
Volume 30 - Number 2 - Winter 2024
Pages: 139 - 267
Ferraro, T. (2024). Fear and loathing in the new America. Clio’s Psyche, 30(2), 203-208.
Fear and Loathing in the New America
Abstract
This article explores the causes of what it calls the growing fear and loathing in America, which it describes as a climate of contentiousness, paranoia, alienation, and hypervigilance. The author proposes two essential causes, rather than attributing the climate mainly to the COVID-19 pandemic or computer technology. Drawing on Slavoj Žižek’s view that the world needs two superpowers to maintain a balance of power, the author argues that America’s rise to unrivaled dominance and the collapse of communist Russia deprived the nation of an externalized enemy, a “bad object” in psychoanalytic terms, onto which to project its aggression. The author contends that this aggression was introjected and turned inward, citing 1990s campaigns against artists and the arts, a red-versus-blue polarization paralleled in the media, and a rise in mass shootings and domestic terrorism, which the author interprets as the return of the repressed. The second cause is multiculturalism and diversity. The author maintains that an unconscious dismantling of family, community, religious, and political institutions left an ideological vacuum, so that a formerly cohesive American identity fragmented into competing subgroups. The author concludes that fear is best addressed through understanding these dynamics and through self-knowledge rather than physical barriers, and expresses continued faith in the enduring American Dream.
American identity, anxiety, communist Russia, dehumanizing impact, diversity in America, fall of communism, global balance of power, loathing, loss of the “bad object” aggression, multiculturalism, paranoia, psychoanalysis, psychology, world dominance
This Call for Papers on the psychology of fear is perfectly attuned to the current American zeitgeist. Over the past decade, I’ve noticed the rise of fear and loathing. The new American is contentious, hyper-competitive, paranoid, alienated, and hyper-vigilant. It would be far too easy to blame all this on the COVID-19 pandemic or the dehumanizing impact of the computer age (although undoubtedly they are factors). I suggest that there are two essential causes of our fear and loathing.
Losing the Global Balance of Power
I think a large part of America’s growing sense of fear and anger, especially since the 1990s, relates to what Slavoj Žižek (2010) predicted shortly after the fall of the Berlin Wall and Communist Russia. The famous Slovenian philosopher and social critic said that the world needs two super powers, not one, to provide a point/counter-point balance of power. He suggested that the loss of the global balance of power has had numerous and quite sinister consequences.
America slowly ascended to world power during the first half of the 20th century, and after World War II, we were unequaled in military and economic strength (except for the Soviet Union). This marked the beginning of the Cold War, which pitted capitalism against communism, and by 1990, the communist ideology was defeated, the Berlin Wall crumbled, and the Soviet Union economy was in ruins. Without another super power to project our aggression onto, we had lost the externalized enemy (“bad object” in psychoanalytic terms), and America was faced with the question of where to displace its destrudo or death wish. We may find an answer to how America managed this problem by observing what occurred in the 1990s shortly after the fall of Communist Russia. America was left without an enemy, forcing it to introject its aggression and seek out new targets within its own borders. This introjection produced three immediate outcomes over the next decade.
First was the censorship movement of the 1990s. But this was not like the McCarthy-era paranoia over communism. In the 1990s, American conservative leaders, led by Republican Senator Jesse Helms of North Carolina, engaged in attacking what they called “Pornography in the Arts,” which threatened the existence of the Endowment for the Arts. Robert Mapplethorpe and his homoe-
Page 204
rotic photographs were targeted, as were Andre Serrano’s “Piss Christ,” Karen Findley’s performance art, and musicians Ice-T, Snoop Dogg, and Tupac Shakur for inflaming Black rage. The discourse about the arts in the 90s was Orwellian and began to insinuate that art was evil and dangerous.
So, the first outcome was the censorship movement in the 90s produced by America’s need to find a new target to hate and fear by choosing artists, Blacks, and feminists.
The second occurrence that emerged in the 90s as America ascended into unrivaled world dominance was how we seemed to fracture into red versus blue states. This internal splitting may have happened since we no longer had an external target to project our fears onto. This red versus blue state split gained traction and was paralleled by the media splitting into liberal (CNN, MSNBC) versus conservative (FOX) channels. The new war was with ourselves. This process became so extreme that during the Trump impeachment hearings, it was as if the two sides of Congress were actually living in different universes and speaking different languages.
The third and perhaps most alarming trend that gained strength in America after the fall of Communist Russia was the emergence of mass shootings, school shootings, and domestic terrorism in America. In 1995, Timothy McVeigh killed 168 in the Oklahoma City bombing. In 1999, Harris and Klebold killed 13 at Columbine High School, and in 2012, Adam Lanza killed 26 children at Sandy Hook Elementary School in Connecticut. These were expressions of murderous paranoid madness and the return of the repressed in America.
Multiculturalism and Diversity
The second major cause of the growing fear in America relates to multiculturalism and diversity. This was not always the case. Through the first 75 years of the 20th century, American identity was largely intact and supported by our major religious, political, communal, educational, and family institutions. However, there was a systematic, subtle (albeit unconscious) process of dismantling these institutions. In the media and entertainment industry, we saw how the dismantling of the presidency destroyed Nixon. The film and TV industries made a mockery of fathers. All in the Family (1971-1979) was not My Three Sons (1960-1972). Community was extinguished due to the power and magnetic pull
Page 205
of television and now social media. Teachers were made into fools due to the effectiveness of great films like Ferris Bueller’s Day Off (1986). Religious institutions were permanently damaged due to large-scale sex abuse allegations. All this left the American identity in a state of confusion and crisis. With the erosion of the patriarchal power structures of family, community, church, and politics, America experienced an ideological vacuum it has yet to recover from. Our national identity evaporated and crystallized into numerous internal groups. We now live in this leaderless void with many subgroups vying for power. Welcome to the world of diversity.
It is no wonder that there is a Call for Papers on fear in America. We are afraid of our neighbors, who have become veritable strangers to us, we are afraid of planes taken over by terrorists, and we are afraid of psychotic citizens who are ready to explode in rage with the help of guns or bombs. These are times of fearful confusion in America. We live in an extremely prosperous nation that is unequaled in power, might, and creativity. But at the same time, we are on edge. Educational institutes are hyper-vigilant and will suspend children if they look at gun web pages for too long. If your front doorbell rings, it is a cause for alarm rather than joy. If you walk down the street, you have a feeling of unease. Gated communities are growing in number.
The traumas we hear of on the news build up and make our fears worse. It was no surprise to me that the government decided it was a good idea to legalize marijuana. It’s a last-ditch effort to soothe the savage beast that is the American character. But as any psychoanalyst knows, pot breeds more paranoia, not less.
The American identity has been destabilized. As the dominant world power with capitalism as an unrivaled economic ideology, our status in the world is clear. But our status among our own neighbors is far from that. Are we ahead of our neighbor or behind him? Does it matter? Should I be proud of who I am or ashamed? Should I hate my neighbor or love him?
The Cure
I think the remedy for our fears is to understand the dynamics that drive them. The lack of an externalized enemy has produced a manic internal hunt for the enemy. The American landscape is more diverse and multicultural than ever. Trump’s “Wall” was a response to these two dynamics, but concrete walls on the border will not be the answer to this largely psychological question.
Page 206
The greatness of the psychoanalytic message is that peace only comes through self-knowledge and self-awareness. As a nation, we have ascended to the top, but as citizens, we seem to be sinking into fear, isolation, and paranoia, strangers in a strange land. But this is still America, an exceptional place to be, and much of the world looks at us with envy.
In his 1933 Presidential Inauguration address, Franklin D. Roosevelt said “the only thing we have to fear is fear itself.” Leaders are there to reassure and remind us that fear is a concept that we need to fight off. America remains the great melting pot and the great beacon of hope. Our strength is found in our diversity, openness, energy, and courage. We are all in this together. Despite all of our fears, the American Dream seems to be inextinguishable and lives on. America may not be the way it used to be, but in the American heart, there is still hope and the dream still lives on.
Artists say it best. I like the way Damien Chazelle presented this idea of the inextinguishable American dream in his Academy Award-winning film La La Land (2016). The scene was with Emma Stone, who played a down-and-out woman about to give up on her dream, but she was offered one last audition for a role in a film to be made in Paris. She was asked to tell a story, so she started to talk about her aunt who lived in Paris. But she transformed the story into a song called “The Fools Who Dream” with an incredibly poignant, repeating refrain:
Here’s to the ones who dream,
Foolish as they may seem.
Here’s to the hearts that break,
Here’s to the mess they make. (Chazelle, 2016)
So it is in America, a nation filled with lots of lonely dreamers who just keep on dreaming despite all the mess, fear, and confusion surrounding them.
Page 207
References
- Chazelle, Damien (Director). (2016). La La Land [Film]. Summit Entertainment.
- Žižek, Slavoj (2010). Living in the end times. Verso.
How to cite this article
Ferraro, T. (2024). Fear and loathing in the new America. Clio’s Psyche, 30(2), 203-208.



