
Volume 23 - Number 3 - Spring 2017
Pages: 225 - 337
SYMPOSIUM
Fuchsman, K. (2017). What is the death instinct and does it apply to psychohistory? Clio’s Psyche, 23(3), 248-252.
What is the Death Instinct and Does It Apply to Psychohistory?
Abstract
The author emphasizes the struggle of even defining Freud’s death drive and attempts to tease out its various interpretations as an instinct. He asserts that Freud’s own confusion sheds little light on the true interpretation of the idea and further posits that it is impossible to explain death as the result of an internal motivation.
death drive (Todestrieb), death instinct, Eros, history, human destructiveness, Paul Elovitz, psychoanalysis, psychohistory, Sigmund Freud, violence
Homo sapiens are the most resourceful killers on the planet. Our ingenious innovations on how to end the lives of other animals, plants, and fellow humans have contributed to making us Earth’s dominant species. A controversial attempt to make sense of our magnificent destructiveness was made by Sigmund Freud;
Page 248
yet his notion of a death instinct is a conceptual muddle. Its lack of coherency raises questions as to whether the death instinct can help explain our violence and killing or be used sensibly within psychoanalysis, history, and psychohistory.
First, what does Freud mean by the death instinct? He writes: “that ‘the aim of all life is death’” for there is “a truth with no exception that everything living dies for internal reasons” (italics added by the author). Each “organism shall follow its own path to death,” for “the organism wishes to die only in its own fashion.” The “first instinct” is “to return to the inanimate state” (Freud, S.E., 18, 1920, 38-39).
There are a few things to note. The drive toward death here is biological. It is clearly directed inward toward the organism and not outward toward others. It presents all life as containing planned obsolescence, as life is a terminal disease. The death instinct is not just symbolic; it without exception includes actual deaths. The drive toward one’s demise may be mental in certain species, but it is not described as involving consciousness.
All organisms eventually die, but not all organisms intentionally end their own existence. The decision to commit suicide, even if impulsive, involves consciousness. Suicide is a death choice rather than a death instinct. To meet Freud’s initial criteria, a death instinct has to be both instinctual and universal, and suicide is not the only cause of death, nor does it appear to be instinctual.
This raises the thorny question of what is an instinct. Online, the Merriam-Webster definition of an instinct is “a largely inheritable and unalterable tendency of an organism to make a complex and specific response to environmental stimuli without involving reason” (Merriam-Webster, 2016, merriam-webster.com). Freud, on the other hand, views instinct as arising from “within the organism” and not from “the external world” (S.E., 14, 118). Freud also asserts that an instinct is constant, and to respond to the instinct the organism makes “an appropriate (‘adequate’) alteration of the internal source of stimulation” (S.E., 14, 119). Freud does not clearly show the various manifestations of this internal stimulus. He also adds that “from a biological point of view, an ‘instinct’ appears to us as a concept on the frontier between the mental and the somatic” (S.E., 14, 121-122). At the time of this 1915 writing, Freud viewed the mind as being composed of
Page 249
preconscious, unconscious, and conscious elements.
He does not specify which aspects of the mental apparatus are used in response to instinctual stimuli. This leaves a major gap, and Freud often recognizes this. In 1915, he says that the meaning of instinct “is still somewhat obscure”; in 1920, he writes that instincts are “the most obscure element of psychological research” (S.E., 18, 34). Even in 1924 after Freud proposes the structural model of the mind with id, ego, and superego, he again writes that the “theory of the instincts is…the least complete portion of psychoanalytic theory” (S.E., 7, 168, note 2).
Considering Freud’s failure to give an adequate description of how instincts function within the mind, the way the death instinct acts remains obscure. We are left with two views of the death instinct. On the one hand, given its admitted obscurity, there is no way to know to what degree the death instinct is conscious, subconscious, or unconscious, and whether it is part of the id, ego, or superego. On the other hand, in specific descriptions of the death instinct, there are reasons to believe that it works internally without including the conscious or ego elements of the human mind.
As Freud’s death instinct focuses on the organism’s internal workings, how can he get to the point of it applying to others? First, he asserts that at one time he equated ego instincts with death instincts, but then backed away, saying only libidinal instincts are within the ego. This then still leaves him without a pathway to the external. Later, Freud rhetorically asks if it is “plausible” that “sadism is in fact a death instinct” for “obtaining erotic mastery…coincid[ing] with that object’s destruction” (S.E., 18, 53-4).
“Sadism,” Freud writes, “consists in the exercise of violence or power upon some other person or object” (S.E., 14, 127). In calling sadism a death instinct, Freud makes a great leap. With a sleight of hand, Freud has taken an internal phenomenon and made it interpersonal. But there are problems. Sadism is clearly one person acting on another, so it is not internal and is not usually intended to be homicidal. Even if sadism contains a symbolic death wish, Freud’s notion of the death instinct is about a drive that always produces demise. Since sadism is not usually aimed at a literal death, it cannot accurately be called a death instinct, nor is sadism an occasional drive toward death consistent with Freud’s declaration that
Page 250
without exception all life forms die for internal reasons. Freud has contradicted his own description of what the death instinct entails. His portrayal of a death instinct toward others is as obscure, inconsistent, and incomplete as is his instinct theory. If there is actually a death instinct, Freud was not able to show how it applies to actions between humans in ways that conform to his own criteria. Freud’s explication of the death instinct is self-contradictory and incoherent.
Later, Freud wrote that “human instincts are of only two kinds: those which seek to preserve and unite…and those which seek to destroy and kill.” He calls the first erotic, sexual, or Eros, and the latter aggressive and destructive. Almost as soon as Freud separates them, he then adds that the erotic may often contain aggressive components and destructive idealistic elements. Instead he never attempts to clarify how we can separate the preservative from the destructive, but continues as though they are two clearly distinct instincts (S.E., 22, 1932, 209-210). Furthermore, identifying aggression as primarily aimed at killing is one-sided. While so many aggressions are dangerous, deadly, and destructive, they can be positive forces. In basketball, aggression can be driving past your opponent to make a lay-up; in business, surpassing a rival; in science, Watson and Crick were aggressive in wishing to beat their competitors to uncover the secrets of DNA. Aggression can be as much Eros as Thanatos, as creative as destructive. It may be directed toward winning as much as destroying. Freud failed to show why aggression should be grouped with killing, yet not with preserving and enhancing.
Psychoanalyst Charles Brenner says Freud’s death drive is based on the biological opposition of life and death, but in fact “there is no such clear distinction between life and death…biologically” (The Mind on Conflict, 1982, 17). As psychologist Thomas Suddendorf said, “all animals…have to eat other organisms—whether plant, fungus or animals—for sustenance” (The Gap, 2013, 1). The Oxford English and Merriam-Webster dictionaries each define killing as taking the life of plants and animals. Survival requires ending the lives of living beings. To live is to kill. While lethality is not all of life, Freud underestimates how closely tied together the preservative and the destructive are. If what leads to death can preserve life, then distinctions between Eros and Thanatos become fuzzy. No matter how he slices it, Freud’s explication of the death instinct is conceptually confused.
Page 251
Neither psychoanalysis nor psychohistory is an experimental science. Still, the questions a scientist should ask have merit in evaluating a concept: what does the idea mean and what evidence is there for and against it? With the death instinct, Freud’s assertion that without exception all organisms die for internal reasons is clearly not the whole story. Being killed by a lightning strike or catching a fatal infection in infancy cannot be reduced to just an inward death instinct.
Subsequent writers who sought to revive the death instinct have not escaped the pitfalls that bedeviled Freud. There is not yet a reliable account showing how the death instinct works either inwardly or between humans. This Freudian notion is obscure, internally confused, overly broad, difficult to apply to cases, and is missing serious attempts to find evidence to confirm or disconfirm it. At this point, the Freudian death instinct cannot be of much help in understanding human destructiveness, in part because Freud’s notion of the instinct is vague, undeveloped, and full of gaps. A critique of psychohistory is that it sometimes turns to half-baked ideas that do not meet scholarly standards for evidence and argument. Until the time conceptual clarity is reached and a truly empirical evaluation is undertaken, the words “death instinct” should not be part of the active vocabulary and practice of psychohistorians.
Page 252
How to cite this article
Fuchsman, K. (2017). What is the death instinct and does it apply to psychohistory? Clio’s Psyche, 23(3), 248-252.



