Volume 24 - Number 1 - Summer 2017
Pages: 1 - 133

MISCELLANEOUS ARTICLES

Hansen, I. (2017). Resisting denial of the psychologist’s role in post-9/11 torture. Clio’s Psyche, 24(1), 115-120.

https://doi.org/10.70763/72007983849f4fcb0ad565439834756b

Resisting Denial of the Psychologist’s Role in Post-9/11 Torture

article

Abstract

In 2014, the American Psychological Association (APA) contracted David Hoffman of Sidley Austin, LLP to investigate whether officials of the APA had colluded with the U.S. government regarding its enhanced interrogation program. The result was “The Hoffman Report,” which suggested that key APA officials had indeed colluded to accommodate Department of Defense (DoD) priorities, effectively puncturing a decade of official denial and obfuscation around this issue in spite of already abundant evidence. The Hoffman Report pressured the APA to make significant changes to its ethics policy on psychologists’ involvement in interrogations. This progress is not irreversible, however, and to prevent denial from returning, the disturbing conclusions of this report must be clearly faced and widely discussed amongst all psychologists in the profession.

Keywords:

9/11 terrorist attack, American Psychological Association (APA), David Hoffman, denial, Department of Defense (DoD), enhanced interrogation program, ethics policy, “The Hoffman Report,” psychohistory, psychology, U.S. torture program

The historical details of the psychology profession’s involvement in post-9/11 U.S. “enhanced interrogation” torture remain a contested subject, but the broad outlines of that involvement

Page 115

are now relatively clear. Encountering this means confronting the fact that authorities within a generally admired profession became witting or unwitting accessories of the U.S. torture program. Processing the disturbing facts of this story without obfuscation, minimization, and authoritarian deference to apparent luminaries in the profession is essential to keeping psychology from sliding back into being an accessory to systemic torture.

In July 2015, the New York Times released the full contents of an independent investigator’s report into whether the American Psychological Association (APA) colluded with the U.S. government’s use of “enhanced” interrogation techniques since 9/11. The independent report by David Hoffman concluded, “that key APA officials, principally the APA Ethics Director joined and supported at times by other APA officials, colluded with important DoD [Department of Defense] officials to have APA issue loose, high-level ethical guidelines that did not constrain DoD in any greater fashion than existing DoD interrogation guidelines.” Furthermore, “we concluded that APA’s principal motive in doing so was to align APA and curry favor with DoD” (“The Hoffman Report,” 9).

It is important to note that the DoD had articulated its “existing […] interrogation guidelines” in the context of memos from the Office of Legal Counsel in the Department of Justice to various government agencies on the legality of “enhanced interrogation” practices. These memos denied the torture status of enhanced interrogations by redefining torture as such a narrow category of experience that government commitments to use only “non-torture interrogation” were emptied of legal meaning.

The loose, high-level APA ethical guidelines that the Hoffman Report refers to are primarily those that the APA-organized Psychological Ethics and National Security (PENS) Task Force articulated in 2005. During the PENS task force process, then APA Director of Ethics Stephen Behnke consulted regularly with task force members on what APA ethics policy should be. Behnke also ghostwrote the e-mails that the Chair sent to task force members. In this capacity, Behnke was careful to limit the scope of the task force’s mission to assessing what kind of interrogations psychologists could ethically be involved in, rather than the general question of whether it was ethical for psychologists to be involved in interrogations at all. This limited scope of ethical inquiry was in notable contrast to that of the American Medical Association (AMA) and the American Psychiatric Association, which had policy discus-

Page 116

sions resulting in both organizations banning their members from being involved in any kind of interrogation by 2006.

The PENS task force reached a conclusion that condemned torture and forbade psychologists’ participation in it, while nevertheless allowing that “psychologists may serve in various national security-related roles, such as a consultant to an interrogation, in a manner that is consistent with the Ethics Code” (APA, 2005, 6). However, there were major loopholes in this apparent humaneness.

The torture memos arguably gutted the legal meaningfulness of the PENS report’s prohibition on psychologist participation in “torture.” In addition, the “do no harm” ethos of the APA Ethics Code had been preemptively gutted in 2002. In that year, the APA Council of Representatives had amended section 1.02 of the Ethics Code in a way that critics charged was tantamount to putting the Nuremberg Defense at its core. The original section 1.02 read: “If psychologists’ ethical responsibilities conflict with law, psychologists make known their commitment to the Ethics Code and take steps to resolve the conflict in a responsible manner.” After the 2002 amendment, the same section included an extra sentence: “If the conflict is unresolvable via such means, psychologists may adhere to the requirements of the law, regulations, or other governing legal authority” [author’s emphasis].

With the help of some key media allies, a small number of psychology dissidents began to push back against the PENS subterfuge in 2006. In addition, media reports began to hint at the likely collusion between the APA, CIA, and DoD regarding the enhanced interrogation program. Journalists also reported on the close relationships between influential APA officials and the two military psychologists who designed the Bush Administration’s “enhanced interrogation” program for $80 million.

However, such media revelations generally just prompted APA denials, so significant accountability remained elusive for almost a decade. Then this situation changed rapidly when New York Times investigative reporter James Risen published Pay Any Price (2014), which included excerpts of emails he obtained from a deceased CIA/RAND corporation contractor, Scott Gerwehr. Gerwehr had been regularly included in email communications between DoD and CIA representatives and APA officials on interrogation policy. Some of the details of these emails were explosive.

Gerwehr’s emails provided evidence, for instance, that prior

Page 117

to the formation of the PENS Task Force, Behnke had arranged a private meeting between key APA officials and representatives from the DoD and the CIA addressing the Abu Ghraib scandal that had cast “enhanced interrogations” and the psychologist-led Behavioral Science Consultation Teams assisting them in a disturbing light. Behnke wrote to the CIA and DoD invitees that “in the meeting we will neither assess nor investigate the behavior of any specific individual or group […] and the APA wants to take a positive approach, in which we convey a sensitivity to and appreciation of the important work mental health professionals are doing in the national security arena” (Risen, 197). Risen interpreted this email as suggesting that, “The insiders were being given a chance to influence the APA’s stance before anyone else” (198).

Prompted by Risen’s report, the APA contracted David Hoffman to investigate the merit of Risen’s allegations. Together, Risen and Hoffman’s work managed to puncture the once-robust shield of denial and obfuscation around the APA’s ethical accommodation to U.S. government interrogation policy. Prior to Risen’s and Hoffman’s disclosures, those in charge of APA public relations were skilled at promoting psychologist involvement in interrogations as something liberal and humane. The official line, which appealed to the positive self-image of most psychologists, was that having psychologists involved in interrogations would increase the degree to which such interrogations would be “safe, legal, ethical and effective.” That is, psychologist involvement in U.S. interrogations would be a prophylactic against them becoming abusive and torturous because of psychologists’ benevolent liberal nature. (Counterpunch, December 4, 2007).

Since August 2015, the APA has become much more transparent about its recent dark history, though denial is returning as a tempting prospect, and with it a temptation to reverse some of the fragile ethical progress the profession has made. The APA Council of Representatives voted last year 157-1 to remove psychologists from Guantanamo-like detention settings and forbid them from assisting ongoing national security interrogations.

The DoD has also begun to follow through with removing psychologists from Guantanamo. This change potentially puts a heavy constraint on the government’s ability to torture in the future, since a systemically-executed torture program is very hard to maintain without health professionals to facilitate and legitimize it. In addition, torture-assisting health professionals are difficult to find if

Page 118

their professional organizations do not enable them in some plausibly deniable way. It is very significant when organizations of health professionals—and, in the APA’s case, educators and research scientists—explicitly close off the loopholes and draw a bright white line between the deontological “do no harm” ethos of their professions and the (at best) utilitarian harming methods of the military and other executors of state violence. Under these professional constraints, torture may even become pragmatically impossible as a systemic practice.

It is concerning, therefore, that DoD officials have raised objections to the APA’s new ethically defensible policy on interrogations and detention settings. Also, a number of pre-Hoffman APA leaders still in governance have attempted to discredit the Hoffman Report. The APA has enjoyed a longstanding friendship with, and dependence on, the DoD, and no report can make the psychological and structural features of that dependence disappear.

As the Hoffman Report puts it, “DoD is like a rich, powerful uncle to APA, helping it in important ways throughout APA’s life. Acting independently of a benefactor like this is difficult” (72). Nevertheless, the stakes are very high, and the psychological antecedents to renewed collusion call for the same degree of vigilance that all defenses of liberty require, especially as torture has returned as a potential cornerstone of U.S. foreign policy.

Part of this vigilance should include a willingness to face and professionally digest the contents of the Hoffman Report. All divisions of the APA and the broader psychology profession should confront, and not minimize, the history that the report documents. This confrontation means not only encouraging discussion of the report on professional listservs, but also inviting dissident psychologists to present at professional conferences and encouraging publishers to include accounts of this unpleasant history in the relevant college-level textbooks. So far, this professional confrontation with psychology’s recent dark history has not occurred on anything close to the scale that it should.

The profession of psychology now stands at a crossroads. Will it confront the most disturbing features of its own recent past and grow into a profession that lives up to the admiration that many still hold for it? Or will it sink back into a state of denial and dependence on the powerful militaristic forces that encouraged it to betray the ethical and moral trust of the American and international

Page 119

public?

Page 120

About the author

Ian Hansen

Ian Hansen, PhD, is a social psychologist and Assistant Professor at York College, City University of New York. He is also a member of the Steering Committee and nominee for president-elect of Psychologists for Social Responsibility. His research focuses on the political, cultural, religious, and ideological dimensions of psychology. He can be contacted at .

How to cite this article

Hansen, I. (2017). Resisting denial of the psychologist’s role in post-9/11 torture. Clio’s Psyche, 24(1), 115-120.

https://doi.org/10.70763/72007983849f4fcb0ad565439834756b

PDF downloads