Volume 18 - Number 1 - June 2011
Pages: 1 - 121

THE PSYCHOLOGY OF AMERICAN EXCEPTIONALISM
SYMPOSIUM: DOMESTIC AND FOREIGN POLICY

Ferraro, T. (2011). From de Tocqueville to Baudrillard, Lasch, and Bacevich. Clio’s Psyche, 18(1), 46-50.

https://doi.org/10.70763/97af07a14cacba681feacf3012730892

From de Tocqueville to Baudrillard, Lasch, and Bacevich

response article

Abstract

In this response article in the symposium “The Psychology of American Exceptionalism,” the author replies to Frank Summers, “A Psychoanalytic Approach to Exceptionalism in Foreign Policy,” and Paul H. Elovitz, “Extreme American Exceptionalism: Narcissism and Paranoia,” both of which explain American character and foreign policy in terms of narcissism. The author accepts their account of the problem but questions whether it offers a way out, noting that Heinz Kohut and Otto Kernberg regarded many forms of narcissism as untreatable. The author cites Christopher Lasch on narcissism in American society and Andrew Bacevich’s argument, in The Limits of Power: The End of American Exceptionalism, that foreign policy reflects entitlement. Turning to Alexis de Tocqueville’s Democracy in America and Jean Baudrillard’s America, the author contends that the traits Tocqueville described (practicality, Puritan work habits, commercial orientation, and indifference to the arts and sciences) persist, and that Baudrillard’s portrait of emptiness reflects a later stage of the same character. The author attributes present-day national depletion to consumer goods, advertising, and easy credit, and offers comparisons such as sports and dance attendance. The author concludes that the arts and literature may be the nation’s best remedy, urges Americans to adopt European habits of leisure and cultural life, and argues that a nation with an inner life to match its outer one would be exceptional.

Keywords:

Alexis de Tocqueville, American character, American exceptionalism, Christopher Lasch, entitlement, foreign policy, Frank Summers, Heinz Kohut, Jean Baudrillard, The Limits of Power: The End of American Exceptionalism, narcissism, national character, Otto F. Kernberg, Paul H. Elovitz, psychohistory

The term “exceptionalism” has been used to define the American character for at least 180 years. In papers by Paul Elovitz and Frank Summers, the psychological trait of narcissism is used to explain both the American character and our foreign policy traits. Although they describe the problem in clear and persuasive ways, what is lacking is a reasonable pathway out of our narcissistic binds. Heinz Kohut and Otto Kernberg, the leading luminaries on the subject, found many forms of narcissism to be untreatable. If we as Americans suffer from this condition on a large-scale basis, as Christopher Lasch stated in 1979, then exactly how is one to find a way out? Furthermore, Andrew Bacevich, in The Limits of Power: The End of American Exceptionalism (2008), has stated that

Page 46

our foreign policy reflects our attitude of entitlement and endangers our world standing. I will refer to Alexis de Tocqueville’s initial use of the term exceptionalism in 1835 and 1840 to explore our national character and will extend his work by reviewing Jean Baudrillard’s America to assess the changes in American character over a century and a half.

Alexis de Tocqueville’s View of the American Character

The French aristocrat and historian de Tocqueville (1805-1859) wrote his two-volume masterpiece of sociological insight, Democracy in America, in 1835 and 1840 based on his travels in the United States for nine months. He wrote that “the position of the Americans is therefore quite exceptional, and it may be believed that no democratic people will ever be placed in a similar one.” He bases it on “their strictly Puritanical origin, their exclusively commercial habits, even the country they inhabit,” which “have singularly concurred to fix the mind of the American upon purely practical objects.” De Tocqueville repeatedly emphasized our practical, puritanical, hard-working, and commerce-minded traits, as well as our lack of aesthetic interest in literature, the fine arts, or science. This still holds true. The world still considers us “ugly Americans.” The American way of life is work-oriented; we take fewer vacations than any other industrial nation. Our social life has deteriorated dramatically, as Robert Putman has shown in his book Bowling Alone: The Collapse and Revival of American Community. But our interest in commerce and money is remarkable. De Tocqueville was also correct about our lack of interest in fine art. Compare the attendance numbers at a Yankees baseball game versus a Paul Taylor Dance Company performance. Americans are a practical, work-oriented, and money-minded lot with a Puritan streak even in the age of a consumer society.

Jean Baudrillard’s View of America: “A Desert Wasteland”

De Tocqueville is not the only French thinker to attempt to describe the American character. Jean Baudrillard (1929-2007), the French social critic and post-modernist, is considered to be one of the 20th century’s greatest thinkers. He came to the country in 1970 in search of the “true” America. His book America (1986) was meant to be a response to and extension of de Tocqueville’s work, and he begins his book with “the America of the empty, absolute

Page 47

freedom of the freeways, not the deep America of mores and mentalities, but the America of desert speed, of motels and mineral surfaces. I looked for it in the speed of the screenplay, in the indifferent reflex of television,” and he continues, “in the film of days and nights projected across an empty space, in the marvelously affectless succession of signs, images, faces and ritual acts on the road.”

He traveled across America in a rental car, which he felt reflected our speed and sense of isolation. He described America as a culture of vast emptiness and noted our embrace of Disney, television, and malls. He emphasizes the desert-like quality of America; this, of course, is an apt description of the narcissist. Narcissists sense their own deadness and emptiness, forcing them into endless competitiveness and a hunger for admiration.

How do we go from being described as “exceptional” due to our practicality and our work ethic to being a nation of empty, overcompetitive narcissists? De Tocqueville described America as a fully realized utopia of freedom and equality; Baudrillard describes us 150 years later as a vast empty wasteland. What went so wrong?

Christopher Lasch on Narcissism in America

Narcissism is now seen in epidemic numbers throughout America. The 1970s were coined the “Me Decade” by Newsweek, and the situation has only gotten worse with the characterization of the selfish, greedy, hyper-competitive American. This same attitude of exceptionalism would inevitably be seen in our government and in our foreign policy. Lasch was able to describe this problem as far back as 1979. These exceptional American traits have produced a military and financial world power. Our gross national product, as well as our military budget, is by far the largest in the world. Our narcissism and our lust for more have produced great superiority in these areas.

In The Limits of Power, Andrew Bacevich described America as profligate, extremely imperialistic, and on the verge of depletion. The current debate about the decline and fall of American exceptionalism borrows from his scholarship.

I have written about the current causes of the Americans’ state of depletion in the past (Clio’s Psyche Vol. 15, No. 4, March 2009). Our current state of depletion has three main causes: 1) the

Page 48

amazing beauty of the objects produced by our capitalistic system are difficult, if not impossible, to resist; 2) the persuasive power of Madison Avenue to sell these objects; and 3) the financial industry’s ability to offer credit. These help explain our addiction to materialism, our shallowness and our sense of being a valueless nation. It seems to me that our only real value is money and all it can buy. This is the current bind we find ourselves in.

Is There a Way Out of the Desert?

Alexis de Tocqueville noted how practical, down-to-earth, hard-working, and money-minded we were. The Declaration of Independence fostered the concepts of liberty, individualism, and egalitarianism. As a nation, we have remained fiercely puritanical and compulsive toward work and money. As individuals, we have turned into over-competitive consumers who fetishism commodities and use them to obtain status and undo equality. But to address this problem, as President Carter found out during his malaise speech, is certain political death.

We now have an overworked, overspent, debt-ridden America that is lost to its emptiness and consumer-crazed habits. Summers and Elovitz were correct in their assessment of narcissism in America. The rub is to find a way out. The answer may be in de Tocqueville’s simple comment that America is not very interested in science, the arts, or literature. As an example, Europeans regularly have poetry festivals in all their major cities. When was the last time you went to a poetry festival in America? Americans are far more apt to read People Magazine than Clio’s Psyche; America likes baseball far more than ballet.

Yes, we are exceptional Americans, thanks to our intense work ethic, Puritan inclinations, down-to-earth pragmatism, and love of money and commerce. But this has led us to joyless narcissistic exhaustion and a profound sense of meaninglessness. No matter how many Louis Vuitton bags we buy, the emptiness and fatigue remain. Do you recall when Jesse Helms almost dismantled the National Endowment for the Arts because he took offense to Robert Mapplethorpe and Andre Serrano? There is great disdain for the arts in America, as well a great disdain for an inner life. The fine arts and literature, both of which can be curative, may be America’s last hope. There are simply not enough psychotherapists

Page 49

to treat an entire nation, so we must leave much of the work to our artists and writers.

We work too hard, we fight too much, and we love the external world too much. Our exceptionalism in these ways has exhausted and depleted us as a nation. We are depleted of health, of meaning and of savings. We need to learn how to play, how to slow down, and how to relax. It is no surprise that Starbucks, the wonderful espresso bar concept modeled after Italian culture, is so wildly popular here in the U.S. But we need more than a coffee break. We need to import the European love of beauty and the arts. We also need to import the European custom of taking seven weeks off per year. Until we do that, we will remain a superpower that needs a very long vacation—a superpower that needs to learn how to play and how to rest. We need to become a nation that has an inner life to match our outer one. It is only then that we will become exceptional. This is the domain of the arts and letters; the domain that de Tocqueville pointed out as lacking so very many years ago.

Page 50

About the author

Tom Ferraro

Tom Ferraro, PhD, is a writer and psychoanalyst whose work has been featured in The New York Times, The Wall Street Journal, and The London Times. He can be reached at .  

How to cite this article

Ferraro, T. (2011). From de Tocqueville to Baudrillard, Lasch, and Bacevich. Clio’s Psyche, 18(1), 46-50.

https://doi.org/10.70763/97af07a14cacba681feacf3012730892

PDF downloads