
Volume 26 - Number 3 - Spring 2020
Pages: 265 - 387
Harris, J. (2020). The passion of Elisabeth Young-Bruehl. Clio’s Psyche, 26(3), 363-367.
The Passion of Elisabeth Young-Bruehl
Abstract
The author offers a retrospective look at Elisabeth Young-Bruehl’s many contributions to the fields of psychobiography, psychoanalysis, and sociology through her books, essays, and memoirs. Young-Bruehl was known for her excellent psychobiographies on Hannah Arendt and Anna Freud, and this article follows the trajectory of her writings on women, childrearing, psychoanalytic theory, cultural criticism, and social democracy. An uncommon thinker with an uncommon passion, Elisabeth Young-Bruehl traced the contours of our shared human experience.
Anna Freud, anti-Semitism, child psychology, cultural criticism, Elisabeth Young-Bruehl, empathy, feminism, Hannah Arendt, prejudice, psychoanalytic theory, psychobiography, psychohistory, social democracy
Elisabeth Young-Bruehl was a dedicated thinker and author who probed the roots of ideology and bias in her quest for social justice and change. Her training as a philosopher and psychotherapist enriched her impassioned understanding of the human psyche. Her research and theoretical works span the fields of psychohistory, philosophical inquiry, and psychoanalytic theory, as well as biography. Her influential biographies of Hannah Arendt, her teacher and mentor, and Anna Freud, with whom Young-Bruehl shared an abiding interest in child psychology, are now considered essential reading and have been translated into many languages.
Throughout her prodigious career, Elisabeth Young-Bruehl held that psychoanalysis is the instrument of choice both for exploring the psychological roots and social determinants of conflict and/or prejudice as well as for formulating possible strategies and interventions for reducing aggression and intolerance among divided segments of society. She well understood how the most basic and powerful psychological forces—love, hate, identity, desire, and fantasy—ultimately function as both causes and effects of cultural phenomena that reflect on group identity. Like Vamık Volkan, Young-
Page 363
Bruehl went beyond academic speculation to offer real solutions to international and interethnic conflicts. She was a dedicated teacher and wrote unceasingly in the form of journals and correspondence, but the clear milestones of her career are the major books Hannah Arendt: For Love of the World (1982), Anna Freud: A Biography (1988), Freud on Women: A Reader (1992), The Anatomy of Prejudices (1996), Subject to Biography: Psychoanalysis, Feminism, and Writing Women’s Lives (1999), Cherishment: a Psychology of the Heart (2000), Why Arendt Matters (2006), and Childism: Confronting Prejudice Against Children (2012).
Elisabeth Young was born in Maryland in 1946. Her maternal grandmother was a Mayflower descendant, and her father’s family were Virginians, several of whom were trained in theology at the College of William and Mary. She attended Sarah Lawrence College, where she studied poetry with Muriel Rukeyser. After completing her undergraduate education at The New School for Social Research, she married Robert Bruehl, whom she later divorced. As a PhD candidate in philosophy at The New School, Young-Bruehl wrote her dissertation under the mentorship of Hannah Arendt, who recognized in her an uncommon ability to synthesize many interdisciplinary fields at once. Her biography of Arendt is still the standard work on the social theorist and philosopher’s life.
In 1983, Young-Bruehl enrolled for clinical psychoanalytic training and in it met several of Anna Freud’s American colleagues, who invited her to become Anna Freud’s biographer, leading to the 1988 book Anna Freud: A Biography. This book not only chronicled the life of Anna Freud, but also offered insights into an analysis of Freud’s relationship to his most ambitious offspring. In 1991, Young-Bruehl moved to Philadelphia, where she taught part-time at Haverford College and in the College of Letters of Wesleyan University while continuing her psychoanalytic training. She also opened a private practice as a therapist there and later in New York City. In 2008, she married her partner, Christine Dunbar, a Canadian psychotherapist, and resided in Toronto in Ontario, Canada. from 2007 until her untimely death in 2011 from a pulmonary embolism.
Before becoming a psychoanalyst, Young-Bruehl was influenced by the intellectual rigor of Hannah Arendt, a Jewish émigré from Nazi Germany who barely escaped prior to coming to the United States. Arendt studied the roots of modern prejudice, seeking a foundation for her political and philosophical views in a varie-
Page 364
ty of topics encountered during her formative years in the intellectual and political ferment of Weimar Germany and her early involvement with Zionism. The New York Times described Young-Bruehl’s biography of Arendt as “biography at its best” (Peter L. Berger, “A Woman of this Century,” April 25, 1982). A philosopher of the public life, Arendt remained secretive about her private life; yet Young-Bruehl’s exhaustive interviews and recordings of Arendt’s friends allowed for a careful reconstruction of Arendt’s education, her affair with Martin Heidegger (later a Nazi Party member), her style of thought, and the genesis of her monumental works, The Origins of Totalitarianism (1951) and the more controversial Eichmann in Jerusalem (1963). Arendt focused on what she called “political theory” in order to understand both the history of Jews in this age and contemporary American culture. The most bitter controversies of Arendt’s life arose after her account of the Eichmann trial and her interpretation of some of the events of the Holocaust, particularly the role played by the Jewish councils in the Final Solution. Emotions still run high on all sides of the issue, but Young-Bruehl was careful to approach it from a humanist stance sympathetic to views of her mentor.
Young-Bruehl’s next major work, Anna Freud: A Biography (1988), centers on Freud’s relationship with her father and notes that Anna was born into an intense sibling rivalry with her father’s psychoanalytic work, something she could only overcome by becoming an analyst herself. Once immersed in Freudian theory and its permutations regarding Anna Freud’s lineage, Young-Bruehl refined her research, and, as a feminist critic, took on Freud’s most misogynist views of women in a text entitled Freud on Women: A Reader (1992), where she argued that Freud often denigrated women by creating blind spots in his theorizing about their drives and psychosexual development and by overemphasizing their psychosexual maladies. To read Freud on Women was to embark on a controversial pattern of Freud’s countertransference with regard to patients like Dora, who understandably frustrated his attempts to sexualize her associations in order to make them fit neatly into his theories.
After immersing herself in history and biography, Young-Bruehl returned to themes in contemporary life. In The Anatomy of Prejudices (1996), which won an American Publisher’s prize for Best Book in Psychology, the author distinguishes between four strains of bigotry (racism, sexism, anti-Semitism, and homophobia),
Page 365
each having a distinct cause. She then determined that each strain was rooted in three characterological types (obsessional, hysterical, and narcissistic). Anti-Semitism corresponds with the obsessional character fearing Jews as aggressive, whereas racism stems from the hysterical type and is rooted in sexual fear. Her observations about the causes of prejudice are actually predictive of what is occurring today in the Trump era with the rise of white nationalism.
After such scholarly work, Young-Bruehl ventured into a collaborative and self-reflective project, resulting in her work Cherishment: A Psychology of the Heart, co-authored by another psychotherapist, Faith Bethelard, with whom she was living and collaborating. Together, the authors embark on an extended conversation regarding Eastern theories of infant development and how these differ from those of the West. They point out the importance of the baby’s primal longing for oneness with the mother, which if satisfied produces a sense of infinite well-being that is constant throughout life. While Freud’s drive theory describes a range of infantile desires, it offers little to account for this expectation of care, which Young-Bruehl and Bethelard called “amae” (cherishment), and is arguably the essential core of psychological development. The authors warn that Western culture’s premium on independence and weaning as its paradigmatic process might lead to a lack of receptivity and even to a pathology of alienation. They advocated a return to the value of dependency within the mother/infant dyad as a route to inner receptivity and secure bonding. Late in her career, Young-Bruehl vigorously took up the topic of childrearing in her book, Childism: Confronting Prejudice Against Children, focusing on how some people imagine children as possessions that need to be controlled, making discipline their main responsibility. As Molly Castelloe writes in her remembrance of Young-Bruehl, the purpose of children from this perspective is “naturally subservient” and serves the needs of others, which is a symptom of potentially destructive habits in childrearing.
Elisabeth Young-Bruehl understood the imperatives of social and psychoanalytic inquiry and how they intertwined. As a biographer, she was uniquely equipped to explain the very process of empathetically entering into the subject and at the same time preserving her own autonomy as a record-keeper and observer. This was the focus of Subject to Biography: Psychoanalysis, Feminism, and Writing Women’s Lives (1991), where she analyzes her own feelings and ambivalences. In it she illuminates the psychological
Page 366
and intellectual demands writing biography makes on the biographer and explores the complex and frequently conflicted relationship between feminism and Freudian psychoanalysis. In a separate essay in that book, “The Biographer’s Empathy with Her Subject,” she remarked, “the usual, indeed, the clichéd way of describing empathy as ‘putting yourself in another’s place’ seems to me quite wrong. Empathizing involves, rather, putting another person in yourself, becoming another person’s habitat.” For Young-Bruehl, psychoanalysis was a form of vocalized biography, with two people working together to recover a life story.
In conclusion, I was fortunate to have had the friendship of Elisabeth, something I deeply value and miss. I can only imagine her response to current national politics and the divisions within our communities, and how she would have been on the front lines analyzing it and offering interventions. Her books were largely celebrated in reviews, although some critics (and especially critics of psychohistory) faulted her for rejecting sociological explanations of behaviors like prejudice in favor of the speculative and unproved approach of psychoanalysis. As she stated in her blog, which she began writing only one year before her death, her “historically critical” approach would assess America’s problems as resulting from a “multiple personality disorder.” Her task in her own words was “to make a diagnosis” and “propose a therapy.” I can think of no better voice to gather up our better natures and work together to bring about a truly pluralistic and functional democracy in which all voices can be heard.
Page 367
How to cite this article
Harris, J. (2020). The passion of Elisabeth Young-Bruehl. Clio’s Psyche, 26(3), 363-367.



