
Volume 25 - Number 1 - Fall 2018
Pages: 1 - 125
SPECIAL ISSUE
Ferraro, T. (2018). They’re mad as Hell…. Clio’s Psyche, 25(1), 26-28.
They’re Mad as Hell…
Abstract
In this brief article, the author considers American women’s responses to the 2017 sexual harassment and abuse allegations against prominent men in news, entertainment, sports, and politics. He begins with the mass Women’s March held the day after the presidential inauguration and compares the public outcry to the anger expressed in the film Network. He interprets the ensuing disclosures, lawsuits, and resignations as women’s refusal to tolerate abuse any longer, and suggests that the accused men now face shame and guilt. The author then raises a deeper concern about the effects on young people. Drawing on a brief example from his work with young athletes and on a newspaper report that many teenage girls are pressured for explicit photographs, he contends that sexually abusive public figures have become damaging role models. He suggests that such leaders have been immune to the Zimbardo effect, in which the demand characteristics of one’s immediate environment shape behavior and sense of propriety. He maintains that the violation of human decency provokes social outrage and grassroots movements, and he likens this to the popular rage aroused by aristocratic arrogance in the French Revolution.
cultural leaders, human decency, #MeToo movement, psychohistory, role models, sexual abuse, sexual humiliation, social outrage, Women’s March on Washington, women’s movement
On January 20, 2017, Donald Trump was inaugurated as the 45th president of the United States. The following day over 500,000 women marched through the streets of Washington, DC, chanting “Hey, hey, ho, ho, Donald Trump has got to go!” There were similar marches in 161 cities throughout the world. One of the co-founders of the Women’s March on Washington, Evvie Harmon, stated, “Women of the world were sitting on a powder keg and Donald Trump just lit the match.” Apparently, the marchers’ outrage and solidarity strengthened many women, because over the next several months we learned, in a series of head-spinning headlines, of sexual abuse allegations levied against some of the nation’s leading television anchors, entertainment moguls, and politicians, which led to lawsuits and to resignations by major political and media figures.
I was reminded of the award-winning 1976 film Network where TV anchorman Howard Beale encouraged his listeners to lean out their windows and shout, “I’m as mad as hell, and I’m not going to take this anymore.” All these sexually abused and humiliated women were sick and tired of the abuse and blew the whistle
Page 26
loudly and clearly. Goodbye, Bill O’Reilly; so long, Matt Lauer; see you later, Charlie Rose! Let the cleansing begin. Who could have imagined that fame and fortune would create such arrogance, entitlement, and abuse of power? But now the victims were speaking out. When you see 500,000 people marching in the streets of the nation’s capital, you know there is social outrage.
In 2017, we witnessed stunning sexual abuse allegations levied against Roger Ailes, Bill Cosby, Dustin Hoffman, Louis CK, Kevin Spacey, and Harvey Weinstein, all major players in the news and entertainment industries. In politics, allegations were made against President Donald Trump, Senator Al Franken, Congressman John Conyers, and candidate Roy Moore. In sports, Dr. Larry Nassar was not only accused but tried and convicted. The abused women can feel vindicated, while the men can begin the gruesome process of experiencing shame and guilt as they wear the scarlet letter A. But in this case the letter stands for Abuser and the men are wearing it, not a woman.
What is a deeper concern is exactly what impact all this news of sexual abuse will have on the youth of the nation. I work primarily with professional athletes or those who are headed there. One of my patients is a young, elite swimmer, who has been depressed for the last few months. She divulged that the boys in her neighborhood have taken to whispering salacious taunts toward her on a daily basis. All sorts of inappropriate sexual innuendo have been coming her way, and, naturally, she is anxious and flooded with confusion as to what to do.
On January 2, 2018, I read a report in the New York Times by Dr. Lisa Damour, entitled “Teenagers: Stop Asking for Nude Photos.” Research has shown that about two out of three teenage girls have been asked for explicit photos and have been threatened with slander or violence if they failed to comply.
Long gone are the days when the nation could hope that our cultural leaders would be influenced by the moral tone and gravity of their positions and offices. Instead, they have been somehow immune to the Zimbardo effect, where the demand characteristics of one’s immediate environment influence one’s behavior and sense of propriety. Indeed, what role models our sexually abusive leaders, including a “pussy-grabbing” president, have become for teenage boys! One may agree with former professional basketballer Charles Barkley that he is not a role model, but there must be
Page 27
some who take on that responsibility. (Even psychoanalysis has neglected much discussion about conscience and guilt, as Donald Carveth reminds us.)
Despite all the abuse, there remains such a thing as human decency, and decency is the thing that continues to be outraged when we hear constant news about abuse of power by cultural leaders. As long as that continues, and human decency is ignored and disgraced, there will also be human outrage and grassroots revolutions. Human outrage is the reason women marched through the streets, and human outrage is the reason they spoke out against sexual abuse. Political movements are a cry for justice. This is exactly what happened in the late 1700s during the French Revolution. Aristocratic arrogance elicited so much rage that people took to the streets.
Page 28
How to cite this article
Ferraro, T. (2018). They’re mad as Hell…. Clio’s Psyche, 25(1), 26-28.



