Volume 26 - Number 3 - Spring 2020
Pages: 265 - 387

COMICS IN AMERICAN FANTASY (PRIMARILY STUDENT AND ALUMNI ARTICLES)

Ferraro, T. (2020). Split-personalities, narcissism, grandiosity, and loneliness in our comic heroes and culture. Clio’s Psyche, 26(3), 345-348.

https://doi.org/10.70763/e73fecc08ee9b0e1a876614ec3178bac

Split-Personalities, Narcissism, Grandiosity, and Loneliness in Our Comic Heroes and Culture

article

Abstract

In this article, the author analyzes Superman, Batman, Spider-Man, and Iron Man as they appear in comics and major film franchises, treating them as cultural symbols whose hidden meanings call for interpretation. He identifies three shared characteristics. The first is a split personality, in which an invulnerable, powerful public figure coexists with a meek, timid, or ashamed everyday identity. The second is grandiosity, expressed in extraordinary powers and equipment. The third is loneliness, as heroic activity repeatedly undermines intimate relationships. Drawing on psychoanalytic writing on narcissism, particularly that of Heinz Kohut and Jeffrey Seinfeld, he compares the superhero to the narcissistic character, whose grandiose presentation functions like armor against inner shame and whose anti-dependent stance avoids intimacy. He argues that the prominence of superheroes reflects a broader epidemic of narcissism in America, which he attributes in part to advertising imagery that cultivates shame and a hunger for grandiosity. He describes these as junk food times, in which glossy fantasy figures entertain and pacify rather than address cultural anguish. He also discusses the film Birdman (2014), whose ambiguous ending, in his view, leaves its treatment of narcissistic grandiosity, power, and fame unresolved.

Keywords:

American fantasy, Batman, comic books, grandiosity, Iron Man, loneliness, narcissism, psychoanalysis, psychohistory, Spider-Man, split-personality, Superman, symbols

Certain cultural elements take on an iconic status and symbolize key features of our collective unconscious. In his essay on the Eiffel Tower, Roland Barthes describes the iconic Parisian tower as transcending rational function and serving instead as a symbol of the French aesthetic. The Trumpian wall goes far beyond its ra-

Page 345

tional security role of keeping out foreigners and has become a symbolic expression of America’s fear of losing its core identity. When a thing is elevated into a symbol, it contains a hidden meaning.

Every culture produces symbols that contain meanings in need of solving and comics are no exception. The comic book industry has produced a variety of mythic superheroes in the form of Superman, Batman, Spider-Man, and Iron Man. These superheroes are considered part of pop culture and their presence is now seen in major film franchises. A look at the character traits of the superheroes mentioned above reveals that they share three similar characteristics.

One is a split personality. These superheroes all present a dual personality with one side of them being invulnerable, powerful, handsome, and courageous. The other side tends to be meek, timid, and shameful. Superman could “move faster than a speeding bullet,” but Clark Kent wore glasses and was a mild-mannered reporter. Spider-Man swung through the air with those spider webs, but Peter Parker was shy and unassuming. Batman was powerful, brave, and had a big chest, but Bruce Wayne was merely a lonely businessman. Iron Man flew far and wide, but Tony Stark had a drinking problem. All presented as brave on the outside but were shameful and weak within.

Two is grandiosity. All the superheroes have superpowers that make them virtually impossible to defeat, although at times they show weakness. Superman can leap tall buildings in a single bound. Batman has a Batmobile, a bat outfit with wings, a batplane, and a variety of weapons that would make James Bond green with envy. Iron Man has a red and gold metal suit that allows him to fly from here to the Middle East without any stopovers. Spider-Man can swing through New York with the help of his spider webs and walk on ceilings, much like a real spider.

Three is loneliness. All of these superheroes have an interest in intimate female attachments and have had multiple romantic relationships, but the heroics often kills the relationship, either figuratively, literally, or both. There can be no doubt that Clark Kent liked Lois Lane, but she is mostly remembered as not reciprocating. Batman, Iron Man, and Spider-Man were inveterate bachelors and seemed to be caught up in their careers and heroic activities to such an extent that they had little energy left for love or intimacy. Bat-

Page 346

man does have the habit of falling for villains, meaning he will be unable to have a real relationship with them. After seeing the Spider-Man (2002) film and how Peter Parker failed to show more interest in Mary Jane is mindboggling to me, but that’s what happened. Let us say these heroes all have what psychoanalysts Heinz Kohut and Jeffrey Seinfeld call anti-dependent character traits.

I’ve just described the narcissistic character. Sigmund Freud was first to talk about this character type, but many others have focused on them as well including Kohut, Otto Kernberg, James Masterson, Christopher Lasch, and Seinfeld. The narcissistic character develops a grandiose all-powerful presentation, almost like wearing a suit of armor, but has shame within. Just like kryptonite for Superman, rejection or public humiliation is the Achilles’ heel of the narcissist, which can penetrate his character armor that he defends against at all times. Shame is the effect that lies within. The narcissist, like the superhero, has an anti-dependent personality, avoiding intimacy at all costs since it will reveal underlying shame and may produce a vulnerability.

We are in the midst of an epidemic of narcissism. Popular writers like Tom Wolfe, magazines like Time, social critics like Lasch, as well as analysts like Kohut and Seinfeld, have all demonstrated that this pattern has emerged and predominates psychoanalytic thinking. The emergence of narcissism derives partly from the power of Madison Avenue advertising. Edward Bernays, Freud’s nephew, was the man whose books and theories guided Madison Avenue ads from the outset. John Berger’s work, including Ways of Seeing (1972), described the mesmerizing power of the advertising image and how repeated exposure to these perfect images serves to create shame and hunger in our society, which are two key character traits of the narcissist.

It is easy to understand why the cult of superheroes has emerged. These comic and film characters describe the current dilemma that Americans now face. Thanks to the power of Madison Avenue we have all been thrown into this narcissistic zeitgeist. The question is whether there are any real efforts to address this problem seriously. It’s fun to watch Iron Man fly around and kiss Pepper Potts but no one would say that watching this is the way to resolve our cultural anguish.

One film that dealt with the superhero problem was Birdman (2014), which won an Oscar for its director, Alejandro Iñár-

Page 347

ritu. This film was about an actor who gained fame by starring in a series of superhero roles, which left him feeling empty and alone. However, the ending of this film was sufficiently ambiguous to suggest that Iñárritu is just as confused about narcissistic grandiosity, power, and fame as the rest of us.

We live in junk food times. Ask any music critic to assess the music of a Taylor Swift or Bruno Mars and they will immediately tell you that they are a musical version of junk food. Jeff Koon’s stainless steel sculptures of the Hulk or Popeye are junk food for the eyes and comic book figures are junk food for the brain. They are fun to watch but what human value do they serve? Ken Fuchsman is writing a book on what it means to be human, and I doubt that he will spend much time talking about Superman as a role model.

Of course, we need fun and entertainment from time to time, but culture seems caught in a feedback loop of banal narcissistic images. These glossy fantasy figures remind me of the drug Soma that Aldous Huxley wrote about in Brave New World (1932). These candy land images keep people happy, tranquil, and entertained. America is currently drowning in images of grandiosity. Turn on the TV and you will see super-cool Samuel Jackson hawking a Capital One credit card. Switch the channel and you will see an even cooler Matthew McConaughey selling you a new Lincoln MKZ. Turn to the next channel and try to resist Keira Knightley as she soft sells you some Chanel perfume. All this stuff leads us to feel inadequate, low, ugly, and ordinary.

In our current psychological zeitgeist, we are bombarded with images that simultaneously shame us and instill a desire for grandiosity. We are being trained into becoming both Peter Parker and Spider-Man at the same time. Be anything but yourself because being yourself is not good enough. Just like in Birdman, the Michael Keaton character shouts as he discovers his wife sleeping with someone else, “Why can’t anybody love me? What’s wrong with me? Why aren’t I good enough anyway?” Then he proceeds to shoot off his nose, which makes him famous. These are the sad, tragic, and mesmerizing times that we live in. Hey gang, let’s go to the movies!

Page 348

About the author

Tom Ferraro

Tom Ferraro, PhD, is a writer and psychoanalyst whose work has been featured in The New York Times, The Wall Street Journal, and The London Times. He can be reached at .  

How to cite this article

Ferraro, T. (2020). Split-personalities, narcissism, grandiosity, and loneliness in our comic heroes and culture. Clio’s Psyche, 26(3), 345-348.

https://doi.org/10.70763/e73fecc08ee9b0e1a876614ec3178bac

PDF downloads