychohistorical explorations, I did a lot of work on why I had trouble asking for help myself as opposed to an eagerness to help others. As I’ve gone further and further back in

Page 269

my consciousness, my earliest memory is of asking shortly after I was toilet trained for help from my father and being rejected. Then, as I’ve previously written, I would face at ages four or five a duel trauma in which I was terrified and felt very guilty about asking for any assistance from my overworked mother (“How My Greatest Trauma Helped to Shape My Life,” Clio’s Psyche Vol. 25, No. 3, Spring 2019: 242-246).

To provide service to others, I had to struggle with my own envious impulses. I grew up very envious of my big brother, who was four years older and had all sorts of privileges that I wanted. I also remember being very eager to get additional food at the dinner table and became Mom’s helper partly because that meant I would have more access to leftovers. Under Mom’s strong influence, I believed envy was not an emotion I should have. In my mind, good boys and men were not envious. This suppression and repression of my envious impulses resulted in my being conflicted about them and their becoming stronger. I also inclined to deny my anger. Fortunately, in analysis and from the example of my very direct second wife Geri, I was able to confront this envy and look for ways of getting around it. I learned to sometimes directly compliment those I envied, point out how I admired what they did, and with an appreciative smile often get them to explain how they were able to achieve these things. The green monster was not totally tamed since I can be a fairly competitive man, especially when dealing with other competitive men, but it certainly is much less of a problem. I was angered and upset when a colleague cheered the demise of the valuable Psychohistory Review in 1999. To me, it is about growing applied psychoanalysis and psychohistory, not just Clio’s Psyche. I thoroughly enjoyed helping a friend when he started the psychoanalytic journal J.A.S.P.E.R. The pleasures of giving and having good relations is enormous, although this is not always possible.

The generosity of others intrigues me. Examples that come to mind include a middle-aged woman who works two part-time jobs, donates 10% of her income to her church, and can be incredibly generous to those in need who she meets in everyday life, including donating masks she made early in the COVID-19 crisis to maternity ward nurses; two of my granddaughters becoming social workers because of their desire to care for others; and the acupuncture/chiropractor in my neighborhood who runs marathons for charities and last summer ran over 1,000 miles to raise money for draw-

Page 270

ing attention to a charity for women and children in a depressed industrial city. I am appreciative of the members of Henry Lawton’s church, who in his last years came every morning and evening to take him to the bathroom, help him dress and undress, and put him to bed. I am appreciative of his analyst, who came to his home to continue the treatment of this man who courageously soldiered on in the face of extreme disability.

For years my late friend Harriet worked quite hard as a professional, making a good living into her mid 80’s; but she died several years later while living on her meager social security monthly check because she kept giving away the hard-earned fruits of her labor to her children, friends, and people she mentored. As a child, her mother had continuously called her very bright daughter dumb and lazy, saying she would never amount to anything, when in fact, she was a well-respected professional, achieved a great deal in her life, and made a lot of money that she failed to hold onto. It is my assessment based upon an over four decade long close friendship that while she struggled to disprove her mother’s assessment, some unconscious part of her agreed with her mother by not keeping the benefits of her work. (Note that in the original version of this paper I referred to Harriet Lenzing [August 20, 1929-July 4, 2019] as “H.” and her husband Fred Ludwig [August 15, 1927-March 5, 2020] as “F.” Since both are deceased I have now included their full names—they should be remembered.)

One of the many nice things she did was to encourage her second husband, Fred, who has beautiful white wavy hair and a marvelous white curly beard, to serve as Santa Claus. She also paid for the voluminous small toys he gave away and his attending Santa Claus school. Without receiving a cent for his efforts, he spent eight years at the Santaland in his hometown as the official Santa Claus and went to old age homes and other facilities to play Santa, which he thoroughly enjoyed and did as long as he was physically capable of doing it.

Fred was also a very giving person. As a 17-year-old wanting to serve his country in World War II and seeking adventure, he joined the Seabees and spent his 18th birthday driving a bulldozer and cooking on the island of Iwo Jima as Japanese snipers fired down on the GIs. Fred loved to bake and cook and as long as Harriet was alive he continued to do so despite at age 92 a virtual inability to walk. He served 68 years as a volunteer fireman and spent his last months in the New Jersey Firemen’s Home in his

Page 271

hometown. Like me as a child, he had liked hanging around the kitchen. However, his mother had medical problems that resulted in her being hospitalized for long periods, giving him far more incentive to not simply be mother’s helper but to cook for himself and his brothers. At the fire department for 20 years he was famous for making tasty homemade food for the monthly meetings. Indeed, he once commented to me that a fellow fireman was so appreciative of his cooking that he declared: “If you had tits, I’d marry you!” He delighted in bringing food to his friends and was a nurturer. At his funeral between 50 and 60 volunteer firemen and women in full uniforms filed past his open casket in recognition of his service and friendship.

There were other parts to his personality. When at a Yankees Stadium home opener there was not the promised place for his wheelchair-bound wife to observe the game, at the customer service desk Fred was not satisfied to wait his turn behind the many people in front of us. He was so furious that it felt like he was ready to jump over the counter and strangle the service people who could provide the accommodation. This was the only time that I observed his rage, which was connected to his caring self for his wife. As much as I was shocked by his behavior, it reminded me that as a child I wouldn’t fight for myself because my mother had said it was wrong to fight; but I would fight fiercely for a friend, and the same inclination continued into adulthood, though at that point it was not physical fighting.

For many years I have phoned both Harriet and Fred on a weekly basis as their health deteriorated. This pattern of calling to cheer relatives and friends up I trace back to my mother urging me to keep in contact with Aunt Mollie, who would all but give you the shirt off her back, only to eventually say you owed her. Her giving had long strings! Mom felt sorry for her sister-in-law, who had never been able to leave her own mother and create a satisfactory life. Mollie was not nice to Mom and was extraordinarily envious of my father, her mother’s favorite child. Then too, after Mom’s death, I eventually started calling her younger sister in Oregon, which we both enjoyed. Perhaps phoning relatives is an early aspect of what I call “the obligations of survival” that have led me to write carefully crafted memorials of psychohistorical colleagues shortly after their deaths.

The colleague who introduced me to psychoanalysis and psychohistory when I taught at Temple University made the point

Page 272

that some people do for others what they wish was done for themselves. This has certainly been true in my life. My early denial of my own anger, envy, and many of my other needs made me a less happy person. When in psychoanalysis I became a more self-accepting person, I was able to give more freely to others and to the field of psychohistory that I love. The psychic rewards of giving and interacting with a wonderful group of colleagues have been enormous. While I am still very much a work in progress, I find life to be quite satisfying despite the many struggles involved.

Page 273

About the author

Paul H. Elovitz

Dr. Paul H. Elovitz, PhD, began organizing scholarly meetings when he started as a faculty member at Ramapo College and then as convener of the Institute for Psychohistory Saturday Workshops (1975-1982). In 1982, he founded the Psychohistory Forum to nurture psychohistorical research and continues to lead its Executive Council. In 1994, he created Clio’s Psyche (cliospsyche.org) to publish its scholarship, of which he is Editor-in-Chief. Prof. Elovitz is a historian, psychoanalytic researcher, and author of well over 400 publications, covering presidential psychobiography, teaching, documenting the field of psychohistory, and much more. After taking his doctoral degree in history, he trained and practiced as a psychoanalyst for three decades, and in 2019 was made the first Research Psychoanalyst by the New Jersey Institute for Psychoanalysis. Elovitz is the author of The Making of Psychohistory, editor of The Many Roads of the Builders of Psychohistory, and edited or wrote eight other books. He is a founding member and past president of the International Psychohistorical Association (1978-) who held all but one of its offices and continues to serve on its leadership council. He is the sole founder of the IPhA who has attended and presented at all of its annual meetings. In recent years, he has devoted himself to editing, publishing, and writing psychobiography.  Prof. Elovitz was a founding faculty member at Ramapo College who previously taught at Temple, Rutgers, and Fairleigh Dickinson universities. Aside from teaching Western and World Civilizations, his focus on teaching was on American, English, and European history; childhood; gender; genocide; the Holocaust; identity; leadership; psychobiography; psychohistory; the psychology of creativity and innovation; and war and peace. Presently, he teaches post-graduate courses on creativity, psychoanalysis, psychobiography, and other aspects of psychohistory online at psychoanalytic institutes. A Festschrift honoring him is scheduled for publication in Clio’s Psyche in 2024. He may be contacted at .

How to cite this article

Elovitz, P. H. (2020). Exploring my impulses for service. Clio’s Psyche, 26(3), 265-273.

https://doi.org/10.70763/83ddfbd1c4f871159c148d7a010e69be

PDF downloads