Volume 21 - Number 2 - September 2014
Pages: 123 - 243

THE MARILYN CHARLES
SYMPOSIUM

Covitz, H. (2014). Women are from Mars & men have a penis. Clio’s Psyche, 21(2), 142-144.

https://doi.org/10.70763/3983e1512aa570c564fab522bdb3efa5

Women Are from Mars & Men Have a Penis

response article

Abstract

This response article, part of the Marilyn Charles Symposium on the theme of “Are Women the Dark Continent?”, replies to the lead essay of that title by Marilyn Charles. Writing as an admirer of Charles’s work, the author offers a slightly different perspective. He contends that variation within gender classes is likely greater than variation between them, which makes gender categories less interesting than the culture assumes. Drawing on his chapter in Patricia Munhall’s Emergence of Man into the 21st Century, he describes his own sense of gender identity as an amalgam of identifications, cultural imperatives, and observed parental relationships. He maintains that people take up cultural categories idiosyncratically rather than essentially. He proposes a more meaningful division between those capable of intersubjective functioning and those who treat others as objects. He agrees with Charles that history has depreciated women’s agency and authority, attributes this in part to fecundity envy, citing Bettelheim, Mead, and Rank, and notes psychoanalysis’s record of excommunicating gay practitioners. He is admiring of Charles’s review of Milner’s works in the International Journal of Psychoanalysis. He reads Freud’s Dark Continent remark as an admission of analysts’ ignorance of female sexuality, and closes by wishing that generals’ sexual lives and morality resembled the purported female type.

Keywords:

female psychoanalysts, gender differences, gender identity, Marilyn Charles, psychoanalysis, psychohistory, sexualization, Sigmund Freud

As an admiring fan of Dr. Charles’s volumes, papers, presentations, conferences, and reviews for many years, I’ll still take this opportunity to see things from a slightly different perspective. To begin, let me say that while, as Marilyn Charles opines, our culture embraces such writings as Grey’s on gender differences (as that with which I take liberties in the title), there are those of us who accept that the variation within gender classes is likely greater than that between these same classes, rendering these gender categories less interesting than one might anticipate from the Mobius (sexualized universe) in which we live.

In dealing with the envy I feel for my wife, I compared the convoluted complexity of understanding my gender identity to one that might obtain peering into in my chapter of Patricia Munhall’s Emergence of Man into the 21st Century (2002):

“an array of mirrors. Some… fine reflectors… others… foggy or cracked or but partially reflective due to some aging process in the surface’s material. Some face each other and others face away. Diagonal, orthogonal, pairwise skewed — a congeries of mirrors set in a never to be replicated pattern. I imagine choosing a spot in a singular mirror upon which to focus my gaze. I shall have arrived at this moment and this place and this choice of spot after years of trekking through many other such mirror mazes. Still, I… marvel and fascinate at the array of sequential visions… visible through this chosen spot in this mirror. The images… stare back at me at that moment. Not simple images, but compound ones that, if I look with care, may include me, the intrusive observer… inadvertently been cast as a shadowy figure in his own observations” (Covitz, 2002, 29).

Indeed, my notion of what it means to be male is an amalgamation of my identifications with important male figures, cultural

Page 142

imperatives, and my sense of what I might see in my Mother’s gaze at my Father and what I saw in her eyes as reflections on her sense of her own Father and much more. My notion of what it means to be a woman is one step further removed.

The categories that the culture constructs dichotomous and otherwise are not necessarily intrinsic or “essentialistic” to our being or even unambiguous cultural precipitates. No. We embrace them idiosyncratically according to our complex interactions with whatever mazes of mirrors have been created by and around us. As an example of such an errant category, I often think of the presumption made by others that I identify as a white male… that I see myself as a member of a subgroup that lives in the intersection of two categories – race and gender – that are not necessarily essential ingredients of who I am. People may attempt to impose these categories on me from the outside… so be it.

There are many other categories in which I do see myself as on one side or the other of such a categorical divide. Most compelling for me is the one that separates those capable of intersubjective functioning—of seeing the other as a subject in their own right (an expression that permeates both Marilyn’s and my own writings) capable of respecting the relationships of their near and dear to others and to these near-and-dears’ own theories and gods. As well as those who seek unilaterally dyadic relations with others who are essentially treated as objects (an object being something that lacks multilateral relationships with others). What to say? I feel far less the kin of dogmatic psychoanalysts (and Marilyn is not one of those) than to those practitioners of whatever stripe who hold to their own models in a primus inter pares (the first among equals or first among peers) fashion (as Marilyn, in my experience, consistently does).

I certainly agree with Dr. Charles that human history has been saturated with the depreciation of the sense of agency and authority of women. This is both shameful and incontrovertible. To think that one of the premier thinkers in Freud’s time, Sir Thomas Huxley, compared the absurdity of giving the franchise to women and blacks and that psychoanalysis itself has a shameful history of excommunicating outed gay practitioners based on what was called their “object choice.” However, here I tend to agree with Bruno Bettelheim, Margaret Mead and Otto Rank that fecundity envy has run amok in the wild underbrush of supposedly cogent thought and has sons and even daughters and psychotheorists depreciating the

Page 143

powers of the grown woman, she who is at least the potential life giver and the one who—as many a mother has reminded her child – has the power to take that life back again.

One more comment and a bone to pick. Dr. Charles takes up many of these same issues in her International Journal of Psychoanalysis (JPA, 2012:3) review of Marian Milner’s works, works which she emphasizes above. Her review of Milner’s five books is brilliant and brought Milner’s thinking out in the clearest and simultaneously most elegant way imaginable. As to getting picky? Now, I am being a defensive male. I read Marilyn’s paper in part as a member of one of the first professions in which a Felix (Deutsch) could be known as a Helene’s husband and one in which Anna, Karen, and Melanie could lead important groups that led to major changes in the field. True. Freud’s at least twice repeated contention that “the sexual life of adult women is a Dark Continent to Psychology” (not, by the way, that women were thus but that he and his colleagues were clueless as to female sexuality) and that their sense of morals were never fully divorced from feelings and relationships are, indeed, complicated. Still and frankly, after recent scandals and wars, I often find myself wishing that the sexual lives and morality of our generals held more to the purported female type than to the male.

Many thanks for both pieces and the opportunity to discuss.

Page 144

About the author

Howard H. Covitz

Howard H. Covitz, PhD, ABPP, NCPsyA, has been a psychoanalyst for 45 years and served as the director of Psychoanalytic Studies Institute and Institute for Psychoanalytic Psychotherapy in Philadelphia. He now limits his practice to psychoanalysis, psychoanalytic psychotherapy, and psychoanalytic supervision. He can be contacted at .

How to cite this article

Covitz, H. (2014). Women are from Mars & men have a penis. Clio’s Psyche, 21(2), 142-144.

https://doi.org/10.70763/3983e1512aa570c564fab522bdb3efa5

PDF downloads