Volume 24 - Number 1 - Summer 2017
Pages: 1 - 133

MISCELLANEOUS ARTICLES

Fuchsman, K., & Elovitz, P. H. (2017). Why Hillary lost: Economic, political, psychobiographical, and psychohistorical factors. Clio’s Psyche, 24(1), 99-108.

https://doi.org/10.70763/caa202034f268232c26fac9435f54e15

Why Hillary Lost: Economic, Political, Psychobiographical, and Psychohistorical Factors

interview

Abstract

This interview is a dialogue between psychohistorians Ken Fuchsman and Paul H. Elovitz on why Hillary Clinton lost the 2016 presidential election to Donald Trump, setting aside Russian hacking, the FBI Director’s role, and the Electoral College. The discussion draws on campaign-event counts from the Boston Globe, turnout figures, Pew Research Center and exit-poll data on women and non-college-educated white voters, and episodes from Clinton’s career. Fuchsman argues that Clinton campaigned less than Trump, gave too little emphasis to the economy, and did not draw women voters as Obama had, and he disputes that her gender was the main cause. He characterizes her theme of consensus as ill-suited to the moment and sees a pattern in earlier episodes such as Whitewater and health care reform. Elovitz proposes that she did not connect emotionally with Rust Belt white working-class voters. He tentatively links her relationships with her father and mother to her conduct while acknowledging he cannot yet draw a clear line to the campaign. He contends that her gender, her insider status, and the electorate’s reaction against the previous presidency weighed more heavily than her weaknesses as a candidate. They also discuss the Clinton Foundation, her email server, and her outreach to Sanders supporters. Fuchsman concludes that Trump was electorally vulnerable and Clinton should have won; Elovitz maintains she could have won by campaigning more among ambivalent Democrats, independents, and moderate Republicans.

Keywords:

2016 U.S. presidential election, Donald Trump, Hillary Clinton, interview, political polarization, psychobiography, psychohistory

PHE (Paul H. Elovitz): In 2015 and ’16 I was so busy hoping that we would have our first woman president and focusing mostly on Trump in my writings, that I missed what a poor candidate the Democrat was, as well as her pattern of losing, as she did with health care reform in 1993 and against Obama in 2008. (Please note that for the purposes of this discussion we are not focusing on Russian hacking and pro-Trump leaks, the FBI Director’s role at a crucial point in the campaign, or the undemocratic elements in our Electoral College.)

KAF (Ken A. Fuchsman): Like you and many pollsters, I expected that Hillary would triumph in the Electoral College. I was flabbergasted when it became evident that she would lose to Donald Trump. During the campaign, I was surprised that Hillary did not run more on the state of the economy at a time when many were still suffering from the lingering impact of the Great Recession. I remember being heartened by a noontime appearance before the New Hampshire primary, where she spoke about economic needs and the way her hus-

Page 99

band, as president, had dealt with the recession he had inherited, bringing prosperity and a budget surplus. But rarely after that did her rallies focus on the economy. I was puzzled why she underplayed that issue, not only to win the election, but because jobs and growth are so important for the nation’s well-being.

PHE: Many Trump voters were enraged that prosperity came to a few while they stagnated. Clinton’s failure to consistently focus on the economy was certainly quite damaging. As you have often pointed out, it was compounded by her predecessor’s failure to have a jobs bill as one of his highest priorities in 2009. In the latter stages of the election, she was busy going to red states in the hope of creating a Democratic landslide victory instead of campaigning sufficiently among union workers in some traditionally Democratic areas. My greatest concern is what in her personality and leadership style led to her defeat. I hope we can devote most of our dialogue to these factors.

KAF: Hillary Clinton, like many of us, is double-sided. On the one hand, she can be collaborative, collegial, and work hard to bridge the gap between those holding opposing positions. On the other hand, she can be self-righteous, arrogant, and overestimate her own strength and appeal. This over-confidence manifested itself in 2016 after the political conventions. She campaigned much less than Trump. According to the Boston Globe, between August 1st and October 10th, Hillary Clinton held 52 campaign events. In the same period of time in 2012, Barack Obama had 74 events and Mitt Romney had 76 campaign stops. Also, between August 1st and October 10th, Donald Trump held 88 rallies. In other words, in this ten-week period, for every three campaign events Hillary Clinton had, Donald Trump had five.

Only a small portion of her inactivity can be attributed to her pneumonia, as she took less than a week off from campaign appearances due to her illness. It should be remembered that she had many fundraisers in August, but few public events, and she would withdraw from public appearances while doing debate prep. Basically, Hillary Clinton let Trump out-campaign her. This is not a winning strategy. A cardinal rule of close campaigns is that you outwork your opponent. Hillary Clinton failed to do this and lost to someone who campaigned much harder than she did. How much of this is due to her sense that her victory was inevitable and how much is due to other factors, we are not yet in a position to know.

PHE: I agree that Hillary’s failure to campaign as much as her op-

Page 100

ponent really hampered her electoral efforts. Voters want to be asked. Furthermore, she was unable to inspire her supporters sufficiently. Part of her problem was that she had a sense of overconfident entitlement since she had been a loyal Democrat who had built her resume since losing to Obama in 2008. After all, she was running against a Republican with no governmental experience whatsoever and major character flaws, so it was easy for her and others to underestimate her opponent.

KAF: I, too, think that Hillary Clinton had trouble inspiring the electorate. Voter turnout in 2016, according to CNN, was the lowest in 20 years. But here is the big thing: according to the Pew Research Center, Barack Obama pulled in a higher percentage of women voters than Hillary Clinton did. While 54% of women voted for Clinton in 2016, in 2008, 56% of females voted for Obama, and in 2012, he received 55% of the women’s vote. In 1996, the Roper Center reports, Bill Clinton won 55% of the women who voted.

Also, in 2008, when a self-identified African-American was nominated for president, according to the New York Times, the turnout jumped from 60% to 65% of eligible blacks. In 2016, with Hillary Clinton running, the increase in female voters was just 1%. Hillary did not lose so much because she was a woman but because she did not sufficiently appeal to women.

This was especially the case among non-college-educated white women. The census bureau says that in 2015, men and women over 25 had graduated college at comparable rates, and 57.2% of whites in 2015 did not have any college degree. This is a big chunk of voters, as almost two-thirds of all Americans and about the same number of women are white. In 2016, exit polls showed that white women without a college degree gave 34% of their votes to Clinton and 64% to Trump. This group of females voted overwhelmingly for a man who regularly and publicly said degrading things about women rather than cast their ballot for someone of their own gender. Again, Hillary lost less because she was female but rather because women voters did not surge to her, despite the overt sexism of her opponent.

PHE: Part of my enthusiasm for wanting Hillary to break the presidential glass ceiling had to do with the first woman president in countries with strong military traditions or threats to be challenged. She has to show that she is tougher than her male predecessors. This situation leads to civil or foreign war or the impeachment of

Page 101

the president. Whatever their failings, the driving out of the Brazilian and South Korean presidents within the last year is partly a reflection of this. I thought that with the counsel of her husband (known as “Slick Willie” in Arkansas), who has a genius for surviving tight situations, she could weather these challenges. However, it turns out that she didn’t even take enough of her husband’s advice to get elected. What are your thoughts on these subjects?

KAF: As Secretary of State, Hillary Clinton was hawkish, idealistic, collaborative, and diplomatic. Two of the major triumphs of Obama’s second term owe a great deal to Clinton’s efforts in his first. She worked skillfully to get a diplomatic rather than a military solution to the Iranian threat of developing nuclear weapons, and she was instrumental in starting what became a climate change agreement. Her idealism came through in the ways she worked globally for women and children. On the hawkish side we have her role in supporting the raid on bin Laden, undermining regimes in Libya and Egypt, and her condemning the corruption of a Putin-led Russian election. Hillary’s multi-dimensional approach to foreign affairs distinguishes her from “Iron Lady” Margaret Thatcher. A major failing was that Hillary certainly did not focus on the economy as Bill did both times he was the Democratic candidate.

PHE: Yes, Hillary is a complex individual. Her commitment to helping children clearly goes back to her time at Yale Law School when she worked at the psychoanalytically-based Yale Child Study Center, which produced The Psychoanalytic Study of the Child.

KAF: Like many of us, Hillary Clinton has changed as she has gotten older. By the time she ran for president in 2016, she seemed more comfortable talking at Goldman Sachs events than with middle-aged white working class males. Do you think this is accurate? Do you think this contributed to her defeat, and if so, how do you relate this to her personality and leadership style?

PHE: Certainly, it was easier for Hillary to speak to Goldman Sachs employees who paid big money to hear her but did not necessarily give her their votes. For a senator from New York, Wall Street was an important constituency. Speaking to them in New York meant raising lots of money and sleeping in her own bed. It was another thing for her to speak to those she thought fit into a “basket of deplorables” because they were inclined to vote for Trump. It is my impression that Hillary felt morally superior to them and they could feel it. She had programs aimed at solving many of their economic problems, but she did not feel for them.

Page 102

 Trump emotionally reached the white workers in the Rust Belt in a way she could not. They voted their emotions, not their ultimate self-interest.

KAF: What strikes me in Hillary’s change over the years is that for much of her career she campaigned hard to help those who were less fortunate. Working in Massachusetts right out of law school, Hillary found that many children with disabilities were not attending school because there were not facilities for them. Her discovery as well as others led to a change in education for the disabled. As first lady of Arkansas, she spearheaded major reform of the Arkansas school system, which had been one of the worst in the nation. Of course, health care was her cause when her husband was president. As times changed and different groups became less fortunate, why Hillary did not identify with and fight as much for them as she had when she was younger is a major question.

PHE: Like almost all candidates, the longer she was in politics, the more she focused on Washington and less on the ideals of her early career.

KAF: During your four decades of examining American presidents and presidential candidates, you have often illuminated how their childhoods have helped shape who they are as successful politicians. Do you think there is a connection between the different ways she identified with her dominating father and her admirable mother and how she conducted herself in running against Donald Trump?

PHE: There are wonderful moments as a psychobiographer when you can show a direct relationship between formative life experiences and subsequent actions and policy. When Lincoln says, “I used to be a slave,” referring to when his father sold his adolescent labor to neighbors, one can see a connection with his decision to end slavery. Such a moment with Hillary is when, as a four year old in a new neighborhood, her mother tells her she has permission to hit back with the kids who play rough and she proudly comes home declaring that “I can play with the boys now!” However, in the campaign I haven’t yet achieved such clarity with Hillary.

Hillary Diane Rodham was her Goldwater Republican father’s favorite child and she strongly identified with his politics until sometime in her college career. Unlike Fred Trump, Hugh Rodham spent lots of time with his kids, but was harsh and unforgiving if Hillary and her brothers did not live up to his standards. Hillary expected a lot of herself and perhaps that carried over into her

Page 103

looking down on workers. Hugh had contempt for Chicago Democratic bosses and unions, which probably did not make it easier for Hillary to warm to them on the campaign trail. Her mother Dorothy was quiet about her own political values and deprived childhood. In law school, Hillary fell in love with Bill Clinton, whom she believed would be president and was forgiving of his transgressions as her mother had been of her father’s major character flaws. I suspect she gains a lot of her strength by pleasing a man. But in running for president everything was up to her, and I don’t know how confident she really is.

KAF: Tell me more about why you think Hilary has confidence problems, and how does this connect to the criticism of her being arrogant and that she assumed she was a shoo-in to be elected against the unqualified Donald Trump?

PHE: I just don’t see Hillary as a natural politician and she has said she is not one. She works at it, but it does not come easily to her. Certainly, in 2016 she did not know how to tie into the emotions and fantasies of the White working and even middle classes as well as her opponent. The majority of my white male students who I polled voted for Trump. Clinton’s honesty, and at times lack thereof, are worth examining. Like virtually all politicians who have been around for a while, she has been caught in lies and misremembering things, such as when she repeated a number of times that she flew into Sarajevo under enemy fire.

Much of her problem is that, at times, she has been hurt by being too honest, as when she focused on helping coal miners through job training rather than claiming that she could restore their jobs in a period where the nation is trying to move away from coal with increased reliance on natural gas through fracking, investment in clean energy, and the mechanization of the coal industry, which requires far fewer workers. In West Virginia, where only about 5% of the population works in mining, her electoral efforts were crushed because of West Virginians’ identification as a coal-producing state. Trump’s ability to connect with this nostalgic identification served his campaign well but ultimately won’t be very helpful to West Virginians. Does honesty in a politician mean that they are self-defeating?

KAF: Not necessarily. Hillary Clinton has not always been forthright. As first lady, she did her best to keep her documents about the Whitewater issue hidden. During 2016, she publicly mischaracterized what the FBI Director said about her actions with her

Page 104

emails. Then, after stumbling through a 9/11 rally, she came out the same day and said she was now fine; later her campaign announced she had been suffering from pneumonia. These examples reinforced a public impression about her lack of honesty. The West Virginia example to me is more about a lack of political astuteness than being overly honest. Are there other factors that you thought led to her loss?

PHE: Loyalty and electoral success don’t always mix. Trump dropped campaign managers quite readily while Hillary stood by her longtime aide, Huma Abedin, when it would have been beneficial to dismiss her for the campaign because of Abedin’s husband’s sex scandals and the fact that she is a Muslim. She lost because she was a woman and because she couldn’t inspire workers she saw as deplorables. Unconsciously, I suspect she doubted seeing herself as being number one. What do you think?

KAF: It is hard for me to decide how much of her overconfidence mixed in with self-doubt and a repeated pattern of political self-injury. This includes her actions in relation to Whitewater, her self-defeating arrogance in handling health care when Bill was President, believing her husband about other women despite so much evidence to the contrary, and her taking Barack Obama, Bernie Sanders, and Donald Trump for granted.

PHE: According to a good friend of mine, there are quite a few ways in which Hillary made choices and took actions that ultimately did not help her campaign, some of which he suggests you might label as self-defeating. She didn’t do enough to reach out to and harness the energy of the Sanders voters, and he thinks she should have chosen Bernie as her vice president. Furthermore, he also suggests that she should have distanced herself more from her husband and not have had minorities and women so prominent at her convention and in the campaign. This is part of the reason white males turned to her opponent. Do you agree with him?

KAF: Well, it was not only white males that led to Hillary’s downfall; she lost non-college graduate white females almost as badly as she did white males without a college degree. I do think she should have followed the economic campaign themes of her husband in 1992, campaigning more on his presidential record. Similarly, Bernie Sanders kept talking about the disappearance of the middle class and the concentration of wealth, and Hillary would have benefited from stressing these themes.

Her campaign theme of “Stronger Together” was specifical-

Page 105

ly designed to contrast with Trump’s declaration that only he can fix things. Yet Hillary’s slogan seemed to echo Obama’s hopes for post-partisanship, and this has not worked out well. Between 1933 and 1993, Democrats controlled the House of Representatives in all but four years; since 1994, they have only had majorities in the House in four years, and after 2014 there were fewer Democrats in Congress than there were before the Great Depression. Both Presidents Clinton and Obama sought to transcend party, and both saw Republicans dominate in Congress. Hillary Clinton following in their footsteps did not help herself.

As a nation, we were not stronger together in 2016. The Great Recession devastated certain blocks of Americans while others profited enormously. Clinton’s stressing consensus more than division made her seem out of touch with much of the electorate. She resides now in a suburban multi-million-dollar compound and not in the White House.

PHE: It is hard to know if Clinton’s failure to distance herself from the Clinton Foundation could have made a difference. Just the name probably made it impossible. The constant hammering from Republicans of the Foundation certainly hurt Hillary in the eyes of many voters, which did much to lessen the impact of Trump’s failure to support humanitarian causes. While there is little question that the Clinton Foundation did an enormous amount of good, the openness to receiving large amounts of money from dictators and corrupt individuals who wanted access to a former and potential future president hurt her candidacy. The constant attack of her using a private email server was also damaging, even though this was a common practice until very recently. Clearly, hindsight is 20/20 and it would be easy to simply chalk up every criticism of Hillary as part of her being a poor candidate. However, I continue to think that there is much merit in President Obama’s statement, “I don’t think there’s ever been someone so qualified to hold this office [the presidency],” and that the biggest issue was that she was running for an office never before held by a woman. She was previously reelected as senator of New York with 67% of the vote and was highly praised as Secretary of State.

In retrospect, in an election where so much of the electorate was looking for outsiders like Sanders and Trump, Hillary was far too much of an insider for a large number of swing voters. Again, I think she could have won had she campaigned far more among ambivalent Democrats, Independents, and moderate Republicans.

Page 106

Though Democrats have thus far been slow to publish books about Hillary’s failures as a candidate, clearly Trump is hardly the only American who hates losers, which makes it easy to declare her a failed, even self-defeating, candidate.

KAF: I do think there is reason to see her candidacy in 2016 as deeply flawed, which connects to patterns she has shown intermittently in her career. Of course, there is another side as she had to show many self-affirming traits to achieve as much as she has in her life. We also need to place the way she ran her campaign in historical and political perspective.

PHE: The electoral victories in America are so often a response against the last presidency. Thus, the last five victors have had very different personality types. Carter (religious and intense) was replaced by Reagan (the “Teflon President”) and then the elder Bush (loyal and conscientious) by Clinton (“Slick Willie”), followed by the younger Bush (a tough-taking Texan), who was followed by the intellectual Obama from Chicago. By electing a biracial newcomer to Washington in 2008, most voters felt themselves to have put prejudice behind them. Instead of hearing on the news what an unprejudiced people they were in post-racial America, many white voters heard a very different story. They saw a compromising (therefore, in their minds, “weak” president), the Black Lives Matter movement, what seemed like endless political correctness, and the first Democratic female nominee, whose campaign manager was openly gay, and whose closest aide was a Muslim married to a man considered a national joke (Anthony Weiner). Voters in the states with the most electors did not want more of the same and decided to take a chance on a billionaire businessman who projected decisiveness and strength as a TV personality. Hillary was not a strong candidate, but that is probably not the largest part of the story.

KAF: Whatever the largest part of the story may be, outside of possibly Goldwater and McGovern, Donald Trump was the most vulnerable major party candidate since 1960. Despite her own liabilities, Hillary Clinton should have easily won. She was once again overly confident, did not campaign enough, and failed to recognize how central economic issues remain. In a country where almost two thirds of the population is white, and most of them have no college degree, she lost white men and women without college degrees by astonishing numbers. Bob Dylan said you don’t need a weatherman to know which way the wind blows. Hillary, unfortu-

Page 107

nately, was in dire need of an accurate weather forecaster. The short version of why Hillary lost is: she blew it.

Page 108

About the authors

Ken Fuchsman

Ken Fuchsman, EdD, is an emeritus professor at the University of Connecticut, where he also served as Director of the Bachelor of General Studies (BGS) program. He met Philip Roth in 2001 when UCONN gave Roth an honorary degree and they conversed before commencement. Dr. Fuchsman has been president of the International Psychohistorical Association since 2016. He can be reached at .

Paul H. Elovitz

Dr. Paul H. Elovitz, PhD, began organizing scholarly meetings when he started as a faculty member at Ramapo College and then as convener of the Institute for Psychohistory Saturday Workshops (1975-1982). In 1982, he founded the Psychohistory Forum to nurture psychohistorical research and continues to lead its Executive Council. In 1994, he created Clio’s Psyche (cliospsyche.org) to publish its scholarship, of which he is Editor-in-Chief. Prof. Elovitz is a historian, psychoanalytic researcher, and author of well over 400 publications, covering presidential psychobiography, teaching, documenting the field of psychohistory, and much more. After taking his doctoral degree in history, he trained and practiced as a psychoanalyst for three decades, and in 2019 was made the first Research Psychoanalyst by the New Jersey Institute for Psychoanalysis. Elovitz is the author of The Making of Psychohistory, editor of The Many Roads of the Builders of Psychohistory, and edited or wrote eight other books. He is a founding member and past president of the International Psychohistorical Association (1978-) who held all but one of its offices and continues to serve on its leadership council. He is the sole founder of the IPhA who has attended and presented at all of its annual meetings. In recent years, he has devoted himself to editing, publishing, and writing psychobiography.  Prof. Elovitz was a founding faculty member at Ramapo College who previously taught at Temple, Rutgers, and Fairleigh Dickinson universities. Aside from teaching Western and World Civilizations, his focus on teaching was on American, English, and European history; childhood; gender; genocide; the Holocaust; identity; leadership; psychobiography; psychohistory; the psychology of creativity and innovation; and war and peace. Presently, he teaches post-graduate courses on creativity, psychoanalysis, psychobiography, and other aspects of psychohistory online at psychoanalytic institutes. A Festschrift honoring him is scheduled for publication in Clio’s Psyche in 2024. He may be contacted at .

How to cite this article

Fuchsman, K., & Elovitz, P. H. (2017). Why Hillary lost: Economic, political, psychobiographical, and psychohistorical factors. Clio’s Psyche, 24(1), 99-108.

https://doi.org/10.70763/caa202034f268232c26fac9435f54e15

PDF downloads