
Volume 21 - Number 4 - March 2015
Pages: 363 - 482
SPECIAL ISSUE
Fishkin, R. E. (2015). Group process in online discussion groups. Clio’s Psyche, 21(4), 405-409.
Group Process in Online Discussion Groups
Abstract
In this article, the author recounts personal experience with three e-mail listserv discussion groups: the Open Line and the Members List of the American Psychoanalytic Association (APsaA), both limited to psychoanalysts, and the Clio’s Psyche Listserv, which includes historians and other professionals. The author characterizes listservs as stimulating and democratizing but prone to conflict that can deepen organizational divisions, lead participants to take sides, lurk, resign, or be pushed out. The account is limited to how some members come to recognize that discussion has gone wrong and what efforts follow. On the APsaA lists, the author reports that a 2001 debate over certification, and later discussion of the organization’s history and bylaws, was followed by mass resignations from the Open Line, creation of the Members List with a weekly posting limit, and silent lurking by certification proponents. Governance disputes remain unresolved. On the Clio’s Psyche Listserv, the author describes a dispute over the Israeli/Palestinian conflict, including whether criticism of Israel reflects anti-Semitism, and characterizes it as marked by disparagement, bullying, and excessive posting. The author reports the responses: calls for guidelines, a three-posts-per-day limit, criticizing ideas rather than posters, and several resignations. The author reports that the list became more civil and asks whether such results offer hope for containing human conflict.
digital age, electronics, internet, listerv, online discussion groups, psychohistory
Participation in e-mail listserv discussion groups has become popular and absorbing, but at times it becomes a frustrating experience. Listservs have proliferated under the auspices of professional organizations and loose networks of professionals with common interests. While stimulating, educational, and democratizing, listserv discussion groups are notorious for the ease with which they can become vehicles for vitriolic conflict that could sharpen organizational schisms and create permanent enmity between participants. They may cause participants to choose sides based on various allegiances, to lurk without participating, to resign in rage or disappointment, or to expel, either directly or indirectly through mass action, participants with unpopular views or styles of participation that are unacceptable to the group, or that defy group rules created to contain conflict.
I have had experience with three listservs. Two of them have been limited to psychoanalysts and the third was a mixed group that included various professionals, including psychoanalysts, historians, and a few laymen. My experiences form the basis of this communication. Many fascinating aspects of listserv interactions, as well as a review of the expanding literature on this topic, could be explored but are beyond the scope of this brief report. I will limit my comments to the awareness (or its lack of) on the part of some of the group members that something has gone awry in the discussion process, and on the efforts that arise to fix the problem.
The Open Line and the Members Lists are two listservs. They are open to active members of the American Psychoanalytic Association (APsaA) and have become forces for democratization and the dissemination of essential knowledge about the history of the organization’s political past. In 2001 The Open Line, at the instigation of Arnold Richards, became the vehicle for a “lively and spirited discussion… with many participants from the pro- and anti-certification camps weighing in. It appeared that although views differed on the validity, reliability, and relevance of the test, there
Page 405
was widespread agreement that making certification a requirement for voting for educational bylaws or for running for office was neither rational nor adaptive for the APsaA.” In 2001 and 2002, it became the locus for a series of “Civics Lessons,” authored by Paul Mosher, acquainting the membership with the history and politics of the organization and reorganizations of the APsaA, as well as basic facts about the lack of compliance of aspects of its bylaws with provisions of the New York State Not-for-Profit Corporation Law (Paul Mosher and Arnold Richards, “The History of Membership and Certification in the Apsaa: Old Demons, New Debates,” Psychoanalytic Review, 92: 865-894, 2005).
“Lively and spirited” puts a civilized face on the discussion. It was an intense renewal of an old war. Accusations of group and individual bullying, dishonesty, arrogance, and disparaging and insulting tone, were, essentially, valid. There were several consequences of the discussion. Mass resignation from the Open Line occurred so that it shrunk by about two-thirds. Some members even resigned from the Association in a “plague on both your houses” kind of despair. Another list, the Members List, was created with a two post per week limit to accommodate those who objected to the high volume of posts on the Open Line. The Members List maintains about twice the number of subscribers as the Open Line and hosts the same discussions, but at a reduced intensity. Most of the proponents of certification ceased posting but many remained on the list as silent lurkers, monitoring the conversations but not participating, so that the discussions often had the quality of a one-sided monologue.
Privately, and at meetings of the Board of Professional Standards (BOPS, a Committee of the Corporation) and its subcommittees, the lurkers demonized and distorted the messages of the opponents of certification, and labeling them, pejoratively, a political party. Periodic calls for civility have brought about increased respect for the tone of the discussions. A series of liberalizing bylaw amendments failed to gain the two-thirds necessary for passage, but did gain support from the majority of members. A major reorganization designed to concentrate control in a small cadre of career politicians was proposed by four officers, but was voted down by the members as a consequence of concerted opposition on
Page 406
the Members and Open Line listservs. A set of bylaw amendments to bring non-controversial aspects of the bylaws into compliance with the state law was passed, but major conflicts about whether the BOPS or the Executive Council (the APsaA Board of Directors) has final responsibility for education and standards remain unresolved despite an unexpectedly successful lawsuit that enjoined the BOD from making policy for matters that the bylaws assign to BOPS as “duties.”
The third online discussion group that I have had experience with is the Clio’s Psyche Listserv. I witnessed and participated in a battle on the list that had been fought, without resolution, before I joined on February 21, 2014 and since. This battle on the Israeli/Palestinian conflict was about whether or not negative public opinion of Israel was a product of worldwide anti-Semitism, and how any criticism of Israeli tactics and strategy was or was not the witting or unwitting product of that anti-Semitism. The problems with the discussion were the inability of proponents on either side to acknowledge the strong factors that motivated their opponents, the passions brought to and aroused by the discussion, the disparaging, intemperate, distorting, accusatory, and provocative tendencies of many of the participants, and the sheer volume of e-mails that crowded out other topics and made keeping up with the discussion almost impossible if one had anything else to do.
In short order, it became obvious to many of the participants that something seriously wrong had developed in the discussion process, but there seemed to be a reluctance to address it directly. This reluctance was understandable because when it was addressed, it quickly became subsumed into the polarizing defensive tendency of some to attack the writer who had called for reflection on the group process. Nevertheless, calls for lowering the temperature of the discussion increased, and soon others began to object to the intemperate and vicious bullying and scapegoating toward other participants. For example:
we need to identify the constantly carping, denying, blaming subgroup, the subgroup that blames every difficulty on the Jews posting on Clio about Jewish history, Jewish issues, and Israel, those who indulge in Jew-baiting tactics,
Page 407
perhaps out of latent, perhaps out of overt anti-Semitism. What reenactment, what repetition compulsion, what regression, is that group caught up in? It seems they might want a Judenfrei Clio, or, because they are not total bigots, perhaps they will tolerate the good Jews who agree with them.
This was followed by a call for a set of guidelines that would address the various ongoing abuses. Soon a consensus developed that disparaging and bullying was occurring. A member who denied such action was confronted by direct evidence from e-mails she had posted showing there was substance to the accusation. This member “apologized,” but clearly insincerely because shortly thereafter, in a defiant statement, she resigned.
Another member antagonized many others on the listserv by “spamming” the list with article after one-sided article from the Internet to support his position. This led to a proposal agreed to by consensus that participants would limit themselves to three postings per day, an agreement that the “spammer” could not hold to. It was even suggested that he post several links in one post, but he refused and ceased contributing, though he remained on the list as a lurker. Others, in sympathy with him, also threatened to resign but only one member followed through. These events ended the discussion of the Israeli/Palestinian conflict on the listserv. After a brief period of relative quiet, vigorous and interesting communication on the Listerv resumed, with a distinctly more civil and mutually respectful bent, and with a new readiness not to tolerate bullying and disparagement.
What kinds of guidelines were proposed on the listserv to deal with these excesses? In addition to the three post per day limit, discussions included the replacement of ad-hominem attacks by a practice of criticizing the idea, not the poster, and the self-screening of posts prior to sending them in order to reduce the expression of anger, contempt, combativeness, condescension, shaming, scolding, psychopathologizing, propagandizing, provoking of conflict between others, and needing to respond to every e-mail. We began to see examples of humor instead of anger used as a more gentle way of dealing with outrageous ideas. An idea that
Page 408
was floated, but not adopted, by the group itself was the creation of a voluntary parallel list for the posting of e-mails about other topics of interest to individual members that went beyond the mission of the main list. What are the results? Recently, on December 1, 2014 a member spontaneously wrote the following to another member:
I will say this, there has been [a] noticeable shift in the tenor and tone of the contributions to this forum of late… less tension, greater latitude for expression. You, along with others, have contributed to that. I’m pleased.
In such a very heterogeneous and random collection of individuals, could there be a better result? When calls for civility and mutual respect result in such general compliance with so few withdrawals, is there hope for the containment of human conflict?
Page 409
How to cite this article
Fishkin, R. E. (2015). Group process in online discussion groups. Clio’s Psyche, 21(4), 405-409.



