Volume 17 - Number 4 - March 2011
Pages: 275 - 371

BOOK REVIEWS

Ihanus, J. (2011). A family history of Russian revolutionary terrorists [Review of the book Lenin’s Brother: The Origins of the October Revolution by Philip Pomper (2010)]. Clio’s Psyche, 17(4), 348-352.

https://doi.org/10.70763/d324a0cc02881779dcda44a675fdcaaa

A Family History of Russian Revolutionary Terrorists

book review

Abstract

This book review of Philip Pomper’s Lenin’s Brother: The Origins of the October Revolution (W. W. Norton, 2010) describes the book as a biography of Alexander Ulyanov (1866–1887), Lenin’s elder brother, who was hanged for taking part in the failed 1887 plot to assassinate Tsar Alexander III. The reviewer reports that Pomper draws on Moscow archives and on the memoirs of the brothers’ sister Anna. According to the reviewer, Pomper maintains that Alexander’s role and fate shaped Lenin, and he portrays a secretive household, a demanding father, and sharply different temperaments in the two brothers. The reviewer judges Pomper’s account of family relations impressionistic and observes that the book cites no psychological sources. The reviewer suggests that family systems theory, object relations theory, and developmental psychology could have made it more coherent. The reviewer then offers further readings of Alexander, including his attachment style, his relationship with co-plotter Raisa Shmidova, and his attitudes toward women. The reviewer also asks how bonds formed within the conspiratorial group so quickly. The reviewer praises Pomper’s treatment of Lenin’s motivations in Chapter 9 but finds his account of Lenin’s years abroad less full, and points readers to Helen Rappaport’s Conspirator: Lenin in Exile and to Anna Geifman’s work. The reviewer credits the book with reappraising the Ulyanov family through historical research and regrets its limited attention to the Okhrana. The reviewer concludes that psychohistorians still have much to learn about the childhood, adolescence, and family origins of those drawn to revolutionary terrorism.

Keywords:

Alexander Ulyanov, book review, historical documents, Lenin’s Brother: The Origins of the October Revolution, Philip Pomper, psychohistory, Russian revolutionary terrorists, terrorism, Tsar Alexander III, Ulyanov family, Vladimir Lenin, Wesleyan University

Review essay of Philip Pomper, Lenin’s Brother: The Origins of the October Revolution (W. W. Norton & Company, 2010), xxvi, 276 pages, ISBN 978-0-393-07079-8, Hardcover, $24.95.

The Ulyanov family, with its professional revolutionary son Vladimir (Volodya, later known by his pseudonym Lenin), has been researched from different viewpoints, but the psychodynamics of the family have mostly been bypassed or only vaguely hinted at.

Page 348

It is, of course, difficult to form a clear picture based on the rather few historical documents. Philip Pomper, Professor of History at Wesleyan University, has earlier written on Russian revolutionary intelligentsia. In his new book he gives a comprehensive biography of Alexander “Sasha” Ulyanov (1866-1887), Lenin’s elder brother and a terrorist who was hanged in 1887 for taking part, with a small group of disillusioned students, in the failed assassination of Tsar Alexander III.

Pomper stresses that Alexander’s role and fate were important in shaping Lenin, who had strong sibling rivalry with his elder brother since being estranged from each other when Alexander was arrested. Unfortunately, there is no correspondence between the brothers, but their sister Anna’s memoirs provide valuable (albeit also biased) material of family relations and dynamics. After Lenin’s death, Anna tried to reveal the Ulyanov family’s Jewish background (the father of their mother had converted from Judaism to Russian Orthodoxy), but Stalin turned her down sharply. Pomper has also been able to use archival sources from Moscow and other Russian references, which gives his book and its narrative a well-balanced historical base.

According to Pomper, Anna and Alexander experienced the family atmosphere as secretive and secluded, hindering their “lifejoy” and producing “a kind of impacted anger, wordless and expressionless, but ready to explode” (p. 29). Alexander has in every photo “the same morose face,” from the age of four to 21, when he was a soon-to-be-hanged prisoner. Alexander’s father had chosen him to follow strict standards of behavior and pursue his studies dutifully. Alexander was delegated his father’s ambitions. However, the younger brother Vladimir (Lenin) is described as more playful, outgoing, and self-confident; temperamentally more like his father, sharing his mischievous humor. The adolescent Alexander silently rebelled against his father and was worshipped by the whole family—except Vladimir, who was indulgently raised by a nurse and rebelled more against his mother.

The Ulyanov family seems to have led a kind of hothouse existence, the children socializing with their cousins and extended family. The Ulyanovs were neither poor nor well-off, but the father focused on learning and science and the mother esteemed literature,

Page 349

music and drawing. There were traumas (for example, two infant deaths) and secrets (the suicide of their mother’s brother) in the family. Father rarely praised the children and opposed “pampering.” As developmental research has shown, every child has, psychologically, its own unique environment within the family. It is difficult to trace the family dynamics from multiple perspectives, and in the case of the Ulyanov family the documentation is too meager to show such perspectives. Anyhow, Alexander’s temperament did not fit with his father’s temperament and expectations; there were more reactive correlations than sensitive fits between the father and the son.

The relations between the Ulyanov family members are interestingly but somewhat impressionistically characterized by Pomper. Additions from psychological family theories, object relations theories and developmental psychology, for example, could have conveyed a more coherent view. Perhaps Pomper did not go into more detailed psychological argumentation in order to avoid very speculative interpretations. Actually, there are no references to psychological sources in Pomper’s work. Pomper raises many intriguing questions that need further psychohistorical research. For example, what kind of bonding, or web of attachments, was created between the co-conspiratorial members of Alexander’s group in such a short period of time? The passionately committed organizer of the group, Peter Shevyrev, was both charismatic and paranoid and managed to recruit the much more skeptical and rational Alexander, who subordinated himself to the group because of justified “scientific” reasons while also becoming more and more agitated for the “righteous cause.”

There was even a brief romantic relationship between Alexander and co-plotter Raisa Shmidova, literally with bombs under their bed, just before the attack on the tsar! Such an enactment of love tells about mismanaged individuation and a violent attempt at separation. One could call Alexander’s attachment style “avoidant.” The adolescent Alexander expressed harsh opinions about women in a January 1887 letter to his female cousin. For him, women were too romantic and too individualist, mostly lacking critical and scientific thought as well as energy and initiative, and prone to accept prejudices. He clearly had poor skills of relat-

Page 350

ing with women; with his careless behavior he even endangered his sister, who was not participating in the terrorist plot. His mother was sadly disappointed by Alexander’s passion for terror, and not for reciprocal love. Alexander and Vladimir’s father had died over a year before the attack. Another curious coincidence was the death of their mother in 1916, also a year before the October Revolution. Pomper does not dwell on these deaths, but he states succinctly, “Revolutionary morality required that one sacrifice loved ones, if the cause demanded it” (p. 59).

Pomper’s insights in Chapter 9 on Lenin’s motivations for his revolutionary class struggle and revenge against the tsarist family, regime, and the whole bourgeois society deserve praise. However, Pomper is more elusive about Lenin’s personality while working to launch the Revolution from abroad (1900-1917). Such information has to be sought from other sources. For example, Helen Rappaport’s work Conspirator: Lenin in Exile (2010) shows Lenin as gentle, engaging and modest and at the same time supporting brutal violence and mass-scale bloodshed. From another angle, Anna Geifman’s works introduce the history of Russian revolutionary terrorism from 1897-1917. It seems that both Alexander and Vladimir had found a strong sense of existential/ideological purpose in fighting against the tsarist system and defending its victims. Alexander was more amateurish and conscientiously self-sacrificing, while Vladimir developed his more calculated and professional production of terror and revolution to the extremes and worked tirelessly (writing millions of words and maneuvering ideological power positions) for the collective Communist utopia and atheistic fundamentalism.

The cult of Stalin is gradually being deconstructed and the demystification of the October Revolution has started in Russia. Pomper’s Russian friend commented, “In Soviet times Sasha was a revolutionary martyr; now he’s just a fanatic and suicidal terrorist” (p. 215). De-Leninization has not really begun, but it is Pomper’s impressive scholarly achievement that the Ulyanov family, a kind of “holy family” in the Russian Marxist mythology, has now been reappraised by thorough historical research.

Besides portraying Alexander and the Ulyanovs, Pomper’s highly readable and insightful work reveals several aspects of 19th

Page 351

century Russian society, especially the university and its students, the legislative and the judicial systems, the underground terrorist plotters and the nihilistic doctrines behind terrorist acts. What I personally missed was a closer look at the tsarist secret police, the Okhrana, its methods of surveillance and its tactics of political policing. After having read Pomper’s clear and exciting work, I sense that there are still many puzzles left for the psychohistorians who try to understand the childhood, adolescence, family origins, and the developmental niches and trajectories of the fundamentalist/ terrorist mindset.

Page 352

About the author

Juhani Ihanus

Juhani Ihanus, PhD, is Associate Professor of Cultural Psychology at the University of Helsinki, and Associate Professor of the History of Science and Ideas at the University of Oulu. He is also an international member of the Psychohistory Forum who has published books and articles on psychohistory, cultural and clinical psychology, and the history of psychology. Dr. Ihanus may be reached at .

How to cite this article

Ihanus, J. (2011). A family history of Russian revolutionary terrorists [Review of the book Lenin’s Brother: The Origins of the October Revolution by Philip Pomper (2010)]. Clio’s Psyche, 17(4), 348-352.

https://doi.org/10.70763/d324a0cc02881779dcda44a675fdcaaa

PDF downloads