
Volume 21 - Number 4 - March 2015
Pages: 363 - 482
Ferraro, T. (2015). The psychoanalytic significance of zombies. Clio’s Psyche, 21(4), 466-469.
The Psychoanalytic Significance of Zombies
Abstract
This article applies psychoanalytic film theory to the recent cycle of American zombie films, principally World War Z (2013) and I Am Legend (2007), with reference to the television series The Walking Dead. Drawing on approaches collected in Glen Gabbard’s Psychoanalysis and Film, which treat film as cultural mythology, as an expression of developmental crisis, and as a collective dream screen, the author also draws on Klein, Kernberg, and Kohut on narcissistic disorders, John Berger’s Ways of Seeing, and Christopher Lasch’s The Culture of Narcissism. The author rejects Steven Schlozman’s neurological account of zombies in Zombie Autopsies and proposes instead that zombies are projections of the repressed emotional state of middle-class America in 2014. The author reads their hunger, rage, envy, and deadness as corresponding to the psychology of narcissistic disorder and as symbols of despair over consumerism, competition, and the loss of communal life. Joel Bakan’s critique of the corporation and Michael Vlahos’s view that the films orient audiences toward a new civilization are cited in support. The author concludes that the films give voice to a denied hopelessness, that their closing images of small, simple communities offer an ascetic, communal life as a remedy, and that they warn against the present culture. The author is sharply critical of consumer capitalism and maintains that the corporation is prevailing over this message.
action film, digital generation, primitive oral rage, psychoanalysis, psychohistory, World War Z, Zombies
One of the more unsettling scenes in the action film World War Z (2013) took place in the holy city of Jerusalem. There is an 80 foot concrete wall protecting a small section of the ancient city and those within this area are still untouched by a zombie plague which has infected the world. Outside the wall, thousands of zombies are observed aimlessly wandering about. Within the safe zone is Gerry Lane (played by Brad Pitt) who is a U.N. investigator assigned to find possible clues to the reason for the zombie outbreak. As Gerry talks to the Israeli Director of Mossad, the camera pans down to the plaza below them which shows a lively song and dance celebration by those who are still healthy and safe. The sound of the jubilation rouses the zombies outside the walls who then become enraged and begin to throw themselves against the wall, creating a mountain of bodies that allow them to scale the wall and quickly overrun Jerusalem. This disturbing scene of violence and unstoppable cannibalism has hidden beneath it themes of primitive oral rage, hunger, and envy within those who are now half dead.
American film and television have become obsessed with apocalyptic zombie films. World War Z, which grossed $540 million worldwide, is the latest in a long series of zombie films which include blockbusters like I Am Legend (2007) starring Will Smith and 28 Days Later (2003) directed by Oscar winning filmmaker Danny Boyle. There is also now a popular American television series called The Walking Dead (2010-) which is based off of a popular comic book series of the same name. There have been 373 zombie films made since 1960. In 1983, when Michael Jackson portrayed one of the walking dead in his video “Thriller” it became the most popular music video of all time. There is a large amount of unconscious symbolism projected into these over determined zom-
Page 466
bie images.
Harvard Medical School psychiatrist Steven Schlozman describes zombies in Zombie Autopsies (2011) as displaying primitive neurological function with difficulty controlling the base emotions of hunger and rage. This book, which is now being turned into a major film, misses the point entirely. The character traits of zombies which include somnolence, rage, and oral greed are better discussed for what they really are, psychological projections of modern America’s unconscious emotional state.
These films express the disowned and repressed state of middle class America in 2014. The middle class sense of despair, inability to “get ahead,” and profound disgust and disappointment in the consumeristic rat race is killing them. Living in a post capitalist society has produced an overly competitive America with no real communal life to counter-balance this. The result is a simmering, yet denied, sense of rage and despair. The great appeal of the zombie genre is that it gives voice to this despair and deadness.
Psychoanalytic Film Theory
Glen O. Gabbard edited Psychoanalysis and Film (2001) which provides seven psychoanalytic approaches to film analysis. One theory is based upon Ray (1985) who says that films tap into underlying cultural mythology. Hollywood producers unwittingly served as cultural anthropologists. Their films, especially those that were successful at the box office, tapped into the commonly held unconscious wishes and fears in the mass audience. In pleasing the audience, filmmakers also articulate the cultural mythology of the era, specifically Levi-Strauss’s idea in The Raw and the Crooked: Introduction to a Science of Mythology (1975) that myths are transformations of fundamental conflicts or contradictions that in reality cannot be resolved (Gabbard, 2001, 7).
Some psychoanalytic film theorists, including Slavoj Zizek, suggest that films portray universal developmental crises. Zombies are pre-oedipal in nature, showing no interest in sex and are instead are filled with more developmentally primitive oral hunger and hatred. Other psychoanalytic film critics have developed theories around the idea of film as a collective dream screen which uses standard dream processes including condensation, displacement,
Page 467
and symbolization. I suggest that zombies symbolize the death of the modern human spirit, our feelings of intense greed and murderous envy. Other popular big budget films have reinforced these emotions. Phrases like “greed is good” in the film Wall Street (1987) and “show me the money” from the film Jerry Maguire (1996) are now cultural catch phrases.
The greed and inhumanity of zombies are also apt symbols of profiteering and the sociopathic nature of the corporation. Joel Bakan feels that the greedy sociopathy of the corporation is slowly destroying America and the American Dream (The Corporation, 2005). Zombies may be the perfect metaphor for the rat race in extremis, a terrifying visual image of a mad consumer-driven culture whose hunger is never satisfied. Dream images are typically brief, meager, and laconic but film images are worked on through secondary process thinking by the filmmaker and allowed to express the deeply felt terror that lies within.
The emotional states of zombies as greedy, hungry, angry, and dead describe the character of the pathological narcissist. Klein, Kernberg, and Kohut are leading psychoanalytic theorists who have treated and theorized about the rise of narcissistic disorders. These patients have an insatiable hunger for admiration, are prone to feelings of envy and hatred, tend to swallow interpretations rather than discuss them, and will often complain of feeling empty, depressed, or even dead.
In 1973 John Berger wrote Ways of Seeing where he predicted that the over exposure to multiple publicity images would inevitably create an extreme sense of envy, self-despair, and the death of the self as the culture became trained to see what they did not have and enter a state of self-loathing while they made exhausting and futile efforts to purchase “these images of happiness.”
In the Culture of Narcissism (1979), Christopher Lasch predicted that primitive oral rage would befall America. He felt that the aggressive self-destructive part of the superego was no longer being modified through experience with real ego ideals. The media’s slow dismantling of all forms of authority precluded our chance to identify with mature authority figures which could soften early fantasies of parents as devouring monsters. According to
Page 468
Lasch, “If that experience is lacking – as it so often is in a society that radically devalued all forms of authority – the sadistic superego can be expected to develop at the expense of the ego ideal, the destructive superego at the expense of the severe but solicitous inner voice we call conscience” (12).
Michael Vlahos, professor in the Strategy and Policy Department at the U.S. Naval College and author of Counterterrorism, American Exceptionalism, and Retributive Justice (2013), feels that zombie films have become popular because we need to collectively orient ourselves toward a new future civilization. These films express a coming apocalyptic crisis and also point to ways in which the culture must change in order to survive.
Conclusions
All these psychoanalysts and social theorists seem to suggest that culture in its present condition no longer provides a good enough holding environment which has resulted in a large-scale regression to more borderline and primitive states of psychological functioning. Zombies have appeal to the audience because they express this denied state of hopelessness and rage. Our current lifestyle is dominated by overwork, shopping, and television.
The two most successful zombie films, World War Z and I Am Legend, end in similar ways. The few lone survivors are now living in small community settings, pleasant looking towns in New England or Canada where there is a small Main Street with groups of families bonded together, evidently living a slower and simpler life style. The ascetic and communal life is offered up by the filmmaker as the antidote to the plague that has beset us.
Films express cultural myths, cultural crises, and attempt to provide solutions. Apocalyptic zombie films signal a warning to postmodern culture. They tell us that things cannot go on like this. There is too much alienation, greed, deadness, hunger, aggression, shallowness, competition, and envy. These films all attempt to break through our denial of our current state and also provide a direction toward asceticism, simplicity, restfulness, and community. However this message is so threatening to the economic system that thus far the war is being won by the corporation and the people are losing.
Page 469
How to cite this article
Ferraro, T. (2015). The psychoanalytic significance of zombies. Clio’s Psyche, 21(4), 466-469.



