Volume 22 - Number 3 - December 2015
Pages: 123 - 223

APPLIED PSYCHOHISTORY

Ihanus, J. (2015). Resistances and counter-resistances in psychohistory. Clio’s Psyche, 22(3), 209-213.

https://doi.org/10.70763/a0443c8c8c3372d662e9173c18faaa2c

Resistances and Counter-Resistances in Psychohistory

article

Abstract

In this article, the author considers resistance to psychohistory from other disciplines and argues that psychohistorians’ own reactions to it deserve equal attention. The author recalls Lloyd deMause’s view that psychotherapists, historians, and social scientists resisted psychohistory, Rudolph Binion’s suggestion that reliance on depth psychology was a false start, and David R. Beisel’s reports of resistance to psychology in Holocaust studies and in history generally. Referring to Freud’s and Wilhelm Reich’s accounts of resistance and to the psychoanalytic concept of countertransference, the piece proposes the term counter-resistances for psychohistorians’ impatience, arrogance, and defensive devaluation of other approaches to knowledge, and maintains that these hinder interdisciplinary dialogue. It suggests that deMause’s group-fantasy of specialization among psychotherapists may have a counterpart in a group-fantasy of exceptionalism among psychohistorians. It reports Miguel Angel Gonzalez-Torres’s pilot study, which found a lower share of recent references in psychoanalytic journals than in psychiatric, physics, and general medicine journals, and cites Arnold M. Cooper’s characterization of American psychoanalysis as a plurality of orthodoxies. It asks whether psychohistory resembles them, noting that psychohistorical journals have not been examined this way. The author is critical of theoretical fixation, contends that no single psychological theory should be prioritized, and concludes that psychohistory should stay open to dissident views, rethinking, and self-evaluation.

Keywords:

counter-resistance, historical data, history of childhood, interdisciplinary, leadership, Lloyd deMause, psychoanalysis, psychodynamics of small groups and leaders, psychohistory

Psychohistorians, like psychoanalysts before them, have become accustomed to detecting and revealing persistent resistances to their field from other disciplinary fields. In several instances, Lloyd deMause repeated the idea that psychohistory, as an emerging investigative enterprise, was surrounded by hostile, reluctant, or indifferent opponents. The opponents were accused of missing the crucial points of psychohistorical orientation and research. Such argumentation claimed that the opponents misunderstood historical data, for example, concerning the history of childhood, and the psychodynamics of small or large groups and their leaders. They seemed to fail or refuse to accept the role personal attachments, childhood experiences, unconscious conflicts and motivations, and embodied emotional traumas played in human (both distant and contemporary) history, including relations to past and present leaders and ideologies.

When Lloyd deMause encountered surprising evasions from a group of American psychotherapists to express their professional appraisals on political issues (e.g. Richard Nixon’s personality and its influence on his enemy chase, the imminent threat of nuclear war), he concluded that they did not want to get involved with personally menacing problems. Instead of that, they had formed “The Group-fantasy of Specialization” that “denies the direct application of the insights of psychotherapy to history” (deMause, “Psychohistory and Psychotherapy,” in Lloyd deMause, ed., The New Psychohistory, 1975, 309). The burden of research on historical and political events was de-emotionalized and handed over to the social sciences. However, deMause made an acute observation by stating that “most of the theories of the ‘social sciences’ have been motivated by a flight from psychology, a vast defensive response to the growing discoveries of depth psychology” (310).

Although there are several orientations in psychology, most of them have made important findings on how the human mind works. Psychohistorians’ task is to apply psychological knowledge to highlighting how the human mind works in historical and political settings. It may be that leaning heavily on “depth psychology,” psychoanalysis, or psychodynamically oriented psychology was a

Page 209

“false start” for psychohistory (see Rudolph Binion, “Psychohistory’s False Start,” Clio’s Psyche, 6, 4, 2000, 133, 138–39). Even if mainstream academic psychology is currently cognitively and neuroscientifically oriented, psychohistorians can learn from, and creatively use, different orientations of psychology. No single theory should be prioritized in the psychological interpretations of history. An urgent work for psychohistorians is to be open not only to dissident views but to their own ambivalences, defensiveness, and resistance.

As David R. Beisel has shown, there is strong resistance to psychology in Holocaust studies (“Resistance to Holocaust Scholarship,” The Journal of Psychohistory, 27, 2, 1999, 124–35), and in history at large (“Psychohistory and the Historians: 1970–2015,” Clio’s Psyche, 22, 1–2, 2015, 15–20). Resistance has prevailed from non-psychohistorians, and in the psychohistorians themselves to non-psychological historians, thus making transdisciplinary dialogues and negotiations difficult. History of psychohistory has plenty of examples of psychohistorical interpreters who have had their theoretical fixations approaching reductionist “psychologism.”

Psychoanalysts, as well as psychohistorians, have recognized that the core of resistance often contains an unconscious conflict between being bound to the past and striving toward new extensions. Several forms of resistance have been analyzed and becoming conscious of resistance has been used as a tool both in psychotherapy and in psychohistory. Like the psychotherapeutic process, psychohistorical research opens unpleasant and distressing possibilities from which people shelter to seemingly more secure hiding places. Insights about growth and development can be painful and are evaded through excuses and self-deceptions. Psychohistorical thinking and reasoning are neither separate from individual and collective emotional conflicts and memories nor from the experiential history of the individual and sociocultural mind-brain-body.

In the psychoanalytic setting, resistance is directed to communication, contact, content, and, finally, change. Freud differentiated ego, id, and superego resistances according to his structural model of the mind in Inhibitions, Symptoms and Anxiety (1926, S. E. XX). Especially important in the psychoanalytic process are expressions of resistance that are linked to repression, transference, the feelings of guilt and shame, and the fear of change. In psychoanalytic work, the focus has been on the resistance phenomena of the analysands though, of course, analysts have their own profess-

Page 210

sional and personal fixations, customs, and repetitions that may disturb the analytic process. Freud made it clear in “The Future Prospects of Psychoanalytic Therapy” that no psychoanalyst can professionally reach further than his or her own complexes and inner resistances allow (1910, S. E. XI). Wilhelm Reich proposed in Character Analysis that “character resistance” manifests itself in the whole personality and concentrates on the exclusion of new and surprising initiatives (1933/1972).

In psychohistorical work, resistance has been mostly located outside the psychohistorical “us group.” Becoming conscious of and working through one’s inner and “in group” resistance is tedious and demands patience, but it can lead to positive change in the continuous professionalization of psychohistory. At the same time resistance appears, there is much meaningful, humanly touching value that cannot be forced or precipitated. Psychohistorians can develop their skills for studying and clarifying the motivational bases of resistance: social, cultural, political, and historical rituals, routines, manners, and repetitions. What makes us maintain resistance, the avoidance of the unknown? Does it ease one’s living, or take one’s resources that would be needed for realizing one’s potential?

Psychohistorians have transferences to their research data (people, events, settings, etc.). What psychoanalysts call countertransference, the unconscious emotions of the analyst in relation to the analysand’s thoughts, emotions, and behavior, is also present in the psychohistorians’ relations to the representatives of other disciplines and their interpretations of history. Countertransference can fuse with regressive states that imply, for example, impatience, unbelief, arrogance, and manipulative maneuvers that are directed against resistances to psychohistory from other fields of knowledge. These states I call psychohistorians’ “counter-resistances,” which may actually sabotage collaborative efforts and new insights. Beisel has given an example: “Sometimes psychohistorians brought the wrath of historians down upon themselves, defensively blaming historians for being ‘too defensive.’ One self-defeating example was Lloyd deMause’s essay, ‘The Independence of Psychohistory,’ published in (…) 1975, wherein he asserted psychohistory was a science and called historians astrologers” (2015, 15–16).

Personality features, attachment styles, and defenses of psychohistorians can be inflexible, such as the stance, “here I stand and I cannot do otherwise.” Unconscious and only partly conscious

Page 211

counter-resistances of psychohistorians can hinder interdisciplinary contacts, but they can also block new ideas that originate from those who are seen to be stubborn opponents of psychohistory. Perhaps it is easier to become aware of others’ resistance phenomena than of one’s own counter-resistances that hide obsessive ideas, fixed principles, and the ritualized devaluations of other routes to knowledge. Epistemological inflexibility can include opposition to emerging dissident theories that are considered irritating and adding too many painful challenges. Adopted “right doctrines” are thus defended against “false notions.” The specialties of psychohistorical knowledge construction do not justify isolation from the scientific community and its critical, often provocative debates. What deMause called “The Group-fantasy of Specialization” of psychotherapists may have transformed into “The Group-fantasy of Exceptionalism” among psychohistorians. Psychohistory has certainly met simplified, distorted, and hostile receptions in scientific discussion. Psychohistorical approaches evoke both intellectual and emotional involvement and may thus lead to resistance and outright maliciousness that help the critics of psychohistory to camouflage fears of their own unconscious conflicts.

Psychohistorical or any other knowledge does not get constructed only so that I know, or we know, what is permanently right. Observing and knowing one’s self otherwise gives a changing ground to the personal and professional development of psychohistorians. Mutual efforts at creating new connections and horizons for understanding complex and dynamic phenomena are needed. The “theoretical identities” of psychohistorians reflect their personal proclivities, attitudes, and values. In psychotherapy research, psychodynamically oriented psychotherapists have usually scored higher than (cognitive) behavior therapists in intuition, openness for experience, need for cognition, risk-taking, and ambiguity tolerance. Whether this applies to the theoretical orientations of psychohistorians as well has not yet been studied. There are also biases in scientific research connected with using too much intuition, and tolerating ambiguity and unfounded assumptions.

Contradictions between different approaches can be a guarantee of lively scientific discussion. Progress in research is often enhanced by multiple approaches and voices. Dialogical psychohistory is a part of human sciences that may have fruitful contacts with several scientific fields, opening up resistance and

Page 212

heading toward updated insights in our historical self-observation, self-knowledge, and self-realization.

In his pilot study, “In the Mind of the Teacher,” reported at the XVIII International Forum of Psychoanalysis in Kaunas (September 17, 2014), Miguel Angel Gonzalez-Torres compared psychoanalytic journals with psychiatric, general medicine, and theoretical physics journals, noting the number of bibliographical references and the number of recent references (published within the last ten years). The percentages of recent references were in psychoanalytic journals only around 20%, while in psychiatric and theoretical physics journals it was around 50%, and in the field of general medicine it was 80%. Such results raise a disturbing doubt that psychoanalytic knowledge is heavily dependent on old authorities, avoiding confrontations with their views. Nobody has studied psychohistorical journals and their references in this way. However, we can ask whether psychohistory has the same kind of situation as American psychoanalysis, and “more a multiplicity of authoritarian orthodoxies rather than a truly scientific discourse,” as depicted by Arnold M. Cooper (“American Psychoanalysis Today: A Plurality of Orthodoxies,” Journal of the American Academy of Psychoanalysis and Dynamic Psychiatry, 36, 2, 2008, 235–53).

It is not the repetition of old errors but openness to rethinking that characterizes scientific advancement within psychohistory. Psychohistory is not a closed knowledge system but an unfinished enterprise, ready for self-evaluation and change. Its radical reformism and awakening of consciousness are based on re-appraising personal, social, and cultural issues that were formerly considered self-evident. Surely, psychohistorians do not resist observing and reanalyzing their own conceptions, do they?

Page 213

About the author

Juhani Ihanus

Juhani Ihanus, PhD, is Associate Professor of Cultural Psychology at the University of Helsinki, and Associate Professor of the History of Science and Ideas at the University of Oulu. He is also an international member of the Psychohistory Forum who has published books and articles on psychohistory, cultural and clinical psychology, and the history of psychology. Dr. Ihanus may be reached at .

How to cite this article

Ihanus, J. (2015). Resistances and counter-resistances in psychohistory. Clio’s Psyche, 22(3), 209-213.

https://doi.org/10.70763/a0443c8c8c3372d662e9173c18faaa2c

PDF downloads