Volume 06 - Number 2 - September 1999
Pages: 41 - 88

ELECTION 2000

Immelman, A. (1999). Why Al Gore will not be elected president in 2000. Clio’s Psyche, 6(2), 73-75.

https://doi.org/10.70763/445e24b5f22cacb9d51a837c10e91a3f

Why Al Gore Will Not Be Elected President in 2000

article

Abstract

In this article, the author predicts that Vice President Al Gore will not be elected President in 2000, provided the Republicans nominate a relatively outgoing candidate. The author draws on his 1998 study of Gore, which used Millon’s Index of Personality Styles Manual, the five-factor model of Costa and McCrae, Simonton’s “Presidential Style: Biography, Personality, and Performance,” and Renshon’s The Psychological Assessment of Presidential Candidates, and which rated Gore high in conscientiousness and low in extraversion. The author then presents a tentative worst-case scenario, formulated in June 1998. In it, a Gore Presidency might, like Woodrow Wilson’s, relentlessly advance a policy in which Gore has a stake, such as the environment, government efficiency, or the high-tech industry, and might withdraw from coalition building and public relations. The author judges the risk of personal scandal to be low and does not expect a transformational Presidency. Using Rubenzer, Faschingbauer, and Ones’s extraversion rankings, the author maintains that nearly every President since Franklin D. Roosevelt has been relatively extraverted, and speculates that since John F. Kennedy the more outgoing candidate has usually won. The author concludes that saturation television coverage and the blurring of leadership and celebrity disadvantage Gore.

Keywords:

Al Gore, character integrity, George W. Bush, personality profiles, political personality, political predictions, presidential leadership, psychohistory, U.S. presidential election 2000

Unlike President Clinton, Vice President Al Gore possesses well-consolidated character integrity; however, its outward expression in discernable personality traits does not auger well for his candidacy in an era where political campaigns are governed by saturation television coverage and the boundaries between leadership and celebrity have become increasingly blurred. It is for this reason that I predict that Al Gore will not be elected President of the United States in 2000—provided the Republicans field an outgoing, relatively extraverted, charismatic candidate. [See the author’s “The Political Personality of George W. Bush” on page 74.]

In support of this contention, I quote and paraphrase from the abstract of my 1998 study of Al Gore, following which I present my “worst-case” scenario for a prospective Gore Presidency (formulated in June, 1998). I conclude with some observations on emerging electoral trends framed as personality effects in the context of the growing impact of television on election outcomes.

Al Gore’s Personality Profile

I found Vice President Gore “to be primarily conscientious/dutiful and introverted/aloof.” Based on Millon’s Index of Personality Styles Manual (1996), Simonton’s “Presidential Style: Biography, Personality, and Performance,” and the model of Costa and McCrae, it is implied “that Gore is highly deliberative/conscientious, somewhat lacking in interpersonality/agreeableness, and low in charisma/extraversion.” If we turn to Renshon’s The Psychological Assessment of Presidential Candidates (1996), we find that “Gore’s profile suggests that his ambition is rooted in a sense of duty; that his character integrity is well consolidated; and,” to conclude, “that his interpersonal relatedness is marked more by detachment than by a tendency to move toward, away from, or against others.” [Editor’s note: See the June issue for the full citations of these studies.]

“Conscientiousness and low susceptibility to ethical transgression” are “major personality

Page 73

20th-Century U.S. Presidents Ranked In Descending Order Of Extraversion    
PresidentDev’n.RankClass.
Theodore Roosevelt+2.281Extra. +
Franklin D. Roosevelt+1.782Extra. +
Bill Clinton+1.383Extra. +
John F. Kennedy+1.274Extra. +
Lyndon B. Johnson+1.236Extra. +
Ronald Reagan+0.917Extra.
Harry Truman+0.898Extra.
Warren Harding+0.3011Extra. –
Dwight D. Eisenhower+0.2512Extra. –
Woodrow Wilson+0.1416Extra. –
George Bush+0.0618Extra. –
Jimmy Carter-0.0422Intro. –
Gerald Ford-0.0523Intro. –
William Taft-0.1626Intro. –
(Bob Dole)(-0.52)N/A(Intro.)
Richard M. Nixon-1.0137Intro. +
Herbert Hoover-1.4340Intro. +
Calvin Coolidge-2.2741Intro. +

strengths” of Al Gore. On the other hand, “his major personality-based limitations,” which would affect his performance as President, “are deficits in the political skills of interpersonality, charisma, and spontaneity, and his self-defeating propensity,” as I pointed out last year when I presented on him at the International Society of Political Psychology meetings in Montreal, “for tenaciously pursuing a pet policy or dogmatically advancing some central principle in defiance of legislative or public disapproval.”

A Personality-Based Assessment of Political Risks

In the unlikely event that Vice President Gore should succeed Bill Clinton as President, my tentative “worst-case” prediction is that by virtue of the moralistically conscientious features in his profile he may be inclined, like Woodrow Wilson, to relentlessly advance a defining policy or program in which he has a vested interest (e.g., the environment, government efficiency, or the high-tech industry). Such single-minded, dogged determination incurs the risk of alienating some constituencies and diverting inordinate energy, attention, and resources from other endeavors, tasks, and duties.

The prominence of the introverted component in his personality style could further erode his support if a President Gore were to withdraw to the Oval Office and disregard the important Presidential tasks of coalition building and public relations.

Regarding the risk of scandal, there will be none of consequence that personally involves the President. Respectful, dutiful personalities are much too scrupulous in matters of morality and ethics; in fact, like Woodrow Wilson, they run the risk of being overly moralistic, if not condescending. Finally, Al Gore’s introversion, in stark contrast to the narcissistic-outgoing pattern exemplified by President Clinton, is associated with meager affective and erotic needs, which attenuates the risk for sexual misconduct—even without factoring in the potentiating effect of the principled scruples of the conscientious character. The dominance of conscientious features in Gore’s profile suggest that he is not likely to be a visionary, highly imaginative, President or a transformational leader.

Polls Versus Personality and Electoral Trends

The 2000 election is too distant to attach great significance to polls, which fluctuate with the vagaries of the moment (although even at this early stage Al Gore is lagging behind likely Republican contenders). Polls change, but personality does not. What, then, can we learn from an analysis of long-term electoral trends, framed as personality effects? The extraversion-introversion dimension, as shown by factor-analytic studies, is the key personality attribute in reference to impression formation. In addition, extraversion is a major element in interpersonality, charisma, personal charm, and warmth. Extraversion, as supported by the research of Rubenzer, Faschingbauer, and Ones (see table below, modified) support a series of inferences: (1) Every U.S. President (relative to other U.S. Presidents) has been extraverted, starting with Franklin D. Roosevelt. The exceptions are Richard M. Nixon, Gerald Ford (a never-elected President), and Jimmy Carter (who is an anomaly as a result of the Watergate scandal). (2) Despite the lack of empirical data for defeated candidates Barry Goldwater,

Hubert H. Humphrey, George McGovern, and

Page 74

Walter Mondale, it can be confidently speculated that, at least since John F. Kennedy, the more outgoing candidate has consistently won the Presidency. The exception is Richard M. Nixon in 1972 as McGovern was almost certainly more outgoing than Nixon, and perhaps in 1968 since Humphry was perhaps more outgoing (S. Rubenzer, T. Faschingbauer, & D. Ones, “Personality Scores and Portraits of U.S. Presidents,” paper presented at the 104th Annual Convention of the American Psychological Association, Toronto, Ontario, August, 1996).

Page 75

About the author

Aubrey Immelman

Aubrey Immelman, PhD, is an associate professor of psychology at Saint John’s University and the College of Saint Benedict in Minnesota. He is a political psychologist specializing in the personality assessment of Presidents, Presidential candidates, and other public figures.

How to cite this article

Immelman, A. (1999). Why Al Gore will not be elected president in 2000. Clio’s Psyche, 6(2), 73-75.

https://doi.org/10.70763/445e24b5f22cacb9d51a837c10e91a3f

PDF downloads