Volume 30 - Number 1 - Fall 2023
Pages: 1 - 137

PSYCHOANALYSIS/PSYCHOLOGY OF ANXIETY AND FEAR (SYMPOSIUM): PART I

Fogelman, E. (2023). Rejecting fear as a grandchild of Holocaust survivors: Volodymyr Zelensky. Clio’s Psyche, 30(1), 25-28.

https://doi.org/10.70763/20b02dc95171540bc52912baf3aa709d

Rejecting Fear as a Grandchild of Holocaust Survivors: Volodymyr

psychobiography article

Abstract

This psychobiographical article considers Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky as a grandchild of Holocaust survivors, drawing on his family history, public statements, and career path. Eva Fogelman recounts that his grandfather fought in the Red Army while other relatives, including his great-grandparents, were killed by the Einsatzgruppen. She maintains that intergenerational transmission of trauma or resilience is not a psychological disorder, but that a family’s trauma can shape descendants’ behavior, worldview, identity, and emotions. Using Judith Kestenberg’s concept of transposition, she explains that descendants of survivors may place themselves in dangerous situations requiring survival, or, when victimized, turn to behaviors such as hiding, escaping, disguising identity, or fighting. Fogelman proposes that Zelensky’s mobilization of Ukrainians against Russia reflects identification with his grandfather. She argues that this background also helps explain his invocation of the Holocaust, including his accusation that Putin is pursuing a “Final Solution” against Ukraine. She further suggests that his earlier work as an entertainer and his law degree may carry meaning related to his family history. She also describes his temperament and notes that some descendants of survivors see him as a present-day hero of resistance. She concludes that many such descendants transform their inherited legacy into life-affirming action.

Keywords:

anxiety, family dynamics, fear, “Final Solution,” grandparents, great-grandparents, Holocaust, intergenerational transmission of trauma, Judith Kestenberg, psychobiography, psychohistory, resilience, transposition, Ukraine, Volodymyr Zelensky, World War II (WWII)

Today, the most visible grandchild of Holocaust survivors is Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky. Zelensky grew up on

Page 25

family stories of courage and victimhood. His grandfather, Semyon Ivanovich Zelensky, along with Semyon’s three brothers, fought in the Red Army during World War II. Only his grandfather survived. His great-grandparents and numerous other family members were shot by the Einsatzgruppen (the German Army’s mobile squads). During an evacuation of Jews, a grandmother escaped to Kazakhstan. After liberation, she returned to Kryvyi Rih, became a teacher, and married. Two years later, she gave birth to a son, and 31 years later, on April 21, 2019, that son had a boy who, at the age of 40, became President of Ukraine.

In Zelensky’s memory, his grandfather is a hero who defended Ukraine from the Nazis. He comments on Facebook, “Thanks for the fact that inhuman ideology of Nazism is forever a thing of the past. Thanks to those who fought against Nazism – and won” (Brockell, February 25, 2022). These words were uttered before the barbarism that the Ukrainian people are now suffering. For centuries, antisemitism manifested in Ukraine and other Eastern European areas. During World War II, Ukrainians participated in the mass killings of Jews along with the German Einsatzgruppen.

The fervor and tenacity with which Zelensky has unified his Ukrainians to fight Russia are not surprising. He is identifying with his grandfather, who fought against the Germans until they were defeated. Intergenerational transmission of resilience or trauma is not a psychological disorder. This means that descendants do not suffer from a personality syndrome that causes more depression, anxiety, paranoia, or bipolar than any comparative group. However, the parents’ or grandparents’ trauma seeps into one’s psyche and influences behavior, worldview, identity, and emotions in a myriad of forms. One of its consequences is what is known in psychological parlance as transposition, a term coined by psychoanalyst Judith Kestenberg.

Transposition means that descendants of Holocaust survivors may voluntarily place themselves in a dangerous situation where they would have to survive (Kestenberg, 1989, p. 67). Or, if they find themselves in circumstances where they are victimized, they will resort to behavior that facilitates a family member’s survival, such as hiding, finding a rescuer, escaping, disguising one’s identity, or fighting. By understanding Zelensky’s Holocaust family background, we can appreciate his references to the Holocaust during this war against Russia. Zelensky is accusing President Vladimir Putin of carrying out a “Final Solution” against Ukraine.

Page 26

Zelensky is referring to the German formulation of its plan to annihilate the Jews. But, “This time it is about the Ukrainian question,” not the Jewish Question (Federman, March 20, 2022).

Another observation about Zelensky as a grandchild of Holocaust survivors is the other professions he chose before becoming President. He started his career as an actor, performer, producer of stand-up comedy, and scriptwriter. Other sons, daughters, or grandchildren of survivors also acknowledge feeling like they had to make their parents or grandparents happy by entertaining them. This role often started early on in childhood. While still performing, Zelensky earned a law degree, which also has significance related to his historically-traumatized family background.

The genocide of the Jewish people did not begin with criminals on the streets killing Jews. It was initiated by the government, which institutionalized it into law. Whether consciously or unconsciously, Zelensky armed himself to understand the workings of how to sustain a democratic society. His unrelenting fighting spirit is not just to protect Ukraine as a democratic country but to preserve democracy worldwide.

Zelensky’s temperament cannot fit into one type of personality. He portrays extraversion in his assertive, energetic, and gregarious behavior. At the same time, he has a sense of responsibility and duty, as well as an openness to experience, along with a goal-oriented and driven foresight. Above all, Zelensky is a leader who encourages working as a team. Clearly, he is an outgoing, people-oriented extrovert.

For some descendants of Holocaust survivors, Zelensky is a present-day Jewish hero, in the model of the iconic partisan of Vilna, Abba Kovner, who exhorted his fellow Jews to rebel against the Germans. Aviva Kempner, who conceived, co-wrote, and produced the 1986 film Partisans of Vilna, echoes what she hopes most of us feel: “great pride in President Zelenskyy, a fellow Jew, who has become a hero of resistance.” Kempner adds, “While Kovner had to act clandestinely, Zelensky is in our living rooms every night” (personal communication, April 2, 2022).

Russia’s invasion of Ukraine and the world’s response to the Jews and other citizens looms large in the minds of many, but especially in the minds of descendants of Holocaust survivors, many of whom had ancestors who were murdered in Ukraine. A daughter of Holocaust survivors, Jane Jelenko, makes these re-

Page 27

marks when she is honored at a fundraiser for the United States Holocaust Memorial Museum on April 27, 2022: “I can’t help but see my parent’s faces in those of the Ukrainian refugees of today.” She concludes by saying, “I learned from my father Mendel that I have a strong personal responsibility to act, not to just sit by the sidelines complaining about the ills of the world.” Descendants of Holocaust survivors, such as Jelenko, find meaning in transforming the legacy that was transmitted to them into life-affirming behavior to make a difference.

Page 28

References

  • Brockell, Gillian (February 25, 2022). Putin says he’ll ‘denazify’ Ukraine. Its Jewish president lost family in the Holocaust. The Washington Post.
  • Federman, Josef (March 20, 2022). Zelensky invokes Holocaust as he appeals to Israel for aid. PBS.
  • Kestenberg, Judith S. (1989). Transposition revisited: Clinical, therapeutic, and developmental considerations. In Paul Marcus & Alan Rosenberg (Eds.), Healing their wounds: Psychotherapy with Holocaust survivors and their families (pp. 67-82). Praeger Publishers.

About the author

Eva Fogelman

Eva Fogelman, PhD, is a social psychologist, a psychotherapist in private practice in New York, a filmmaker, and the author of the award-winning Conscience and Courage: Rescuers of Jews During the Holocaust (1995). She was Co-Founder and Co-Director of Psychotherapy with Generations of the Holocaust and Related Traumas, TIMH. She was the Founding Director of the Jewish Foundation for Christian Rescuers, ADL (originally the Jewish Foundation for the Righteous). She is currently the Co-Director of Child Development Research. She moderates the podcast The Blue Card Stories of the Holocaust: Overcoming Historical Traumas and a Zoom program, “Transforming Moments: Second Generation of Holocaust Survivors,” for the Museum of Jewish Heritage. She may be contacted at .

How to cite this article

Fogelman, E. (2023). Rejecting fear as a grandchild of Holocaust survivors: Volodymyr Zelensky. Clio’s Psyche, 30(1), 25-28.

https://doi.org/10.70763/20b02dc95171540bc52912baf3aa709d

PDF downloads