
Volume 21 - Number 1 - June 2014
Pages: 1 - 121
Ferraro, T. (2014). The psychology of the one percenters. Clio’s Psyche, 21(1), 106-111.
The Psychology of the One Percenters
Abstract
In this article, the author asks how a psychoanalyst might understand the American one percenters, the group named by the Occupy Wall Street movement of 2011, whom he holds responsible for three decades of lost middle-class wealth. He cites the convictions of Michael Milken, Bernie Madoff, Ken Lay, and Martha Stewart as illustrations of conduct he characterizes as deceitful and indifferent to others. He faults psychoanalysis since the 1950s for turning from conscience toward the self, citing Don Carveth, and invokes Christopher Lasch’s warning that a culture without authority figures to admire loses its moral bearing. He relays Joel Bakan’s argument in The Corporation that, because the law treats corporations as persons, they can be assessed against a World Health Organization personality checklist and match a clinical profile, and cites George Tyler on deregulation and wage stagnation since the Reagan years. Drawing on Stanley Milgram’s obedience experiments (1963) and Philip Zimbardo’s Stanford prison experiment (1971), he contends that environment overrides personal ethics, so that mostly ethical executives and employees comply with a profit mandate and disown responsibility, a pattern he compares to Nazi bureaucrats. He concludes that the problem lies in the corporation rather than the individual psychology of the one percenters, criticizes government and Reaganomics, suggests school shootings may reflect national anger, calls for a political leader willing to confront lobbyists, and looks to the media, despite its corporate ownership, to act as the culture’s conscience.
American elite, American middle class, Occupy Wall Street (OWS) Movement, one percenters, Phillip Zimbardo, psychoanalysis, psychohistory, psychology, Stanley Milgram, wealth appropriation
The “one percenters”—a term brought to public attention by the Occupy Wall Street Movement that began in the fall of 2011 is the group that has siphoned the wealth from the American middle class over the last 30 years. It includes the legacy wealth holders, entrepreneurs, millionaire athletes, Hollywood stars, hedge fund managers, and senior firm officials connected to American enterprise. What kind of diagnosis would a psychoanalyst give these individuals?
A Closer Look at a Sociopath
In the words of Gordon Gecko, the anti-hero of the film Wall Street (1987), “Greed, for lack of a better word, is good.” His character was modeled after Michael Milken, the Junk Bond King who was convicted of racketeering and fraud and sentenced to 10 years in prison. There are many like Milken: Bernie Madoff, Ken Lay, and Martha Stewart were also convicted of criminal actions and sentenced to serve time. All appeared to show a lack of concern for others, deceitfulness, unquenchable greed, a lack of guilt, and a failure to conform to the social norms of the law. These are
Page 106
all symptoms of the sociopath. Why has the emergence of the sociopath become so commonplace in big business? So commonplace that it caused a global meltdown we have yet to recover from?
Some blame must be placed on the field of psychoanalysis itself, which turned away from a focus on conscience and morality beginning in the 1950s and instead focused on issues of the self and how to help patients obtain greater satisfactions in life. Don Carveth’s A Still Small Voice: Psychoanalytic Reflections on Guilt and Conscience (2013) clearly describes this trend.
Back in 1979, Christopher Lasch, author of The Culture of Narcissism, who President Jimmy Carter consulted about societal malaise, observed that the media’s constant devaluation of all forms of authority would lead to dire consequences. He predicted that when a culture no longer had ego ideals to look up to for guidance, it would begin to lose moral bearing. This has occurred, yet it takes a certain kind of environment to draw out and give license to the traits of a sociopath—traits found in the psychology of the corporation.
The Corporation
The modern corporation is a system that has been around for only 150 years, and it has grown to become the most dominant institution of modern times, even exceeding the reach and power of governments. In 2003, Joel Bakan, law professor at the University of British Columbia, wrote The Corporation that traced the history of the corporation. He explains that the corporation was originally created to have limited scope and designed to insure the public good; so far, no harm no foul.
However, the 14th Amendment designed to guarantee equal rights for all—was transformed by the successful assertion of highly-paid lawyers that the corporation was also a legal entity, with all the rights and privileges of a person. This led to greater protection for the corporation under the law and also led to the ability of each corporate owner to be protected against serious legal action. The goal of any corporation and its legal mandate is to make as much profit as possible for the stockholders. So from an entity that was first established to have limited power and to serve
Page 107
the public good it slowly became an institution that had unlimited power and was designed to serve its owners only. The corporation has become a hungry machine that does not feel, does not have compassion, and exists only to make money.
Bakan does something very creative. He argues that if the corporation is now considered a legal person under the law, then exactly what might this person’s diagnosis be if he were to be psychoanalyzed? He lists the major traits that one sees in most corporations, and he shows ample evidence to support each description:
- A lack of concern for the feelings of others the bottom line is profit, not people
- An incapacity to maintain enduring relationships downsizing is commonplace
- Reckless disregard for the safety of others in the pursuit of profits
- Deceitfulness, repeated lying, and conning others for profit Chase Bank and the mortgage bundling debacle
- An incapacity to express guilt Chase has set aside a vast sum to defend its innocence
- A failure to conform to lawful behavior see the Bernie Madoff case
He concludes that according to the Personality Diagnosis Checklist of the World Health Organization, corporations can be diagnosed as “sociopaths.”
As George Tyler explains in What Went Wrong: How the 1% Hijacked the American Middle Class and What Other Countries Got Right (2013), these trends became malignant in the Reagan era, which emphasized deregulation and a laissez-faire attitude toward big business. The 150 million employed corporate workers in America have experienced stagnation since 1985. The “trickledown effect” of Reaganomics seems to have been defying gravity for the last 30 years, and the money keeps trickling upward to the one percenters instead.
The Milgram and Zimbardo Experiments
The majority of CEOs and heads of global companies are educated and ethical men with good consciences, not psychopaths.
Page 108
Yet the trend toward exploitation, greed, and lack of fairness continue in unabated fashion, as President Barack Obama acknowledged on television in September 2013. So why are the heads of corporations and banks allowed to continue to make such seemingly unethical, reckless, immoral, and greed-based decisions? Why do ethical leaders and the public permit the corporation to exploit their workers, the customers, and the environment?
One answer can be found in a classic psychological experiment conducted at Yale University in 1963. Stanley Milgram was a psychology professor interested in why adults are so obedient to authority figures. He set up an experiment looking at the willingness of participants to obey authority figures who instructed them to perform acts in conflict with their personal conscience, referencing the willing participants within the Nazi regime. His findings showed a shocking willingness to go to almost any length on the command of the authority. His electric shock experiments found that ordinary people, without any particular hostility, can easily become agents in a terribly destructive process and would shock su jects who would writhe and scream in pain.
Along the same lines, Phillip Zimbardo, a psychology professor at Stanford University, conducted the so-called Stanford prison experiments funded by the State Department in 1971. This experiment discovered that when subjects were placed in an environment that licensed cruelty and sadism, most were more than willing to carry out acts of extreme cruelty against others. The experiment became so violent that it had to be stopped within six days.
Both experiments support the idea that environmental demands override personality traits or personal ethics. This is what happens in most corporations. When placed in an environment that demands profit without regard to human compassion, many bow their heads, turn a blind eye, and do their job.
Conclusions and Solutions: What the Media Can Do
America is now a nation of people that are angry, overworked, depleted, depressed, and disgusted with both large corporations and a government that failed to protect them from this. The Milgram and Zimbardo experiments illustrate that the corporate
Page 109
worker will comply with the authoritative mandate of the corporation and thereby disown any personal responsibility, like the Nazi bureaucrats who were complicit in the extermination of six million Jews during the Holocaust.
The real issue here is not the psychology of the one percenters. They simply have adapted to the psychology of the corporation. However, as Bakan so brilliantly showed, the personality of the corporation is sociopathic. The corporation is a hungry, ruthless, amoral money-making machine that does not feel your pain.
What will be needed is a leader in government who is able and willing to address this issue, facing up to the vast array of Washington lobbyists that the pharmaceutical, insurance industry, oil and gas, securities, and so many other industries spend billions on to force governmental cooperation. Currently in 2014, there are fewer jobs for lower wages. It is hard to argue that we are still the land of opportunity. President Obama even said in September 2013 that 95% of all income growth since 2009 has gone to the top 1%. Widening income disparity and the shrinking middle class can become a potential threat to our democracy. The government has failed in its responsibility to protect the public good.
Three decades of Reaganomics has darkened the American Dream for most of us. These patently unfair conditions have created a growing rupture in the social pact that many Americans feel has bound them to the nation. Occupy Wall Street was a small whimper that seems to have vanished, but discontent remains. An argument can be made that the recent escalation of school shootings may be a reflection of this; those who are the weakest and most vulnerable in the society contain the deepest anger of the nation and express it for the rest. The one percenters are the new winners in this game and the remaining 150 million workers are the losers.
The only system large enough and powerful enough to address this problem is the media itself, which has a long history of serving as the conscience of a culture. The growth of investigative journalism was responsible for the overthrow of the Nixon administration. The media has a responsibility in all of this, and the fact that the media is owned by corporate power and is beholden to corporate advertisers makes this extremely problematic.
Page 110
Alexis de Tocqueville wrote that the American character was overly concerned with commercial interest, work, and survival, and not interested enough in the arts or literature. I think he was correct in this, and it leads to our obsession with money and consumerism. The corporate monster is a powerful greed machine, and we the people are all suffering because of this. The monster is slowly destroying the American dream, and no one seems to be able to do much about it.
Page 111
How to cite this article
Ferraro, T. (2014). The psychology of the one percenters. Clio’s Psyche, 21(1), 106-111.



